Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To teach my 12 year old how to count calories as well as teaching what a balanced meal means

131 replies

Wills · 27/06/2022 20:00

Firstly to those mums who want to shout before reading what I’m saying please note I’ll ignore your posts. I wouldn’t post on an AIBU unless I was really worried what I feel I’m about to do and hope that between me, and Mumsnetters that don’t shout, that there is an alternative out there and am hoping some Mumsnetter/s have solutions I don’t have.

My DD (aged 12) is the youngest of 4. All of us have struggled with weight (including myself and my mother) but I have made it ONE of my mothering focus points (amongst other things) to teach my children what a balanced and healthy diet looks like. All my kids have struggled with their weight but with guidance have sort of come round. Once they’re post 18 I feel its their decision to be who they want to be, but (and sometimes this is unasked of) try to guide their decisions to healthy eating - my point being that its fine for them to be ‘large’ but I always stress a balanced diet and healthy exercise routine.

However, in the last year DD3 (4th child) has gone from an age 12/13 age child clothes to an adult size 14 and in certain skinnier shops 16. All my normal coping strategies have failed. She’s like a heat seeking missile for sugar. I rarely buy biscuits/sweets/cake (for 2 years now) and before she was born, given my other children’s fight with weight have given up my love of baking. So there are no typical biscuits/sweets etc as a norm in the house (which my other kids complain about - but what do I do? If I bring in anything sugary she finds it - including under my bed (HOW - does she have a sugar sensitive nose FFS). Sorry about the swearing but I do feel she’s exceptional.

So just over a year ago she had a wonderful bonding experience with her granny (Their grandad is dying with dementia - to be blunt I didn’t think he’d still be alive when I last saw him at Xmas/Easter). They put together a raspberry crumble including oats. As ‘treats’ come this seemed like something that was wonderful for her to learn.

Fast forward - so I have stopped buying ‘snacks’, biscuits, puddings - in fact anything that might represent a treat (feel like the grinch). But DD3 is really intelligent/clever! For the last 9 months I daren’t have sugar or flour and butter in the house! If I do she gets up at 5.00am in the morning and puts together a crumble mix that would feed (with fruit) four people and then eats it for breakfast. I’ve stopped buying sugar and flour, which was fine when 2 of my kids where at Uni, but they’ve come home and bought the stuff themselves and get upset when its gone in the morning.

I try to punish but 3 out of 4 of my kids are autistic spectrum. My youngest is not. I can see the elements of spectrum that she shows but I do believe most of her behaviour is learnt.

So… Please help me. I’m very aware that just being aware of calories is shortsighted. So just teaching her to calorie count is crap, but if coupled with an emphasis on what represent’s a balanced diet - what else can I do.

To give an example…. She ate 3 full fat sesame bagels for breakfast. How do I tell her this is unreasonable without her screeching at me that I’m calling her fat.

Hope you see my difficulties.

REally really need some guidance as have run out of ideas!

OP posts:
PurpleMarie · 28/06/2022 02:58

What does her therapist say?

Because if you're so worried about your child's health surely you've gotten her help for her disordered eating?

beautyisthefaceisee · 28/06/2022 00:00

PlasticsFantastic · 27/06/2022 23:12

Honestly I’d be talking less about food and weight not more. I’d demonstrate eating 3 meals and not snacking/high calories in between. I’d cut out the sugar in the house but keep the butter.

I’d use as little processed foods as possible.
I’d encourage her to drink water for hydration.
I’d discourage her from sugar for tooth decay.
I’d stop calling high sugar foods a treat.
I’d encourage her to take vegetables for the iron / vitamins.

A treat is something expertly crafted, uncommon, exceptional fresh eg eating home grown sugar snap peas. Not a twix.

PF, I liked my grandad's garden peas as much as the next guy, but you cannot be serious about that being the treat.

I say that as a child who was denied fast food and fizzy drinks, and the best friend of someone who wasnt allowed to drink until shed left home.

You can imagine how that went for both of us!

beautyisthefaceisee · 27/06/2022 23:58

Shes very concerned about her children's health in general. They all have autism or ADHD, and (apologies if theres something im missing here) is convinced they are going to get cancer.

The rambling story about the crumble - what did OP actually do while the child sat there and ate 4 portions?

I think OP is the one who needs the concern here, not the child. (and I mean that kindly, OP).

bridgetreilly · 27/06/2022 23:46

Not calorie counting. You need to teach about normal portion size and consideration for others. One bagel for her breakfast, the rest are for other people in the house etc.

catflycat · 27/06/2022 23:21

Have you thought about some counselling for both you and your daughter? It sounds like your daughter has disordered eating, it's so common for people to unintentionally pass their food issues on to their kids. You've mentioned loads of things e.g....

Your mum always dieting, your battles with weight..you sound like you've grown up dieting (like most of us!)

You describe food as 'healthy' or 'unhealthy ' and don't keep any 'unhealthy' food in the house. It's not unusual to crave things you're not allowed access to or that has been put on a pedestal. The more you restrict the more a person wants and craves those things. As evidence see what happens to most people who diet - they may lose weight initially, but it tends to all come back as most people can't sustain a ridiculously restrictive diet for the rest of their lives. Really it's all just food, food that offers different things out bodies need, and it's really important to learn to trust your own instincts about food, she needs to be able to go out into the world and trust her body about what she needs. I'm just not sure how you can learn that living in such a controlled environment.

You seem to be very concerned about your children being fat, is that just because you've struggled with your weight before? It sounds like you have an issue with larger bodies as you mentioned always thinking what bad parents parents of fat children are. .. You have clearly described fat as being very bad and thin as being the ultimate goal - do you think they could feel their value lies only in their body size?

It's really normal to gain weight and change shape during puberty. The bullying is so hard - I was always a little overweight, but actually hardly any bigger then my peers when I started to be bullied for it. I look back now and can't believe how poorly I felt about myself for years and years when I was fine, but guess what, starting dieting at age 10/11 and being told your body is wrong from even younger then that does not have good outcomes for avoiding disordered eating and having a normal relationship with food! For my kids I've prioritised them understanding that their value doesn't lie in how they look, providing a big variety of foods but not talking about foods as good/bad/treats etc. Making sure food is available to them and letting them control how much they eat. I won't say it's alway easy - my son seems to be able to eat so so much at the moment but he's growing and active and I believe he's hungry. I do sometimes ask him to slow down and check he definitely wants more - but he also does just enjoy food, and that's ok too. He enjoys a variety and we make sure to serve up all sort of different things for them to eat, he chooses what he wants to eat. ( I think this is called 'division of responsibility ').

PlasticsFantastic · 27/06/2022 23:12

Honestly I’d be talking less about food and weight not more. I’d demonstrate eating 3 meals and not snacking/high calories in between. I’d cut out the sugar in the house but keep the butter.

I’d use as little processed foods as possible.
I’d encourage her to drink water for hydration.
I’d discourage her from sugar for tooth decay.
I’d stop calling high sugar foods a treat.
I’d encourage her to take vegetables for the iron / vitamins.

A treat is something expertly crafted, uncommon, exceptional fresh eg eating home grown sugar snap peas. Not a twix.

DuckBilledPlattyJoobs · 27/06/2022 23:07

SexyLittleNosferatu · 27/06/2022 20:12

Well you're already setting her up for a food obsession and potential eating disorder so sure crack on with calorie counting too 🙄

This
poor kid

milkyaqua · 27/06/2022 23:07

To give an example…. She ate 3 full fat sesame bagels for breakfast. How do I tell her this is unreasonable without her screeching at me that I’m calling her fat.

Don't keep bingeable food in the house, for starters.

beautyisthefaceisee · 27/06/2022 23:07

OP and her family clearly have lots, and lots, and lots of various issues. I think the food thing is the least of her worries and think it is telling she is fixating on this.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 27/06/2022 23:05

As I have a child (suspected ASC) who is slowly recovering from anorexia I strongly urge caution in making food more of an issue.

There are strong links between ED and ASC.

If she does a lot of sport she will need a fair amount of calories, it's also normal for pre teens to gain weight as this kick starts puberty.

I would put a few rules in place around what's an acceptable amount for your dd to eat but not restrict her if she is hungry.

It sounds like you have a lot of anxiety around weight gain and have fat phobia which you need to make sure isn't passed on to your kids.

the illustrated mum · 27/06/2022 23:02

Some autistic people cannot recognise when they are full or they mistake another feeling for hunger. They have a disconnect with introception. Id guess she has struggled with toileting issues too. This is likely whats going on as you mention its been an issue for all your dc. Unfortunately it cannot be cured but it can be managed with strategies. You need professional help here.
You could make a start by implementing a solid routine around food. Without making it a big deal. So you all eat at the table at the same time every single day. When this happens its a balance of food in appropriate portions. Its easier said than done though if she will simply help herself at other times. This is why you need support from specialists. You can use visuals to support this routine. You can also use visuals to teach portion control and healthy habits. Again you need professional help here because using visuals needs certain techniques. Its counter productive to simply print off a whole routine in one go and needs to start very simply with 2 visuals using now and next strategies. Even for dc who are verbal and seemingly able to communicate well.

