Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
howtomoveforwards · 06/07/2022 18:16

I seriously doubt their actual charitable impact (a few scholarships and offering their pool out isn't exactly that)

I obviously can't speak for all independent schools, but the one I work at raises in excess of £40k annually for local charities. Our 6th formers run a number of activities over the year for older people, there are endless trips to old people's homes with our musicians and choir in tow, and we take part in lots of community activities over the year. Our facilities are used as a means by which to help local charities promote their causes and make money at special charity fairs 3 times a year. We have a number of students who pay no fees whatsoever and care is taken to ensure that these children are coming from homes that otherwise couldn't afford the fees.

You clearly know very little about what is going on in at least some independent schools. Confused

TyneTortoise · 05/07/2022 19:00

faffadoodledo · 05/07/2022 10:19

Oh here we go. The leafy comps arguments coming out. The truth is, in areas where there these mythical beasts reside, there is also plentiful private provision. I moved from SW London (peak leafy suburb) where the comps were ok (not excellent tho) and yet they were surrounded by grammars (Tiffin) and privates (LEH, Hampton Boys, St Catherine's, Surbiton etc etc)
I now live in an area of rural deprivation (albeit one tourists love) and there are evenly spaced average or below average comps and 20 miles hence in the county town a couple of (non selective) privates. Who surprise surprise still manage to squeak more Oxbridge candidates in, not bc their grades are better, but bc they have specialist help in house.
Rambled a bit there but what I'm saying is this postcode lottery argement is a red herring bc private schools exist in 'nice' areas in even greater profusion

Their coexistence have nothing to do with the crux of the argument - which is the buying of privilege.

It may not even be a ‘good state school’ per se that attracts wealthy parents. But that schools in wealthier area have more resources. Parents who can contribute money, time and connections.

Thebeastofsleep · 05/07/2022 16:42

antelopevalley · 05/07/2022 16:35

Here:
£11,600
£8.700
Just under £7,000

I only looked at their websites, but the two cheaper ones look no different to the primary schools around here. I have heard of the more expensive one as it has a decent reputation.

I mean if you want to pay a lot of money for what you can get for free, it is up to you. I do not see any point though unless what you are getting is significantly better.

I think it depends what is important to you.

My children go to one of schools I put the fees of. The reasons are:
Small class sizes, more individualized curriculum, excellent and flexible wrap around and holiday provision (the biggest factor given our local state alternatives), lots of different learning opportunities, styles and clubs.

Our local state schools are very good but wrap around provision is non existent and class sizes are enormous (35 in the class DC was allocated to) and they only do 1 class trip/ additional learning opportunity a year. So we couldn't get it for free. But I believe some areas are better for all of that and we may have made a different decision in those circumstances.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 05/07/2022 16:38

I agree they shouldn't have charitable status. I seriously doubt their actual charitable impact (a few scholarships and offering their pool out isn't exactly that) and I don't have a huge amount of sympathy for the poor private school parents who then won't be able to afford. With the exception of specific children and some specialist schools, private education is buying your children a privilege. That might be the way you choose to spend your money, but it's not a charity, and there is no reason the state should pay for it through lack of taxes.

However, given the educational background of the government, this will not change.

antelopevalley · 05/07/2022 16:35

Here:
£11,600
£8.700
Just under £7,000

I only looked at their websites, but the two cheaper ones look no different to the primary schools around here. I have heard of the more expensive one as it has a decent reputation.

I mean if you want to pay a lot of money for what you can get for free, it is up to you. I do not see any point though unless what you are getting is significantly better.

Thebeastofsleep · 05/07/2022 16:22

DdraigGoch · 05/07/2022 11:27

That's the point though. Averages will cover a range of values, some cheaper, some more expensive. Not all private schools have state of the art swimming pools.

Of course if you added 20% to the cost, you'd price out middle earners and leave good education for only the very rich.

The nearest 4 private primary schools to us are per year:

£6390k
£7359k
£8142k
£8905k

That's for the first child and year 6.

Badbadbunny · 05/07/2022 12:30

Indeed, some private schools are pretty cheap really, especially in the regions which don't typically attract the uber-rich/foreigners etc. Our plasterer's son goes to a local independent - he only got sent there (it's residential) because of getting into trouble with the gang at the local comp and heading for a life of crime. His parents can't really afford it, but they're making sacrifices to avoid their son getting deeper into problems with crime etc. They certainly couldn't afford 20% more as they're already not having holidays, running a crappy old car, etc to pay for it. Thankfully it's working and the son has turned his life around now he's not in the gang culture, and is now expecting to do well in his exams and aiming for Uni etc., so a "win win" for society as a whole to have one less "problem"/criminal to look after.

DdraigGoch · 05/07/2022 11:27

antelopevalley · 05/07/2022 11:11

@DdraigGoch that cost is way below average. Unless a specialist school like Montessori, I would question the benefit of a primary school that charged those fees.

That's the point though. Averages will cover a range of values, some cheaper, some more expensive. Not all private schools have state of the art swimming pools.

Of course if you added 20% to the cost, you'd price out middle earners and leave good education for only the very rich.

antelopevalley · 05/07/2022 11:11

@DdraigGoch that cost is way below average. Unless a specialist school like Montessori, I would question the benefit of a primary school that charged those fees.

DdraigGoch · 05/07/2022 10:41

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 03/07/2022 09:44

@BungleandGeorge @justasking111 you quote average hh income of £38k as though these make private school affordable.

The average private school fees are £15k so I don't see the point? No one on average income without a massive scholarship/ bursary or family money will be able to afford half that income on average private school fees.

That's an average though, plenty of schools will be cheaper. One near me is £7k for primary, payable in monthly installments. Cost of housing isn't too high here either so the fees are definitely affordable for a household with two working adults and only one child.

faffadoodledo · 05/07/2022 10:20

Sorry not aimed at you @Badbadbunny! Your point about alternative provision contributing to a school's exam success is spot on

faffadoodledo · 05/07/2022 10:19

Oh here we go. The leafy comps arguments coming out. The truth is, in areas where there these mythical beasts reside, there is also plentiful private provision. I moved from SW London (peak leafy suburb) where the comps were ok (not excellent tho) and yet they were surrounded by grammars (Tiffin) and privates (LEH, Hampton Boys, St Catherine's, Surbiton etc etc)
I now live in an area of rural deprivation (albeit one tourists love) and there are evenly spaced average or below average comps and 20 miles hence in the county town a couple of (non selective) privates. Who surprise surprise still manage to squeak more Oxbridge candidates in, not bc their grades are better, but bc they have specialist help in house.
Rambled a bit there but what I'm saying is this postcode lottery argement is a red herring bc private schools exist in 'nice' areas in even greater profusion

Badbadbunny · 05/07/2022 10:01

Even worse than the post code lottery is the schools that select by religion, where you get the "pushy" parents pretending to be religious and who start attending church regularly for a couple of years just to get enough "points" to gain a place.

If we want a level playing field, then ALL forms of selection, whether by 11+, religion or independent need to be scrapped. We'd still have the post code lottery, but the effects wouldn't be so severe.

In my town, we have two huge religious schools which suck all the kids from pushy parent families. That leaves the remaining "comp" schools inevitably failing schools.

ChristinaXYZ · 04/07/2022 20:06

Clymene · 27/06/2022 10:59

If people couldn't afford private schooling, more money would go into state education. The two tier education system in this country is a disgrace.

What is a far bigger disgrace and affects far more kids is schooling by post code lottery. Loads of professional parents on two incomes buying houses near outstanding state schools. At least independent schools are honest - everyone knows money has changed hands. Everyone knows what is going on. We pretend the state system is equitable but it is not. If kids go to a good state school it is because their parents have 1) enough middle class know-how to judge the right school and how to get into it; and 2) enough money to buy a house in the right place. It is this kind of middle class clustering that makes average schools worse and good schools better. (Not because the middle classes are 'better' in any way but are more likely to have the time, money (for extra-curricula), energy and know-how to support their kids to most advantage. ).

ChristinaXYZ · 04/07/2022 19:54

User112 · 27/06/2022 09:48

That’s irrelevant. Other businesses pay taxes! Independent school is hardly charity work!! They are a money making business

To be fair it can't be both a money making business and a charity. That's two different things. If you mean that it is a charity that has a high income it is still not a business in the sense that it has an owner or shareholders who are raking in the profits.

Any profits from the charity income would need to be spent on the aim of the charity (educating kids, maybe in smaller classes or with better paid staff, or better facilities but still part of the aim of the charity - in other words the parents are getting what they paid for). Or the charity can keep money aside for a rainy day - in case expenditure suddenly went up or income went down.

Many independent schools are quite hand to mouth actually. One small economic shock and it is curtains. There are several smaller independent schools in my area that have closed in the last 10 years, and a couple that were a bit bigger that have be come state schools as they could not keep going on the income they had - their reserves had just been whittled away over the years - so now anyone can apply, the entrance exams have gone and there are no fees, just a standard state academy school.

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 19:29

LillyDeValley · 04/07/2022 18:53

Private health insurance is just that insurance. It doesn’t pay for a service.

Would people feel the same about putting tax on private health care? What about vat? Surely a lot of the same arguments about schools can be used about private healthcare. More money for the nhs? Encourage people to use nhs more so drive up standards?

Interesting point tax on health insurance. Successive governments always wait until enough folks are on board before taxing anything though. When they went after pensions there was uproar. Yet now with fuel and energy being so high they must be coining it. Tobacco isn't as lucrative so vaping may go on the hit list. Meat has been suggested

DuesToTheDirt · 04/07/2022 19:28

I don’t believe private schools should be abolished per se but I think they should be taxed and the money put into state schools to compensate for the fact they’re buying their child an unfair advantage

Would you also like to tax parents living in good catchment areas, as they have also bought an unfair advantage? We went private as we are in a poor catchment and couldn't afford a good catchment - private was cheaper than moving house...

LillyDeValley · 04/07/2022 18:53

Private health insurance is just that insurance. It doesn’t pay for a service.

Would people feel the same about putting tax on private health care? What about vat? Surely a lot of the same arguments about schools can be used about private healthcare. More money for the nhs? Encourage people to use nhs more so drive up standards?

ChiselandBits · 04/07/2022 18:21

@antelopevalley I work in the sector. I know about the margins they operate on and I know something about the finances of many parents who stretch to afford the fees, Yes there will always be some who can afford it and they will go to the schools that can afford to absorb this and the sector will get narrower and even more elitist and the state schools will not magically be endowed with millions more revenue to cope with the additional students they are now having to educate. I don't understand the point of arguing for something that will not achieve anything positive.

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 17:42

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 17:27

Most people just buy that basic private health insurance that pays towards dental and eye care costs and a set amount if you stay in hospital overnight. It is pretty cheap.

Just been reading the average cost of private health insurance per annum is 1400 pounds per year

Plantstrees · 04/07/2022 17:30

Reference for anyone who wants more details on Eligible Educational Bodies:

www.gov.uk/guidance/vat-on-education-and-vocational-training-notice-70130#section-4

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 17:30

@justasking111 I don't think US state education is something we should look to learn from 😂

I wouldn't be surprised on private health cover. Tories tend to wreck public services so that those who can afford to, look elsewhere and then they have no skin in the game so don't care that state provision gets gradually worse. It's then easy for the rich and privileged to support a sell off as they're ok out of the system. We need them to stay with the state services so they can be appalled and campaign for improvement

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 17:27

Most people just buy that basic private health insurance that pays towards dental and eye care costs and a set amount if you stay in hospital overnight. It is pretty cheap.

Plantstrees · 04/07/2022 17:27

I really don't care whether schools have charitable status or not as I don't think it will make much difference to anyone financially (although I do think schools will stop offering bursaries etc). Charitable status removes the liability to Corporation Tax only.

The provision of education (teaching, books, etc) is exempt from VAT. Removing charitable status is irrelevant. However if we remove the exemption from VAT from education, then everyone will be taxed on their university fees, creating yet more student debt for our children. I guess the Government could single out private schools but where would the line be drawn - the laws around eligible educational bodies would need to re-written.

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 17:22

Some type of private health care insurance is used by 11% of us now. I wonder if there's been a recent spike

Swipe left for the next trending thread