Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 15:07

I am not confused. Preferential tax treatment is a taxpayer subsidy. We give this to charities as they have purposes for the common good. Many charities the state depends on such as RNLI, Red Cross and WRVS. Not paying business rates on buildings is a reasonable taxpayer subsidy given their purpose.
Private schools provide education for mainly children of the top 5% of earning families. I do not think they should have a taxpayer subsidy. Parents should pay the full cost and not have taxpayers subsidising them.
Not including subsidies as part of any economic discussion is short-sighted. The government could decide that any income I earned was no longer taxed - just me. Even though the government is not giving me hard cash, it is clearly giving me taxpayers money through a subsidy.
There are times using taxpayers money in this way is justified and genuine charities is one of them. Private education is not a justified use of taxpayers money.

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 14:51

Plantstrees · 13/07/2022 08:28

The charitable status has very little impact as most schools do not make a huge taxable profit. They are charities so their income is necessarily spent on fee reductions or capital investment etc. I believe the main impact will be the liability to business rates.

The much bigger issue is VAT on fees and that has nothing to do with charitable status.

If we want education to be chargeable to VAT at standard rate then we will also see VAT on nursery fees and university fees. How can you differentiate private schools from any other form of educational supply? It would also mean input VAT arising on much of their expenditure on tuition materials etc and this would increase the expense to all schools including the state sector. I don't see how any new laws could single out private sector education as standard rate without the state sector being seriously impacted too. Many of the posts on here (and elsewhere on the internet on this topic) just show a lack of understanding of how tax works.

Amén to this. Finally some actual understanding and sense

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 14:49

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 12:27

@Badbadbunny That is irrelevant. Taxpayers are subsidising people's choice to put children in private schools. I am simply saying that if people want to privately educate their children, they need to pay for it and not expect a taxpayer handout.
I do not get a taxpayer handout because I have bought my home rather than living in social housing. I do not get a taxpayer handout if I use private ante natal classes rather than those run by the NHS.
Taxpayers should not be paying for this. And I think it is incredibly entitled of private school parents to think taxpayers should be giving them handouts.
If I was Prime Minister I would start by making it law that all private schools had to publish what fees would be without charitable status, and what they are now. I would want all parents to know just how much taxpayers are funding fees by. Then we could have a proper conversation about whether this was a good use of taxpayers money.

There is no handout. You appear not to understand the difference between giving and taking.
the confusion is deep, my friends

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 14:48

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 10:14

The state subsidises them by letting them pay less tax than businesses. Charities have a number of tax breaks on business rates on buildings, vat on fees, and can claim Gift aid from the government on donations.
I do find it amazing that the top 5% of earners in the country apparently need subsidising by the government. It is a true nanny state.

You keep making the assertion that this is subsidy without explaining it. I pay tax at a higher headline rate than a corporation does. Do you think that means the corporation is being subsidised?
conceptually your argument is all over the goddamn place.

sunja · 13/07/2022 14:23

@antelopevalley it's coming across as if you cannot appreciate and understand the points being made on this thread because you are blinded by your distaste for those who have the choice to privately educate their DC.

PP have explained repeatedly that parents who choose private schools are paying their taxes towards state schools as well as their place at PS.

Subsidy has also been explained, the state is not subsidising PS places which you state that appreciate re VAT but then turn to business rates.

It seems like it's an issue that personally disgusts you as you're not able to appreciate the points that people are making?

Clearly, it wouldn't be beneficial for the state for multiple PS to close and those children to go into state.

If you are so against PS, don't send your children there?

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 12:27

@Badbadbunny That is irrelevant. Taxpayers are subsidising people's choice to put children in private schools. I am simply saying that if people want to privately educate their children, they need to pay for it and not expect a taxpayer handout.
I do not get a taxpayer handout because I have bought my home rather than living in social housing. I do not get a taxpayer handout if I use private ante natal classes rather than those run by the NHS.
Taxpayers should not be paying for this. And I think it is incredibly entitled of private school parents to think taxpayers should be giving them handouts.
If I was Prime Minister I would start by making it law that all private schools had to publish what fees would be without charitable status, and what they are now. I would want all parents to know just how much taxpayers are funding fees by. Then we could have a proper conversation about whether this was a good use of taxpayers money.

Badbadbunny · 13/07/2022 12:19

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 11:37

@Badbadbunny I was wrong about the vat then. But I am not wrong about the business rates on buildings.
Why should parents with children at private schools be subsidised by taxpayers?

They're not. The amount of the business rate reduction is less than the taxpayer saving of having fewer people in state schools costing the taxpayer several thousand pounds each per year.

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 12:05

So private schools only offer bursaries and scholarships because they are forced to?
I am surprised you are defending taxpayers paying for this. And I am surprised that you think families will abandon private education if they are no longer getting taxpayer subsidies. Nearly all children who attend fee-paying schools live in a household with an income of £100k or more. Do their parents not value their education enough to reprioritise their spending for what will be a relatively modest fee increase? Are they not willing to make sacrifices? I find that opinion sad.

oldwhyno · 13/07/2022 11:46

No, absolutely not. Removing their charitable status would mean the end of means tested bursaries and scholarships, and create profit driven businesses (which despite what people think, they aren't currently).

This would largely kill the independent school sector off for all but the ultra wealthy (the 0.1% rather than the 8%). A healthy school system that is INDEPENDENT of government is one of the cornerstones of a civilised, democratic free country.

Under no circumstances should the government have a monopoly on education! Insane suggestion!

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 11:37

@Badbadbunny I was wrong about the vat then. But I am not wrong about the business rates on buildings.
Why should parents with children at private schools be subsidised by taxpayers?

ClassSize2022 · 13/07/2022 11:31

Looking at how state schools are unable to accommodate children seeking school places - I’d leave private schools to it! From
the people
i know who send their kids private yes it’s a choice but it’s a bloody stretch and the state sector could not cope with the increase. It can’t cope now!

Badbadbunny · 13/07/2022 11:09

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 10:14

The state subsidises them by letting them pay less tax than businesses. Charities have a number of tax breaks on business rates on buildings, vat on fees, and can claim Gift aid from the government on donations.
I do find it amazing that the top 5% of earners in the country apparently need subsidising by the government. It is a true nanny state.

They don't get a "tax break" of no VAT on fees because they're a charity. Provision of education (of a kind taught in schools) is VAT free whether it's a charity or not. Taking away charitable status doesn't make their fees VATable. They've had to change the VAT law so that education was VATable whoever provides it, therefore people would end up paying VAT on everything, i.e. music tuition, swimming lessons, etc etc whether they're at a private school, state school, or out of school activities.

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 10:14

The state subsidises them by letting them pay less tax than businesses. Charities have a number of tax breaks on business rates on buildings, vat on fees, and can claim Gift aid from the government on donations.
I do find it amazing that the top 5% of earners in the country apparently need subsidising by the government. It is a true nanny state.

easyday · 13/07/2022 09:21

Private schools cannot make a profit by definition of their charitable status. So they wouldn't pay tax on something they don't have. But they only pay 20% of rates on buildings they own. This does account for millions overall. Having schools pay this would mean they pass on the cost to the parent, making it unaffordable for many (most?) and putting these kids in state schools.

Plantstrees · 13/07/2022 08:28

The charitable status has very little impact as most schools do not make a huge taxable profit. They are charities so their income is necessarily spent on fee reductions or capital investment etc. I believe the main impact will be the liability to business rates.

The much bigger issue is VAT on fees and that has nothing to do with charitable status.

If we want education to be chargeable to VAT at standard rate then we will also see VAT on nursery fees and university fees. How can you differentiate private schools from any other form of educational supply? It would also mean input VAT arising on much of their expenditure on tuition materials etc and this would increase the expense to all schools including the state sector. I don't see how any new laws could single out private sector education as standard rate without the state sector being seriously impacted too. Many of the posts on here (and elsewhere on the internet on this topic) just show a lack of understanding of how tax works.

TullyApplebottom · 12/07/2022 22:49

First of all, a subsidy involves giving something, not failing to take it. But leaving that aside, What tax break do you think the government gives them?
as stated, different types of legal persons are subject to taxation in different ways and at different rates. I am taxed at a higher rate on my income than a company limited by shares is on its profits. Do you think that means the company is getting a “tax break”?

antelopevalley · 12/07/2022 22:41

Private schools are subsidised by the state as their status as charities gives them a tax break.

TullyApplebottom · 12/07/2022 19:19

antelopevalley · 12/07/2022 12:44

Or maybe people should just pay for themselves rather than expecting the "nanny" state to subsidise private education?
Or does self-reliance as a philosophy only apply to poor people?

Can you explain how you think the state is subsidising private schools?
different types of legal person are taxed at different rates. A company’s profits are taxed at a lower rate than my income, for example. Do you think that equates to state subsidy of corporations?

antelopevalley · 12/07/2022 16:14

Tanith · 12/07/2022 15:02

"Virtually all the pupils are in the top 5% income of households."

That's not true. You appear to have very little idea of what you're talking about if you can assert that sort of wild claim.

I did not assert it. I posted already on this thread a link to the research that shows this fact.

antelopevalley · 12/07/2022 16:13

Deguster · 12/07/2022 15:03

Top 5% covers a vast salary range - from about £100k. Our basic outgoings (not including school fees) are <£5k per month and that's just to stand still. There will be plenty of people in the income bracket who have larger mortgages, high loan repayments, etc and will not be able to just "find" the extra.

Those at the very top - yes. But there is absolutely no question that it would increase state school numbers.

No DC in private school personally, but mainly because I'm in the catchment of a lovely village state school. I don't judge the choices of others who may not be.

If you are not prepared to prioritise your spending, why would you expect taxpayers to bail you out?

Deguster · 12/07/2022 15:04

Doh, >£5k per month!

Deguster · 12/07/2022 15:03

Top 5% covers a vast salary range - from about £100k. Our basic outgoings (not including school fees) are <£5k per month and that's just to stand still. There will be plenty of people in the income bracket who have larger mortgages, high loan repayments, etc and will not be able to just "find" the extra.

Those at the very top - yes. But there is absolutely no question that it would increase state school numbers.

No DC in private school personally, but mainly because I'm in the catchment of a lovely village state school. I don't judge the choices of others who may not be.

Tanith · 12/07/2022 15:02

"Virtually all the pupils are in the top 5% income of households."

That's not true. You appear to have very little idea of what you're talking about if you can assert that sort of wild claim.

Tanith · 12/07/2022 15:00

antelopevalley · 12/07/2022 14:05

Plenty of SEN children go to private schools whose fees are paid by the local authority.
If the local authority does not pay the fees, then yes you should pay the full fees.

You said "I do think people should pay for it themselves without any state support".

I know many go to private schools with LA funding. That was my point.

antelopevalley · 12/07/2022 14:39

The idea that children in private schools will suddenly all be in the state sector if the state no longer subsidises private schools is nonsense. Virtually all the pupils are in the top 5% income of households. Are you really saying this top 5% of income households value their private education so little that a relatively small rise in fees will make them put their child in the state school?

Swipe left for the next trending thread