Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if your automatic car is any good?

140 replies

Wouldloveanother · 27/06/2022 21:56

Planning to buy an automatic in a few weeks (second hand, I’m not made of money!). It needs to fit a toddler car seat in the back so I’m thinking not a hatch back. But ideally quite small and un-fancy.
If you drive an automatic, I would be really grateful for your car reviews!
sorry there wasn’t a ‘car’ section so AIBU it was..

OP posts:
RincewindsHat · 28/06/2022 12:38

2019 Honda Civic automatic, love it. I had a manual car before this and wasn't fussed whether I had automatic or manual as my next car but it's lovely to drive, so much easier for long drives in particular and really why wouldn't you pick automatic over manual?

devonianBiatch · 28/06/2022 12:32

I've got a 2019 be Tiguan Rline tech pack and it's swoony. I anxiety LOVE it. Nice high seating aspect, flappy paddles for a more responsive drive, tons of room, electric EVERYTHING. And it looks gorgeous too.

JudgeRindersMinder · 28/06/2022 12:21

Wouldloveanother · 27/06/2022 22:37

Thanks everyone!
im taking my driving test (automatic) in a few weeks, if I pass I want to buy a car instantly so I don’t ‘lapse’. Budget is maximum £2500, so not much really. I thought a hatchback wouldn’t be great as there’s no door to get kids in and out? Maybe im mistaken there! But really just something easy to drive/park that isn’t mega embarrassing (my dad insisted on a Toyota jimney for my sisters first car, poor thing)

Buy a 5 door hatch then!

Good luck with your test!

FemmeNatal · 28/06/2022 11:56

Wouldloveanother · 28/06/2022 07:59

Thanks for the suggestions everyone wow I didn’t expect so many replies!
ive done some maths and I can afford up to £6,000 (2k deposit, the rest finance). DH wants to get rid of his car so we can pool resources and get something a bit better to share.
ive seen a Nissan note with very low mileage and reasonable price, I’ll keep an eye on that and have a look for some other cars mentioned here.

Make sure you get to try before you buy.

Some small-engined automatics have very bad performance, and hesitant gearboxes, which can make pulling out and joining traffic quite unpleasant.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/06/2022 11:49

At £6000k you could definitely have afforded our old car which was a black 2010 Volvo s40 5 wheel drive .Leather seats, lovely interior - 92,000 miles - full service history- went for £3850 at 9 years old in 2019 - even with the second hand uplift it would probably still be about the same - Volvos are well built workhorses with great auto gearboxes

Lemonyfuckit · 28/06/2022 08:16

sjxoxo · 27/06/2022 22:20

LOVE automatics. Dream to drive.

I have a little Mercedes A class 2012, so it’s the old shape. I love love love it. It’s unbelievably big inside for such a small car on the outside!
I had a baby like you needed car with 4 doors and space for buggy and baby seat. I absolutely love it. It’s the old shape - they went really sporty with the A class after 2012 and I’m not a fan of the new models! For some reason there’s quite a lot like mine from 2012 with really low mileage and not expensive either imo. Have a look on autotrader! Mine has self park & sat nav, all seats fold flat, boot expands.. they’ve thought of everything. After 2012 the model changed dramatically so I can’t comment on those but I’d recommend a 2012 even if they’re a bit old! Mines done hardly any miles- 40,000.

On the other end of the space spectrum DH has a BMW X5 also automatic. V comfortable to drive but does feel like you’re driving a tank. Expensive to fill too.

hope you enjoy your automatic! Xx

We have a Mercedes A class automatic too. Quite new (don't know the year maybe 2020) and AMG so quite sporty, but really comfortable, spacious etc. SO easy to drive, wouldn't go back to a manual. That one is really economical on petrol too if drive it in eco mode.

chocolatemademefat · 28/06/2022 08:13

I have an automatic Nissan Duke and I love it. I wouldn’t go back to manual and the Duke is a great size. Roomy enough inside and quite nippy - doesn’t cost a fortune at the pumps either.

DontKeepTheFaith · 28/06/2022 08:11

Mini Cooper s automatic here, it’s amazing. So easy to drive and very nippy. I love it.

I drive a Kia hybrid thing at work and that is awful to drive, very slow to accelerate and the satnav is shit.

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 28/06/2022 08:10

Love my automatic. I drive manual Cara at work each day and hate it. I've had automatic for years and much prefer them. Dh has always had manual as he says he prefers them.

CredibilityProblem · 28/06/2022 08:08

Six grand sounds a lot more manageable than two and a half. Do a spreadsheet comparing road tax, average fuel costs, parking permits, and insurance costs. Brace yourself for insurance costs with a brand new driver and no NCD, but at least you're not a teenager.

Rockbird · 28/06/2022 08:03

I've always had a Focus, currently an auto estate but we've just got rid of a 57 plate Focus auto which was fab and a complete workhorse. DH just unilaterally decided we didn't need a second car...Hmm

Wouldloveanother · 28/06/2022 07:59

Thanks for the suggestions everyone wow I didn’t expect so many replies!
ive done some maths and I can afford up to £6,000 (2k deposit, the rest finance). DH wants to get rid of his car so we can pool resources and get something a bit better to share.
ive seen a Nissan note with very low mileage and reasonable price, I’ll keep an eye on that and have a look for some other cars mentioned here.

