Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
SummerPuddings · 27/06/2022 18:41

It's disgusting.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 18:21

From looking at a few school websites (Gordonstoun, glenalmond, dollar academy) they are still describing themselves as charities ….

greywinds · 27/06/2022 18:14

Probably too early to say - I hear significant few rises across the patch this year, the first ones post pandemic. Not 15 percent though.

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 18:07

Scotland has already brought in reforms away from private schools having charitable status. Does anyone know how that has impacted more widely?

OP posts:
greywinds · 27/06/2022 18:04

I don't really care about the charitable status question itself - not sure why I posted. Charitable status is gone in Scotland, I'm there and it's fine:

But in general of course there is no data for percentage SN in private - you can't even get clear data for this in the state sector let alone any accountability whatsoever.

I don't quite understand how more children with SN coping in private schools being forced back into the state sector is desirable for anyone, regardless of the percentage or parental income.

My point really is that parents of kids with ASN need more options not fewer and it benefits state school kids for my DC not to be hogging a larger share of resource than the average pupil to fail in a state school.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 18:03

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 17:40

No one is saying abolish private schools. I'm saying, make fees taxable just like any other luxury.

By the age of 30 a private school educated person earns 22% more than state school educated people.

That's what most parents are buying. A service that advantages their kids. That service should be taxed, just like any other service.

And yes I think the £1.22bn that a 15% tax would get should be put into the state sector.

Again, education is not a luxury. In a free society if people wish to make arrangements to educate their children outside the state sector they should be permitted to do so provided the alternative provision is of good quality.

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 17:58

Loads of people say they should be abolished. If you slapped 15% on the fees, lots of parents would simply have to withdraw their kids and put them in the state sector.. regardless of as already overstretched capacity. Some schools would close entirely and those teachers may or may not choose to apply in the state sector but the schools can't afford to employ more anyway. Typical example upthread there of the donation to Eton cited as evidence as though it's typical when it is categorically not. My school does blatantly and unashamedly fundraise because we have to to fund capital projects.

Seashor · 27/06/2022 17:53

My son was at a Woodard school and they did plenty to help the community. The local schools were always using their sport and drama facilities and they weekly opened their doors to cubs, scouts, a cinema club and gymnastics to name but a few. Just because you don’t know what they do doesn’t mean that they don’t do anything charitable.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 17:40

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 17:25

scholarships and bursaries add up. If a school is making less than 200k "profit" a year and they have to use half of that to cover the fees of scholarship and bursaries there will be v v little left to invest in keeping up the facilities, staffing levels etc. Again, whilst some schools have v wealthy endowments, ancient benefactors, assets etc, the vast majority really don't and have been hit hard in the last two years by Covid causing a drop in international boarders. As a pp said, if the aim in abolishing private schools was to somehow use it to massively improve and diversify the state sector that would be great. If its ideological "smash the rich" just to bring everyone down to the same poorly funded and over used state level then no.

No one is saying abolish private schools. I'm saying, make fees taxable just like any other luxury.

By the age of 30 a private school educated person earns 22% more than state school educated people.

That's what most parents are buying. A service that advantages their kids. That service should be taxed, just like any other service.

And yes I think the £1.22bn that a 15% tax would get should be put into the state sector.

Sparklybutold · 27/06/2022 17:34

There is absolutely no ethical justification for private schools to hold charitable status. But then I find private schools deplorable and elitist anyway.

MainePyarKiya · 27/06/2022 17:32

To all the fee paying parents who have apparently sent their children private and sacrificed their children's state school place for the good of the rest of society and are apparently paying tax twice 🤣 OP you are not unreasonable at all!

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 17:26

jcyclops · 27/06/2022 17:21

I've said on previous threads that if these schools want to retain their charitable status, they should raise funds on high streets with collection boxes, or are they scared or ashamed of trying it.

It is also noticeable that the charities are often not registered with the school name. It may be easier and less shameful to raise money for the "New Children's Sport Facility" than for xxxx private school.

Many private schools also receive gifts and donations. If the donors are UK taxpayers then the government gives them an extra 25% through Gift Aid.

£8.5m was donated to Eton in 2018 - worth about £62,000 per pupil and Gift Aid could have added another £15,500 of taxpayers money. Compare this to the £7,000 average funding per pupil in state schools.

This makes no sense. On the one hand you are saying the schools should raise funds by direct donation - and in the next breath condemn them for doing it. which is it to be?

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 17:25

scholarships and bursaries add up. If a school is making less than 200k "profit" a year and they have to use half of that to cover the fees of scholarship and bursaries there will be v v little left to invest in keeping up the facilities, staffing levels etc. Again, whilst some schools have v wealthy endowments, ancient benefactors, assets etc, the vast majority really don't and have been hit hard in the last two years by Covid causing a drop in international boarders. As a pp said, if the aim in abolishing private schools was to somehow use it to massively improve and diversify the state sector that would be great. If its ideological "smash the rich" just to bring everyone down to the same poorly funded and over used state level then no.

Summerwhereareyou · 27/06/2022 17:25

Antelope valley, my DC doesn't have prevelant enough Sen to warrant being sent to a Sen school.

However she has enough to know she won't be educated properly at our local comp which is known for letting down Sen pupil's ( leafy).

Having a special Sen school would also lead to far more stigma than the grammar system ever did.

Summerwhereareyou · 27/06/2022 17:22

@Dogtooth

I couldn't disagree more.
Our local comp is quite good but is not doing right by its Sen pupil's. I know a few mums who have got on governess board/lobbied/ complain and it's all fallen on deaf ears. The SLT are known for being totally arrogant and blinkered?

What else are parents supposed to do for goodness sake?

jcyclops · 27/06/2022 17:21

I've said on previous threads that if these schools want to retain their charitable status, they should raise funds on high streets with collection boxes, or are they scared or ashamed of trying it.

It is also noticeable that the charities are often not registered with the school name. It may be easier and less shameful to raise money for the "New Children's Sport Facility" than for xxxx private school.

Many private schools also receive gifts and donations. If the donors are UK taxpayers then the government gives them an extra 25% through Gift Aid.

£8.5m was donated to Eton in 2018 - worth about £62,000 per pupil and Gift Aid could have added another £15,500 of taxpayers money. Compare this to the £7,000 average funding per pupil in state schools.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 17:17

ArcheryAnnie · 27/06/2022 16:34

This makes a lot of sense to me.

I think the "local charitable activities" thing is a red herring. We have several highly-regarded private schools near where I live, who offer "extra resources" to local primary schools, which are insulting and embarrassing, and certainly not what they'd offer their own kids. It's so clearly a tick-box exercise about "local charitable activity" which uses state school children as props, rather than a real exchange.

I do think independent SEN schools should either remain charities, or be brought into the state system to be fully or properly funded. I have been surprised by the mention of these schools here as my experience has been of witnessing the opposite: families where the expected thing is for all the kids to be sent to a high-end private schools, apart from the disabled kid, who is sent to a state school because that's where its possible to insist on proper disabled provision, and the private schools don't provide that as it's too expensive.

I think parents and caregivers ought to be able to send their kids to whatever schools they like, but if those schools are outside state provision, then they shouldn't be subsidised by the state in the form of charitable status.

Schools are only allowed to be charities and be taxed accordingly if they operate as charities. Can you explain why you think that’s a subsidy? It’s surely more a question of being taxed according to the sort of creature you are - provided you meet the requirements.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 17:15

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 17:08

@greywinds @Thebeastofsleep do you have any data on the disabled and SEN children in private schools, I've looked and can't find anything.

Whilst I can believe that there are some parents who scrimp and save to send their SEN children to private school because they can't get an ECHP I don't buy the idea this is the typical private school parent.

A tiny number of low income families do this but among high earners (£300k +) 60% of kids go private.

The income you need to have a spare £15k for private school is a high income.

Meanwhile 40% of EHCP kids get free school meals.

My DS has an EHCP (he has ASD) and has been educated in mainstream private school throughout.
in the early days thst was because the state sector simply refused to accommodate the provision he required. Now it is also to do with the fact that the particular skills he has are far better catered for in the private sector. Plus they deal with bullying robustly.
the state won’t support kids like mine properly. It just won’t do it.

Summerwhereareyou · 27/06/2022 17:13

Unfortunately because the mainstream offer from the state is so narrow,I don't believe for one second private education is causing huge issue's.

We need more variety of school not less.
Having said that, I do feel that they need to do more for the local community, give more scholarship's, do more out reach etc.

State provision has woefully provided for one DC and I have to pay to fill in the gaps.
The other is catered for only by grammar.

entropynow · 27/06/2022 17:10

The provision of education is in and of itself charitable in law and has been since defined in the early 17th century. Nothing to do with social equality.

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 17:09

I know that my school has a very small surplus left over after salaries, pensions, upkeep, resourcing etc. Our facilities are actually pretty dated and dire compared to some local state schools but what we do have is v small class sizes and pastoral groups of less than a dozen. A day that runs from 8.0-6.30 with 3 meals provided if needed, over a hundred extra curricular clubs and so on. The tiny surplus we have is ploughed straight back into direct benefit to the school site, facilities, improved SEN provision etc. There is literally no profit in the traditional sense being made and as I say, that is MUCH more typical of most indie schools than what people think.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 17:08

@greywinds @Thebeastofsleep do you have any data on the disabled and SEN children in private schools, I've looked and can't find anything.

Whilst I can believe that there are some parents who scrimp and save to send their SEN children to private school because they can't get an ECHP I don't buy the idea this is the typical private school parent.

A tiny number of low income families do this but among high earners (£300k +) 60% of kids go private.

The income you need to have a spare £15k for private school is a high income.

Meanwhile 40% of EHCP kids get free school meals.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 27/06/2022 17:03

Worrying about private schools having charitable status just comes across as petty, jealous, and small minded IMO.

They are educating children, saving the state sector a fortune, and they don’t make huge profits.

Merryoldgoat · 27/06/2022 16:55

LillyDeValley · 27/06/2022 16:17

@Merryoldgoat really? Most schools spend 70-90% of income on staff costs. Surely you would have to be making big capital purchases each year to mean you offset the vat and not pass on?

We pay about 50% income in salary costs.

Our biggest costs aside from staff are catering, transport and premises, a lot of which would have VAT to reclaim. Plus recruitment and capital etc it’s a big chunk.

Wed not be unscathed but we have plans to weather it.

ArcheryAnnie · 27/06/2022 16:34

Merryoldgoat · 27/06/2022 15:51

Because we’re not really charities - we exist (in the main) to create profits (after providing education of course). Yes, they aren’t distributed to shareholders but they allow us to accumulate wealth and assets that don’t benefit many people.

Successful schools making a surplus should pay tax.

I’d exempt schools that are for the provision of special education of course.

This makes a lot of sense to me.

I think the "local charitable activities" thing is a red herring. We have several highly-regarded private schools near where I live, who offer "extra resources" to local primary schools, which are insulting and embarrassing, and certainly not what they'd offer their own kids. It's so clearly a tick-box exercise about "local charitable activity" which uses state school children as props, rather than a real exchange.

I do think independent SEN schools should either remain charities, or be brought into the state system to be fully or properly funded. I have been surprised by the mention of these schools here as my experience has been of witnessing the opposite: families where the expected thing is for all the kids to be sent to a high-end private schools, apart from the disabled kid, who is sent to a state school because that's where its possible to insist on proper disabled provision, and the private schools don't provide that as it's too expensive.

I think parents and caregivers ought to be able to send their kids to whatever schools they like, but if those schools are outside state provision, then they shouldn't be subsidised by the state in the form of charitable status.