Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
greywinds · 27/06/2022 16:17

if we're driving private schools closed with an actual plan to increase state school diversity, halving class sizes plus giving home schoolers and flexi schoolers tax breaks I'll be on that picket line.

But if it's just some vague sense that you'd like even more abysmally failed kids in your classes being disruptive to meet a sense of fairness then...

LillyDeValley · 27/06/2022 16:17

@Merryoldgoat really? Most schools spend 70-90% of income on staff costs. Surely you would have to be making big capital purchases each year to mean you offset the vat and not pass on?

Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 16:11

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 16:03

@Merryoldgoat I work for an independent school too and I disagree. My school is old, established and not at all cash rich. Many of our parents would not be able to afford 20% more and the school couldn't afford to lose its charitable status. We'd close, which would remove provision for a large number of kids, many of whom are not top drawer academically but thrive in our small, close, friendly environment. I think our school is much more typical of most independent schools than the stereotype of Eton and Harrow.

I agree.

I think mumsnet has quite a fixed opinion on what a "typical" private school looks like. And its nothing like the reality, particularly outside of London.

greywinds · 27/06/2022 16:10

It's more complicated than that though - plenty of private schools help kids with ASN who didn't cope in mainstream that aren't specifically special schools.

Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 16:06

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 15:08

But why are private schools so special? Only 6% go private, it's a luxury choice.

Other luxuries are taxed.

There are plenty of examples where taxes fund the public version and those who decide they want a private version pay for it and are taxed on it....private healthcare, transport, security.

But somehow buying private education can't be taxed?

But it isn't always a luxury, as has been explained on this thread. It would disproportionally impact disabled children.

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 16:03

@Merryoldgoat I work for an independent school too and I disagree. My school is old, established and not at all cash rich. Many of our parents would not be able to afford 20% more and the school couldn't afford to lose its charitable status. We'd close, which would remove provision for a large number of kids, many of whom are not top drawer academically but thrive in our small, close, friendly environment. I think our school is much more typical of most independent schools than the stereotype of Eton and Harrow.

Merryoldgoat · 27/06/2022 15:56

How the fuck can you compare a private school to the RSPCA? 🤣🤣

Merryoldgoat · 27/06/2022 15:55

@LillyDeValley

Currently we can’t reclaim VAT on purchases.

If we had to charge VAT we’d adjust fees to take into account the VAT we could reclaim and take a lower surplus so parents don’t see any real increase.

We’ve already modelled this successfully without any significant impact to our bottom line with current surplus being exceeded within 5 years after changes.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 15:53

BungleandGeorge · 27/06/2022 15:09

I don’t quite get your argument. Huge amounts of money pass through many charities and most of them help a minority of the population?

My point isn't about the minority, it's that private education is a luxury only some can afford and we have a model that says it's appropriate to tax luxury goods and services.

Charity services that are provided free can't be taxed by the person paying.

Merryoldgoat · 27/06/2022 15:51

Because we’re not really charities - we exist (in the main) to create profits (after providing education of course). Yes, they aren’t distributed to shareholders but they allow us to accumulate wealth and assets that don’t benefit many people.

Successful schools making a surplus should pay tax.

I’d exempt schools that are for the provision of special education of course.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 15:49

@TullyApplebottom I'm not disputing the right to choose a private provider but our model is that people pay tax on services. Private healthcare, private security, private transport. No where else I can think of do people argue they shouldn't pay tax on a service because there is public sector provision in place.

I just don't get why it's different.

LillyDeValley · 27/06/2022 15:48

@Merryoldgoat but it’s not the school who will pay VAT. It’s the parents who will pay it on the fees.

prinnycessa · 27/06/2022 15:42

Merryoldgoat · 27/06/2022 14:55

I work for an independent school and think we should pay tax and VAT.

Sorry @Merryoldgoat that should have said why?

prinnycessa · 27/06/2022 15:38

@Merryoldgoat ?

Thebeastofsleep · 27/06/2022 15:22

And this couldn't be done without increasing state provision. Lots of parents couldn't long term afford a 20% rise in fees so would have to place children in state schools. Where I live they are already over subscribed. I don't mean the good ones, I mean ALL of them. Classes on 35+ in the infants. We desperately need more state provision but there are no plans to build more schools here.

greywinds · 27/06/2022 15:21

Eliminating private schools would not eradicate a two tier system, just reduce diversity. We need more educational diversity, not less. Different children suit different types of schooling options.

And yes to more support for homeschool and flexible schooling.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 15:13

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 15:08

But why are private schools so special? Only 6% go private, it's a luxury choice.

Other luxuries are taxed.

There are plenty of examples where taxes fund the public version and those who decide they want a private version pay for it and are taxed on it....private healthcare, transport, security.

But somehow buying private education can't be taxed?

Education is not a luxury. If a parent chooses to procure education from a provider other than the state, in a free and democratic society that is a perfectly reasonable choice (as long as the provider meets minimum standards).

BungleandGeorge · 27/06/2022 15:09

I don’t quite get your argument. Huge amounts of money pass through many charities and most of them help a minority of the population?

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 15:08

CousinGregg · 27/06/2022 15:02

Yes tax everyone twice, thrice and a gazillion times! Whoo hoo I loathe dogs and would prefer they are all put down. Shall we tax the RSPCA now too?

But why are private schools so special? Only 6% go private, it's a luxury choice.

Other luxuries are taxed.

There are plenty of examples where taxes fund the public version and those who decide they want a private version pay for it and are taxed on it....private healthcare, transport, security.

But somehow buying private education can't be taxed?

CousinGregg · 27/06/2022 15:02

Yes tax everyone twice, thrice and a gazillion times! Whoo hoo I loathe dogs and would prefer they are all put down. Shall we tax the RSPCA now too?

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 15:02

Namenic · 27/06/2022 14:38

Where do academies stand? Are some academies associated with companies?

Possibly but there's no point taxing them as it's public funded. It would be the government taxing itself.

SofiaSoFar · 27/06/2022 15:00

antelopevalley · 27/06/2022 12:12

@namechangeduetoimpatience if your finances are so tight that you can not reprioritise your spending to afford £40 a week, then your private school fees were always precarious anyway.

Is this only applicable to people paying school fees, or does it apply to other areas of expenditure, too?

I can imagine how well it will go down on other threads...

"We're having to pay an extra £2k for the holiday we're about to set off on due to issues with flights..."

"If your finances are so tight that you can not reprioritise your spending to afford £40 a week, then your holiday was always precarious anyway"

Etc...

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 27/06/2022 14:58

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 09:46

You do realise that the parents also pay tax just like everyone but do not take up the school places in the state sector right?

I’m not sure how it works in England, but where I live, schools are funded based on the number of students. So if parents opt out of the state system, the state schools won’t get the money that would have flowed to them with the extra student. The parents paying taxes is irrelevant to the school system.

Merryoldgoat · 27/06/2022 14:55

I work for an independent school and think we should pay tax and VAT.

Florenz · 27/06/2022 14:53

If it was up to me I'd privatise all education and give all parents tax credits to use towards their child's education.