Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racist message in group chat WWYD?

360 replies

Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 20:00

DH, not me. Is in a group chat for an up coming stag group. DH only knows he stag and no other attendees/ group members. One group member has been posting 'banter' in the chat - memes, videos etc. Most of these have been fairly normal fodder, some slightly offensive. No one in the group has reciprocated/ commented on these but he keeps doing it. Stag has commented that its a group to plan the stag do, not a jokes thread and tried to get it back on track. Now the same person has posted an overtly racist video. Its shocking. DH is absolutely outraged.

WWYD:

  1. comment that the video is completely in appropriate and leave the group and not attend the stag do.
  2. comment that the video is completely inappropriate and leave group but still attend the do.
  3. comment as above but stay in the group and attend.
  4. say nothing, leave the group.
  5. say nothing, act like it didn't happen.

DH is erring on 1 at the moment but he has no idea who this person is in relation to the stag/ rest of the group other than he isn't the best man.

OP posts:
rnsaslkih · 28/06/2022 12:04

I’d assume the person was not only racist but also had mental deficits. It’s not possible in 2022 to think that racism is acceptable if you have a functioning brain.

the stag should make a new group without this person and deal with him separately

Oestrogelsmuggler · 28/06/2022 11:53

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 09:06

Never ceases to amaze me what passes for humour in groups of men

and here we have a classic example of misandry. Next time a woman on any thread acts like a moron or says something racist etc let's see how a

''Never ceases to amaze me what passes for humour in groups of women'' would go down. 1 man said it-should all men be blamed???

You really are bored, aren't you Mr Chippy?

wellhelloitsme · 28/06/2022 11:19

@SurfBox

White privilege doesn't mean that all white people are 'privileged' in that they are rich etc.

White privilege doesn't mean a white person's life hasn't been hard. It means that their skin colour isn't one of the things making it harder.

It also means white people benefit from institutions that inherently value and protect white people above other races.

These aren't difficult concepts to understand if you're open to listening and learning.

Hopefully you understand now that white privilege doesn't mean being rich or living in a mansion.

You said on MN all men live in mansions, are minted, have high profile jobs etc. You must be missing the literally hundreds of threads where normal women post about their families who earn normal wages, asking for help budgeting, for advice re childcare solutions etc etc. And many threads aren't about men at all, they're by women asking for help and advice on a massive variety of topics.

Your confirmation bias must be astonishing if you happen not to recall those types of threads when you paint MN as a hotbed of misandry.

And of course the relationships section, for example, is going to have more examples of male partners people are unhappy with, because women in a happy relationship are much less likely to be asking for relationship advice...

5128gap · 28/06/2022 11:09

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:53

This is exactly what people mean when they mention whataboutery

it's not about whataboutery though, it's asking people here acting so high and mighty to have the same approach to all intolerance they see. You can't pick and choose.

Oh, and in answer to your request, that would be a no from me.
I will not take the same approach to a video advocating shooting people of colour as I would to some negative comments about men on MN.

Gunpowder · 28/06/2022 11:07

Surfbox you are misunderstanding white privilege. It doesn’t mean that white people are all privileged, you can have black investment bankers and white people on the dole. It means that as a cohort, white people have more advantages than black people. Because of inherent racism and unconscious bias in our society the white investment banker is more likely to earn more than the black investment banker. The black boy from a council estate is more likely to be stopped and searched than the white boy from a council estate and so forth.

5128gap · 28/06/2022 11:03

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:00

I wouldn't not attend the stag as it isn't the stag that's the issue and he can't control this person

this, the people saying they wouldn't attend are a bit ott.

This is a very tolerant approach from someone so high and mighty about misandry. I thought you couldn't pick and choose?

wellhelloitsme · 28/06/2022 10:56

IncompleteSenten · 28/06/2022 10:54

But you can pick and choose what you wish to discuss on a specific thread.

Exactly this.

wellhelloitsme · 28/06/2022 10:55

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:53

This is exactly what people mean when they mention whataboutery

it's not about whataboutery though, it's asking people here acting so high and mighty to have the same approach to all intolerance they see. You can't pick and choose.

Again, if someone in one instance is fundraising for breast cancer research would you feel the need to say that xyz other cancer is also terrible and they need to be doing the same for that one too? Tell them they can't 'pick and choose' which cancer is worse? I assume you wouldn't. Because it would be ridiculous.

You've successfully me-railed a thread about racism.

Congrats.

skippy67 · 28/06/2022 10:54

@SurfBox, why not start your own thread about misandry if you feel so strongly about it? Or is it more that you don't give a shit about racism, so you're trying, and failing, to equate the two? I'm also the mother of a son. A black son. I find it galling that you're saying misandry is the same as racism? How many men have been murdered just because they're men? How many offensive words exist for men? How many men are pulled over by the police just because they're men?
Get in the bin with your nonsense.

IncompleteSenten · 28/06/2022 10:54

But you can pick and choose what you wish to discuss on a specific thread.

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:53

This is exactly what people mean when they mention whataboutery

it's not about whataboutery though, it's asking people here acting so high and mighty to have the same approach to all intolerance they see. You can't pick and choose.

wellhelloitsme · 28/06/2022 10:47

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:38

If you think its all the same you should really educate yourself. Once you start, you will likely come across the concepts of privilege and power. After that, I think the penny might drop

oh yes I forgot that all white men live in Notting Hill mansions.

You're successfully me-railing a thread about dealing with a racist incident.

Please, you've made your point clear now.

This is exactly what people mean when they mention whataboutery.

You can start a discussion on a thread of your own and people can discuss misandry.

What you're doing is the equivalent of walking up to someone fundraising for breast cancer research and saying "oh so you don't care about liver cancer then?"

It's not constructive and it is unfortunately representative of the whataboutery that happens a lot in discussions about racism.

Comedycook · 28/06/2022 10:47

Misandry is as bad as racism

It really isn't...for so many reasons which I can't be bothered to explain and which would no doubt be lost on you anyway

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:46

So white privilege doesn't exist then

ofcourse it does but by mn logic every white man lives in a mansion, has a high profile job, has millions in the bank and lives like a Hollywood star.

You never ever see poor white men or those living um normal lives or living on minimum wage etc.

HarryStottel · 28/06/2022 10:44

I think he should leave the group, have a word with the stag ( already done by the sound of it ), and not go to the stag do if this person is going.

I'm wondering why the racist is still invited to the stag do and wedding though, what possible justification is there for that?

As someone has pointed out, a load of booze at both occasions is hardly going to make them more tolerant. both the stag do and the wedding could be a disaster with this moron attending.

Meraas · 28/06/2022 10:40

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:38

If you think its all the same you should really educate yourself. Once you start, you will likely come across the concepts of privilege and power. After that, I think the penny might drop

oh yes I forgot that all white men live in Notting Hill mansions.

So white privilege doesn't exist then? Grin

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:38

If you think its all the same you should really educate yourself. Once you start, you will likely come across the concepts of privilege and power. After that, I think the penny might drop

oh yes I forgot that all white men live in Notting Hill mansions.

5128gap · 28/06/2022 10:17

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 09:03

This is a thread about racism. Go start your own thread

misandry/misogyny/racism/homophobia....it's all the bloody same. I've heard alot of predjudice comments against the Americans also on mn as off late.

If you think its all the same you should really educate yourself. Once you start, you will likely come across the concepts of privilege and power. After that, I think the penny might drop.

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 10:00

I wouldn't not attend the stag as it isn't the stag that's the issue and he can't control this person

this, the people saying they wouldn't attend are a bit ott.

CannibalQueen · 28/06/2022 09:52

Well there's no way I'd go to a stag do with someone who thinks that's an appropriate 'joke' and a bunch of other people who won't challenge him. Asking for trouble. Drink will not make him more tolerant.

5128gap · 28/06/2022 09:44

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 08:55

Shocked that people think keeping a good atmosphere at the stag do/not making it awkward for the groom (who deserves zero consideration if he tolerates mates like that) justifies ignoring something like this. I'm glad it's not my world either

I don't see you or other posters calling out the misandry on mn though-so that's ok?

You must be on a different site to me. A poster only has to mention an issue with a man and the MRA and their sympathisers are all over it with their whataboutery/women do it too/it'd be different if it was a man...with tedious predictability.
I have heard that some even use threads about racism to shoe horn in their agenda. But I'm sure not even the most ardent supporter of men could think that a video laughing at shooting POC and a few LTB posts on MN were comparable.

Meraas · 28/06/2022 09:43

SurfBox · 28/06/2022 09:14

You're aggrieved by someone questioning the humour in a whatsapp chat where a man has been racist

no I'm aggrieved by one man's actions are used to paint the behaviour of all men. Many threads on mn are about racist/sexist/homphobic comments/jokes made by females as well. Nobody would dare blame all women for the actions of one.

Misandry is as bad as racism. I speak as the mother of sons and find it offensive males get a bashing on here.

Let's us not kid ourselves that you give one shiny shit about racism Grin

TheWayoftheLeaf · 28/06/2022 09:43

Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 20:43

DH has decided to go for a mix of 3 and 6. He has messaged the group saying racism is unacceptable and asking the person to remove the video. He has also messaged the stag.

The video is a collection of video clips/ images of black people with a song over the top in an American deep south style (don't know the name of the style, heavy with banjo) about shooting [insert racist term].

Wow that's not even a terrible joke that's just... pure unadulterated white supremacy. Vile.

Meraas · 28/06/2022 09:42

beautyisthefaceisee · 28/06/2022 09:09

I'm not defending him in the slightest.

Why are you so bloody aggressive? Did you even read what I wrote?

Do you actually behave like this IRL? stomping about telling people what to do when it's got nothing to do with you?

How am I being aggressive? Grin

I haven't sworn at you, you keepYou're the one telling me to 'bloody' do this and 'bloody' do that.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 28/06/2022 09:40

I wouldn't not attend the stag as it isn't the stag that's the issue and he can't control this person.

I'd definitely reply that the video was disgusting and inappropriate.

Probably 3 and maybe talk to the stag - he may well remove the bloke from the group instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread