Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think not paying maintenance should be grounds for blocking contact

184 replies

Whypaymumwillsavetheday · 28/06/2022 02:34

I’ve always gone along with ‘the child’s right to contact with their parent comes before any disputes over money’, ‘maintenance isn’t linked to contact’ ‘it’s not pay per view’. I’m now starting to think it is not in the best interests of a child to have a relationship with a parent who is unwilling and/or unable to provide the basic necessities. If I was to disregard my child’s needs in the same way, there would likely be serious intervention from social services. What is the difference?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Isaidnoalready · 30/06/2022 09:39

AnneElliott · 28/06/2022 22:37

I would criminalise non payment of CMS and send the offender to prison. That would mean non contact in any event.

Absolutely agree children are not pay per view but they are not free either non resident parent should pay

Nothappyatwork · 30/06/2022 09:07

LegInLegOut · 29/06/2022 02:25

@Nothappyatwork We don't know for sure if some can afford to pay or not, some people don't care either.
Of course there are always going to be none resident parents who can afford to pay but choose not to.
Not allowing the kids to see the none resident parent on the basis of whether the maintenance is paid or not is punishing the kids for something that isn't their fault.

We do have a very robust system that allows us to access either self-assessment of PAYE tax returns that would ascertain in no one certain terms whether someone can pay.

it seems little known on mumsnet that if the income and the lifestyle do not add up you can go back to the family court and get a court order for payment, if you will ever see the money or not is another matter but it is possible.

LegInLegOut · 29/06/2022 02:25

@Nothappyatwork We don't know for sure if some can afford to pay or not, some people don't care either.
Of course there are always going to be none resident parents who can afford to pay but choose not to.
Not allowing the kids to see the none resident parent on the basis of whether the maintenance is paid or not is punishing the kids for something that isn't their fault.

AnneElliott · 28/06/2022 22:37

I would criminalise non payment of CMS and send the offender to prison. That would mean non contact in any event.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/06/2022 22:29

Equity in your scenario would mean that refusing or restricting contact results in no child support being paid.

Move away and make it impossible to see the child every Wednesday? That's a third off the payments. Impossible to get from work in time to pick up the child on a Friday afternoon and drop them off at school on Monday? Lose some more. Non resident parent is on a low wage/UC and unable to afford £120 one way on the train? Not a penny.

cheninblanc · 28/06/2022 22:29

It's difficult so what I did when they were old enough was tell them when it wasn't paid. Half their pocket money came from me and half from maintenance, so when it was missing they were missing half. Mind you 3 years ago he decided not to be involved, but has recently been back I touch with them for how long who knows

Isaidnoalready · 28/06/2022 22:25

Crispyturtle · 28/06/2022 21:31

I don’t think it’s up to one parent to decide whether a child gets to have a relationship with the other parent (abuse notwithstanding).

When your child is older and asks why they don’t see their dad, would you be happy to tell them it was because they didn’t give you any money?

Truthfully my 22 year old knows part of the reason she stopped seeing her dad was over money that and drugs I insisted he was straight and reasonably sober when he came to see her however he was always desperate for money he would steal from me he stole from her money box (let daddy borrow this till next week I will pay you back I promise etc) he would pay me child support in cash then spend the next hour "going to the toilet" trying to find my purse upstairs to take it back he was a nightmare once I told him return the money or I'm calling the police so he refused to come see her as he was "scared" of me so he stopped seeing her and of course he stopped paying because I "was abusive" and would clearly waste the money nothing to do with his constant theft I has to keep my cards and purse on me at all times in my own home! I couldn't let him take her out the house he took her to a drug dealers house and got high the one time I let him so technically yes he didnt see her because he firmly believed every penny anyone had was for him and his drugs

and no he didn't have a drug problem when we were together he developed one after she was born and went downhill rapidly after we split up

blackheartsgirl · 28/06/2022 22:22

Nothappyatwork · 28/06/2022 19:02

But they won’t call him out on it. They’ll accept the crumbs that he fix their way and think the sun shines out of his arse.

Mum is held to a far higher standard

Dd15 already has called him out on it. She’s a very independent and switched on teenager. She saw a lot of bad stuff when me and her dad were together and is under no illusion that her dad is an idiot.

dd3 on the other hand…

Crispyturtle · 28/06/2022 21:31

I don’t think it’s up to one parent to decide whether a child gets to have a relationship with the other parent (abuse notwithstanding).

When your child is older and asks why they don’t see their dad, would you be happy to tell them it was because they didn’t give you any money?

Nothappyatwork · 28/06/2022 21:15

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 20:30

@A580Hojas Because money doesn't make you a good or a bad person.
But for my father, I would probably have ended up either in prison or dead.
My mother on the other hand didn't give a shit as long as she could point score.

No but purposely withholding support does. The discussion is about wont pay not can’t pay

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 20:30

@A580Hojas Because money doesn't make you a good or a bad person.
But for my father, I would probably have ended up either in prison or dead.
My mother on the other hand didn't give a shit as long as she could point score.

A580Hojas · 28/06/2022 20:16

My parents divorced in the 1970s and my father was a high earner. I know he paid generous maintenance because when he later got together with his girlfriend she openly moaned in front of me about still having to work. She was in her early 30s at this point and had no children and obviously felt she shouldn't have to work as she'd bagged a high earning much older man.

She went on to have 3 children with him who got everything from my father that I didn't have - time, attention, holidays and Christmasses. Even a share of his will! I was 16 when they had their first child and never received a penny from him after I finished University and never had more than half a day a week contact with him after I was 11 or 12.

Now I know this just wasn't good enough and I don't think of him as a good Dad. I gradually came to this feeling over the years, confirmed for definite when he wrote me out of his will in 2010 (when I was in my late 40s) leaving everything to my step mother and my 3 half siblings.

Your children might look fondly on the absent parent for a while but as they grow up and learn more about the real world ... it could all change.

A580Hojas · 28/06/2022 19:58

It's obviously really difficult, but how can anyone argue that a father is a good father if they don't pay maintenance?

??

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 19:56

@ILikeHotWaterBottles She never gave a reason. They divorced when I was six. She just used to say he didn't want me and other hurtful things about him.
I used to sneak off to see him when I got to be around fourteen without her knowing.
He never said anything bad to me about my mother, even when I was crying about the injustice of it to him.
I found out in my later years that my mother had an affair, which he found out about which led to him leaving.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 28/06/2022 19:43

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 19:37

@ILikeHotWaterBottles I think you're misunderstanding, I adored my father and spending time with him. I resented and never forgave my mother for preventing me from spending time with him.

Oh I did misunderstand, I thought youeant she sent you to your dad and he wasn't nice, like other posters had to deal with. She shouldn't have stopped you if he wasn't abusive, what was her reason?

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 19:37

@ILikeHotWaterBottles I think you're misunderstanding, I adored my father and spending time with him. I resented and never forgave my mother for preventing me from spending time with him.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 28/06/2022 19:29

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 19:10

@ILikeHotWaterBottles I've been that child, the end result was I resented my mother for it and never forgave her.
It is not something I would subject my own kids to.

Exactly my point, I'm sorry she did that to you. People here aren't listening to people like you, who have been forced to spend time with a shit parent. They think they know better

LegInLegOut · 28/06/2022 19:10

@ILikeHotWaterBottles I've been that child, the end result was I resented my mother for it and never forgave her.
It is not something I would subject my own kids to.

Nothappyatwork · 28/06/2022 19:02

blackheartsgirl · 28/06/2022 12:47

I’m more of the let the child slowly make thier own mind up which they often will when they’re older.

my ex is going on holiday to Spain next month and paid for his gf and all of her kids, but he’s skint and can’t afford maintenance this month.

the kids are starting to see through him now

But they won’t call him out on it. They’ll accept the crumbs that he fix their way and think the sun shines out of his arse.

Mum is held to a far higher standard

Whiskeypowers · 28/06/2022 13:48

@FrankLampardsBrokenHand
”And honestly it really sickens me when people use their child to get at another adult.”

which is PRECISELY what nrp are doing when they refuse to pay maintenance.

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 13:37

You argue 'most men do x' based on your own isolated experience?

Anyway, that wasn't the purpose of this thread so it's not really relevant. But comments like this really show the double standard in wanting fathers to step up more but only in the way that is beneficial to mum.

Isaidnoalready · 28/06/2022 13:35

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 13:26

There are also plenty of studies that suggest the opposite. My personal situation proves that it's entirely possible and beneficial to the child, although I realise one example doesn't prove anything, and biomum is an amazing and selfless person which is rarely the case in these types of situations.

Your comment that divorced men 'don't have their own house but rather one with a new woman who rules the roost making the children feel particularly unwelcome' is based on nothing and reeks of bias.

I did not say that the house with the new woman rules the roost making the kids feel unwelcome I said in my personal experience my ex goes from womans house to mummy's house and perhaps I wasn't clear HE says they are not welcome and his MOTHER says they are not welcome with his ex children services said they could not stay at her house with this one who knows I don't know her and I haven't been called by children services as yet so until they do I can only assume she is stable

And again it's based on my personal experience so not based on nothing

QuirkyTurtle · 28/06/2022 13:26

Isaidnoalready · 28/06/2022 11:36

Which comment? The 50/50 one is fairly easy to source there are many non biased sources that claim YOUNG children benefit emotionally from having a solid home base for the early years so more one parent than the other when they are teenagers 50/50 can benefit however by that time they will want their friends more than parents in most cases

If its the comment about the housing its a common theme man and woman seperate man goes back to parents man meets another woman moves in with her etc etc my ex husband has done this many times he has never in 8 years had his children overnight because he doesnt have his own home and they are not welcome where he "stays occasionally" this is a repeated theme that I've seen all too often

There are also plenty of studies that suggest the opposite. My personal situation proves that it's entirely possible and beneficial to the child, although I realise one example doesn't prove anything, and biomum is an amazing and selfless person which is rarely the case in these types of situations.

Your comment that divorced men 'don't have their own house but rather one with a new woman who rules the roost making the children feel particularly unwelcome' is based on nothing and reeks of bias.

whumpthereitis · 28/06/2022 13:13

TiddleyWink · 28/06/2022 07:40

OP I agree with you. I also believe parents who have an affair should forfeit the right to shared custody. They have proven that they aren’t capable of making decisions with their kids’ interests at heart and why on earth should the other parent lose out on a significant chunk of this children’s childhood in order to send said children off to someone who has proven they put their sex life above their children’s secure home life. You always read on here that someone’s ability to be a good parent is separate to their ability to be a good spouse but I completely disagree. Not shagging around and blowing up your children’s home is very much part of being a good parent who puts them first.

I know people generally disagree but that’s my opinion. It’s not in a child’s interests to nurture a relationship with a parent who doesn’t prioritise their wellbeing, be it through providing for their basic material needs or doing everything they can to ensure they have a secure home life.

Would this also apply to those who end a relationship ‘just because’ they’re unhappy? After all, the outcome is the same, the secure home of the children is changed.

Denying someone access to their children should not be punishment for infidelity. It doesn’t just hurt that person, it will hurt the children too if they otherwise have a good relationship with the parent. I’ve seen this in real life, and the children involved (my friend and her brother), while they know their father was wrong to cheat, have never forgiven their mother for responding how she did and depriving them of a relationship (when they were teenagers they were able to contact their father, and ended up both moving in with him). It’s their father they have a relationship with now, not their mother.

Imo linking contact to maintenance is going to end up meaning that more fathers are going to completely check out, rather than pay. While there are men already that don’t pay and have no contact, there are men that don’t pay yet will still maintain a relationship with their child/children, are financially responsible for them when they have them, and at least give the mother a break. So not only does the mother not get maintenance if the father completely checks out, she becomes 100% responsible for the child. No break, and a greater financial burden.

blackheartsgirl · 28/06/2022 12:47

I’m more of the let the child slowly make thier own mind up which they often will when they’re older.

my ex is going on holiday to Spain next month and paid for his gf and all of her kids, but he’s skint and can’t afford maintenance this month.

the kids are starting to see through him now