Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 13:01

I think it is a difficult one to have blanket policy on. Lots of SEN schools are private, but most children are funded through the LA as the state schools cannot meet the needs of the child, particularly those with profound disability or needing physical support (lifts, accessible changing facilities etc).

But equally lots of the children at these schools are privately funded because their parents can either afford it and can't be bothered to go though the very difficult process of EHCP or can make the sacrifices necessary to pay until an EHCP can be organised.

Sockwomble · 27/06/2022 12:31

The problem is that state sen schools as they exist now, are not specialist enough for children with the most complex needs. The state sen sector would need to change enormously. Ds's school takes children from hundreds of miles away.

LuaDipa · 27/06/2022 12:25

User112 · 27/06/2022 09:48

That’s irrelevant. Other businesses pay taxes! Independent school is hardly charity work!! They are a money making business

Other businesses pay tax bases on the income they generate. A school is not ‘a money making business’ if they are a charity. Any ‘profits’ have to be reinvested, they can’t be removed or spent on anything other than the school.

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 12:20

The simple solution is to have state SEN schools. It is what should be happening anyway.

Sockwomble · 27/06/2022 12:19

"so a lot of sen schools are private (and very expensive). If you put 20% on fees then LA will have to pay for this."

You could exempt schools where LA pay the fees although LA also pay the fees that some ordinary independent schools for some pupils.

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 12:12

@namechangeduetoimpatience if your finances are so tight that you can not reprioritise your spending to afford £40 a week, then your private school fees were always precarious anyway.

ShipwreckSunset · 27/06/2022 12:11

The types of ‘community outreach’ some of these schools do to justify their charitable status is a joke. Eg use of running track for school tournaments (plenty of the schools round here could host as they have the facilities ie a large field).

The one that particularly annoys me is the 5-10% ‘bursary’ award, which seems to be a subsidy to parents who are already planning to send their kids there because let’s face it that isn’t going to be the defining reason you can suddenly afford it. The schools round here seem to use it to attract particularly gifted children in sports and music… who are likely to come from a more privileged background anyway (eg need to have parents able and invested enough in sending them to various competitions around the country), plus it makes the school results look better when they can claim to have pupils excelling in various fields. Great marketing plan, but hardly worthy of charitable status.

prinnycessa · 27/06/2022 11:54

@DomPerignon12 I agree. We are seeing something similar with the proposed changes in the rental markets - essentially penalising LLs by restricting what they can do with their own properties and wanting them to bridge the gap that has been created by a lack of social housing.

I think wealthy/high income individuals can oftentimes be penalised when people perceive there to be some injustice, inequality or a shortfall of any description and automatically turn to those with more money to fix it.

It wouldn't be fair or reasonable to remove charitable status from PSs with the hopes of improving state education. That's an issue that the government should be considering and identifying resources to manage. It's their issue to solve, not the parents of privately educated children.

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 11:53

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 11:25

I think a 15% tax on private school fees is reasonable.

It would raise an extra billion for the state sector and be ~£40 a week for parents. If you are paying private school fees this should be doable.

At least that way those on bursaries or scholarships wouldn't suffer and the really high fee paying places would pay more.

And how do you know £40 a week will be doable?

Bramshott · 27/06/2022 11:48

Do schools that are not charities have to charge VAT on fees? I thought education was generally exempt from VAT whoever was providing it?

Charitable status is beneficial to private schools in other ways - it means they can raise funds more easily, and claim Gift Aid on donations, and of course it means they must not make profits which are taken out of the business. Education is generally assumed to be charitable purpose otherwise PTAs (who also only benefit a specific group of children, not all children) could not be charities.

DomPerignon12 · 27/06/2022 11:46

Dogtooth · 27/06/2022 11:11

The double tax thing is a red herring. Everyone pays taxes that cover the current generation of schoolchildren, regardless of whether they have zero kids or three in state schools or seven in private schools.

Private schools should not have charitable status because they entrench the class system and are therefore a social ill. If the well-heeled had to send their kids to the local comp, you can be damn sure that standards at the local comp would improve. Instead they give their kids a leg-up to make sure they do better than other kids who may have more inherent potential.

I think Labour looked at ending charitable status and wimped out, went for increasing the obligation on schools to demonstrate broader benefit by opening up facilities to the community. Hence the token efforts to invite people in, to tick that box.

The ugly truth is that parental involvement is a big indicator of outcomes. It’s not just about money. It’s about attitude - like certain groups culturally valuing education, hence their kids do well even if they’re not white and middle class.

People who can pay will organise tutors, music lessons etc or as a PP said home educate in small groups.

The only way of making the ‘local comp’ improve is to pressure the GOVERNMENT to pour more money in. Which isn’t in the hands of most people who can afford private school, it’s in the hands of the rich and elite who won’t be affected by charitable status of schools anyway.

CoalTit · 27/06/2022 11:41

The argument that you save the system money by opting for a tax-exempt private version of any service is too superficial and facile for anyone to really believe.
The state-school system would be amazing if the resources of would-be private-school parents were directed toward it. Not just financial resources, but time, skills, influence and political pressure.
I'm sure I'd send my (hypothetical) children to private schools if I thought they'd benefit and I had the money. But I hope I wouldn't insult people's intelligence by telling them I was doing state-school parents some sort of favour by going private.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 11:40

I don't think it's unfair. They are buying a luxury service they don't pay tax on. That's not how things usually work so it's appropriate that we close the loophole.

You pay tax on private healthcare so it just lines up with that.

LillyDeValley · 27/06/2022 11:38

So removing charitable status is mainly about putting vat on school fees. Business rates is a much smaller element (I think 1.6 billion and 100 million). As the biggest expense for most schools is staff costs then they could not “offset” against vat much and so would need to pass on to parents.

The thing is it’s one of those things which seems catchy and popular, but when you drill down probably isn’t going to help and could cause more problems:

  • so a lot of sen schools are private (and very expensive). If you put 20% on fees then LA will have to pay for this.
  • Some Parents won’t be able to afford 20% hike so will move children to state sector. So you won’t get the vat and in fact take more out of the treasury, without putting anything else in
  • what about tutoring, clubs etc? All private education. They would have to do the same.
  • If you start with education surely you can make the argument for things like private healthcare?
  • Round here it will just increase house prices round outstanding state schools further.
  • Wealthy foreign nationals could claim back tax
  • Private schools become more elite
If you want to get more money for education your best option is to tax at source.
Snuffy28 · 27/06/2022 11:37

A charity spends all money it takes in on its charitable purposes.

Actually, no. For the big charities, a lot is spent on salaries for management and TV adverts.

prinnycessa · 27/06/2022 11:34

@ThinkAboutItTomorrow you say it will raise a billion for the state schools but throughout this thread it has been repeatedly mentioned that the parents who send their DCs to private school contribute to state schools through their taxes? It sounds as if people want to penalise those who have choices by virtue of their wealth/income which is unfair

Snuffy28 · 27/06/2022 11:33

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

Why should it be the job of schools to 'promote equality'?
Society isn't equal, in any way.

Parents who pay for private education still have to pay tax, part of which pays for state schools. Why shouldn't they be offered a tax rebate to compensate?

Sockwomble · 27/06/2022 11:28

Some private schools are special schools that take the children that there is no maintained school for.

ProseccoStorm · 27/06/2022 11:27

@Dogtooth

We wouldn't send our kids to the local school if private schools closed.

We would pay for a tutor, perhaps even our existing teacher, and perhaps we'd be joined by a few local friends who used to go to the same school. We have space for these lessons or we'd hire the village hall which is empty in the day. And we'd pay for sports tuition, art and music. I'd imagine these local friends would also join in our lessons.

You'd find that many parents would do exactly the same.

Not private school, simply home educating in small groups.

I went to a local comp. It was hideous, hence very firmly my children would not go to one were there any other or pom.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 11:25

I think a 15% tax on private school fees is reasonable.

It would raise an extra billion for the state sector and be ~£40 a week for parents. If you are paying private school fees this should be doable.

At least that way those on bursaries or scholarships wouldn't suffer and the really high fee paying places would pay more.

SafferUpNorth · 27/06/2022 11:25

@Dogtooth This statement is so narrow-minded and classist in itself: Private schools should not have charitable status because they entrench the class system and are therefore a social ill.

Apart from places like Eton, most independent schools are not just populated with kids from the British 'upper classes' but have children from a wide variety of backgrounds, very often with foreign heritage, and class is pretty much irrelevant. My DC's school has a far greater cultural diversity than the local comp.

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 11:24

Dogtooth · 27/06/2022 11:11

The double tax thing is a red herring. Everyone pays taxes that cover the current generation of schoolchildren, regardless of whether they have zero kids or three in state schools or seven in private schools.

Private schools should not have charitable status because they entrench the class system and are therefore a social ill. If the well-heeled had to send their kids to the local comp, you can be damn sure that standards at the local comp would improve. Instead they give their kids a leg-up to make sure they do better than other kids who may have more inherent potential.

I think Labour looked at ending charitable status and wimped out, went for increasing the obligation on schools to demonstrate broader benefit by opening up facilities to the community. Hence the token efforts to invite people in, to tick that box.

Its incorrect to say that parents who send their kids to fee paying schools to make sure they do better than other kids. I send my kids to get the most out of them. Would it be better if I spent it on holidays and fancy trainers for them?

aiding · 27/06/2022 11:22

If charitable status were to be removed, fees would go up and that would mean many families would no longer be able to afford it.

This would then increase pressure on an already overstretched state system and they would not be able to cope with the new intake of kids.

This would then make the likes of Eton etc even more elitist and full of wealthy international students; thus contributing to the money making private education system.

So absolutely should private schools hold charitable status.

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 11:21

Anyway so many well-off people like telling other parents that the only reason their kids go to private school is that they prioritise what they spend their money on. Surely if charitable status was withdrawn you would simply reprioritise what you spend your money on?

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 11:20

@SafferUpNorth You ordinary folks would still have the choice to pay for private schools without the state subsidy of charitable status. And it is a state subsidy.