Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think not paying maintenance should be grounds for blocking contact

184 replies

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 02:34

I’ve always gone along with ‘the child’s right to contact with their parent comes before any disputes over money’, ‘maintenance isn’t linked to contact’ ‘it’s not pay per view’. I’m now starting to think it is not in the best interests of a child to have a relationship with a parent who is unwilling and/or unable to provide the basic necessities. If I was to disregard my child’s needs in the same way, there would likely be serious intervention from social services. What is the difference?

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 28/06/2022 07:00

OP do you also believe that if contact is prevented by the RP that maintenance shouldn't be paid?

Because that is the other side of this?

Terriblethirtytwos · 28/06/2022 06:58

I don’t disagree with you that not paying for your child is neglectful. The thing is, @Whypaymumwillsavetheday , parents who neglect their children do still see their children, generally. The vast, vast majority of children in foster care removed for neglect continue to have contact with their parents, and whilst this is complicated, not seeing their parent(s) is generally worse for the child than seeing their parent(s). Neglect in itself isn’t a reason to sever ties between a parent and a child, because it’s about the child’s right to see and know their parent, however crappy and unfit that parent might be.

Your exP sounds like a bag of shit, though, and I’m sorry for what you and your DD are going through.

Spabreak · 28/06/2022 06:57

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/06/2022 04:09

What I would really like to see is CMS being merged or linked with HMRC.

Of course this should happen. The reason why it doesn't is probably the combination of too few women in Parliament, together with many of those that are appearing to be misogynistic, including the women.

How many of those men in Parliament are on second or third wives? Including our PM. I doubt many of them want the spotlight shown on their own personal situations, so they'd prefer to let the taxpayer fund child maintenance.

I find it absolutely shocking that people are able to avoid paying for their own children by lying to CMS. Although HMRC are not perfect and don't catch everyone who is not paying their due amount of tax, they seem to have more powers to investigate and more information than the CMS.

SmileyPiuPiu · 28/06/2022 06:50

What would people say about a resident parent who openly admits to not working as they don't need to due to the maintenance they receive from NRP. Should they have their contact with their children removed?

Sistanotcista · 28/06/2022 06:45

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/06/2022 04:01

It certainly isn’t a back and white issue. I see your point, OP, and I think I agree (sort of) in principle if not in practicality.

I think a better approach would be to criminalise the non-payment of child support (as happens in other countries) and for the non-payer to be imprisoned and lose contact that way. It would certainly concentrate the minds of some financially neglectful parents!

There are flaws in that plan too, of course, but I think it is an option that should be considered in government.

So agree with this!

OP - I totally get where you’re coming from. Dead beat dads who can’t be bothered (as in unwilling, not unable) to contribute to their kids don’t particularly deserve a place in that child’s life. I’m not convinced that contact is always for the best, also. How engaged, interested, supportive, loving is a father who won’t pay a cent for his child? Not very :(

MiddleParking · 28/06/2022 06:41

and I know of a case where the non residential parent wanted to buy the food for child concerned, and not pay a % based on their income, but that isn't acceptable either.

I think there’s certainly a case for withholding contact from the NRP in that scenario. That is both illegal and abusive and I don’t believe it’s beneficial to a child to have contact with someone who behaves that way towards them and their main carer.

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 28/06/2022 06:37

P205 · 28/06/2022 04:04

I can’t really understand your point.

Surely, when a dad has contact, he has to pay for necessities such as clothes, food, toiletries, etc. If a dad isn’t feeding or clothing his child during contact, then a court order could be obtained to remove contact or move contact to supervised contact only.

A mother also has a duty to feed, clothe and provide necessities when she has the children in her care.

In the case of 50/50 contact, there isn’t any maintenance paid.

Your having a laugh. I have a court order in place but other than CMS DS father does not have to buy any form of clothing why would he? I pack my child's clothes for the weekend.

Food and toiletries that dad already has at home which are a basic human right how kind of dad to put him self out EOW and provide this for his own blood 🙄

Most people are not 50/50 hence OPS thread in the first place!

I also pay for the majority of activies as DS is with me a lot of the time...

itsjustnotok · 28/06/2022 06:35

You take it to the proper channels. It’s not fair on the child and will likely come
back and bite you in the ass. Sorry you can’t see Daddy/Mummy but they are paying for you so I’m punishing you and them. Children usually find out when their parent is a genuine dirtbag and decide how to handle it accordingly. Don’t be the one to refuse contact and hurt your kid in the process.

