Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids may be kids but also need to take responsibility

110 replies

Stinkyfirecracker · 27/06/2022 20:05

We are very lucky to be able to get top end equipment when we decide to purchase something. This does mean that when our daughters school said she could have a lap top to help her with certain lessons, we got her a £1,000 worth of laptop as it seemed to fit the bill the best.

She has come home tonight and it is very damaged. She dropped it and it may have to be replaced.

She has an account she knows about with over £1k in it. Would it be unfair to ask for her to help (to the tune of maybe 25%) towards the costs of replacement.

We can replace it easily but I am just wondering about the principle of such a lesson making her value what she’s got and being less casual. After all, a contribution like that wouldn’t drain the account (and actually she has a lot more in accounts she doesn’t even know about like isa’s and pensions) but it would be a dent and she is very concerned about net worth and saving so it would hit her.

Is this a lesson you would teach your child at this age? And yes, she’s only 11 so this is why I am hesitant.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maireas · 02/07/2022 13:39

Wheelz46 · 29/06/2022 06:46

Jeez a laptop for school? I can just imagine the school parent pages, instead of asking if anyone has accidentally taken Tommy's jumper home, it will be full of irate parents demanding where the kids £1000 laptop has disappeared to!

Indeed - that's why we don't allow students to bring them in. I have no idea why the OP's child has taken it in!

Davethecat2001 · 29/06/2022 22:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NumberTheory · 29/06/2022 07:12

My 12 yr old broke the screen on her laptop. She wasn't being careful with it and has history of not being careful. We paid for the repair as part of her Christmas present. She's been a lot more careful since.

I think accidents do happen and a laptop at school is obviously at a reasonable amount of risk, some of which she won't be able to help. Some of which will just be her doing things that you would also do (or maybe a bit riskier since she's 11). If she needs the laptop for school that's not really risk she has chosen to take on and the cost of financing that risk is an expense to do with her education just like buying the laptop in the first place. If there is also more risk because she's cavalier about it's safety then I think you're looking at something that is more her fault.

Since you can afford it, I would make the decision about whether to have her contribute towards repair on the basis of how sensible she is with it as a general rule.

SeptemberAlexandra · 29/06/2022 07:06

YABU - It was an accident and that is the risk you take with any item of value. My child has a device specific to their disability which cost £4,500 which is taken to school each day. It’s been damaged twice and both times repairs were in excess of £100. I wouldn’t entertain taking this money from my child.

Wheelz46 · 29/06/2022 06:46

Jeez a laptop for school? I can just imagine the school parent pages, instead of asking if anyone has accidentally taken Tommy's jumper home, it will be full of irate parents demanding where the kids £1000 laptop has disappeared to!

PinkSyCo · 29/06/2022 06:09

I see no harm in asking her to pay some money towards a new laptop. She needs to learn that money doesn’t grow on trees in order to respect her possessions. Did she ask you to buy such an expensive laptop though? You were silly to spend so much on it. Maybe charge her 25% of a more sensibly priced one that you should have got her, and make her earn the money if you really want to impress upon her the value of it.

Fraaahnces · 29/06/2022 01:44

I’d get a reconditioned one and get her to pay for a proper padded bag.

bridgetreilly · 28/06/2022 18:08

You get (a less expensive) new laptop, she pays for the protective case for it, not from a savings account but earning money from chores.

zingally · 28/06/2022 17:16

You were foolish to buy an 11 year old a £1000 laptop. She absolutely DOES NOT need something like that for school. You could have got something more than adequate for half that.

She's only 11, she shouldn't be made to pay. Accidents happen. But replace it with something more reasonable for a child.

Johnnysgirl · 28/06/2022 15:27

Stinkyfirecracker · 27/06/2022 21:12

I said high end because I know I don’t live in a real world.

🤣🤣🤣

nowlook · 28/06/2022 12:51

I think this is a valuable lesson. When she comes to month-end, this is going to hit cashflow (unless she's already accrued for it?). Could make for a disappointing Q2.

Herejustforthisone · 28/06/2022 10:28

Ha, just saw the net worth thing. Must be a wind up.

Favouritefruits · 28/06/2022 09:35

You DD hasn’t dropped it on purpose. I’m not really sure why she’s got a £1k laptop surely at that age they only need a cheap one for homework. It’s a lot of responsibility to look after something so expensive at age 11.

Herejustforthisone · 28/06/2022 09:13

An eleven year old taking a grand’s worth of MacBook to school. Hmm. Did you at least put it in a robust case?

Is she so used to have ‘top end’ everything that can be easily replaced, that she doesn’t value things?

Crazyhousewife · 28/06/2022 09:10

At 11 she understands about looking after her items. I’m presuming she is in secondary school or about to go into it. I would ask her how it happened and if she had been dropping it, depending on the damage if it has happened more than once. I would be asking her to pay for a replacement but get her to look at the laptops and pay for it. She needs to understand not to be so careless. My 10 year old son is also facing similar consequences with his television after he threw a remote at it and damaged the screen. This has now meant a loss of pocket money next month but I will be handing him the money to pay for it so he understands that it is a lot to pay out and also once he hands over that money he may be more responsible for his possessions and take better care with them.

SlashBeef · 28/06/2022 08:56

Her net worth 😆

onlythreenow · 28/06/2022 08:36

*worrying

onlythreenow · 28/06/2022 08:35

it would be a dent and she is very concerned about net worth and saving so it would hit her

Wow, poor kid. An eleven year old should not be worring about "net worth"

TheTeenageYears · 28/06/2022 08:23

When our DC wanted apple products rather than something else which would do the job we contributed to rather than bought so they could see exactly how much they cost and I also said I wasn't prepared to underwrite the liability of expensive gadgets at a young age so they needed to buy insurance for them or accept when something happened to them they paid the price. They got a free pass on a phone screen once but that's all. When DS broke an ipad screen he had to pay to repair. I completely understand teaching the value of money but unless like mine she begged for the (i'm going to say MacBook Air) rather than another perfectly suitable laptop then it's down to you. If you don't want to use household insurance take out the cover available when you buy a product. An 11 year old should not be concerned about net worth. I don't think it matters which world you move in, that is not an appropriate concern for an 11 year old and has been very much learned from you or her school/social network.

Xanthe68 · 28/06/2022 08:21

I second the padded bag idea. I think schools aren’t really set up for pupils carrying a grand’s worth of tech around with them (for obvious reasons)- eg at my kids’ school they all have to leave their bags outside the lunch hall in a pile and things get damaged or people accidentally pick up the wrong bag all the time.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 08:17

A few things. My DD is 16. A kind and conscientious person but perhaps due to teenage brain and perhaps so much in her head - with school work has by accident cracked numerous screens over the past four years. Given the amount of time they have spent on online work, the heavy use the things have and given the issues some teenagers have to grapple with I'm choosing my battles. I don't believe it has been deliberate its a learning curve.

Yes to a cheaper (and/or refurbished model)

Make friends with an old style repair shop which offer them refurbished at lower prices.

They will repair screens. Note: some companies screens are easier and cheaper to repair than others.

As others have said - sometimes it is not worth paying the excess on insurance and sometimes compainies like HP don't actually cover accidental damage anyway so I found that their care packages were fairly rubbish (there may be better ones out there).

There are also companies like Byteback in Bristol where you can donate/purchase broken laptops/buy refurbished items.

Finally, make sure they have a rucksack/bag with a proper - padded and correct size in the back.

This doesn't solve the dropping problem - but does solve the dropping the rucksack on the floor issue!

SnowyPetals · 28/06/2022 08:14

Nope, poor parenting choice on your part. Do not send children into school with over-specced technology and then be annoyed when accidents happen. Get her a laptop that's sufficient for her needs and no more. Then get it insured. Sure, if she'd deliberately chucked it under a bus there would be consequences but otherwise it's just normal damage to school kit, like ripping a hole in their blazer by catching it whilst running.

Choopi · 28/06/2022 08:11

My ds needs laptop for school as all of their books are digital. The first thing we did was buy gadget insurance. I'm glad we did because he dropped it and broke the screen and it's actually with the insurance company now for repair. We had to pay €75 excess. It was an accident, accidents happen and as adults it's our responsibility to prepare for them by insuring things that are important.

Noisyprat · 28/06/2022 08:10

I'm guessing you bought an Apple.l? Agree with others, lesson learnt as DC do not need such an expensive but of kit.

Can it be fixed? If not and it's broken I would be replacing with cheap laptop/chrome book. I'm willing to guess that this will be met with a reaction from your DD. The 'punishment' for not looking after things is that you get a cheaper replacement. If that gets 'dropped' then there is no equipment to take to school and she has to use school computers.

Shiningstarr · 28/06/2022 08:09

Are you even for real? Why would you spend that much on a laptop that's being carried to and from school and not have taken out the insurance when purchased? Wasn't that a bit short sighted? You would then have accidental damage cover for the laptop.

We've had lots of mishaps with our home laptop, and it's been repaired easily each time, all under the insurance.

I'm sure it was just an accident, which can easily happen. What do you want your daughter to do exactly, other than say sorry, she's 11!

I think the person that needs to learn a lesson here is you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread