Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think not paying maintenance should be grounds for blocking contact

184 replies

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 02:34

I’ve always gone along with ‘the child’s right to contact with their parent comes before any disputes over money’, ‘maintenance isn’t linked to contact’ ‘it’s not pay per view’. I’m now starting to think it is not in the best interests of a child to have a relationship with a parent who is unwilling and/or unable to provide the basic necessities. If I was to disregard my child’s needs in the same way, there would likely be serious intervention from social services. What is the difference?

OP posts:
howtomoveforwards · 28/06/2022 12:25

Children are women's work. Until we change that as a society, there will be no shift in how we tackle the non-payment of maintenance. Single mothers are seen as bottom of the social pile, single dads are heros. Look at Boris. I don't think I have ever heard anyone call him out on his dreadful behaviour towards his ex-wives/wife and children.

We see maintenance as a private matter - a very British thing, let's not talk about money. We assume there's more to it. We allow ourselves the argument 'but he worked and she worked part time so actually he gave her the house and everything in it' to take over. Or the 'but she earns more than him so why should be pay?' or even just 'she's a cow, why should he pay?'. We always blame the single mum for having had children with the man in the first place, like she was supposed to know it would end up a particular way and should take responsibility for it. Mothers, family members, colleagues, friends....all ignore the vocal man who claims he's not giving the greedy ex a penny. We never challenge.

I am 13 years and counting with no maintenance. My children enjoy a positive relationship with their father but I have not hidden the truth of the matter from them and never will. It's up to them. I believe strongly that things would improve rapidly with a few high profile cases where the CMS and the courts work together to nail a few parents who clearly live the high life and who's accountants have - legally or otherwise - made the money disappear for maintenance assessment purposes. A social media campaign that names and shames would pull many into line. The fact that it's possible to get away with paying no maintenance is the loophole - we need to close it.

Longleggedgiraffe · 28/06/2022 12:16

YABU. The financial concerns are real, but they should be your concerns, not a reason to deprive the children of their father's company. Children should not be used as blackmail tools in a relationship.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 28/06/2022 11:47

It's important to remember that children have a REALLY low bar for what they consider a good parent. They will nearly always want to see both their parents, even if one of them feeds them crap food, doesn't buy them anything, and lives in a shithole. Being prevented from seeing a parent is psychologically really harmful and feels like abandonment.

Sometimes the parent is so abusive that contact is more harmful than abandonment. But mostly, it's in the child's interest to see the shit parent.

Isaidnoalready · 28/06/2022 11:36

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 10:40

I'd love to see the studies this comment is based on.

Which comment? The 50/50 one is fairly easy to source there are many non biased sources that claim YOUNG children benefit emotionally from having a solid home base for the early years so more one parent than the other when they are teenagers 50/50 can benefit however by that time they will want their friends more than parents in most cases

If its the comment about the housing its a common theme man and woman seperate man goes back to parents man meets another woman moves in with her etc etc my ex husband has done this many times he has never in 8 years had his children overnight because he doesnt have his own home and they are not welcome where he "stays occasionally" this is a repeated theme that I've seen all too often

LorW · 28/06/2022 11:11

Hmmm. Issue is for those that are shit neglectful parents they aren’t really going to care about contact being cut are they, it probably won’t encourage the NRP to pay either, just going to have loads of kids with absent parents which will cause more psychological damage.

AchatAVendre · 28/06/2022 11:04

A non-mysoginistic world would tackle the issue differently and properly punish parents who don't pay for their own children when they are able to do so. Imagine if it were criminalised? Why shouldn't it be? Obviously not those who cannot pay but those who simply do not pay and repeatedly do not. Don't deprive them of contact but punish them appropriately when they don't pay for their own children.

Resident parents who fail to support their own children are criminalised after all.

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 10:40

Nothappyatwork · 28/06/2022 10:09

Because its not healthy for the kids. Pissing around going from one house to the other, no real base to call their own.

Let’s be honest most men don’t have the own house, they have their house with the new woman who rules the roost making the children feel particularly unwelcome

I'd love to see the studies this comment is based on.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 28/06/2022 10:39

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 08:40

Denying a child the right to have a relationship with the none resident parent is disgusting.
Dress it up how you like, but it is still using that child as a weapon to score points.
It's not about the parents, it's about the child, and money shouldn't come between the child and parent, however much it annoys you.
Horrible behaviour from a resident parent who should know better.

Yes give the child to a parent that refuses to feed it or cloth it, and constantly berates the only actual parent in their life. Great idea...

There's been plenty of examples of actual people saying how shit their dads were, even giving treats to step kids and ignoring their own child. But you think that's ok to force on an innocent child, because they must have contact or it's disgusting. 🤔

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 28/06/2022 10:37

I'm struggling to see the logic in effectively punishing the child twice, first by the other person failing to meet their financial needs and then secondly by the residential parent blocking them seeing their other parent.

And honestly it really sickens me when people use their child to get at another adult.

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 10:37

Luidaeg · 28/06/2022 09:26

And watching your child suffer because you refuse to pay support because she spends it on her nails and sky tv is ok?

If you cant be bothered to support your child, why do you have the right to be involved. In fact this kind of parent is probably one who wont make specific plans to see said child either, and turns up when they bloody feel like it - which is much worse for the child as they will constantly be in limbo

No one is saying that that is OK.

It's not about what the dad's 'right' is, it's about the kid's right. The issue with this kind of discussion is that too many people see it as mum vs dad and not about what's most beneficial to the child.

PeekAtYou · 28/06/2022 10:37

The problem with no maintenance, no contact is that the parents who don't see their kids might stop paying because they don't see the kids anyway.

I agree that contact with a crap parent isn't better than no contact with a crap parent but it's not for the other parent to decide. Too many kids are going through low level abuse- the too small clothes, not being fed properly etc are common stories on here and I'm not sure that the emotional damage done living like that outweighs not seeing their crap parent at all. It's also very common to hear about kids who stop going to contact because they are the age that judges deem them capable to stop contact. How many of those were tolerating crap because they were legally forced to and could have escaped earlier?

The non payment of CM should he treated more harshly. People ask how can NRP work without a license but they aren't paying with a license either. Yes to linking CMS and HMRC. If you tell CMS you earn £200pw then that is the figure that should be used when you try and get a mortgage or credit... I think that moving to a system where government pays RP then collects from NRP would lead to higher collection rates. It's scandalous that some parents are owed 5 figure sums and then the CMS ask them if they can write it off because they child is 18.

TiddleyWink · 28/06/2022 10:36

Bananarama21 · 28/06/2022 10:31

Don't weaponize your child. Go to cm.

CMS are inept, incompetent and ineffective. It’s very easy for feckless parents to avoid paying and CMS have no teeth to make them. Not sure why you’re convinced they’re the solution, going by the numerous stories on this thread and others like it of CMS doing nothing at all.

A parent who has to be forced by CMS to pay for their child’s food is a bad parent who has no place in that child’s life. How about we teach children from the start to have higher standards and not accept shitty crumbs of ‘care and affection’ from the men in their lives? Instead of damaging them by teaching them that someone who patently gives not a shit about them is still worthy of their time?

roarfeckingroarr · 28/06/2022 10:35

Yeah, 50/50 would happen over my dead body.

Bananarama21 · 28/06/2022 10:31

Don't weaponize your child. Go to cm.

Triffid1 · 28/06/2022 10:27

I understand where OP is coming from. Of course, it's not fair to "weaponise" contact etc, but there is clearly a very high correlation between men who don't pay child support (when they could/should) and men who are not good fathers.

There's this pervasive idea that a relationship with the dad is always better than no relationship. But I question that. Because a relationship with an abusive, selfish person is never good for anyone and all it does is teach children that they should be grateful for what small crumbs of attention and engagement they get from people they love. How often on here do we see women asking if they're being unreasonable to expect their partners to be nice to them occasionally - one has to wonder what happened to make them be uncertain about whether this is a realistic expectation or not.

Having said that, rather than banning contact, I'm with other posters - methods to get money out of deadbeat dads should be far more stringent and consequences more significant. Remove drivers licenses, link to HMRC, issue criminal charges etc.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/06/2022 10:24

A lot of Mums don’t think 50:50 is in their child’s interests rather than not wanting to do it from their own pov. For instance the Dad didn’t actually do any parenting when they were together (often the reason for the break up!) and they wouldn’t have a clue what to do now.

In some cases 50:50 works for teens where it doesn’t for younger ones, who want the stability of a “main home”.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/06/2022 10:21

I understand why you think this and it’s really crap when maintenance isn’t paid - and you know they can pay.