Are there any sen support groups in your area?

ehb102 · 27/06/2022 22:59

Calorie counting only works healthily in an environment of body acceptance. Look up HAES. Calories are information, but calorie counting is for losing weight, you have to be detailed about it. Knowing the nutritional value of your food is a different skill, one that you learn with calories as a part off. It's important to know that this is 500cals and this is 200cals but this 200cals is empty sugar but this 500cals.has protein and fibre and fat and low GI carbs, and I need 500cals for lunch anyway.

Calorie knowledge allows you to eat, it avoids the "you mustn't eat, you're fat" diet culture message that leads to binging and starving rather than consistent slight deficit and steady weight loss.

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/06/2022 22:48

OP there's so much to be read into your post... it really does appear you've somehow projected many of your issues with food onto your DD, who clearly needs some unravelling by a professional.

But at first home:you've used phrases like "punishment, full fat bagel etc" . It's clear your own relationship with food needs some better levels of understanding and that balance doesn't mean eliminating major good groups.

I've never met a grown adult who's hidden food under their bed, this is not normal behaviour, though I can read in your post that you're desperate to make some changes in your family line. Which is great, however your current methods are unhealthy and not working...

What are you trying to achieve with calorie counting?

Not all calories are equal, I think this is a terrible idea when things are clearly not right.
Could you contact your daughter's ASD team re food obsessions? And also seek a GP referral to a dietitian? Also consider other elements like hitting puberty versus any meds she may be taking.

The one positive o read into your post was how enthusiastically your DD replicated your fathers crumble recipe. If you could maybe get both booked into a healthy cooking course together over the holidays to encourage understanding of balancing food and nutrition, along with making her own informed better choices would that work?

I hope you get some help- please find proactive alternatives to calorie counting . X

Manamala · 27/06/2022 22:37

Wills · 27/06/2022 21:36

Have tried this! Tried with 1st child, 2nd, 3rd and 4th (the one I’m discussing here). This may work with other children and I really hoped taking the emphasis off food would work for all of them but I can assure you that out of 4 tries all have failed. 😢

Sounds frustrating! There's quite a few ways to approach that. What did you try and in what way did it fail?

Manamala · 27/06/2022 22:27

Do you think it's likely that your mum passed on her weight/food issues to you? What work/therapy have you done to try and understand your own issues with food and the way you feel about your body and make sure that you are not passing on the same to your DC?

You said you have always been open about your weight issues with them - what does this entail? If you have modelled body dissatisfaction and low self-esteem then the likelihood is that your children have aquired this themselves. Low self-esteem combined with restriction and perception of foods as good/bad is the root cause of binge eating.

You sound very defensive. Are you sure you are truly open to engaging with other perspectives and committed to understanding the root issues? Or are you here seeking confirmation for what you have already decided is right?

This is not about food, it is about your daughter's poor mental health and the underlying causes. She has an eating disorder. She needs a gentle approach with professional help and unconditional kindness. I'm not surprised to hear of your poor experiences with healthcare providers so far. Sadly the NHS is often unhelpful. It sounds like your DD would benefit from private psycotherapy.

What resources/research have you found to support you so far? The Ellyn Satter institute is fantastic. www.ellynsatterinstitute.org/product/feeding-with-love-and-good-sense-12-through-18-years-2/

IvorCutler · 27/06/2022 22:20

Haven’t read tft yet but I’d be inclined towards offering everything in moderation. By hiding treats under your bed you’re making them forbidden fruit. I’d talk about what foods are good for making you feel full too (without having to eat them 3 times).

ehb102 · 27/06/2022 22:12

Wills · 27/06/2022 21:16

Thank you! So its relatively easy to calorie count in this day and age, but can you suggest how to I can help her (and my other kids for that matter) to put together a good balanced meal. My mum was always on an diet, holidays abroad were dependent on her achieving some weird weight. So I’ve always gone out of my way to not talk about weight, but equally they (my kids) need to know how to put together a balanced diet and that should include overall calories. So thank you for acknowledging it!

Look up the hand sized portion guide. It's not something I follow, but some people find it works well for them

A standard rule used to be: drink a glass of water before you eat anything. Stops you confusing thirsty with hungry.

I personally confuse tired with hungry, so I have a no food after 9pm rule of thumb.

Thing is, you can't have it all ways. You have to work within a framework wether that is calories, carbs, hand sized portions, not eating certain things. There is no way you can consciously control what you are eating without any kind of schema. You are already a person who isn't normal, who isn't staying naturally at an approved weight, so you have two choices, so it differently or be fatter than people seem ideal

Marblessolveeverything · 27/06/2022 22:02

It sounds like there is something else going on. I think you may need to get some help to see if there is something else going on.

Perhaps it is emotional eating or sensory seeking but I would want to rule them out before you take your chosen approach.

What is her activity like? Are there opportunities to up that.? Couch to 5km together?

Wills · 27/06/2022 21:59

Thank you all for your comments, especially those not critiquing. If you don’t mind have read, and will re-read in the morning. So thankful for those comments that don’t simply say don’t do it. It’s so hard. Given that 3 of my 4 children have a diagnosis of autism and 2 out of 4 are waiting for an ADHD/ADD diagnosis this was never going to be simple. She has ‘tendencies’, but no obvious symptoms, but in many ways that’s unfair to her. I just want to teach her how to be healthy. Not skinny/fashionable - a size 16 that does loads of exercise will ALWAYS be preferable to a size 10 with zero exercise.

Need some sleep (have loads of other child driven issues) but am so appreciative of your answers. Will look through first thing in the morning. Thank you mumsnetters!

OP posts:
ehb102 · 27/06/2022 21:56

Wills · 27/06/2022 21:27

Thought I’d responded to you. So see where you’re coming from. Thank you

There are lots of medical conditions that make someone's body not respond in the ideal fashion - lipoedema, PCOS, underactive thyroid, diabetes, insulin resistance. When I am properly medicated I can eat intuitively and I lose weight, because I eat well. When I am not, I can't do that. Losing weight is easy when you have a normal body. It's impossible when it's too hard because of these other conditions. I've experienced the difference in natural appetite suppressant and having none - I never felt full until after medication, only physically stomach stretched full. And feeling satiated after I went through leptin resistance was amazing, the difference is incredible. These two points were 15 years apart.

So whatever you do, stay body neutral and avoid diet culture morality. Sure, it's nice to be thin and have the world smile on you, but you can be fat and happy.

megletthesecond · 27/06/2022 21:55

No, I think calories will create more problems.

I do know what it's like to have a child who can't self regulate and won't eat wise food choices though. It's hard.

RoundaboutRacer · 27/06/2022 21:52

I'm voting for ADHD based dopamine seeking behaviour.

I was overweight from a similar age.

Cured only once I was diagnosed and medicated for my ADHD.

Binge eating yes. But chemically lead by the lack of dopamine thanks to ADHD. So you can ignore a lot of the "you've given her an eating disorder" bullshit that lots of perfect mothers are laying on here.

She can't help it. You didn't cause it. But it can be fixed.

beautyisthefaceisee · 27/06/2022 21:51

Wills · 27/06/2022 21:32

I sought help with DD2. The system couldn’t keep up. They came out to help me, but their solutions were worse than I’d already thought about. To give an example they suggested that DD2 drink low sugar drinks. None of my kids have EVER been allowed squash. They happily drink water. Low Cal squash contains (90% of the time) Aspartamine. Family history shows that my kids are susceptible to cancer (that’s a whole other thread so please don’t go there) and they’ve never been allowed to have a drink containing Aspartamine. That a health advisor would come in and suggest it really upset me. So my faith in the services is low! Sorry

This is a lot of health issues in your children. Do you think you might have medical anxiety?

Re the calories - it DOESN'T WORK.

CallOnMe · 27/06/2022 21:49

Do you have a healthy balanced diet?

I definitely think it’s easier to teach these things when we model them ourselves.

I do calorie count myself and buy treats that are lower in calories - popcorn, sugar free jelly, ice poles etc. So my DD feels like she’s not being deprived but there’s also fewer calories than other treats.

MummyingAway · 27/06/2022 21:49

@Fink .
Are you me?
Exactly the same issues!

@Wills
Few suggestions
agreed treat days where you buy her favourite desserts. You walk to the shops to buy it and buy exactly what is needed.

Give her a stash box with biscuits, bars, sweets for the week. When it's gone it's gone until restocked.

Swipe left for the next trending thread