Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
TullyApplebottom · 07/07/2022 16:46

so the state is required to make provision for children with SEN then. SEN is not an add on to what the state is obliged to provide, as the PP implied.

Underhisi · 07/07/2022 11:01

"So the state isn’t required to cater to SEN?
that’s simply not true is it"

All children of compulsory school age are entitled to a full time suitable education. LA must make sure this happens but there is no obligation for the state sector to provide it.

TullyApplebottom · 07/07/2022 08:58

I suspect if they were denied charitable status they would incorporate at CICs which can run on a not for profit basis - without being subject to the governance, scrutiny and regulation which charities are, and without being subject to the public benefit test.
it’s not clear to me how that would improve any of the problems the antis claim to care about, I’m afraid

TullyApplebottom · 07/07/2022 08:56

So the state isn’t required to cater to SEN?
that’s simply not true is it

DdraigGoch · 07/07/2022 00:50

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 19:31

@howtomoveforwards every state school my children have ever attended do similar. What you've described isn't special I'm afraid.

Many state schools have charitable status too. So all seems fair to me there.

DdraigGoch · 07/07/2022 00:47

antelopevalley · 05/07/2022 16:35

Here:
£11,600
£8.700
Just under £7,000

I only looked at their websites, but the two cheaper ones look no different to the primary schools around here. I have heard of the more expensive one as it has a decent reputation.

I mean if you want to pay a lot of money for what you can get for free, it is up to you. I do not see any point though unless what you are getting is significantly better.

You are perfectly entitled to consider them poor value for money. It's a free country. Others may disagree for all sorts of reasons, whether that's because they like the extra-curricular activities, because they want to get their child away from a bad crowd, because the local state school is dysfunctional or whatever. That's their right too, it's a free country.

There are three private schools I can think of local to me, one of which doesn't offer primary. Their day fees range from:

£7,695 (YR) to £11,655 (Y13)

£9,600 (YR) to £16,200 (Y13)
£12,705 (Y5) to £20,130 (Y13)

By the way, I hope that none of those of you proposing to add VAT to school fees are ardent remainers/rejoiners, because EU law prohibits it.

Fulbe · 06/07/2022 22:41

theconversation.com/the-public-cost-of-private-schools-rising-fees-and-luxury-facilities-raise-questions-about-charitable-status-182060

If they were charged taxes, this could add 6% to state school funding. Honestly, some of their 'charitable activities' are laughable. And yet they're able to build state-of-the-art complexes with all their left over dosh.

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:37

TullyApplebottom · 06/07/2022 22:27

So education shouldn’t qualify as a charitable purpose? Hard to think of what should, if that’s the case! What about health charities? Presumably no need for them either, given we have the NHS

Education if it adds to state provision, e.g. schools that specialise in a particular SEN.

If to avoid the hoi polloi, without doing anything extra than the typical state school does for charity? No.

MrsKypp · 06/07/2022 22:36

I think to qualify for charity status they should have to give a minimum number of scholarships to children from families who would not be able to afford private school. Also, they should contribute to the wider community.

TullyApplebottom · 06/07/2022 22:27

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:08

It's not 'charitable ' to do what almost every (state) school does

So education shouldn’t qualify as a charitable purpose? Hard to think of what should, if that’s the case! What about health charities? Presumably no need for them either, given we have the NHS

Soma · 06/07/2022 22:25

In case anyone is interested in this bursary scheme: intouniversity.org/support-us/independent-schools/
We know a lovely DC who benefitted from it, DC wasn't highly academic, musical or sporty, but a thoroughly nice DC who impressed the school.
There are quite a few independent schools (as mentioned up thread) who are not charities. They do not offer any bursaries or scholarships.
A friend's local state primary in North London raises 10k through their PTA's summer fete every year for their school and possibly charity. But an average four bed terrace in that area is £1.5m, the vast majority of parents pay for tutors several times a week from about Year 3, (some earlier) and spend a small fortunate at the local performing arts school. At least 30% try for independent secondary and at least another 25% would if their mortgages were not so big.

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:10

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 22:00

They're not letting exam no hopers one for bursaries though are they?

Exactly, the 'bursaries' and scholarships are for children who will, in effect, advertise their school.

It's not decided on the child's need (charitable), but what benefits the school

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:08

It's not 'charitable ' to do what almost every (state) school does

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 22:00

They're not letting exam no hopers one for bursaries though are they?

KittyKittyKat · 06/07/2022 21:57

@faffadoodledo that’s not how it works for the bursaries, as it’s means tested and non-selective. The scholarships are 10% off, so not particularly meaningful, and are all artistic or sport. Neither of which impact grades.

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 21:54

Then @KittyKittyKat your school would lose talent. They offer discounts on fees in order to attract talent.
Schools don't give places for nowt in return. They get something in return. And often quite cheaply - our local private school gives 15% off to top music students. And guess what they get great music results. Which in turn attracts more pupils. It's great!

KittyKittyKat · 06/07/2022 21:47

I’m saving the government £10k a year by sending my 2 DC to prep school. Their school offers a large number of bursaries and scholarships. Those would be the first thing to go if they lost their charitable status.

If we had to pay VAT on school fees, so be it, but that would be £5k that we stop donating to charity each year. Many more friends would leave the prep school to go to the infant school and make the catchment even tighter and deprive others of places.

It’s a shortsighted approach to make private schooling even more expensive. The fees will rise even steeper over the next year once they pass on more of their increased running costs. The increase for September is already 4.8%.

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 21:15

@howtomoveforwards why the eyes? So your private school raises money for local and further afield charities; so do state schools. I made the point because you made the assertion as if it was a unique thing that private schools do. It really isn't!

TullyApplebottom · 06/07/2022 21:05

Some private schools in fact do operate as corporates (about 40% do) - they have to operate and pay tax in line with the rules applying to companies.

TullyApplebottom · 06/07/2022 21:04

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 05/07/2022 16:38

I agree they shouldn't have charitable status. I seriously doubt their actual charitable impact (a few scholarships and offering their pool out isn't exactly that) and I don't have a huge amount of sympathy for the poor private school parents who then won't be able to afford. With the exception of specific children and some specialist schools, private education is buying your children a privilege. That might be the way you choose to spend your money, but it's not a charity, and there is no reason the state should pay for it through lack of taxes.

However, given the educational background of the government, this will not change.

I find the assertion about “lack of taxes” curious. With a charity, any surplus has to be deployed towards the charitable aims. It isn’t the case that there are profits such as a private or public company might generate which are escaping tax through a break or loophole.

howtomoveforwards · 06/07/2022 20:27

every state school my children have ever attended do similar. What you've described isn't special I'm afraid

but it is charitable. [Confused] as are free places.

state schools aren’t charities so the comparison is apples with pears.

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 19:46

Each form has it's chosen charity, for example. 49 forms, each usually raise at least £1,500. Plenty of pupils on FSM, so not coming from wealthy parents, it takes work.

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 19:43

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 19:31

@howtomoveforwards every state school my children have ever attended do similar. What you've described isn't special I'm afraid.

DD's state school does as well...

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 19:32

Except they don't raise as much cash because generally the parents don't have as deep pockets. But the same sentiments are there

faffadoodledo · 06/07/2022 19:31

@howtomoveforwards every state school my children have ever attended do similar. What you've described isn't special I'm afraid.