Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
Sockwomble · 27/06/2022 14:49

And if a child requires a residential placement which can happen regardless of how close to home the school is, the placement can be £200K a year.

Sockwomble · 27/06/2022 14:45

"But equally lots of the children at these schools are privately funded because their parents can either afford it and can't be bothered to go though the very difficult process of EHCP or can make the sacrifices necessary to pay until an EHCP can be organised."

Specialist independent school places are generally £50 - £100k or more a year and they mostly only take LA funded pupils.

Namenic · 27/06/2022 14:38

Where do academies stand? Are some academies associated with companies?

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 14:29

15% of the average is £2k (based on ISC numbers)

I don't understand why people think of it as 'paying twice'. The proportion of taxes that go towards education come regardless of whether you have a kid in education. Education is a benefit to society, an educated workforce is a driver of our economy. It is in all our interests to ensure public education is well funded. It's sad that some see it as inadequate for their children but paying for private education, like private healthcare is a luxury that should be taxed as such.

Taxes subsidise public transport but car owners don't expect cars to be tax free because they already paid for public transport.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 14:17

toddlingabout · 27/06/2022 13:45

Same for Home Ed parents but they don't get to claim charitable status.

That’ll be because they aren’t charging their children fees.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 14:15

rwalker · 27/06/2022 13:21

What happens to the money the state saves by not having to educate theses kids in private school

It’s either providing better funding per pupil for state schools, or going into other government spending.

Whichever it is, though, if we closed all private schools tomorrow we’d have 8% more pupils in state schools, and would either have to accept that each pupil now got less funding, or find the money from somewhere else.

Getoff · 27/06/2022 13:59

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 11:25

I think a 15% tax on private school fees is reasonable.

It would raise an extra billion for the state sector and be ~£40 a week for parents. If you are paying private school fees this should be doable.

At least that way those on bursaries or scholarships wouldn't suffer and the really high fee paying places would pay more.

15% might be about 3K, which I think is roughly what a place in a state secondary costs each year. So the status quo is that private parents are paying nearly 7 times the cost of a state education, and you think a sensible reform would be to raise that to 8 times, so that those paying nothing and receiving a taxpayer subsidy of 3K a year can get an even bigger subsidy? I think a more sensible reform would be to get all the state school parents who can afford to to pay 3K a year. That would raise vastly more money, and would match a less batshit-crazy definition of fairness.

Snugglemonkey · 27/06/2022 13:50

Fere · 27/06/2022 13:48

@Snugglemonkey

The average person is benefiting. The tax payer does not have to pay for children in private school.

Do you think thst the same argument should apply and we should pay parents who decide to homeschooling their children?

Clearly that is a false equivalence. The equivalent to paying homeschoolers would be me being paid to choose private!

Fere · 27/06/2022 13:48

@Snugglemonkey

The average person is benefiting. The tax payer does not have to pay for children in private school.

Do you think thst the same argument should apply and we should pay parents who decide to homeschooling their children?

toddlingabout · 27/06/2022 13:45

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 09:46

You do realise that the parents also pay tax just like everyone but do not take up the school places in the state sector right?

Same for Home Ed parents but they don't get to claim charitable status.

SeasonFinale · 27/06/2022 13:45

If you looked at what scholarships they offer only then you haven't a true picture of what else they do to maintain their charitable status including loan of premises, access to science labs for other schools, access to playing fields, summer schools, assisted lessons etc. Before making a sweeping statement do access the full picture.

Coldilox · 27/06/2022 13:41

Private schools that are run as profit making businesses are taxed

Private schools that are non-profit making (most, afaik) are charitable and thus not taxed.

Some schools have separate non charitable activities, and these are taxed appropriately.

Snugglemonkey · 27/06/2022 13:38

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 11:25

I think a 15% tax on private school fees is reasonable.

It would raise an extra billion for the state sector and be ~£40 a week for parents. If you are paying private school fees this should be doable.

At least that way those on bursaries or scholarships wouldn't suffer and the really high fee paying places would pay more.

Many parents, ourselves included, make a lot of sacrifices for our children's education. Our fees are rising 8% next year due to the energy increases. This has tipped some parents into not being able to afford it. So no, an extra £40 a week is probably not doable!

Forestgate · 27/06/2022 13:35

Most of them are not run as for profit though

Plus all the other points already raised

Yabu

Jalisco · 27/06/2022 13:34

User112 · 27/06/2022 09:48

That’s irrelevant. Other businesses pay taxes! Independent school is hardly charity work!! They are a money making business

Education is a charitable aim, so they are allowed to apply for charitable status for any activity that is charitable. They may have other activities that are not charitable, and they will pay relevant taxes on those activities - just as many mainstream charities have trading arms that are separate, and do not attract tax relief but actually pay taxes. They can on claim tax relief on expenditure that is solely applied to providing education. If they are “making money” for other purposes then tax relief doesn’t apply. Whilst parents may not pay for state schools, many state schools have charitable status of some sort for fundraising activities, and the same rules apply to them.

edwinbear · 27/06/2022 13:31

And I don't have time, skills, influence and political pressure to help with the local state schools either, I'd just redirect the money saved on school fees to move next door to the best state school I could find.

edwinbear · 27/06/2022 13:26

Bursaries at DC's school are substantially more than 5-10%, they need to be, as to be considered for a bursary, your household income needs to be under £45k.

Sports and music scholarships are more like 10%, these are awarded more as a recognition to the child's ability, as opposed to being meant to provide substantial financial assistance.

DC's school have given places to 12 Ukranian refugees over the last couple of terms, with all uniform and other associated costs fully funded by the school, i.e. full bursaries, as they rightly should.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 13:26

Sewannoying · 27/06/2022 13:23

The state-school system would be amazing if the resources of would-be private-school parents were directed toward it. Not just financial resources, but time, skills, influence and political pressure.

I’m considering private school. I have none of these things (other than some limited financial resource that could be directed at paying for education) and I surely can’t be the only one.

The notion that somehow the state education system would become more responsive because more middle class parents send their kids there is laughable.

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 13:25

rwalker · 27/06/2022 13:21

What happens to the money the state saves by not having to educate theses kids in private school

Apparently its none of our business

Sewannoying · 27/06/2022 13:23

The state-school system would be amazing if the resources of would-be private-school parents were directed toward it. Not just financial resources, but time, skills, influence and political pressure.

I’m considering private school. I have none of these things (other than some limited financial resource that could be directed at paying for education) and I surely can’t be the only one.

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 13:23

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 12:12

@namechangeduetoimpatience if your finances are so tight that you can not reprioritise your spending to afford £40 a week, then your private school fees were always precarious anyway.

That's besides the point. If I decide that my child's needs are best met by an independent school and I choose to make the necessary sacrifices to afford it, you dont get to decided how much more of a burden I should carry.

Not every independent school is like Eton and not every independent school parent is filthy rich.

rwalker · 27/06/2022 13:21

What happens to the money the state saves by not having to educate theses kids in private school

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 13:12

Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 13:01

I think it is a difficult one to have blanket policy on. Lots of SEN schools are private, but most children are funded through the LA as the state schools cannot meet the needs of the child, particularly those with profound disability or needing physical support (lifts, accessible changing facilities etc).

But equally lots of the children at these schools are privately funded because their parents can either afford it and can't be bothered to go though the very difficult process of EHCP or can make the sacrifices necessary to pay until an EHCP can be organised.

In practice you’re highly unlikely to get a place in such a school unless it’s specified in an EHCP. There just aren’t enough of them.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 13:11

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 27/06/2022 09:58

Morally you’re probably correct but the logical outcome is that state school numbers increase by 8% overnight, which benefits nobody given the already parlous state of many state schools.

also many independents (eg for SEN) are actually run by Trusts and provide education for children who cannot survive in the state system because of disabilities such as autism. Do you want to put them out of business or just the ones that benefit rich kids?

Thank you for mentioning this. So often people overlook or ignore the SEN independent sector and it’s critical in helping kids get proper provision.

perenniallymessy · 27/06/2022 13:05

Charitable status has absolutely nothing to do with VAT.

Education is exempt from VAT (that includes training courses, professional qualifications etc).

Where registered charities charge for a service that would be VATable they have to add VAT just like any other business (assuming they have non exempt income over the VAT threshold or if they have voluntarily registered ).

Removing charitable status would just mean a tax on profits. A lot of private schools get donations from alumni, so if charitable status was removed they could presumably set up a charitable trust separate from the business to fund bursaries (just as school PTAs are charities).

If VAT was levied on education it would affect many more people than just those paying for private school. University fees would go up 20%, as would professional qualifications etc.