Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to 12 year old going to friends house without parents details?

136 replies

ddeey · 27/06/2022 17:56

Key facts:
12 year old DD has been invited to a friends house straight from school and would like to be collected at 8pm.
DD does not hang around with these kids at school but they have a shared interest. The idea is that a group of them will be going to the house tomorrow for this shared activity.
I have the address, but asked DD to get a phone no for the hosting parent as wanted to message them. DD says she has asked but has not been given one. Two of the kids have been reminding her today that she should be there tomorrow night.
For context, DD has been bullied previously and can struggle socially at times. Importantly (i feel) we live 45 mins away from where she will be as she goes to school a fair way away. So we don't know the area or local families.
AIBU to think that at age 12 its still ok to say i want to speak to the hosting parent in this scenario or are we being over protective?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
zingally · 30/06/2022 16:43

I understand your concerns, but I think you're being a bit overprotective because of DDs history of bullying/social problems.

I'd let her go, assuming she has a phone. Maybe you could hang out in a Starbucks or something nearby? Just in case?

Mirrorsforyou · 30/06/2022 16:34

I would want the number, if only so I could check with the parent that the invitation was genuine and parent knew about it. I used to be a big fan of friends coming over unannounced, but single parenthood combined with a more full-on job has changed that.

If I’ve got home from work, tired and fed up and just wanting to take my bra off and get some gin down me, finding my DD has invited a group of friends over to discuss anime “and they’ll be here until seven so can we cook some freezer pizzas…?” just makes me want to weep.

Friends they have had for ages, I don’t mind so much. New friends who won’t be used to our crazy dog or our house’s doors that don’t close properly so you HAVE to knock - I’d like to know if they’re coming over so I don’t decide to have a bath at exactly the wrong moment.

KatieB55 · 30/06/2022 16:21

I wouldn't be happy either. Trust your instinct. I would offer to do the pickup and take them there, so you can assess the situation.

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 16:15

I assumed that is why op told us they weren’t dds friends and she had been bullied. I am not sure why it would be relevant to the op otherwise. It’s obvious op is worried for her child

to me it’s irrelevant, 12 year old children should not roaming the streets and god knows where full stop. ESP not when op lives 45 min away

Hyvsvaar · 30/06/2022 15:48

I would want no to text and confirm…my kids are 13 15 and 18
obviously the older 2 I wouldn’t

your daughter should be able to get the number from friend within a few minutes so that raises an eyebrow

CalmDownKaren · 30/06/2022 15:45

Hellocatshome · 27/06/2022 18:07

I would say over protective. Presumably she has her own phone so she can contact you if there is a problem.

At 12? It would be negligent to just send her daughter off there without talking to the hosting parent.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 30/06/2022 14:59

They are known bullies red so ill intent is hardly beyond the realms of imagination. Kids can be very cruel.

They're not known bullies. OP just says her DD has been bullied in the past and that these children aren't her usual group of friends.

LouisRenault · 30/06/2022 14:52

They are known bullies so ill intent is hardly beyond the realms of imagination. Kids can be very cruel.... It would be a dry day in hell that my 12 year old would be trusting known bullies in a house that is 45 mins away with a family I haven’t even spoken to!

Where does op say these girls are 'known bullies'?

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 13:51

They are known bullies red so ill intent is hardly beyond the realms of imagination. Kids can be very cruel.

my children would not be going back to an empty house at 12 full stop. They would be at an after school club or activity, at that age, not roaming the streets. Adult supervision is very important- they are young and indeed in winter it would be dark too.

my dc are quite happy and feel secure with their plans, they are not left to their own devices for hours after school. I was a latch key child but these days there is no need for dc to be left thanks to school provisions.

Parents in my experience take good care of others peoples children - so I always ensure we are in contact and it is confirmed. It would be a dry day in hell that my 12 year old would be trusting known bullies in a house that is 45 mins away with a family I haven’t even spoken to!

redskyatnight · 30/06/2022 12:49

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 12:14

red I disagree. If op calls the mother to check out the logistics she will know the following;

  1. the invitation is legitimate and is less likely to be a set up by girls with ill intent

  2. At least one adult is present and supervising minimising the chances of ops dd being bullied or hurt, and she has someone to immediately turn to if things go wrong.

  3. Times can be confirmed given the distances

  4. Op knows exactly where her dd is that evening.

The child is 12 not 15, of course her parents should still be looking out for her, checking she is safe. She is still very young even without the bullying back story.

I'm not sure the girl would tell her parent she was inviting someone to her house with ill intent! So how would the parent know ....?

Many parents are at work and wouldn't expect to be supervising 12 year olds after school and wouldn't be home until a bit later. Would you insist on parent present or it doesn't happen? Is this safer or less safer than having an unknown adult present? And how many parents actually supervise secondary school children even if they are there?

There is nothing to stop the group detouring off somewhere on route for home....

I'll grant you the point about times :)

Talking to a parent gives an illusion of safety only.

billy1966 · 30/06/2022 12:32

TeaandaBook · 29/06/2022 23:21

Totally agree with this. It’s over protective until something goes wrong!

This.

There is absolutely no way I would entertain this for a minute.

At 15 this wouldn't be happening either.

45 minutes away with people you don't know?

Nope.

I would definitely need to be in contact with the parents.

Very normal for parents to contact and confirm details of meet ups if we didn't know each other.

My children never had an issue with it.

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 12:14

red I disagree. If op calls the mother to check out the logistics she will know the following;

  1. the invitation is legitimate and is less likely to be a set up by girls with ill intent

  2. At least one adult is present and supervising minimising the chances of ops dd being bullied or hurt, and she has someone to immediately turn to if things go wrong.

  3. Times can be confirmed given the distances

  4. Op knows exactly where her dd is that evening.

The child is 12 not 15, of course her parents should still be looking out for her, checking she is safe. She is still very young even without the bullying back story.

redskyatnight · 30/06/2022 12:04

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 11:09

I don’t know why you keep banging on about a phone call?! I certainly haven’t said a phone call will make a difference.
Knowing who your child is with, where they are will make a difference. Monitoring their on line use and being aware of the dangers in your local area will make a difference. Your child cam make ‘make good friends’ and have excellent judgement and skills and still be raped, assaulted, spiked and hurt. Stop being so bloody naive and wake up, it’s not the 1950s anymore.

But OP does know where her child will be (she has the address) and who she will be with.

Of course DD may be somewhere else entirely, or be bullied mercilessly by the "friends", or sexually assaulted by a family member of the child whose house she is visiting.

OP is asking is she unreasonable to ask for the parents' phone number. Having the parents' phone number will not prevent any of the above happening. Not ever letting her child out of her sight and not allowing her unsupervised access to the internet is the only thing that will, but at some point, and 12 seems a reasonable enough age, you need to give your child some independence. If you don't, they will be even less equipped to deal with anything that arises.

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 11:09

I don’t know why you keep banging on about a phone call?! I certainly haven’t said a phone call will make a difference.
Knowing who your child is with, where they are will make a difference. Monitoring their on line use and being aware of the dangers in your local area will make a difference. Your child cam make ‘make good friends’ and have excellent judgement and skills and still be raped, assaulted, spiked and hurt. Stop being so bloody naive and wake up, it’s not the 1950s anymore.

Sally872 · 30/06/2022 10:42

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 10:06

The issue isn’t whether you trust your child or not, it’s not even about your child - it’s about the people around them sally and the child’s capacity, or lack of to deal with a challenging situation, finding themselves alone after an argument or getting involved in the adult world and being exposed to danger. At 12 they have no real idea of the consequences and risk, how quickly situations can escalate and what is going on behind the scenes.

Its not about you trusting your child, you are looking at this from the wrong angle. No 12 year old is going to be a match for a 20 year old man, no child is going to fully understand the mechanics of drug dealing, stabbings, gangs, under age drinking and sex. The child may be entirely trustworthy and STILL find themselves in deep water. They are too young and lack the maturity - and it’s entirely your responsibility and no one else’s to keep them safe from harm first and foremost.

But how will a phone call with parents make any difference? Ideally you would no the parents but once they go to high school that isn't practical/possible anymore.

Teaching my child it is always ok to leave, that i will come at any time and to choose good friends is more important and definitely not lazy parenting because i don't see the need for a phone call.

Stylishkidintheriot · 30/06/2022 10:19

I don’t think Yabu. At that age and upwards my parents tended to trust me and what i was up to.

there was one time I went to a girl from schools house and called to ask if I could stay over. My mum said fine, but my dad asked for the persons surname.

turned out it was a local gangsters daughter I would be staying at . There had been attacks to their and their families homes over the last few months.

so, I would always be a bit worried about who my child was staying with

Provenceinthesummer · 30/06/2022 10:06

The issue isn’t whether you trust your child or not, it’s not even about your child - it’s about the people around them sally and the child’s capacity, or lack of to deal with a challenging situation, finding themselves alone after an argument or getting involved in the adult world and being exposed to danger. At 12 they have no real idea of the consequences and risk, how quickly situations can escalate and what is going on behind the scenes.

Its not about you trusting your child, you are looking at this from the wrong angle. No 12 year old is going to be a match for a 20 year old man, no child is going to fully understand the mechanics of drug dealing, stabbings, gangs, under age drinking and sex. The child may be entirely trustworthy and STILL find themselves in deep water. They are too young and lack the maturity - and it’s entirely your responsibility and no one else’s to keep them safe from harm first and foremost.

TeaandaBook · 29/06/2022 23:21

FunDragon · 27/06/2022 18:25

She’s 12, the house is 45 minutes away, she hasn’t been there before, these aren’t her regular friends and she’s been bullied in the past?

I don’t think you’re being overprotective at all.

Totally agree with this. It’s over protective until something goes wrong!

Sally872 · 29/06/2022 22:25

Provenceinthesummer · 29/06/2022 18:46

So how do you know they are not drinking cider and smoking in the park? Having sex with someone that is grooming them? Trying out drugs or being assessed to become the latest mule for the local dealer?

I guess you don’t, put simply.

Its either extreme naivety or you are hiding behind the independence slogan which is really shorthand for lazy parenting. Parents should know where their 12year old children are unless they live in splendid isolation with sheep, because it is children like yours that become fair game to the predators around them.
I say that as someone that works directly with the outcome. You need to know who your children are meeting are all times, and where they are. I always wondered who those parents were that were so very casual about safety, and how they justified their poor decisions. By the time it comes to us it’s too late.

Exactly how will a phone call to the parents prevent any of that?

I know where my child is because they tell me. Their phone is fully charged and they have earned my trust gradually by sticking to rules as they grow. I monitor their phone periodically and all well, they have made good choices so far in their friends so as they make new ones i will trust their judgement and try to meet her friends at some point. I can track location on phond if i need to. Things could change dd could rebel hopefully i will see changes early enough to intervene. Phoning parents is a snapshot in time and doesn't help much at all.

Hellocatshome · 29/06/2022 19:47

girlfriend44 · 29/06/2022 19:30

Exactly this. The girl from Liverpool aged 12 was stabbed in town. Its a horrible world out there. Best to be safe than sorry. She is a child.

We don't know if her parents knew she was in town or not? Even if they knew which friends she was with and where she was the outcome would have been the same. Just knowing where your child is doesnt stop them being in danger.

girlfriend44 · 29/06/2022 19:30

Provenceinthesummer · 29/06/2022 18:05

To those that do not know where their dc are or who they are with, are you not concerned? And if not, why not? Surely they are too young to be roaming around by themselves at just 12?

Exactly this. The girl from Liverpool aged 12 was stabbed in town. Its a horrible world out there. Best to be safe than sorry. She is a child.

girlfriend44 · 29/06/2022 19:19

waveyourpompoms · 27/06/2022 18:00

You are being overprotective.

You won't be saying that of something goes wrong.
Do what's right for you OP. All you will get here is different answers. Trust your own instinct.

sueelleker · 29/06/2022 18:51

I'd be worried. If she's been bullied in the past, how do you know they won't take her phone and leave her no way to contact you?

Provenceinthesummer · 29/06/2022 18:46

So how do you know they are not drinking cider and smoking in the park? Having sex with someone that is grooming them? Trying out drugs or being assessed to become the latest mule for the local dealer?

I guess you don’t, put simply.

Its either extreme naivety or you are hiding behind the independence slogan which is really shorthand for lazy parenting. Parents should know where their 12year old children are unless they live in splendid isolation with sheep, because it is children like yours that become fair game to the predators around them.
I say that as someone that works directly with the outcome. You need to know who your children are meeting are all times, and where they are. I always wondered who those parents were that were so very casual about safety, and how they justified their poor decisions. By the time it comes to us it’s too late.

Hellocatshome · 29/06/2022 18:12

Provenceinthesummer · 29/06/2022 18:05

To those that do not know where their dc are or who they are with, are you not concerned? And if not, why not? Surely they are too young to be roaming around by themselves at just 12?

No I'm not concerned. Obviously thers is that tiny little niggle in the back of my mind but I get that about DS1 who is 15 and even DH when they are not with me. 12 is perfectly old enough to walk about in daylight hours without your parents knowing your precise location. Its a lot safer now they have phones and mine have all been taught the same old safety things we were told as kids (dont talk to strangers, if you are worried go into a shop and tell an adult etc etc)