Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think myself and my child are being discriminated against by after school club?

220 replies

JudyLemon · 27/06/2022 18:35

My child has Asd and has 1:1 assistance in school all day outside of the classroom. He has his 1:1 due to his behavioural issues, he cannot be in the classroom with the other children as he cannot sit or listen during a lesson and will be extremely disruptive. If he doesn't want to do something or if he doesn't like something he will run away and will threaten his own life. However he is not often physical, he will sometimes lash out at other children but never adults.

I am starting a new job soon and will be requiring childcare after school and in the holidays, I have contacted the schools onsite childcare provider and they have said that they cannot have him. They say they have spoken to the teacher and the teacher feels the environment is not suited to my child. This is because it is very busy and loud and because they cannot provide 1:1 support. I have reached out to them again and asked them what alternative options (perhaps shorter sessions or I could provide sensory toys) they will instead give me and they have said that they cannot accommodate my son at all.

Aibu to think this is discrimination? Am I expected to never work a good job again because of my child? Surely they have to put something in place?

Let me know if any of you have been in this same position and how you made it work please.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 28/06/2022 12:14

Surely being child led is actually more problematic - op’s son lashes out at other kids but not adults. With little adult supervision that sounds really dangerous for the other kids. Child who lashes out at other kids, plus can’t cope with the classroom which will be a fairly calm and regulated environment as it’s a year 6 class, plus a noisy all ages environment, plus little adult supervision? That just sounds like a disaster waiting to happen.

redwaterbottle · 28/06/2022 11:57

Op I would be asking for a trial to see how he copes. I've worked with children who struggle in school due to SEN but actually manage well in ASC's because it is child led, less demands and expectations.

redwaterbottle · 28/06/2022 11:55

Every LA is different and it's always called something different, but in an LA I used to live in I knew of parents who got childcare access funding for 4-14 year olds to access ASC's , childminders.

This link is from the local offer

www.cambridgeshire.gov.uk/residents/children-and-families/childcare-and-early-learning/childcare-information/childcare-funding-for-children-with-additional-needs

sashh · 28/06/2022 08:22

Is it discrimination? Yes.

Is it legal, probably.

Also the way you have described your child's difficulties would he survive the after school club?

He's probably trying his best in the school already, adding an hour to that might be too much.

So sorry I can't offer you any thing more than good thoughts.

Dancingwithhyenas · 28/06/2022 08:07

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 07:53

Can the people who keep suggesting getting a social services assessment get respite to enable you to work please tell us where you live and all of us sen parents will move to this utopia.

Indeed! So much wishful thinking or ‘suck it up’. I sincerely hope no one on this thread who thinks the OP should just quick her job and be poor ever has to experience the profound difficulties with parenting a child who has additional needs of some sort.

Spikeyball · 28/06/2022 08:04

People want to believe there is lots of support out there for families with disabled children but in reality there is very little social care has to provide for children who are CIN through disability. They have no obligation to provide any respite provision for any individual child.

AntlerRose · 28/06/2022 08:04

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 07:53

Can the people who keep suggesting getting a social services assessment get respite to enable you to work please tell us where you live and all of us sen parents will move to this utopia.

quite! Our assessment consisted of a phonecall where they said there wasnt much they could offer. My friend qualified for respite. It is awarded for one afternoon a week and one day each holiday. But she has to bid for it when the sessions open up for booking the week before, so its not predictable and some weeks more people are bidding than places.

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 07:53

Can the people who keep suggesting getting a social services assessment get respite to enable you to work please tell us where you live and all of us sen parents will move to this utopia.

Spikeyball · 28/06/2022 07:46

"You may need to reach out (refer him) to children services for a Child in Need (CIN) plan if you need support for him out of school hours so you can go to work."

A CIN plan will not provide funding to enable someone to work. You may get a personal budget for respite care ( would generally be for a couple of hours a week if you get anything) and you can work during respite hours but section 17 provision does not provide for childcare.

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 07:41

HappyDays40 · 28/06/2022 07:18

It's not statutory care provision but you could approach the local authority to provide the finances nd top up by other means so that you can find a specialist care provider who charges an enhanced rate. This is the issue that so many parents of children with additional needs face you want to work but can't get the childcare.

Do you know anyone thsts managed to get any reasonable amount of funding to enable them to work? I’m guessing it’s different in different local authorities and ours is pretty shocking on this type of thing so maybe my view is clouded. However I know you are only trying to be helpful but if it’s a zero possibility thst this is ever going to happen it’s not really fair to raise the ops expectations. Personally I always find it harder to take when my hopes have been raised about something and I’m turned down than if I’d never bothered in first place

Whereismumhiding4 · 28/06/2022 07:28

You have a child with SEN, who has 1:1 support in classroom on EHCP. You may need to reach out (refer him) to children services for a Child in Need (CIN) plan if you need support for him out of school hours so you can go to work. There would be an expectation you will pay for general childcare and that his needs are what is over that (so for eg the 1:1 part )
ASC are unable to as they don't have access to 1:1 or specialist support and may not feel it's the right environment which is less structured and wider age range than usual classrooms are. You'd be better having a PA care for him whilst you work. He gets DLA?

Often parents with SEN children end up working shorter hours as it is very difficult to find appropriate childcare (for a child with behaviours that can present a challenge to manage in general child settings)

OnTheGoAlways · 28/06/2022 07:26

My DS2 is waiting to be assessed for ASD, he is in primary 3. DS1 and DS2 have always gone to the ASC (we live rurally and other than 1 local CM, this is the only childcare provision). I am a single parent and have always worked or been in FT education.

A few weeks ago the ASC told me they can no longer have DS2 for anymore than 1 hour effective immediately. I can understand their position, but I still feel a warning to allow me to structure my work day would have been far more helpful, especially given I have known them for 7 years. Anyway, I'm on sickness absence as this was the straw that broke the Camels back. And I have been offered a new job with less hours but much the same pay. I have to accept that my son cannot function in this environment and it is not good for anyone involved when he tried to and work around it.

I don't believe it falls under discrimination framework. But you could try and fight for some support hours during ASC.

HappyDays40 · 28/06/2022 07:18

It's not statutory care provision but you could approach the local authority to provide the finances nd top up by other means so that you can find a specialist care provider who charges an enhanced rate. This is the issue that so many parents of children with additional needs face you want to work but can't get the childcare.

BuanoKubiamVej · 28/06/2022 07:13

The after school club isn't guilty of unlawful discrimination. Your child's disability is incompatible with the service they offer. There's no reasonable adaptation they can make to include your child because basically he would need a different room and a dedicated adult and that's totally opposite to the point of an after school club, which works on the principle that affordable childcare for a few hours can happen by having all the kids in a big room with a relatively small number of adults in case of emergency but structure is minimal and light-touch with the kids able to do their own thing. That's simply not the service that your child needs or can cope with and it's not discriminatory to acknowledge that.

I think the only option is a 1:1 after school nanny and you'll need a plan for your career to take your earnings high enough that you are better off after childcare costs - this is certainly possible once you are reasonably senior but you may need to get through a period of barely breaking even before you get there.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 28/06/2022 06:55

Accept your lot in life, is the general attitude I am getting here. I just feel that this attitude would change so quickly should they themselves experience disability first hand.

You're wrong. I acquired a disability in my 20s and went from a completely 'normal life to one where I can barely walk. That means some things are not accessible to me anymore and it sucks, but in most cases it's nobody's fault and I accept that. I get annoyed when there IS a doable fix - like unnecessary stairs - but there isn't a doable fix here for the school.

Gnusmas · 28/06/2022 06:06

Have you considered remote working? Obviously, it depends on your career, skill set ect but there are a lot more remote jobs available than pre pandemic.

www.charityjob.co.uk/jobs/home-based

Meraas · 28/06/2022 05:57

Am I expected to never work a good job again because of my child? Surely they have to put something in place?

It’s after school hours.

TheTerfTavern · 28/06/2022 05:50

I couldn’t go back to work because my ASD son wouldn’t be a me to cope with after school club. Won’t he be distressed after an entire day at school anyway? My son is 9 and still can’t handle after school activities .

As PP said, it’s not discrimination.

HayfeverSniff · 28/06/2022 05:43

If you are struggling for after school care have you considered asking his (or another) teaching assistant from the school to walk DC home and keep him there and you pay them an hourly rate for this?

Or perhaps consider a career as a teaching assistant/school kitchen/school reception so that you are able to take him to school and take him home but also earn some income.

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 05:13

User56785 · 27/06/2022 21:46

If your dc needs extra care you should get the higher components of Disability Living Allowance for your ds (£92.40 a week) which you could put towards a childminder in term time.

The holidays are a different beast though.

you Only get higher rate if they have significant night needs, they can need constant 1-1 throughout the day but if they sleep reasonably well you’ll only get middle rate care.

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 05:09

TheDoveFromAboveCooCoo · 27/06/2022 21:22

No it's not discriminatory. Your child has additional needs that the school cannot meet outside of school hours.

Your statement is "am I never expected to work a good job again" I'll break this to you gently but this isn't about you and your job prospects. You have a child with ASD who needs you right now. I'm sorry but I trying you really need to put the career type jobs on the back burner for now. There's plenty of time as he gets older but it's obvious that right now it's not going to work.

How is there plenty of time when he gets older? There are even less places that are an option then as he gets older.

Morph22010 · 28/06/2022 05:03

AmaryIlis · 27/06/2022 20:38

Has a full care assessment been done by Children's social services? If not, ask for it immediately - it's a statutory requirement under section 17 Children Act 1989. It may be that you can make a case for respite care that enables you to work.

In our area the criteria for respite care is specifically that it is not child care to enable you to work and if that’s why you need it you will be turned down. Also the most people tend to get is an hour or two a week so it’s going to make very little diff to being able to work anyway even if you get

ManateeFair · 28/06/2022 01:25

There should certainly be better provision and funding for children with special needs to be in childcare so the parents can work.

However, it is not discriminatory to refuse a child a place in a childcare environment that is not suitable for them and where reasonable adjustments would clearly not cover his needs. An after school club isn’t school, it’s private childcare. It’s no different from a childminder saying she couldn’t take your son because her home environment or the level of care she can reasonably provide wouldn’t be enough for him.

I sympathise with your situation but I also think you might be a little bit in denial about the extent to which your son can manage in everyday environments. He is different from a lot of his classmates, and he has different needs, and that is perfectly OK. He will not always thrive in the same environments as his classmates, because he is not like them. He’s every bit as important as them and every bit as wonderful, but he is not the same and he won’t always benefit from doing the same things. I understand that you don’t want him to be treated differently, but you need to recognise that there are times when he needs to be treated differently for his own welfare and happiness.

yepmetooo · 28/06/2022 01:12

Do you get Carers's? This is why I claim because I can't work out side of school hours so between my wage, carers and dla it gives me approx 25 hrs of min pay wage when I only do 8. It's not a perfect system but I'm grateful for it.

OverTheRubicon · 28/06/2022 00:47

@Aliceruns reading all the comments on this thread makes me wonder why I even bother fighting, when most people really do seem to think that disabled people and their families should not be afforded the same opportunities as everyone else. Accept your lot in life, is the general attitude I am getting here. I just feel that this attitude would change so quickly should they themselves experience disability first hand

I disagree with you - despite having some first hand experience as a disabled, working single parent of children with SEND.

Many posters (including me) strongly believe that there needs to be more support for families like the OP. However, the after-school club is not the one in the wrong here, it is not discrimination that they don't have the funds available to put right the wrongs of council and government funding, without putting other children at risk.