However I think it’s cutting off you nose to spite your face - then you get no maintenance and no break either! Plus the expenses for that additional time.
If they’re actually crap at looking after the child(ren) when they have them, that’s another thing and a separate reason to consider whether contact is working.

If the children don’t see their parent when they previously did, the danger is they’ll feel abandoned by them and it will affect their self esteem. Not always but it’s a real risk. It’s important to consider this I think.

BiscoffSundae · 28/06/2022 10:12

Nothappyatwork · 28/06/2022 10:09

Because its not healthy for the kids. Pissing around going from one house to the other, no real base to call their own.

Let’s be honest most men don’t have the own house, they have their house with the new woman who rules the roost making the children feel particularly unwelcome

No that’s not the reasons they give trust me it comes up often it’s always “I can’t bare to be away from my kids, it breaks my heart, I have no purpose when I’m not with them, I’m so lonely” it’s all me me me. That’s the reason why dads don’t step up more women don’t actually want them to.

restedbutexhausted · 28/06/2022 10:12

@BiscoffSundae I think this is because once you share 50/50 you get no child support. While that is fair enough I do understand why some mums would find that frustrating.

If the NRP does not have adequate materials for the child in the way of books, clothing, toys, the means to buy healthy food and cook nutritious meals for them and RP will still have to pick up the slack even when going 50/50, RP will be left out of pocket. If it's 50/50 it has to be 50/50 split of costs not just contact time.

Nothappyatwork · 28/06/2022 10:09

BiscoffSundae · 28/06/2022 10:04

Most women don’t want 50/50 though! I am on many single parent groups and the vast majority of mums don’t want to “share” the child and are very against 50/50

Because its not healthy for the kids. Pissing around going from one house to the other, no real base to call their own.

Let’s be honest most men don’t have the own house, they have their house with the new woman who rules the roost making the children feel particularly unwelcome

BiscoffSundae · 28/06/2022 10:06

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 09:06

Yes! We have 50/50 custody (I'm the stepmum) but this is so incredibly rare in this country. Dads are secondary parents here. If the child is old enough and the dad able and willing, custody should be 50/50.

Women don’t want 50/50 though do they and I believe it’s mainly women, I see it on here so many times women don’t want to “share”
their child even though it’s not just their child, or they don’t want to be “part time parents” loads of women seem to actually resent their ex having contact with I find sad, which is probably the reason why many are happy to stop contact if they are not getting maintenance

Nothappyatwork · 28/06/2022 10:06

At one point I was providing my children with packed lunches to go and spend the day with their father now you would think this would result in them (the father) being grateful for this kind gesture but oh no what happened was extreme anger when once he was working and had a job I stopped that and I was told that I ought to be packing a little bag for them without within they need their visits this is all whilst he’s not paying any maintenance by the way.

but what was the alternative I said to him if you can’t look after them and feed them you can’t take them and that looked as though I was withholding contact.

he also kidnapped them one day took them overnight to Hotel and then brought them into school in Yesterdays clothing having not had breakfast and with no lunch to feed them.
Who do you think about the bollocking for that pick up time ? Not to mention the school bailing him out by going and buying breakfast and lunch rather than pointing him in the direction of the shops.

BiscoffSundae · 28/06/2022 10:04

Topgub · 28/06/2022 09:00

Nothing will change until we change how parenting is viewed.

As long as dad's are seen as an optional extra just there to provide the money but not really as equal parents then they'll always think its ok to walk away.

We need to move away from viewing EOW as the norm post split. Shared care should be the aim.

But I have a feeling lots of women dont want that either

We also need to be looking at why society raises men to be shit dads.

Most women don’t want 50/50 though! I am on many single parent groups and the vast majority of mums don’t want to “share” the child and are very against 50/50

TiddleyWink · 28/06/2022 09:59

I don’t think it’s weaponising a child to withhold contact from someone who is a negative influence in their life. A parent who doesn’t provide materially to meet their child’s needs, by choice, or who chooses to harm their child in other ways (e.g. affairs, abuse of child’s other parents) is not a positive person for that child to be around.

Children shouldn’t be weaponised but they should be protected from very negative influences, bad parents and anyone who doesn’t have their best interests at heart. How on earth can it be a positive thing for a child to spend time with someone who chooses not to buy them food, school uniform etc or ensure they have a safe warm home?

Its not weaponising children, it’s protecting them.

SoupDragon · 28/06/2022 09:57

Why set up a system where the punishment only punishes the victims?

Swipe left for the next trending thread