Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think not paying maintenance should be grounds for blocking contact

184 replies

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 02:34

I’ve always gone along with ‘the child’s right to contact with their parent comes before any disputes over money’, ‘maintenance isn’t linked to contact’ ‘it’s not pay per view’. I’m now starting to think it is not in the best interests of a child to have a relationship with a parent who is unwilling and/or unable to provide the basic necessities. If I was to disregard my child’s needs in the same way, there would likely be serious intervention from social services. What is the difference?

OP posts:
Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 04:14

we don’t have shared care so perhaps my own situation is clouding my understanding of your response

OP posts:
Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 04:11

I thought so too P205! My child’s father is a long term benefits claimant according to CMS. Even so they can only manage to take the £29 per month approvingly 3/12 months of the year with no explanation for the other months. Then when superdad deigns to have his rightfully allowed and ‘must never be inhibited’ half yearly contact he spends around £1000 on random treats. No school uniform or other such luxuries unfortunately. However I must remember not to ‘weaponise contact’

OP posts:
Christinatheastonishing · 28/06/2022 04:11

I was thinking along the lines of what @P205 said. If you have shared care, both parents are providing emotionally, practically and financially while child(ren) in their care. So child support is effectively just an attempt to equalise income if one parent is earning more than the other. Is failing to pay that actually neglecting the children?

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/06/2022 04:09

What I would really like to see is CMS being merged or linked with HMRC.

P205 · 28/06/2022 04:06

So, you mean dads who work but refuse to pay maintainable? I thought CMS took maintenance directly from their wages?

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 04:05

Christina - Assuming you mean a SAHP in a couple where one works and the other doesn’t? As otherwise the SAHP would be supporting the child(ren) via their benefits or other savings. So this scenario would he an agreed decision between the parents where one brings in money and the other doesn’t. A bit of a ‘devils advocate argument for the sake of it’ and bringing nothing much to the conversation. A better comparison would be perhaps two ‘SAHPs’ in a couple not providing anything financially, undoubtedly neglectful. Ok to do I if you know the other parent will pick up your slack though? (Again, clearly not talking about a partnership where this is agreed, for the avoiding of doubt)

OP posts:
Whiskeypowers · 28/06/2022 04:05

sellthesizzle · 28/06/2022 03:52

Because contact and financial support are deliberately separated by the law as removing contact damages the child - always.

Removing contact does not always damage a child. You need to qualify that statement.

P205 · 28/06/2022 04:04

I can’t really understand your point.

Surely, when a dad has contact, he has to pay for necessities such as clothes, food, toiletries, etc. If a dad isn’t feeding or clothing his child during contact, then a court order could be obtained to remove contact or move contact to supervised contact only.

A mother also has a duty to feed, clothe and provide necessities when she has the children in her care.

In the case of 50/50 contact, there isn’t any maintenance paid.

RaisinGhost · 28/06/2022 04:02

I see where you are coming from OP. Attitudes of "you can't weaponise contact - that's sick!" but if men can't be bothered to pay child support, "ah well, that's men for you".

The biggest problem with this idea is that lots of men who don't want to pay, also don't really care if they see their kids or not. So this rule would be a double win for them.

I think a better rule would be a much harsher punishments for not paying, up to and including jail.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/06/2022 04:01

It certainly isn’t a back and white issue. I see your point, OP, and I think I agree (sort of) in principle if not in practicality.

I think a better approach would be to criminalise the non-payment of child support (as happens in other countries) and for the non-payer to be imprisoned and lose contact that way. It would certainly concentrate the minds of some financially neglectful parents!

There are flaws in that plan too, of course, but I think it is an option that should be considered in government.

Christinatheastonishing · 28/06/2022 03:58

If not contributing financially = neglect what does that mean for SAHP?

(Playing devil's advocate here, I'm a staunch supporter of child support.)

