Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
faffadoodledo · 14/07/2022 19:13

Oh @Barbadossunset where to start with your lack of awareness? Which rather proves @Nellodee 's point.

Dinoteeth · 14/07/2022 18:54

@Nellodee that is a fair point. I can't remember the country might be Finland or Norway that doesn't allow private schools.

Nellodee · 14/07/2022 18:47

The country and world would be a better place if rich elites actually had to spend time with us commoners. State educating would improve if rich people had to use it, because properly funding it would suddenly become much more of a priority if their children were affected too.

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 18:42

£8.5m was donated to Eton in 2018 - worth about £62,000 per pupil and Gift Aid could have added another £15,500 of taxpayers money. Compare this to the £7,000 average funding per pupil in state schools

What’s stopping state schools from fund raising?

antelopevalley · 14/07/2022 17:30

TowelChair · 14/07/2022 16:32

@antelopevalley I don’t think you’re able to grasp the concept. Or you’re just being obtuse 😂

I know exactly what concept you are promoting. I am disagreeing with you.
Not using a public service, but taking a taxpayer subsidy to use a private service is expecting taxpayers to fund your choices.
Rich people i.e. top 5% of richest households often seem to struggle to grasp the concept that this is about asking for taxpayer subsidies. Where do you think money comes from to provide a subsidy? Do you think because actual money does not change hands that it does not count? Do you also think the temporary cessation of tax pay people pay when buying a more expensive house was not a taxpayer subsidy to the well-off?
Money does not have to actually change hands. Being told you do not have to pay money to the government that would otherwise be owed, is a taxpayer subsidy. It is pretty basic economics.

Arkestra · 14/07/2022 16:35

@TowelChair "The public benefit from private education is that it doesn’t cost the government £5k per child to educate them in the state system."

Private education has a whole bunch of effects, both positive and negative. Which of them you consider most important - which you consider good or bad even - will depend on your more general political philosophy. For example, you might consider the production of characters like Boris Johnson either a positive or a negative reflection on the value of Eton as an institution.

Personally I consider the disbenefit from attendees of private schools grabbing a disproportioniate amount of access to further education is a very serious public harm caused by private education that outweighs the positives.

I agree with you that it's wide of the mark to say that access to improved credentials via e.g. Russell Group unis is the sole motivation of everyone sending their child to private school - obviously that would be a drastic oversimplification, and is clearly not a motivation at all for you in particular. But - on the other hand - an assertion that it's not a significant part of very many people's motivation (even though they may not wish to voice this openly)? That seems equally wide of the mark.

TowelChair · 14/07/2022 16:32

@antelopevalley I don’t think you’re able to grasp the concept. Or you’re just being obtuse 😂

prinnycessa · 14/07/2022 16:09

@antelopevalley I don't know whether you're being deliberately obtuse or you just enjoy annoying people with your poorly articulated points. In any event, if you are so against private schools or the way they are run, just don't send your children. Simple

antelopevalley · 14/07/2022 16:04

@TowelChair so your message is taxpayers need to subsidise your children's private school fees so you can give to charity. Wow!

TowelChair · 14/07/2022 15:37

We currently have monthly standing orders set up to pay £200 to Teenage Cancer Trust and £200 to Mind. Add VAT to our school fees and that money stops being paid to the charities and goes straight to the government to be pissed up the wall (aka poured into the black hole otherwise known as the NHS).

P.s. everyone should use libraries!! It’s the only “free at point of use” service in the UK that I value and appreciate.

antelopevalley · 14/07/2022 15:05

That is a false idea.
People who pay fees for private schools are having those fees subsidised by the taxpayer.
They are choosing to use private schools.
I do not say well I saved my local library x amount of money by buying my own books. The public service is there, it is up to me whether I use it or not. You would be outraged if I said as I am "saving" the taxpayers money by not using the local library, they should subsidise my expenditure on buying books.

TowelChair · 14/07/2022 13:26

The public benefit from private education is that it doesn’t cost the government £5k per child to educate them in the state system.

Also I don’t send my DC to prep school in order to attend a RG uni in future (as asserted by a PP). I don’t mind if they decide to skip uni altogether and become an entrepreneur or join a family business. They’ll have choice and opportunity to develop and learn however they choose.

antelopevalley · 14/07/2022 00:38

@ark Then I am genuinely shocked by their incompetence.

Arkestra · 14/07/2022 00:35

@antelopevalley yes I agree it really shouldn't be that hard. But I think that the governing bodies are perhaps not very oriented towards that end of things - they are caught between their idealised self-image as a charity and the reality of what they actually are. So I can well imagine that, as @TullyApplebottom admits, complying with even elementary oversight is genuinely difficult for them.

antelopevalley · 14/07/2022 00:26

@Arkestra The only thing I can see that might be an issue for some independent schools is if they are used to operating like a sole owner with one person making all the main decisions. But surely they already have governing bodies who make the decisions?
And you can not serve on the governing body if bankrupt or have a criminal conviction for fraud. But why would that be onerous for private schools?
Everything else is basic good practice and not a big deal at all.

Arkestra · 14/07/2022 00:21

@antelopevalley if an institution finds the legal and governance requirements related to charitable status onerous, then this is a signal that they may not be very well aligned towards being a charity.

antelopevalley · 14/07/2022 00:02

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 23:07

So, you are incorrect about the legal and governance requirements for charities not being onerous. If you’ve ever had involvement as a trustee you’ll know that’s not so. But leaving that aside, I’m at a loss still to understand where the subsidy bit comes in. Subsidy, as stated, means being given something. What is it you think the private schools are being given? If the school is a charity, it has to operate in line with charities law, deploy any surplus towards its charitable purpose - it has to be the thing it says it is. And then it is treated accordingly. Where does this involve a subsidy?

I am correct. The legal and governance requirements for a charity are not onerous at all. Audited annual accounts, annual reports, and a properly elected governance body that complies with the law and good practice around issues such as financial regulations and safeguarding. Any school should be doing all this as a matter of course. And if anyone tells you they are onerous e.g. a tiny independent school, then I would be seriously worried about their management and governance arrangements.

Arkestra · 14/07/2022 00:01

(And if you don't think the current treatment of private schools as a charity is in any sense preferential, then what's the problem with them losing that status, assuming they don't actually meet the public good test?)

Arkestra · 13/07/2022 23:58

@TullyApplebottom charities are given preferential tax arrangements in exchange for carrying out activities that are of public benefit.

Whether the activities carried out by private schools are of public benefit is a debatable point, on which reasonable people may disagree.

Rather than getting hung up on what a "subsidy" is, perhaps it would be a more productive discussion if people focused on whether private schools do, indeed, carry out activities of public benefit?

My own view is that private schools do not offer a net public benefit. While I can certainly understand why people wish to pay the money, in exchange for advantage in terms of credential-gaining (via gaining preferential admission to Russell Group universities and other institutions), that's not a public benefit.

What is the public benefit of private schools that justifies their tax treatment?

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 23:08

It’s like saying a company is being subsidised if it complies with company law and is subjected to corporation tax instead of the individuals involved being subjected to
Income taxation. It just makes no sense.

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 23:07

So, you are incorrect about the legal and governance requirements for charities not being onerous. If you’ve ever had involvement as a trustee you’ll know that’s not so. But leaving that aside, I’m at a loss still to understand where the subsidy bit comes in. Subsidy, as stated, means being given something. What is it you think the private schools are being given? If the school is a charity, it has to operate in line with charities law, deploy any surplus towards its charitable purpose - it has to be the thing it says it is. And then it is treated accordingly. Where does this involve a subsidy?

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 15:31

And charity commission oversight is light. I understand charity law, if a private school was struggling to meet that they should not be running. And I mean that they would be chaotic unsafe organisations to care for children. It really is not onerous at all.

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 15:29

The government is giving private schools a subsidy by allowing them to be designated as charities. I am not sure what is so hard to understand about that?
Tax breaks for married couples or blind people are recognised as taxpayers giving a financial benefit to certain people.
I am not making this up as you seem to think. This is well recognised.

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 15:20

And in addition, those schools which operate as charities (not all do) are subject to the constraints applicable to that type of entity. All the regulatory and governance requirements, the public benefit requirement, charity commission oversight. So they have to be the tbh g they claim to be to be taxed on that basis.
id be interested to hear from you what sort of legal personality you think they should have, to meet your exacting social justice requirements

TullyApplebottom · 13/07/2022 15:17

It isn’t preferential tax treatment. Different types of legal entity receive different tax treatment. This has always been the case. as I’ve mentioned several times previously, incomes of corporations are taxed differently to incomes of natural persons. No one thinks this is a subsidy or tax break, because it isn’t.
and you still seem confused about the difference between giving and taking. The government is not giving the schools anything. It is taking from them (ie taxing them) on a different basis to that on which take from other types of legal person.

Swipe left for the next trending thread