Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
Runnerbeansflower · 15/07/2022 23:09

It does seem fairly obvious why private (public!) schools can raise more money than state...

faffadoodledo · 15/07/2022 21:08

Interesting @Runnerbeansflower

Does that answer your question @Barbadossunset?

Runnerbeansflower · 15/07/2022 19:50

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 23:14

Why?
Private schools appeal to former pupils for funds - why can’t state schools do that? You’ve said your children were state educated and have been successful - maybe they’d like to contribute to their old school.

Where to start (as a former professional fundraiser including in the school sector...)

Professional fundraising advice is expensive. If you are going to run a successful multi million pound campaign that is a small %of costs.

However, a successful fundraising campaign needs a lead gift of 10-15% of the total.

I.e. if the total you are trying to raise is £1 million, you need someone connected to the school who can give £100,000-150,000.

Eton has a large number of alumni who could do that if they chose. You local state school - far less likely.

I did run a successful £1 million campaign in a state grammar school - 40% of pupils had gone to a private prep, and almost all would have stayed in private education if they had not got s grammar school place. So there were a number of parents with that sort of money. But it is very rare.

And anything under about £1 million makes paying for fundraising expertise too much compared to the total raised.

Runnerbeansflower · 15/07/2022 19:41

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 18:42

£8.5m was donated to Eton in 2018 - worth about £62,000 per pupil and Gift Aid could have added another £15,500 of taxpayers money. Compare this to the £7,000 average funding per pupil in state schools

What’s stopping state schools from fund raising?

Because they don't have alumni that are rich enough to give £100,000 at a time (as Rishi Sunak did)?

Andante57 · 15/07/2022 16:56

Faffadoodle thank you for answering my question.

faffadoodledo · 15/07/2022 16:39

@Andante57 i don't imagine there's much they can do while in opposition. But I do recall in the late 1990's and early 2000's much WAS done in London at least to improve state provision. There was a vast school rebuilding programme, and Blair's mantra of Education Education Education seemed for a while to translate to actual policy. The primary my two went to was rebuilt, and eventually the secondary they would have gone to had we not relocated got a similar rebuild. It was rather wonderful to see education being taken so seriously. All gone a bit quiet since.
And sadly the rural area we moved to didn't enjoy the same titivation.

Andante57 · 15/07/2022 16:18

You're right. But that only cements the point further that people
In power pay and therefore have no skin in the game the rest of the population have to play

I think it’s unlikely that many Labour MPs educate their children privately. There was uproar when Diane Abbott did it and any Labour mp doing it would be castigated in the press.
I appreciate that Labour are in opposition but their MPs are supposedly influential people - exactly those who many pp have said would improve state schools were private education to be abolished.
Are these Labour MPs doing much to improve state schools?

JasmineVioletRose · 15/07/2022 14:16

.....people in power pay and therefore have no skin in the game the rest of the population have to play.
*

This!!!!* 💯__

faffadoodledo · 15/07/2022 10:28

Andante57 · 15/07/2022 09:07

Plenty of Labour mps object to private education and/or charitable status. Why didn’t they do something about it while they were in power?

You're right. But that only cements the point further that people
In power pay and therefore have no skin in the game the rest of the population have to play.

Andante57 · 15/07/2022 09:07

Plenty of Labour mps object to private education and/or charitable status. Why didn’t they do something about it while they were in power?

JasmineVioletRose · 15/07/2022 07:42

It's disgusting OP.

Aishah231 · 15/07/2022 04:34

Sixth form colleges have to pay VAT unless they are part of an academy chain. Which makes no sense at all as academy chains often make money (for the academy chain) independently run colleges don't. Therefore it is insulting that private schools don't pay tax.

Aintnosupermum · 15/07/2022 01:32

Having spent the past couple of years living in Denmark, they have a terribly low education standard in general but they have a system that enables choice. Every school gets the same funding per pupil, the ‘private’ schools then charge an extra fee on top, which is waived if parents are low income. I think it’s a much fairer system.

My children will all be attending private school after a terrible experience in government schooling in the US and Denmark. My elder two have autism and my youngest needs additional pastoral care as we spent so much more time on the elder two. The school fees in Denmark came to £6500 per year for 3 children. In the US it will be about $110k, which is about £80-90k depending on the exchange rate. If my job offer comes through I’ll be spending about £60k in the UK on fees and another £20k on specific tutoring for the elder two.

I would prefer a system where parents have a real choice when it comes to educating their children. Removing the charitable status from schools doesn’t help anyone. The private schools offer that diversity that so many children need and mainstream settings can’t offer. It’s not about elite boarding schools. The vast majority of private schools are really nothing special and cater to those who wouldn’t thrive in a mainstream setting.

DdraigGoch · 15/07/2022 01:12

TullyApplebottom · 14/07/2022 23:46

Cameron sent his children to state schools. Blair certainly did. Tons of politicians do. It makes no sodding difference. I’m as middle class and sharp elbowed as it gets and I had to take my LEA to fucking tribunal to get the right outcome for DS. Schools and education authorities don’t listen to parents, whoever they are. We all know this.

Of course despite going to state-funded schools, the children of Cameron and Blair aren't mixing with the kids from council tower blocks. No, it's not just fees that help keep the riff-raff away. House prices and religious selection make many good state schools only accessible to the wealthy and sharp-elbowed. What do posters propose to do about the other forms of social segregation in schooling once they've levelled-down the independents?

Dinoteeth · 15/07/2022 00:17

I was going to write front bencher and changed to leader but never deleted the front bit.

Whatever its not going to happen we have a two teir education system long with health care. I can't see the wheel turning back on either of them.

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 23:48

Boris, Keir and Nicola are all private schoolies

Do you mean they went to private schools or their children do/did? If the former, then presumably it was the choice of their parents.
I’d be surprised if Keir Starmer educates/educated his children privately as I’m sure we’d have heard more about it considering the uproar when Diane Abbott sent her son to a private school.
What is a ‘front leader’?

TullyApplebottom · 14/07/2022 23:46

Cameron sent his children to state schools. Blair certainly did. Tons of politicians do. It makes no sodding difference. I’m as middle class and sharp elbowed as it gets and I had to take my LEA to fucking tribunal to get the right outcome for DS. Schools and education authorities don’t listen to parents, whoever they are. We all know this.

Dinoteeth · 14/07/2022 23:40

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 23:22

No but if you abolished private schools, you then force the politicians & Royal children into the state schools. The people who really can make difference will make that difference

Plenty of politicians send their children to state school - why aren’t they making a difference?

Who was the last front leader to send their kids to the local school, particularly a busy city school?

Boris, Keir and Nicola are all private schoolies.

TullyApplebottom · 14/07/2022 23:39

antelopevalley · 14/07/2022 00:02

I am correct. The legal and governance requirements for a charity are not onerous at all. Audited annual accounts, annual reports, and a properly elected governance body that complies with the law and good practice around issues such as financial regulations and safeguarding. Any school should be doing all this as a matter of course. And if anyone tells you they are onerous e.g. a tiny independent school, then I would be seriously worried about their management and governance arrangements.

Far more onerous than those required of CICs, which is what they all will no doubt become if denied charitable status - still able to operate on a not for profit basis, but no longer subject to the public benefit requirement or CC oversight.
I’m at a loss to understand what that will achieve, other than gratification for the mean spirited. It doesn’t feel like the solution to the problems of the state sector, let’s put it that way.

TullyApplebottom · 14/07/2022 23:32

Arkestra · 13/07/2022 23:58

@TullyApplebottom charities are given preferential tax arrangements in exchange for carrying out activities that are of public benefit.

Whether the activities carried out by private schools are of public benefit is a debatable point, on which reasonable people may disagree.

Rather than getting hung up on what a "subsidy" is, perhaps it would be a more productive discussion if people focused on whether private schools do, indeed, carry out activities of public benefit?

My own view is that private schools do not offer a net public benefit. While I can certainly understand why people wish to pay the money, in exchange for advantage in terms of credential-gaining (via gaining preferential admission to Russell Group universities and other institutions), that's not a public benefit.

What is the public benefit of private schools that justifies their tax treatment?

To question whether they provide public benefit is legitimate. To say they are subsidised is untrue, and not legitimate. If you cannot argue your case honestly, maybe it’s not that strong.

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 23:22

No but if you abolished private schools, you then force the politicians & Royal children into the state schools. The people who really can make difference will make that difference

Plenty of politicians send their children to state school - why aren’t they making a difference?

Dinoteeth · 14/07/2022 23:19

As a pp said earlier, what is about private school parents that they can magically improve these schools? Are private school parents somehow superior to state school parents in that they could somehow work wonders whereas state school parents can’t?
Isn’t that incredibly patronising?

No but if you abolished private schools, you then force the politicians & Royal children into the state schools. The people who really can make difference will make that difference.

However it will never happen for another 101 reasons but I can dream on.

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 23:14

faffadoodledo · 14/07/2022 19:13

Oh @Barbadossunset where to start with your lack of awareness? Which rather proves @Nellodee 's point.

Why?
Private schools appeal to former pupils for funds - why can’t state schools do that? You’ve said your children were state educated and have been successful - maybe they’d like to contribute to their old school.

Barbadossunset · 14/07/2022 23:10

Some posters have said that if private education was abolished then state schools would improve as the rich and influential parents would make sure it did.
As a pp said earlier, what is about private school parents that they can magically improve these schools? Are private school parents somehow superior to state school parents in that they could somehow work wonders whereas state school parents can’t?
Isn’t that incredibly patronising?

Swipe left for the next trending thread