Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think not paying maintenance should be grounds for blocking contact

184 replies

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 02:34

I’ve always gone along with ‘the child’s right to contact with their parent comes before any disputes over money’, ‘maintenance isn’t linked to contact’ ‘it’s not pay per view’. I’m now starting to think it is not in the best interests of a child to have a relationship with a parent who is unwilling and/or unable to provide the basic necessities. If I was to disregard my child’s needs in the same way, there would likely be serious intervention from social services. What is the difference?

OP posts:
Getoff · 28/06/2022 08:25

I disagree with the idea that a non-paying parent is necessarily neglecting a child. If non-paying parent knows their non-payment will not affect what is spent on the child, because the RP will make up the difference out of their income, then they are harming the RP, not the child.

The idea that maintenance benefits the children is probably true in the majority of cases, but whenever I read it in threads like these, it feels manipulative and dishonest to me. There is a reason "think of the children" is a joke meme, it's an emotional and manipulative argument that's used in many contexts.

expat101 · 28/06/2022 08:24

JuneJubilee · 28/06/2022 07:43

@expat101

I have known the residential parent fight to refuse additional access to the children by the non resident parent because it was going to change the financial sum they receive if they have the children ''less''.

whilst that might seem harsh, NRP having them more frequently barely changes how much the RP needs to pay to maintain their home, school uniform, other clothes/shoes/coats. It changes the food bill by a meal or two, that's all.

and I know of a case where the non residential parent wanted to buy the food for child concerned, and not pay a % based on their income, but that isn't acceptable either

of course not. It's controlling and the RP has Bills to pay to house & clothe the child not just feed them. It's not up to the NRP just to shove a bit of random food at the RP.

I can't believe you seriously think that's acceptable.

@Whypaymumwillsavetheday I understand what you're saying, I think, on the whole, NRP who choose not to contribute financially to their child's upbringing are probably parents a child doesn't benefit from having in their lives but I think too many children would hear arguments about it & end up feeling the RP was stopping them seeing the NRP.

its all a shit show & many need to grow up & stop being arseholes. However, had they been able to do that, they might not be NRP.

I never said it was acceptable, rather situations that I knew of…

GeorgiaGirl52 · 28/06/2022 08:23

The child support payment system is very different from the USA system, which is a state law based system. If the non-custodial parent does not pay, then the state pays the custodial parent and chases the non-payer for reimbursement.
One judge got the bright idea of taking away the Driver's Licenses of all failure-to-pay parents. In one week the county collected over $500,000 in back child support. Men will pay for what they really want.

motogirl · 28/06/2022 08:21

Children should not be used as bargaining chips, end of. We need a better enforcement system for absent parents, more mechanisms to get maintenance where they are self employed or living off savings, but most of all there should be a culture starting with mediation that parents take a 50:50 role in the upbringing so no maintenance is actually required.

We as women do need to take some responsibility by ensuring that we are in established relationships with financial security even if not married before we have children and not have more than we can afford to bring up if they worse happens eg I know two widows with young children through my work.

A large number of the deadbeat dad stories on here are serial offenders, they will never change, don't have babies with them!

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 08:20

I also believe parents who have an affair should forfeit the right to shared custody.

Wtf. Who punishes their child for their own failed relationship. Pathetic.

SmileyPiuPiu · 28/06/2022 08:18

kitcat15 · 28/06/2022 08:15

I don't agree....I think if people are unwilling to support their children then they lose their rights to contact...end of

What would you say about a resident parent who doesn't work and openly admits this is because they get enough maintenance that they don't have to? Should they lose contact?

thenewduchessoflapland · 28/06/2022 08:18

In my friends DC case her ex was forced to pay via CMS and when having DC he use to tell them mum steals all his money and the reason he can't do x,y&z with them is because he has no money because the robbing *'s from the CMS take it to give it to their mum.

He also send a pathetic begging letter to my friend asking her to drop the CMS claim because "surely you and partner earn enough money not to need maintenance for kids".

It took three years to get the slimey git to pay up;he's still in arrears.

I honestly believe that if he had a choice between either having contact or not paying maintenance then he'd go no contact.

kitcat15 · 28/06/2022 08:15

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/06/2022 03:24

Weaponising contact is sick

I don't agree....I think if people are unwilling to support their children then they lose their rights to contact...end of

caringcarer · 28/06/2022 08:14

My ex and I have 3 children. He was so angry with me he refused to pay maintenance for our DC. Youngest had to come out of fee paying school he was settled in. Eldest was off to uni. Middle child totally bewildered. I had to stop his horse riding lessons and had to say no to school ski trip all his friends went on. At 14 I told him it was all because his shit Dad refused to pay maintenance. Eventually CSA made him pay. Made his employer pay it out his salary every month and I got the back pay too. But too late for D's to go on school trip. It ruined the children relationship with their Dad. My 3 kids are all adults now. Eldest dd rarely sees her Dad or he sees grandkids. Middle child no longer sees his Dad. He moved into his own house last October. His Dad has never even seen it. Youngest still sees his Dad occasionally but recognises he is selfish. It is exh own fault.

Sistanotcista · 28/06/2022 08:14

SavoirFlair · 28/06/2022 07:20

I am sorry but I think this is quite offensive -‘and I would be curious to see if this poster typed the same things if they were faced with similar predicaments to the OP and others.

Children might need their “mum and dad” but there shouldn’t be elastic and forgiving criteria for fathers, and unforgiving ones for mums who by default shoulder a lot of the work.

there are huge swathes of women who enable terrible behaviour from dads by shrugging when they hear of non payment, CMS avoidance, etc by saying “you shouldn’t have had children with them”. Again, placing the blame and responsibility on other women.

I think why this situation doesn’t change is due to what seems to be the continued “right” of a man to lose interest, leave a family, and then resent the existence of that family despite having been active in its creation.

that resentment leads to complete disinterest when they inevitably meet another woman, who in turn is happy if that father keeps that money in their “new”household. Therefore reinforcing the situation that an “old” family is a financial inconvenience.

This is how our society reinforces things. While I am very lucky I am with my original first partner and now DH, I experienced this from my father, and I saw it in countless relationships years later as an adult.

Very well articulated. Totally agree.

Sorry about your father, but so glad you have a great DH now. There are many good men in the world. That doesn’t mean that as a society we should conspire to exonerate the sh*tty ones.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 28/06/2022 08:14

I‘m sorry you had a child with a dickhead @Whypaymumwillsavetheday

I know it would be nice to be able to teach deadbeat/non paying CM dads a lesson.

However

You cannot just cut them out if your child’s life. It might seem fair to you, but it isn’t fair to you child. That’s the risk included in having a child I suppose - you’re forever linked to the other parent, whoever they are.

Even serious, imprisoned offenders get to see their kids - do you really think any court would order to cut contact with a father because he doesn’t pay CM?

As bad and frustrating as it sounds, if your child’s father won’t pay CM anyway, you might as well support their relationship. When your child grows up, they can make their own judgment based on the potential years of hardship they’ve experienced due to lack of CM money.

But unless there’s a safeguarding risk, only that child should decide to go no contact with one of the parents.

SweetSakura · 28/06/2022 08:12

I certainly think it should be treated as financial abuse and a financial crime.

My ex used withholding maintenance all the time as a way to continue the abuse after we split.

It drove me to climb to career ladder so I wasn't dependent on his money any more, but I know not everyone has that option.

It should be a very relevant consideration in contact hearings for certain, as any form of abuse should be a red flag.

Getoff · 28/06/2022 08:09

If I was to disregard my child’s needs in the same way, there would likely be serious intervention from social services. What is the difference?

The difference is that RP has 100% of responsibility for welfare of a child living with them. That level of responsibility does not vary with income, regardless of the income source.

TomPinch · 28/06/2022 08:08

Another problem with the OP's suggestion is that if there's a quid pro quo between maintenance and access it works both ways, ie, access withheld by the custodial parent means she loses the right to recieve maintenance payments and a toxic situation all round.

On a separate point, where I live custodial parents who are owed child support can 'uplift' the debt, ie take on the right to collect it themselves. Not for the faint hearted, but I understand that the UK CSA are useless.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 28/06/2022 08:07

People who have had this happen to them as children are saying exactly how much they don't like their father for doing what they did and that it's ruined their relationship with him.

Yet people think they know better and should force contact. The child when young won't understand, but as a teenager or adult, they will see the truth and why you protected them from their knob head father. Surely the people who have already had to go through this have more of an idea?

Sswhinesthebest · 28/06/2022 08:07

An less than adequate parent may be a dick financially but I wouldn’t say they are in any way a fit parent.
But it very much depends on individual cases whether contact would be better or not.

BiscoffSundae · 28/06/2022 08:01

I also agree with another poster and would happily have no maintenance if my ex would have regular contact with the kids but he doesn’t want to see them and I think a lot of men who don’t want to pay maintenance are also the ones who don’t care about seeing their kids

Justthisonceharold · 28/06/2022 08:00

I disagree OP, and I say that as someone who never received a penny of maintenance. What's best for the child should always be the most important driver - their physical and emotional well-being. A child who is deprived of paternal contact will almost always suffer for that lack of contact.

A parent who is useless in terms of financial support should be punished by our legal system; a child should not be punished in their place.

As for I also believe parents who have an affair should forfeit the right to shared custody I don't really know where to begin with that. Relationships are rarely black and white, and there's a reason behaviour isn't normally taken into account when financial settlements are made. Such a simplistic bad parent/good parent decision which in the end is likely to harm the child above anyone else should never happen.

SavoirFlair · 28/06/2022 07:57

I don’t get some of the posts which disparage the request for NRPs to pay maintenance by calling it “pay per view”.

It seems almost anything can be used to exonerate a man who doesn’t want to pay for his child.

Why do some men, on the breakup of a relationship, refuse to pay for the ongoing needs of that child?

it comes down to emotions. They’ve moved on, and they expect the person they feel has “wronged them” somehow , to bear all the costs.

My friend split from her husband of 10 years (two DCs, 8 and 5) last year.

He moved to another country 1000+ miles away, lives with the woman he met that provided the escape route. He pays no maintenance for the DCs as he bitterly claims that he never wanted the second DC and it was “expectation” that made him do it.

And as simple as that, he’s considered justified in his actions. She earns ok so she can pay for everything. She longs for him to see his kids, which gives the pass he needs to pop by twice a year only, buy them a big meal out and weekend of fun, then disappear.

BiscoffSundae · 28/06/2022 07:49

My ex “doesn’t work or claim benefits” and hasn’t in 5 years so I’m entitled to no maintenance at all, but even then no I don’t agree with you, he doesn't see the children anyway as he doesn’t want to so it wouldn’t “punish” him but that would be the only thing that would actually make the fact that he doesn’t pay a bit better if he was actually a good involved dad but he isn’t so no I don’t think those who don’t pay shouldn’t see their kids.

FloraPostIt · 28/06/2022 07:47

You're right that the child would be removed from your care if you didn't meet their needs, but you would still be allowed contact so it's a false equivalence.

There should be actual consequences of not paying - legal and social. Non-paying parents (almost exclusively dads let's face it) should become social pariahs. There should be a legal requirement on dating apps to include a running total of unpaid child support across their face on their profile pictures.

notanothertakeaway · 28/06/2022 07:46

Children shouldn't be punished for their fathers' refusal to pay child support

But the state should do more eg confiscate driver's licence, TV licence, DBS certificates where people don't make payment. Although I suppose people might argue that without a driver's licence, they cant get to work

RinklyRomaine · 28/06/2022 07:45

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 28/06/2022 07:32

Contact is not pay per view, but when money is yet another method of control and abuse, it should be.
What on earth? You're happy for your little girl to see her abusive father more if he pays for the privilege?
That's just sick.

What? Not remotely. I mean it should be fine to limit contact when the NRP uses money as a form of abuse. Surely that was bloody obvious?

Anothernamechangeplease · 28/06/2022 07:45

I disagree. It isn't "pay per view". It is entirely about the child's right to have a relationship with their parent, however feckless and undeserving that parent might be.

I do think parents who fail to support their children financially should be prosecuted, though, and they should face substantial financial penalties for failing to meet their obligations.

JuneJubilee · 28/06/2022 07:43

@expat101

I have known the residential parent fight to refuse additional access to the children by the non resident parent because it was going to change the financial sum they receive if they have the children ''less''.

whilst that might seem harsh, NRP having them more frequently barely changes how much the RP needs to pay to maintain their home, school uniform, other clothes/shoes/coats. It changes the food bill by a meal or two, that's all.

and I know of a case where the non residential parent wanted to buy the food for child concerned, and not pay a % based on their income, but that isn't acceptable either

of course not. It's controlling and the RP has Bills to pay to house & clothe the child not just feed them. It's not up to the NRP just to shove a bit of random food at the RP.

I can't believe you seriously think that's acceptable.

@Whypaymumwillsavetheday I understand what you're saying, I think, on the whole, NRP who choose not to contribute financially to their child's upbringing are probably parents a child doesn't benefit from having in their lives but I think too many children would hear arguments about it & end up feeling the RP was stopping them seeing the NRP.

its all a shit show & many need to grow up & stop being arseholes. However, had they been able to do that, they might not be NRP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread