Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
SafferUpNorth · 27/06/2022 11:17

Independent school parent here. A few points:


  • Independent schools might look like they have ridiculous amounts of money "going through them" as you put it. But so does the Red Cross and Oxfam. Millions in income... and millions in expenditure. In the same way, most independent schools are not for profit. They are not paying out profits as dividends to shareholders but are ploughing everything back into education. Without charitable status they would not be able to stay open.

  • Most do make their facilities and services available to the local community, be it through running sports camps, community sports clubs, outreach, and yes, scholarships.

  • Kids in private education are not drawing on state resources, so in effect parents are paying twice for their education. Where we live up to 25% of secondary school pupils attend independent schools. It would be chaos all those kids needed a state school place.

  • Many independent school parents, like ourselves, are not ultra rich, just ordinary folk on average professional salaries. But for our own reasons we have prioritised paying for education over, say, living in a large home or driving the latest car. It's about having a choice.

Dogtooth · 27/06/2022 11:11

The double tax thing is a red herring. Everyone pays taxes that cover the current generation of schoolchildren, regardless of whether they have zero kids or three in state schools or seven in private schools.

Private schools should not have charitable status because they entrench the class system and are therefore a social ill. If the well-heeled had to send their kids to the local comp, you can be damn sure that standards at the local comp would improve. Instead they give their kids a leg-up to make sure they do better than other kids who may have more inherent potential.

I think Labour looked at ending charitable status and wimped out, went for increasing the obligation on schools to demonstrate broader benefit by opening up facilities to the community. Hence the token efforts to invite people in, to tick that box.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 11:09

Clymene · 27/06/2022 10:59

If people couldn't afford private schooling, more money would go into state education. The two tier education system in this country is a disgrace.

How? What mechanism would make that happen?

Even assuming it did, would it offset the huge number of additional pupils that it would have to cover?

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 11:01

My experience is private schools are far keener on offering up the use of facilities to local state schools to justify their charitable status, than state schools are in using the,.
Because often these facilities are not that useful to state schools. They still have to transport kids there. So in the example above transport kids to a private school to do a hockey game. Even if they can walk there, it means a higher staff ratio than simply using their own basic pitch within the school. The benefits to state schools are usually incredibly slim to non-existent. It is simply about making private school fees cheaper.

Clymene · 27/06/2022 10:59

If people couldn't afford private schooling, more money would go into state education. The two tier education system in this country is a disgrace.

rhowton · 27/06/2022 10:52

Our school have just built and paid for a national hockey facility, that is used by other local state schools and clubs for free. The school always holds tournaments, science events and sports events throughout the year and allows two of the local primary schools to use their playing fields for athletics during the summer months. It is a hugely charitable school.

It may look like they are making huge amounts of money, but outgoings are large. Teaching salaries, national insurance and pensions make up a huge percentage, as well as heating, generally older buildings. Our school offer hardship funds to support children to finish either their GCSE's or A Levels, if their parents lose their jobs, as well as 10 bursary places a year per class.

If they put fees up by 20% many families wouldn't be able to afford to send their children to private school (us included), but what we can afford are houses in areas with outstanding schools, which would push prices up for others. We would take places in outstanding schools, meaning other children wouldn't have the spaces they need.

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 10:48

Of course, they should not be charities, it is a total con.

The fact that means people do not use state services is irrelevant. Does that mean all private dentist surgeries should be charities?

The state provides services. You choose to use them or not. If you do not use them, that does not allow the business to then claim it is a charity.

It is one rule for the rich and a different rule for everyone else.

Rosehugger · 27/06/2022 10:42

I certainly think that private schools should have to do a lot more to demonstrate the public benefit of their charity.

Rosehugger · 27/06/2022 10:41

Take it up with the government- Nigel Huddleston. Lots of vested interests. Good luck.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 10:39

I think it's less about corporation tax or VAT. I think they should pay rates as a business though.

It would only add ~£850 to the annual fees bill (if you can afford private school an extra £20 a week is peanuts).

Would raise £522,000 for state schools. Not much but something.

CrotchetyQuaver · 27/06/2022 10:36

Oops. Was going to add that a lot of the special colleges for SEN older students are charities too. That stuff is very expensive to provide and places like that and their students would suffer greatly if this was bought in.

I wonder how childless people feel about paying their local and national taxes towards education?
I think you need to drop this

CrotchetyQuaver · 27/06/2022 10:33

I would even go there.
Those with children of school age benefit because the private school kids parents are paying their taxes and paying again for private education. A lot

ittakes2 · 27/06/2022 10:32

You do realise the people with kids in private schools are paying taxes which go to fund government schools but because their children are not taking up government school places this saves the general public millions?

Chessie678 · 27/06/2022 10:27

You need to be clear about what tax you mean.

Corporation tax is only paid on profits. Most independent schools which are currently charitable would make very little profit if the charities exemption were removed because they have huge expenditure and would plough profits back into education. They would therefore pay very little corporation tax. This isn’t a loophole - it’s just how the system works. Nurseries are similar in that they do pay corporation tax but not very much usually as they are a low profit business.

VAT is a separate issue and would involve removing or amending the VAT exemption for education. It doesn’t have much to do with their charitable status. You then have issues such as whether the exemption should also be removed for tutoring, music lessons, universities or schools for children with special needs. Making independent schools charge VAT would allow them to claim back any VAT they pay on services etc which they can’t do at present. So while removing the exemption would result in a net VAT benefit to the treasury it probably wouldn’t be by 20%.

Cyclebabble · 27/06/2022 10:24

To obtain charitable status a private school needs to meet minimum requirements and this often involves community work, scholarships etc. I think it is worth looking at how high this bar is set, i.e. should there be more scholarships etc, but I would not remove charitable status. This would cause serious problems for many institutions which relieve pressure on state resources.

mimbleandlittlemy · 27/06/2022 10:23

Opting out of tax because you don't use the facility is always a fatuous argument. You'd get people who don't have kids/privately educate their kids wanting one tax code, then you'd get people who don't use the NHS wanting another tax code (until the point they discover they can't have what they want on their health insurance or are rushed from a private hospital to an NHS one to save their lives as happened to a friend's mother - so they would need yet another tax code to pay for what they have on the NHS) and then there are the people who don't want to pay for defence - they'd need another tax code. What about the people who have never needed the fire brigade? Should they get money back each year?

This is why tax is universal - it's just not workable otherwise.

Getoff · 27/06/2022 10:19

So the more money they put back into education, including bursaries, local outreach etc, the less tax they would pay.

If they are charities they can't do anything else with the money, it will eventually be spent on those kinds of things anyway. The difference that charitable status presumably makes is that they don't have to spend all their money by the end of each tax year to avoid being taxed, they can save up for a new roof, etc.

Having said that, I think I read somewhere that the effect of being charged corporation tax would be negligible, as there would be hardly any profit. The big problem with losing charitable status would be having to charge VAT on fees. That would put up private school fees 20%, with all the extra money going straight to central government.

Chouetted · 27/06/2022 10:14

Honestly, a lot of private schools would not survive without charitable status. There isn't really that much money running through them - certainly not the one I went to. My class was a hodgepodge of farmers kids, kids from the local villages and estates, and the international pupils who actually paid enough to keep the place running.

If you want your kids to attend school in poorly maintained buildings, with outdated facilities, send them to private school! 😁

edwinbear · 27/06/2022 10:13

If you added tax to the school fees at DC's school, something like 75% of people couldn't afford it and would pull their DC out. That would lead to the school closing and our local borough having to magic up 1,800 places at the local state schools overnight.

CurzonDax · 27/06/2022 10:10

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 09:46

You do realise that the parents also pay tax just like everyone but do not take up the school places in the state sector right?

I don't understand how this is a point?

I pay tax like everyone else, but also do not take up a school place in the state sector. I do not send my children to private school either. I have no children.

Surely those claiming that parents who pay for private education, should get a change in tax code, as they are saving the taxpayers money, by not taking up a state school place - the same goes for all child-free adults too, right?

Amending parents tax code would be very complicated to set up (and I'd imagine there would be an uproar from many childfree people - you're talking 18 years, not just the 3-5 years a child goes to nursery).
The easiest solution would be to just tax the private schools, as any other business. However, any money that goes directly back into the school to spend on the students' education (staffing costs, supplies, and all the other stuff), does not get taxed, as it is an expenditure. It's the profit that should get taxed, and many private schools are making a profit.

perenniallymessy · 27/06/2022 10:10

Well education is VAT exempt, so it wouldn't be the parents being taxed if private schools lost their charity status- it would be the school being taxed on profits. So the more money they put back into education, including bursaries, local outreach etc, the less tax they would pay.

I totally agree that most private schools don't do enough to justify their charitable status. I don't see that a few bursaries are enough either- they should have to show how they benefit the wider community.

Getoff · 27/06/2022 10:10

User112 · 27/06/2022 09:48

That’s irrelevant. Other businesses pay taxes! Independent school is hardly charity work!! They are a money making business

If they were a money making business, they wouldn't be a charity, and they'd have to pay tax.

"Money making" means that some of the money taken in goes as profit to the owner/s. A charity spends all money it takes in on its charitable purposes.

MumChats · 27/06/2022 10:06

As well as parents effectively being taxed twice if that's the case (once from their taxes that goes towards a state school and the second time through increase in fees if private schools were taxed), private schools often do educate a minority for free. Most if not all have scholarships and often "hardship funds" or similar to support enrolled children whose parents are suddenly and unepxectedly unable to continue paying fees. So i think that's partly why they are "charitable".

Squareflair · 27/06/2022 10:02

I can't say this bothers me that much, there are far more pressing issues in relation to education/schools in this country. The local independent allows children from our state school to attend after school clubs (free of charge), does outreach activities for the local community that anyone can attend, and during covid offered a lot. I'm not arsed if they have charitable status or not really.

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 09:59

CounsellorTroi · 27/06/2022 09:57

Perhaps people without children should also get these tax breaks, since they are also saving the state money that would have been spent educating their kids?

At least no one is suggesting that they are taxed twice. Because taxes on independent education will only be passed on to parents.

Also I actually think tax breaks for people without children sounds fair tbh

Swipe left for the next trending thread