Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find that working in a school really puts me off having children?

132 replies

ElephantePicante · 27/06/2022 21:28

I love my job but corr blimey what a form of contraception it is. The genuine mental health issues where children can't get through their daily timetable without 20 time outs and check ins, the students who MUST be escorted from the front gate because they can't possibly walk 2 minutes on their own, the competitive (and questionable) mental health issues about self harm and who has the worst anxiety, the bullying over snap chat, the not recognising that they're nervous for a test (which is normal) and not suffering from an anxiety disorder, the parents who demand that their child isn't possibly absconding from lesson and there must be a genuine reason why their little angel isn't in class, the school refusers, the teachers verbally abused by snowflakey parents at the gate, the parents who find it outrageous that their child gets a sanction for forgetting their P.E. bag. I could go on. Friends who work in Primaries have equally enlightening stories. It's all sad and exhausting at the same time and really makes you stop and think about whether you want to condemn yourself to it all. Nobody holds their gorgeous newborn and thinks they'll turn out to be hard work and the cause of 10 phone calls a week from school.

OP posts:
ballonsinhightrees · 29/06/2022 06:25

"It's not about the time it takes to print one sheet on peach paper.

It's (I would estimate) 100% additional time needed to get these students through an hour's lesson.

I do it, because I'm extremely fond of them, and because it's my job. But don't you dare tell me it's not a lot of extra work."

Very well said @HereBeFuckery, most teachers do want to do their best by all students but the increasing demands on time are making it impossible and causing resentment.
I teach 14 KS3 classes, each class averages 5 registered SEN and about 10 more with other issues; then I have my exam classes on top. That is around 500 people per week whose individual needs I must remember and balance without disadvantaging others.
Then I have my own family whose needs are neglected because there is no time. I haven't seen or spoken to my parents in 6 weeks as every weekend has been school activities eg sports competitions, D of E, exam revision etc.
It sounds easy 'just put the right colour paper in the printer', but that is one child's needs, we are dealing with hundreds.
I would not change jobs ever, it is a standing joke that even if I won the lottery I would still be in front of my classes, but a lack of resilience amongst students is beginning to take its toll on the profession.

schratching · 29/06/2022 06:18

You deal with all the problems so your view is slightly skewed.

It's overwhelming though. You don't have to have kids.

SummerPuddings · 29/06/2022 06:12

oakleaffy · 27/06/2022 22:40

''Competitive anxiety''

Had to laugh at this :)

Is the competitive anxiety, a result of how we are treating it as a society?

SummerPuddings · 29/06/2022 06:10

I don't think you should be a teacher op.

HereBeFuckery · 29/06/2022 05:57

Crocsandshocks · 28/06/2022 20:09

Also the point stands that the bank statement, loan application or passport forms don't come in open dyslexic don't on a peach background....the kids are being helped at school but the gulf to "real life" then gets even wider

So you want to make things as difficult as possible so they will be ready for the battles they will face in adulthood. That's not fair. You should be helping them progress in their literacy not providing extra hurdles. And how long does it really take to provide a different coloured paper or a different background on the screen? They are not making their disability up you know!

How long does it take? Okay, let me see if I can give you a flavour.

I have a y10 class where 3 students have an EHCP, so there are two LSAs in the room. That's two people I have to brief about the lesson content, in advance of the lesson. Every lesson. About 10 mins per LSA, per lesson, so 20 mins per lesson, x 4 lessons a week. We have to talk through the lesson content, the outcomes needed and how to get those kids there.

Then I have another six students with SEN.

One needs everything printed in A3. That takes and extra 5-15 mins - setting up the increased size on the printer, walking to a different block where the printer that spits out A3 is, waiting on the print queue, walking back. So, say 10 mins per lesson x 4 lessons.

2 hrs so far!

There are three students who need me to re write the task instructions in large font, in very short sentences, well spaced, and print for them. Say 5 mins per lesson, again, x 4 lessons per week.

The other two need me to change any writing activity into something more approachable - so instead of 'write three paragraphs' it's 'full in the gaps in para 1, use these sentence stems in para 2 to complete it, and use this word bank in para 3 to finish. Say another 10 mins per lesson.

We're up to 3 hours of extra preparation per week for the 4 hours I teach them.

Now add in the 20 mins or so a week I spend on the phone to parents of that class, some of whom have behavioural issues, the 10-15 per week printing all work for the week for a student who is excluded/secluded or refusing school.

It's not about the time it takes to print one sheet on peach paper.

It's (I would estimate) 100% additional time needed to get these students through an hour's lesson.

I do it, because I'm extremely fond of them, and because it's my job. But don't you dare tell me it's not a lot of extra work.

kateandme · 29/06/2022 05:11

pastaandpesto · 28/06/2022 06:24

@WonderingWanda

Becoming a parent has made me more aware of where parents get it wrong even when they are trying to get it right and it actually making life harder for their own kids.