DockOTheBay · 28/06/2022 03:57

MolliciousIntent · 28/06/2022 02:36

So if a parent is unable to pay maintenance because they're unable to work, due to illness or disability or caring responsibilities, they don't get to see their child? Lose your job, lose your kids? Sounds fucking barbaric to me.

If they were unable to work the amount of maintenence required would be tiny, isn't it something like £7 per week. They do many allowances for those unable to work, but OP is talking about those who do work but don't pay maintenance

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 03:57

removing contact damaged the child sometimes/often, I can agree. There must be circumstances where removing contact is for the best though, this cannot be a hard and fast rule. Parents who wilfully withhold support would fall into the category in a majority of cases, in my opinion.

OP posts:
sellthesizzle · 28/06/2022 03:52

Because contact and financial support are deliberately separated by the law as removing contact damages the child - always.

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 03:43

Expat, I understand exactly what you’re saying and I do also know of a situation where contact is being maliciously reduced to maximise maintenance. This is equally disgusting as the situation I’ve described. I agree there isn’t one right answer. I’m getting increasingly infuriated by blanket statements though. Most of us can agree each situation has nuances, such as those you’ve described. Therefore why is contact seen as a weapon but financial support is often seen as optional

OP posts:
sellthesizzle · 28/06/2022 03:41

Loads of books on the impact of an absent father or mother. Google it there are dozens.
Sorry not trying to be unhelpful but the stuff I read was years ago when I was having counselling.

expat101 · 28/06/2022 03:35

Its an interesting concept and I have given it a bit of thought lately. Where I think the trouble is, is the system makes it appear the residential parent is financially benefiting from the financial contribution the non resident parent pays... and in some cases, it does, and in some cases, it doesn't go far enough.

I have known the residential parent fight to refuse additional access to the children by the non resident parent because it was going to change the financial sum they receive if they have the children ''less''.

and I know of a case where the non residential parent wanted to buy the food for child concerned, and not pay a % based on their income, but that isn't acceptable either.

I don't know what the answer is, but something has to change that benefits the children.

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 03:32

True, being a dick financially doesn’t always mean you’re an unfit parent but there’s definitely a correlation in my opinion. I also have an unfit, non paying father who I finally cut contact with as an adult and honestly don’t see how that ongoing contact benefited me either as a child or now as an adult. Do you have any links to studies about this because I am genuinely interested

OP posts:
Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 03:28

Funnyface, but ‘weaponising’ support for your child is fine?

OP posts:
sellthesizzle · 28/06/2022 03:26

I don't think bring a dick financially makes someone automatically an unfit parent. And lost contact has a significant and life long impact on a child but (generally) a lesser impact on the parent. They've done studies on it. I also speak as someone who lost contact with a parent who wouldn't pay maintenance, when I was quite young and as someone whose ex is a dick about money. But still think yabu.

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/06/2022 03:24

Weaponising contact is sick

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 03:14

CPandme, I appreciate your answer but this isn’t really about the minority of my parents who are truly unable to provide anything. It’s about those who choose to provide nothing or far less than they could. And even those who truly have nothing extra, surely you feed your child before feeding yourself. It’s just not right

OP posts:
Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 03:12

The way I reason it, if I provided the same level of input and support to my daughter’s life as her dad does, she would likely be removed from my care. But when he provides this lack of care, it’s in her best interests to keep up contact. This is where I’m growing frustrated and feel confused about what is right.

OP posts:
CPandme · 28/06/2022 03:10

The penalties for none payment of child support should be harder but I don’t think should be linked to contact.

If the main carer of a child gets ill yes they need still need to feed their child. If on a low enough income they may get more tax credits if already claiming or claim or increase in universal credit. That is not available for the other parent.

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 03:10

Sellthesizzle this is where I have stood until recently, so I can absolutely understand your point of view. Recently my thoughts have become more along the lines of ‘no contact with a neglectful parent is better than contact with a neglectful parent’. What do you think is the benefit to a child’s emotional wellbeing with an unfit parent, to put it bluntly?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread