Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
Plantstrees · 17/07/2022 09:07

Back in the early 1970s we had grammar schools that were feeders for the top universities. Everyone in my town sat the 11 plus. The best school in the area by far was the grammar with a large percentage of each year group going on to prestigious universities. Those parents who could afford it, only sent their children private if they failed the 11 plus. The private schools therefore focused much more on the arts, sports and music rather than academics. This all changed with the abolition of our local grammar. From then onwards, the brightest kids with wealthy parents were sent private and so the whole nature of the local private schools changed and they started competing on their academic success instead of arts etc.

If you want everyone to be given the same opportunities we need our grammar schools back. You cannot reach the same levels of academic excellence in an inclusive classroom.

BungleandGeorge · 17/07/2022 02:49

@NewPotatoSalad because if you don’t consider sources of bias in your evidence it becomes meaningless. To consider anything properly you have to suspend your own prejudice and keep an open mind

NewPotatoSalad · 17/07/2022 02:27

Why are you justifying elitism and discrimination and cronyism, by questioning the statistics, insinuating that they aren't meaningful?

State school children have historically lost out to private school pupils, for elite university places. And continue to do so. It is not because the state school pupils are more stupid. It is because wealthier parents can buy privileges and networks for their children, regardless of how stupid those children are. For example, see Cameron, D, and Johnson, B.

BungleandGeorge · 17/07/2022 02:21

And it may be an unpopular thing to say but ability is not the same in a selective school as at a non selective school. Work ethic isn’t the same at schools who select pupils either. And intelligence does have something of a genetic component.
schools are all totally different, a comp or grammar in a ‘nice’ area is self selecting for a not fit similar demographic of students and parents at most private schools. The ones that service the privileged upper classes are a minority. And does anyone think that those people would be any less privileged if they went to a different school? The connections would still be the same

BungleandGeorge · 17/07/2022 02:04

@NewPotatoSalad i think it’s more like 20% who attend private sixth forms. Many of those unis have large intakes from abroad, how is that accounted for? What about places like royal college of music who will be taking a much higher percentage from private music conservatories (which are funded by government MDS awards based on talent but are still ‘private’). What percentage had scholarships and bursaries based on being gifted in some other way? What percentage of private school students study academic courses rather than vocational courses (which are generally only found at state sixth form colleges). What percentage of the private students were actually at specialist Sen schools? And if you want to be inclusive what percentage of the state school students went to academically selective schools?
so yes it’s important to look at these statistics but they aren’t necessarily that meaningful without some sort of analysis

NewPotatoSalad · 17/07/2022 01:26

Every one of those colleges listed by Soma should be accepting roughly 7% private school pupils, 93% state school pupils.

State school pupils are never more stupid, less able than privately educated pupils.

It's just that the privately educated have greater economic resources in building success scaffolding for their children and there are well-established channels for funnelling privileged kids with rich families into further privilege, regardless of any actual talent and ability.

Sometimes, with disastrous consequences - e.g. Cameron D. and Johnson B.

Thank you, Eton, for foisting those particular recent examples on us. And still male-only.

NewPotatoSalad · 17/07/2022 01:08

So no, the elite schools for 7% of the population should not be receiving tax subsidies from ordinary people.

NewPotatoSalad · 17/07/2022 01:03

According to a 2019 UK Government report: "Just 7% of British people are privately educated." and "The research finds that power rests with a narrow section of the population - the 7% who attend private schools and 1% who graduate from Oxford and Cambridge."

www.gov.uk/government/news/elitism-in-britain-2019

Soma · 17/07/2022 00:51

In case it is easier to see the universities with the fewest state school pupils as a list. Not all the favoured MN's Russell Group.

Regent’s University London: 25 per cent

  1. City and Guilds of London Art School: 30.3 per cent
  2. Royal Academy of Music: 37.5 per cent
  3. Courtauld Institute of Art: 40 per cent
  4. Royal College of Music: 44.8 per cent
  5. Royal Agricultural University: 62.1 per cent
  6. The University of Oxford: 62.2 per cent
  7. The University of Edinburgh: 63.2 per cent
  8. University of Durham: 63.5 per cent
10. The University of St Andrews: 63.9 per cent 11. The University of Exeter: 64.5 per cent 12. Imperial: 65.9 per cent 13. LSE: 67.1 per cent 14. University College London: 67.3 per cent 15. Guildhall School of Music and Drama: 67.4 per cent 16. The University of Cambridge: 69.1 per cent 17. New College of the Humanities: 69.6 per cent 18. Oxford Brookes University: 71.2 per cent 19. The University of Bristol: 71.3 per cent 20. The University of Bath: 71.9 per cent 21. Met Film School Limited: 72.7 per cent 22. Royal Academy of Dramatic Art: 73 per cent 23. Arts Educational Schools: 73.3 per cent 24. Newcastle University: 75.5 per cent 25. King’s College London: 76.6 per cent
Soma · 17/07/2022 00:47

Here's a list of the universities with the fewest number of state school pupils -thetab.com/uk/2021/02/11/revealed-the-unis-who-let-in-the-fewest-state-school-students-194852

NewPotatoSalad · 17/07/2022 00:34

Eton should be paying punitive taxes from now to eternity for foisting on us two of our worst prime ministers ever, Cameron D. and Johnson B., and instilling in them such blinding self-confidence that a very mediocre man indeed can make a competent UK leader.

Arkestra · 17/07/2022 00:15

So I guess we are down to the central problem with private schools having charitable status: that you have to pay to attend, and that their attendees grab a disproportionate amount of access to further education, and that this is a serious public harm, which tips the net public effect of private schools onto the negative side.

If anyone is prepared to engage with this point, I'm all ears.

ThinWomansBrain · 16/07/2022 14:17

Seen as parents are paying tax to fund their kids education if we start taxing school fees, the parents should be able to claim back the tax like childcare

the OP is not proposing a tax on school fees, just that private schools should not have charitable status, and thus their profits would be subject to tax.
If the schools wanted to reduce the tax liability, they could charge lower fees, or subsidise more places.
Making school fees tax deductable is a nonsense - subsidising elitism and encouraging more etonian twats.

Barbadossunset · 16/07/2022 14:06

Faffadoodledoo I’m not assuming it’s simple - just not impossible.
Do you think the Wolfson Trust and Nesta www.nesta.org.uk/blog/future-school-fundraising/ are wasting their time trying to organise ways for state school to fund raise?

faffadoodledo · 16/07/2022 13:50

@Barbadossunset you know full well that @Runnerbeansflower explained how it's not as simple as you assume.

Plantstrees · 16/07/2022 13:35

antelopevalley · 13/07/2022 15:07

I am not confused. Preferential tax treatment is a taxpayer subsidy. We give this to charities as they have purposes for the common good. Many charities the state depends on such as RNLI, Red Cross and WRVS. Not paying business rates on buildings is a reasonable taxpayer subsidy given their purpose.
Private schools provide education for mainly children of the top 5% of earning families. I do not think they should have a taxpayer subsidy. Parents should pay the full cost and not have taxpayers subsidising them.
Not including subsidies as part of any economic discussion is short-sighted. The government could decide that any income I earned was no longer taxed - just me. Even though the government is not giving me hard cash, it is clearly giving me taxpayers money through a subsidy.
There are times using taxpayers money in this way is justified and genuine charities is one of them. Private education is not a justified use of taxpayers money.

Honestly your arguments are bizzare! There is no subsidy and no taxpayers money is being given to private schools. Private schooling saves the taxpayer a fortune by schooling the 8% that attend private schools.

Barbadossunset · 16/07/2022 13:10

Does that answer your question @Barbadossunset?

So only private schools can fund raise because only they have rich students?This implies that no one who goes to state schools is successful in business or their careers which is patently untrue - upthread someone has said they would be happy to give their old school some money.
Apparently the Wolfson Trust are looking into it www.wolfson.org.uk/state-schools-fundraising-toolkit/

faffadoodledo · 16/07/2022 07:31

@Arkestra you make a good point about charitable status for those kinds of speciaist schools who cater for special needs. I have a young friend who teaches in one in Devon which seems to take kids who were excluded from state schools. The LAs appear to pay for the provision. No problem with this kind of set up for special needs.
But St Pauls. or even our local low ranking private school really shouldn't get the same treatment as the above

Aintnosupermum · 16/07/2022 05:19

@Arkestra Its not easy to tell the difference. The other issue is that my elder two both have ASD but both have a need for a highly structured academic setting. My son will do very well in a hot house environment. My daughter will do best in an all girls arts focused school. She wrote her first play at 6 and spent most of covid writing and directly YouTube videos (I filmed but never let her post anything!).

At the other end of the range are the children who really struggle and need specialized access to education. Plenty of private schools do not have amazing grades or have ever sent pupils to Oxbridge but they work with the children who would fail in a mainstream setting.

Runnerbeansflower · 16/07/2022 01:21

It's not a question of 'community'. It comes down to having rich families whose influence and access results in rich offspring.

Runnerbeansflower · 16/07/2022 01:18

It is expensive to stay in touch with alumni.

Worth doing if many of alumni can give £100,000 within 20 years of leaving school (e.g. Eton and the like).

Not financially viable for your standard state school

Arkestra · 16/07/2022 00:50

Aintnosupermum · 15/07/2022 01:32

Having spent the past couple of years living in Denmark, they have a terribly low education standard in general but they have a system that enables choice. Every school gets the same funding per pupil, the ‘private’ schools then charge an extra fee on top, which is waived if parents are low income. I think it’s a much fairer system.

My children will all be attending private school after a terrible experience in government schooling in the US and Denmark. My elder two have autism and my youngest needs additional pastoral care as we spent so much more time on the elder two. The school fees in Denmark came to £6500 per year for 3 children. In the US it will be about $110k, which is about £80-90k depending on the exchange rate. If my job offer comes through I’ll be spending about £60k in the UK on fees and another £20k on specific tutoring for the elder two.

I would prefer a system where parents have a real choice when it comes to educating their children. Removing the charitable status from schools doesn’t help anyone. The private schools offer that diversity that so many children need and mainstream settings can’t offer. It’s not about elite boarding schools. The vast majority of private schools are really nothing special and cater to those who wouldn’t thrive in a mainstream setting.

@Aintnosupermum I think there's a far stronger case for charitable status for private schools that fill gaps in provision - as opposed to those that try to afford preferential access to credentials. I don't know what the balance is between the two though. For instance the Girls' Day School Trust have 25 schools and they are definitely on the "preferential access" side of things. Is there an easy way to tell what the balance is between the two types?

Arkestra · 16/07/2022 00:25

DdraigGoch · 15/07/2022 23:59

There's more to it than that though. Some state school pupils do well for themselves, but they don't make bequests to their old school. Private schools on the other hand seem to work hard to maintain links with alumni. There appears to be a stronger sense of community.

@DdraigGoch that's an interesting point. Private schools certainly do a better job of keeping up with alumni, which obviously makes fund-raising easier. I would happily chuck my old state school some money - it was rough as a badger's backside, but the teachers were great and I really got a good education out of it - but they got shut down around 1990 when London hit a demographic dip.

Perhaps part of the problem is that there might not be a very clear route by which a bequest could be made: the legal entity of a state school can be quite mutable (academy conversions, closures etc) and so it's harder to get something stable that a bequest can manage. What happens to a bequest when the government or local authority decides to mix things up and marge/close schools?

Arkestra · 16/07/2022 00:01

@TullyApplebottom "To question whether they provide public benefit is legitimate. To say they are subsidised is untrue, and not legitimate. If you cannot argue your case honestly, maybe it’s not that strong."

I totally agree with that last sentence! But I didn't say private schools were subsidised at any point in this thread, so I'm afraid that your second sentence is untrue. So overall you appear to be arguing against your own ability to state a strong case? In general, accusing people of dishonesty isn't a very effective rhetorical tactic, for all kinds of reasons. But fire away with both barrels if you want, just try not to blow your own feet off at the same time.

Arguments about private schooling tend to be low quality because people say they are all good or all bad. But like any interesting thing on this planet, our current setup of private schools has positive and negative aspects - to say that anything is totally good or totally bad is puerile. The question is what the net effect is. And whether this is the same across the entire set of private schools, which are a very varied bunch.

For what it's worth, I think there is a strong argument for charitable status for private education that's filling a gap, e.g. in provision for children who can't integrate readily with mainstream education for whichever reason. I'm less sure about the St Paul's of this world, at the other extreme.

You haven't yet responded to my main point: that attendees of private schools grabbing a disproportionate amount of access to further education is a very serious public harm, which tips the net public effect onto the negative side - at least for a substantial proportion of private schools. Why not counter that argument? You could say:

  • it's true, but X and Y offset it (for some kinds of schools or all)
  • it's not true (there's a fair bit of evidence for it though)
  • it's true, but it's not actually a bad thing
  • some other argument that my Guardian-reading-liberal mind is incapable of coming up with by itself

What do you think?

DdraigGoch · 15/07/2022 23:59

Runnerbeansflower · 15/07/2022 19:41

Because they don't have alumni that are rich enough to give £100,000 at a time (as Rishi Sunak did)?

There's more to it than that though. Some state school pupils do well for themselves, but they don't make bequests to their old school. Private schools on the other hand seem to work hard to maintain links with alumni. There appears to be a stronger sense of community.

Swipe left for the next trending thread