Would you be able to expand on this a bit, wondering? As a parent who is trying to do the right thing but often feels like I'm failing, I'd be really interested to have a teachers perspective on what helps teens and what is actually counterproductive!

(especially any tips on dealing with capable but academically lazy teen boys)

I'd say give them cooking too.if you get them to be given the money and go get tea and cook it or start smaller and say it's such and such for tea can you help out tonight.or help out with you.
And then praaaaaise to the rooftops. Boys especially really seem to come into their own around cheffing it up😊.it was a real turning point.from Bolognese to plate swipes of sauce and stacks of chips and fancy lamb chops piles!. They loved it.its gets their heads out of lazy but also gets them excited and then they love the praise. And learning to cook is something they and you will appreciate for life.
Talk to them.keep talking.
Arguments can be really diffused with a note under their doors.
Asking for help rather than making it their job.so shit I've so much to do so you think you could help me out this washing on. A few times of doing this helps them feel useful.
Tell don't ask.stand firm but don't get into a slangung match if you can or make it about what they don't do.ir being up last week's fuck up to berate them with again.
Talk in the car when your both facing the front.
Fuel and sleep.

kateandme · 29/06/2022 04:57

MummaTrinee · 27/06/2022 21:43

Haha, sounds like my daughter 😂

Well to add a side note here. you've got OCD totally wrong so maybe you should watch some videos.part of the problem is the "messy" thinking behind a serious disabling illness.your daughter could have a like up in her room and have the worse OCD out.its not oh I'm so obsessively tidy I'm OCD.that thinking needs to change.

beautyisthefaceisee · 28/06/2022 20:22

Oestrogelsmuggler · 28/06/2022 06:19

She reserved the mocking for the parents - which I think is fair enough.

No.

Crocsandshocks · 28/06/2022 20:09

Also the point stands that the bank statement, loan application or passport forms don't come in open dyslexic don't on a peach background....the kids are being helped at school but the gulf to "real life" then gets even wider

So you want to make things as difficult as possible so they will be ready for the battles they will face in adulthood. That's not fair. You should be helping them progress in their literacy not providing extra hurdles. And how long does it really take to provide a different coloured paper or a different background on the screen? They are not making their disability up you know!

Pinkrollercoaster · 28/06/2022 17:03

I'm the opposite. I loved working in schools pre children but now I've had my own I can't bear the thought of all day then all night and weekend with kids!

GuyFawkesDay · 28/06/2022 17:01

@Crocsandshocks yes it is, however it takes HOURS to prep it, which teachers aren't given)

Also the point stands that the bank statement, loan application or passport forms don't come in open dyslexic don't on a peach background....the kids are being helped at school but the gulf to "real life" then gets even wider

Sleepingsatellite1 · 28/06/2022 16:51

Isausernameavailable · 28/06/2022 00:27

You are clearly in the wrong job. Go and do something that matters to you, for people you don't despise and probably don't have kids as you would probably be a bit shit at it

How dramatic

Sleepingsatellite1 · 28/06/2022 16:49

beautyisthefaceisee · 27/06/2022 23:14

Erm - I can only hope you don't actually work in a school, with the open mocking of pupils and their needs on an internet forum.

What you say behind closed doors is one thing, but these are peoples' children, and if this ever got traced back to you you wouldn't need to worry about working in a school.

She clearly says she does.

Crocsandshocks · 28/06/2022 14:54

I have one class where I need to project my screen with all of a yellow, blue, pink and green background to allow for every child with mild dyslexia to be able to "access" the writing on the board. I increasingly get confronted by children who, from one day to the next, "can't read" the writing of a piece of text, because it has the wrong colour background

Hmm, isn't this called inclusivity? Empathy labs can give you a sense of what it's like to live with these conditions. You should try one and see (I'm not being goady here BTW).

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 28/06/2022 09:24

I was a secondary teacher for 26 years. The kids were amazing. I loved them. Just so funny, hilarious even. All the time. Lots of separate personalities growing up. They were just the best.

And fwiw my dd has severe anxiety issues. Covid did for her.

StottyCakeandJam · 28/06/2022 09:19

@Morph22010 I also have a SEN child but that’s not what I was referring to. I was referring to the parents who have children who are doing well, have friends, are enjoying school yet their parents continuously complain. If their child has a bad day, it’s the end of the world. If they get told off, it’s ruined their life. If they don’t get the main part in the school play, it’s not fair and is knocking their confidence. Life is full of hard knocks and it’s a parent’s job to help children learn to negotiate these things as they grow so that they can deal with all that life will throw at them as adults. I don’t believe the Op was referring to children with genuine issues or needs and not was I! 😉

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 07:50

@WonderingWanda you said you are not talking about kids with additional needs but how do you know which are which unless you are basing on diagnosis/sen register alone? My child is asd and now (thankfully) out of mainstream and in specialist but im still on a lot of parents groups. There are a lot of undiagnosed sen kids and generally parents always know their child best, and as I said unthread unless you advocate for your sen child you’ll get no where and thst goes from initial diagnosis through yo support in school. Do my question is how do you know the difference between parents thst are genuinely advocating for their undiagnosed sen child and parents thst are being over anxious abs their child is fine

SheWoreYellow · 28/06/2022 07:47

OP, you’re not seeing the good bits.

My DD is 14 and has had a fairly tough time with school, being out for a term and moving school. So I’m really happy with how she’s doing now, but you won’t see this.
You won’t see her coming home and telling me about the funny things that happened at school. You won’t see her being nervous about a speaking German test and then doing really well in it. You won’t see her going to maths support sessions and then ‘getting’ it. You only see the problematic bits.

WonderingWanda · 28/06/2022 07:40

pastaandpesto · 28/06/2022 06:24

@WonderingWanda

Becoming a parent has made me more aware of where parents get it wrong even when they are trying to get it right and it actually making life harder for their own kids.

Would you be able to expand on this a bit, wondering? As a parent who is trying to do the right thing but often feels like I'm failing, I'd be really interested to have a teachers perspective on what helps teens and what is actually counterproductive!

(especially any tips on dealing with capable but academically lazy teen boys)

Hi pastaandpesto, I'm not sure I can provide any magical advice for teenage boys. I imagine you are doing it all anyway. I think I was really referring to parents who either systematically over react or underreact to issues with their children. The ones who fail to believe their child would just sit there doing no work and it must be my fault or another students fault somehow, their child never alters their poor behvaviour. Or the ones who don't help to build resilliance in their kids, asking for special arrangements at the first sign of a nervous tummy ache. Their kids can't cope and their anxiety escalates till they are unable to sit in a classroom. I get it, as a parent we want to protect our kids and I'm not talking about kids with additional needs.

Anyway, lazy teen boys. Try to be consistent in rewards and sanctions (not too big, not too small). Don't be the parent who won't confiscate the xbox because they won't like you but maybe don't make that the first punishment. Back up the school as much as you can. Make sure they eat breakfast, get enough sleep (phones downstairs), get enough activity even if it's just you making them walk. Take them to visit colleges and /or universities if applicable so they can see the goal /aspire to more. Don't give up parenting because they look old enough to behave like adults, they still need you.

ChagSameachDoreen · 28/06/2022 07:35

You need to get a job in a better school!

AnIckabog · 28/06/2022 07:22

I've lost it now but @Dancingwithhyenas post about how it isn't parenting - isn't that exactly the OPs point? That she knows from working with children that having children with high needs is a gamble, not something you can parent your way out of? And that it isn't a minority of children anymore but a significant proportion.
Agree entirely with the social contagion. It has been fuelled by the internet and had caused so many problems that wouldn't have existed. And of course, once a child tells themself they have anxiety and it is validated by an adult they end up with anxiety!

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 07:17

balalake · 28/06/2022 07:01

I would suggest that knowing all the lies and excuses you hear, it would make you determined if you had a child that they would be brought up reasonably.

Whst if her child has asd, would she just sit back and say nothing and let the school get on with things and do nothing. Unfortunately the way the sen system works unless you fight and advocate for your child you’ll get no where, I know of many children where parents have trusted the school and now children are out of school completely and not even going out at all, how is thst going to help their adult life? I’m not blaming the schools abs teachers as they are in an impossible situation and I can see why they want to concentrate their efforts and funds on the many rather than a few, it’s the whole way sen funding works in mainstream that’s the issue, thankfully I’m out of it now

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 07:12

@ThrallsWife i can see what you are saying to a certain extent however it’s hard enough having a child with sen and parent blaming really doesn’t help and is something thst Is common with mainstream teachers. My child has asd and can have big meltdowns abs I remember his year 2 teacher having a go at me because he was emotional and I just needed to talk to him about emotions (like it’s something I’d never thought to do before), he also used to get tired at school and I was told I just needed to put him to bed earlier and all issues would be solved. School supposedly put things in place like introducing a communication book so thst I could communicate any issues for the day to try and reduce issues and meltdowns but the teacher never read it and told me she had 30 kids in the class and didn’t have time to read a book. I accept this but why suggest putting things in place if they are not doable in practise then continue to parent and child blame when things don’t work. Mines now in specialist so was probably fairly extreme for a ms child but it would have been a lot less stressful to have worked with the school rather than the constant parent blame

Penguinsaregreat · 28/06/2022 07:07

Totally agree op.
I'd had my children before I worked in a school. Until you have worked there you cannot imagine what it is like and how bad some parents and their children are.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 28/06/2022 07:03

It’s because there is a rising mental health crisis with kids
it’s getting worse not better
and everything is put on the school to handle
its madness and not sustainable

schools are not funded to handle most of the issues you flag

that said being a parent of a kid with mental health issues is far from fulfilling