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 28/06/2022 06:31

Terrible idea. In the heat of the moment yes I could agree with you!

On a calm day no morally it isn't right is it? It would make the main parent morally wrong too and ultimately the DC will most likely grudge the parent who stopped/reduced contact later as an adult it is not the mothers place to do this!

It's a slippery slope..

JanglyBeads · 28/06/2022 06:26

I agree that many dads who evade payment are abusive in other ways, but not all. The others may well not be great parents, but not bad enough to make them harmful to the child.

It's whether you take non payment as a proxy for neglect/abuse (emotional and possibly other forms), given that we don't have the resources to do a case by case assessment and these things scan be hard to assess anyway.

SmileyPiuPiu · 28/06/2022 06:15

I kind of see your point but in some cases the RP uses the maintainance as a reason to work less themselves with no agreement from NRP. Is that not neglect then but the other way around? It's not a black and white situation and I wouldn't want to be the one telling the kids they can't see their parent as they didnt pay this month. There possibly needs to be some kind of law against it with a fine. That might work better than punishing the kids and making them feel their relationship with their parents is about money.

iBrows · 28/06/2022 06:13

I’m not sure how much it benefits children to be around a father who cares about them so little he won’t even pay towards their upkeep.

Vikinga · 28/06/2022 06:06

I agree with you and I also think that child maintenance should be automatically taken from their bank account, whether or not they see their child.

HuntingoftheSnark · 28/06/2022 05:59

@Whypaymumwillsavetheday I completely understand your frustration. I see your point too. I suppose that my situation was clear cut - DD's father didn't pay maintenance, and ensured that he stayed overseas, plus had no interest in seeing her. I was more upset and annoyed about the latter than the former, but the decision wasn't mine to make. Had he asked for contact, I would have been pathetically grateful!

Coffeaddict · 28/06/2022 05:40

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/06/2022 03:24

Weaponising contact is sick

This
Who gets to decide? Is this just if a dad doesn't pay cms maintenance or also refuses top ups?
There are already plenty of people who use kids as pawns in splits giving parents more rights to do this is wrong

Mumofsend · 28/06/2022 05:29

No, the loss of contact on a child is too significant.

Starseeking · 28/06/2022 05:28

The punishment for not paying CMS should be far harsher than it is, should be vigorously applied, and society should shun those who refuse to support their DC.

Cutting contact with a non-payer isn't the punishment I'd go to first, given it would likely impact the DC negatively, more so than the non-payer, so I don't think that is the way to go.

sjxoxo · 28/06/2022 05:17

I agree with the principal of what you’re saying actually. Of course if you are unable that’s different but ‘unwilling’ should be treated with far harsher consequences and maybe that could include lack of contact. The lack of penalty for non payment by CMS is disgraceful and says everything you need to know really about the position of women in our society imo Xx

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 04:20

I have no idea where the money is coming from, he tells our child it is from work. The same work he uses as an excuse for not seeing her. However CMS are adamant he has no income other than benefits

OP posts:
Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 04:18

Christina, respectfully I think the points you are making are red herrings. What you’re describing sound like disputes to me, not anything like neglect. Not providing your child with basic necessities is undoubtedly neglect whatever way you want to spin it

OP posts:
P205 · 28/06/2022 04:17

I understand you now. So, where is his money coming from? From his parents? From illegal activities? Is he doing work but not paying tax?

I think it’s hard to be on benefits long term these days. But whatever system is in place, people will find ways to cheat it. Like the mega-rich not paying tax.

Christinatheastonishing · 28/06/2022 04:16

PS. Your ex is a shit and I'm sorry you're in this situation. I just don't think your solution is the right one. CMS should instead be pursuing him to the ends of the earth to get that money to you.

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 04:16

Couldn’t agree more difficultbloody woman!

OP posts:
Aintnosupermum · 28/06/2022 04:16

Its abusive to not pay child support when you have the ability to do so. It’s abusive to the child and the other parent who has to make up the short fall.

Abusive behavior should have a consequence beyond the slow system they currently have. So many non resident parents owe considerable amounts. The amount owed isn’t even compounded at a reasonable rate.

Christinatheastonishing · 28/06/2022 04:14

And is it still neglect if for example, the paying parent wanted a higher percentage of care but didn't get it? Or if the payee has the ability to increase their own contribution to the children's upkeep by working/working more hours but chooses not to?

So many variables.

Swipe left for the next trending thread