Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids may be kids but also need to take responsibility

110 replies

Stinkyfirecracker · 27/06/2022 20:05

We are very lucky to be able to get top end equipment when we decide to purchase something. This does mean that when our daughters school said she could have a lap top to help her with certain lessons, we got her a £1,000 worth of laptop as it seemed to fit the bill the best.

She has come home tonight and it is very damaged. She dropped it and it may have to be replaced.

She has an account she knows about with over £1k in it. Would it be unfair to ask for her to help (to the tune of maybe 25%) towards the costs of replacement.

We can replace it easily but I am just wondering about the principle of such a lesson making her value what she’s got and being less casual. After all, a contribution like that wouldn’t drain the account (and actually she has a lot more in accounts she doesn’t even know about like isa’s and pensions) but it would be a dent and she is very concerned about net worth and saving so it would hit her.

Is this a lesson you would teach your child at this age? And yes, she’s only 11 so this is why I am hesitant.

OP posts:
MrsToothyBitch · 28/06/2022 07:57

I'd buy a less expensive bit of kit for school and insure it properly for starters. She's 11 and it appears to be accidental. Let her learn from YOUR mistake and show her the problems you've caused yourself.

If it happened at school is there any chance you can claim it on the school's insurance? I broke my mum's digital camera at my school VI leavers ball. I stepped back to take a picture and get people in shot, slipped in unseen spilt booze under my stiletto heel in the dark and went down flat on my back- hard and fast. The hand I flung out to save myself unfortunately had the camera in it and the lense was fucked. When my mum stopped screaming abuse at me on the phone a friend reminded her the school had insurance, we were still covered and it was on school premises. They sorted my mum out with a replacement and I don't have a back or neck injury or get concussion. Win win.

snowmanshoes · 28/06/2022 07:57

It depends- when you bought it did you give her the option of a cheaper laptop? Explain if it got damaged she’d be expected to contribute to repairs/replacement? If no, then I think you’re being unreasonable but if yes, well then you have your answer.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 28/06/2022 07:56

Cheaper and better for the environment to repair it if at all possible. If its a decent brand name machine it can almost certainly be fixed.

Trixiefirecracker · 28/06/2022 07:54

I think the lesson is on you.no child needs a £1000 laptop. Get a cheaper one. No need to make the child pay, it was an accident!

NeedMoreMilk · 28/06/2022 07:54

Don’t make her pay for it. It’s not her fault you chose to buy her a very expensive piece of equipment and you could claim it on your insurance if you wanted to.

It’s up to you whether there should be a separate consequence for it getting broken though, which surely depends on whether it was a genuine accident or whether she was messing about with it at the time? If she literally just dropped it by accident it would be very unfair to punish her.

resuwen · 28/06/2022 07:51

I'm not sure I understand the issue. Next time you send the butler to the family vault to pick up some bullion, why not just have him pick one up on the way back?

Xanthe68 · 28/06/2022 07:50

Am guessing it’s an independent school.

user2908143823142536475859708 · 28/06/2022 07:49

Why is the school not providing a laptop for her.

If she needs it as support for specific lessons then the la should be providing one for her.

Maireas · 28/06/2022 07:46

This is odd.
If the school has encouraged her to use a laptop then they provide it.
Schools actively dissuade students (unless post 16) from bringing in expensive pieces of equipment.
For obvious reasons.
She needs a laptop? School provides.

frazzledasarock · 28/06/2022 07:45

I wouldn’t spend more than £500 for a laptop they’re taking into school, I know for a fact one of mine would lose it immediately she’s utterly ditzy.

I would make her pay towards it, maybe she’ll be more careful, get a hard shell cover for the laptop so when she drops it again it’s at least protected a bit.

Xanthe68 · 28/06/2022 07:40

Unless she broke it mucking about , I wouldn’t expect her to pay. Get insurance next time. School kids do break and lose things occasionally, even when they’re taking reasonable care.

Have you looked into whether it can be repaired?

Unlike others, I don’t think you’re mad to have bought an expensive laptop. My kids have Macs, as do I, because I think they’re worth paying for. But you can’t buy an expensive computer, fail to insure it and then kvetch about completely foreseeable replacement costs.

Pretzerella · 28/06/2022 07:30

Stinkyfirecracker · 27/06/2022 21:12

I said high end because I know I don’t live in a real world.

Have you just troll hunted yourself 🫢

Fraaahnces · 28/06/2022 04:24

How much extra would your home insurance cost? Maybe some of that could be reimbursed by your child. I think 11 year olds absolutely should be taking some of the responsibility for damage if it’s their fault due to carelessness, etc.

Fizzyfish · 28/06/2022 04:21

manysummersago · 27/06/2022 20:15

I don’t think an eleven year old should have been given such an expensive laptop.

I agree

Aria999 · 28/06/2022 02:20

Totally beside the point of the thread but if you're not going to claim that kind of thing on insurance you can save a lot of money by significantly increasing the excess.

We cut our home insurance cost in half that way recently (because I never like claiming the small stuff so why pay as if you are going to).

Littleraindrop15 · 27/06/2022 23:20

hey OP I think you shouldn't charge her for this it was an accident and I don't think the price tag would of made a difference in her dropping at her age.

I do think you paid a lot for a laptop and I personally would of gone for something slightly cheaper as a lot of things can happen like it can get stolen, left on the bus and dropped like this time.

I dont think there's a lesson for her to be learnt she was remorseful and that's the most important.

lljkk · 27/06/2022 23:20

This reminds me of stories DC told about kids dropping their new phones to deliberately break them & get a newer better phone.

fairybaby · 27/06/2022 23:18

I learned early on to not get top of the line equipment ( or clothing, shoes, etc) for my kids. It’s not worth the hassle. I expect my kids to look after their stuff and should they break anything, they will get a chance to replace it or get it fix. Now, because the stuff they have is of good quality yet affordable, they can do figure out how to replace it themselves.That way they buy-in the “teachable moment”, so it’s more meaningful.

easyday · 27/06/2022 23:11

Jeez do you think she did it on purpose? Have you never dropped anything?
If she did it again I'd be replacing it with a much cheaper model, but accidents happen and I don't see why she should be punished.
My son was careless with his phone, and also naturally clumsy. I definitely had any electrical equipment he had insured, and he would pay the excess if it got broken a second time, plus it wouldn't be replaced immediately. If he broke a controller in a fit of FIFA rage, then he did without. But he wasn't 11.

FunLovinGal · 27/06/2022 23:10

She does indeed need to be taught a lesson and sounds very spoiled and entitled! I would make her pay for the full repair from her pension pot. If it can’t be fixed, I’d replace it with a really untrendy one that she’ll feel embarrassed by. That’ll teach her.

AmbushedByCake1 · 27/06/2022 23:04

This definitely happened.

Vionnet · 27/06/2022 22:41

Oh for goodness sake. It was a question @Vionnet. At the end of the day accidents happen but equally, as in everything in life, someone can impact whether or not they are more likely or less. I have got it wouldn’t be appropriate. Give it a rest now

Weird, eh? You post in AIBU and people comment and ask questions. I was trying to glean information beyond 'dropped it.'

Since you've still not answered how it happened - other than 'dropped it' - how can anyone actually say whether YABU to take money from your DD for it?

That's literally the whole point of your thread.

sunlight81 · 27/06/2022 22:38

*gadget

sunlight81 · 27/06/2022 22:38

Buy a new one and ask her to contribute whatever the excess would be on gadget insurance. Then get facet insurance for this one.

WimpoleHat · 27/06/2022 22:32

We are very lucky to be able to get top end equipment when we decide to purchase something.

Just because you’re able to doesn’t always mean it’s the best idea. I’m always very conscious with kids that things get broken/lost more easily, so I don’t get them things that I’d regard as top end or expensive for that reason. Things do go missing and get broken at school and it’s not always wholly in the kids’ control. I’d always buy functional rather than top end for them on that basis, on the expectation that things need replacing more often.