OP posts:
Remainiac · 28/06/2022 07:55

daytimedreams · 27/06/2022 22:21

automatic Volkswagen Golf.

absolute dream

Same. Had the GTD first, now have R. Love them.

ImustLearn2Cook · 28/06/2022 07:49

@Wouldloveanother on your budget you’ll be buying an older car. I think your dad is right on suggesting a Toyota because in my experience they have longevity.

Maybe start another thread asking people who own an older model vehicle what their experience has been on how much it has cost them to maintain their vehicle. How reliable it has been.

Buying an older model car, you really need to know how reliable it is. In terms of quality and reliability I don’t think there will be much difference between the manual and automatic versions of the same make and model car.

PP are right, manual is cheaper to buy than an automatic car.

So, read some reviews online about the specific make and model including it’s date of manufacture that you’ve seen advertised within your price range. You might find reviews that say I’ve had this car for 20 years and it’s still running well and not needed major mechanical repairs. Or you may find reviews saying that this or that major mechanical failing that was this expensive to fix happened after only 5 years.

Some cars have typical things that go wrong with them after they reach a certain amount of kilometres.

You really just need to carefully research each car you are interested in. Make sure there is a service history of the car you want to buy and find out what repairs it’s had. Look at the odometer, how many kilometres has it driven.

30not13 · 28/06/2022 07:49

Bigger than you want but VW tiguan.

Mine is 69 plate but there are older versions they've been around a long while.

First auto and cannot fault it

huuskymam · 28/06/2022 07:34

I bought a hybrid Honda fit last year, great car all round. 50 euro a month for petrol. Small but not squashed. And the back seats fold down completely which is so handy when I'm doing a food shop. The only problem is it would be hard to fit a pram in the boot of needed, my youngest is 12 so we're way past baby/toddler stages. I'll definitely be sticking to automatic hybrids.

pcosandme.x · 28/06/2022 07:33

Depends on the gearbox.

Do your research - it's an expensive fix.

I just changed back to manual as my gearbox in my last car had an ECU malfunction and cost me £1k to fix.

10storeylovesong · 28/06/2022 07:31

I have an auto Mazda 2. It looks tiny on the outside but it fits a toddler seat and a booster seat, and the boot is surprisingly spacious when I needed a pram. It's now filled with camping chairs and various sporting equipment for ferrying my boys around. I used to work at Enterprise Rent a Car and there were some awful autos that felt really clunky when changing gear, but I can honestly say I can't even tell when this changes.

ChagSameachDoreen · 28/06/2022 07:29

I love mine.

It's an Astra from 2009 that I bought for £1,500 two years ago, and it's a great little car.

Would never go back to a manual.

TartanGirl1 · 28/06/2022 07:27

I have an automatic Mercedes A Class, love it. So easy to drive and the most economical car I have ever owned.

Angrymum22 · 28/06/2022 07:25

I have been driving autos for a while. Just bought a VW Polo for DS who is learning to drive ( multiple reasons why he is learning in an auto) . It is a fabulous little car. I don’t really drive little cars but it is really economical (45-50 mpg), very nippy, and has apple CarPlay so I can listen to my play lists. I’ve driven it on the motorway and it easily cruises at 70.
It has a sports setting and a tiptronic gear box so is classified as semi automatic.
Unfortunately if DS passes his test this week I won’t get to drive it as much.

SavoirFlair · 28/06/2022 07:25

CredibilityProblem · 28/06/2022 07:18

We had an automatic five door hatchback Ford Focus when we were at the toddler stage, it did the job perfectly well and we replaced it with a newer version ten years later. I'm surprised to be the first person to mention the Focus, because there's loads about. Google talks about transmission problems but there weren't on either of ours.

The Focus models with the automatic transmission model problems were from 2010-2016

once again, the OP has a budget of £2500 which would realistically only get her into the 2000-2009 models - there’s possibly a couple of the 2010s which will be cheap enough but very high mileage

lady725516 · 28/06/2022 07:24

Wouldloveanother · 27/06/2022 22:37

Thanks everyone!
im taking my driving test (automatic) in a few weeks, if I pass I want to buy a car instantly so I don’t ‘lapse’. Budget is maximum £2500, so not much really. I thought a hatchback wouldn’t be great as there’s no door to get kids in and out? Maybe im mistaken there! But really just something easy to drive/park that isn’t mega embarrassing (my dad insisted on a Toyota jimney for my sisters first car, poor thing)

We have a auto golf and wouldn't be without it.

I work in car sales and you may struggle with your budget. Autos are more expensive than manuals so there won't be much choice out there for you.
You may find getting a car on finance a better option if you want a car which is going to be reliable

Good luck on your test op!!

wonkylegs · 28/06/2022 07:20

Both our cars are currently automatic but probably bigger & more expensive than you want
We have a Land Rover DS and an electric iPace which are both fantastic to drive
I did used to have an automatic VW golf which was also great to drive.
I swapped because my hips and knees are damaged due to RA so it was getting very hard to operate a clutch but also electric cars are automatic so that's the direction of travel.

CredibilityProblem · 28/06/2022 07:18

We had an automatic five door hatchback Ford Focus when we were at the toddler stage, it did the job perfectly well and we replaced it with a newer version ten years later. I'm surprised to be the first person to mention the Focus, because there's loads about. Google talks about transmission problems but there weren't on either of ours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread