Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 27/06/2022 21:36

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/06/2022 19:36

If there were no private schools, politicians and their wealthy donors would have to send their children to state schools. Therefore state schools would improve.

Rich people hold all the power in this country. Private schools perpetuate that.

If private schools don't buy an unfair advantage why does anyone use them?

Wrong. They’d just send them abroad - or home educate them in small groups.
You can never force every child to be sent to school. The rich will always find a way to maintain ‘elitism’.

justasking111 · 27/06/2022 21:11

Charities cannot claim back VAT that's 20%

edwinbear · 27/06/2022 21:06

Are we saying tax private school fees only? Or education in general? So if we can put VAT on school fees, are we going to add VAT to, for example, state school trips as well? So outdoor pursuits now has 20% VAT added to the cost?

Jedsnewstar · 27/06/2022 21:05

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 09:46

You do realise that the parents also pay tax just like everyone but do not take up the school places in the state sector right?

Weak argument. Most people use a small percentage of the things tax pays for. Some more some much less. People with no children also pay tax.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 21:03

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 20:16

It's true it is hard to force change when people are such relentless cunts.

“Relentless cunts”
you got a mirror handy?

MinglingFlamingo · 27/06/2022 20:56

My old school was a Woodard School
At one point. It's a massive company. From what I understand even before it was a Woodard school it was a registered charity. Think it's something to do with giving extra protection if the school gets into financial difficulty

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 20:44

TBH inherited was a bit crass/ dogwhistle. Private education is wrong even if you come from a working class background. Lots of people can make the most of an opportunity, but you have to have the opportunity in the first place - chance, inheritance, background, right place right time, all of these things can generate opportunity (although privilege is the most common). But none of these things are morally justifiable reasons to entrench inequality by buying your children an undeserved (by them, although I'm sure they're lovely) leg up because you had an opportunity.

Pottedpalm · 27/06/2022 20:25

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 19:37

It's remarkable how touchy private school parents are about the fact that others might think they're .. selfish people.

And hilarious that someone has used the word 'diversity' in the context of their choice to buy their kids an unfair advantage.

Of course having the school that suits the child is important. It couldn't be more important. But it's important for every child, not just the middle class ones. The funnelling off of some children has a profound impact on the country as a whole - and not just because the sharp-elbowed remove their attention from the state education system, which would improve with their democratic pressure: here is barely a single aspect of our society which the funnelling off doesn't infect. It props up inequality. It maintains inequality. It is, in fact, inequality. That's what you're buying - inequality.

This is not an act without consquence for others - like choosing Heinz baked beans instead of Sainsburys, because you can afford it and why shouldn't you - and you're all despicably disingenuous in pretending it is. The existence of private education damages all the children left behind, and the adults they go on to become. It damages us all. Except for you, private school parent, and your lovely offspring who were lucky enough to have parents who could afford the fees - - through your own bloody hard work, no doubt, and nothing to do with the class privilege you inherited.

Too right through our own hard work, no inherited wealth or privilege here.

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 20:16

It's true it is hard to force change when people are such relentless cunts.

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 20:09

@SnackSizeRaisin "state schools would improve" How? A pp has just explained exactly how she would respond if forced to send her kid to the local state school. She would buy a house closest to the best one, pay for tutoring and her child and others like them will bulge out the top sets. Parental "power" in schools is minimal. All you'd get is selection by postcode, as is already the case, only even more so, and the most well off, or those on the edges, paying for tutoring.

LuaDipa · 27/06/2022 20:00

That’s assuming the tax raised was funnelled back into schools in it’s entirety.

I’m no politician but I’m pretty sure that wouldn’t be the case. All those extra kids will still need funding though.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 19:45

@LuaDipa but a 20% tax paid by the remaining 90% at private school would bring in £1.5bn.

The billion or so extra to the treasury would certainly help.
You could almost restore the pupil premium to where it was in 2014 before all the real term cuts came in.

justasking111 · 27/06/2022 19:45

namechangeduetoimpatience · 27/06/2022 09:46

You do realise that the parents also pay tax just like everyone but do not take up the school places in the state sector right?

This, more money for the rest of us

greywinds · 27/06/2022 19:45

Why would you edge out schools that are succeeding in order to funnel kids back into schools that have failed to meet their needs? That's pretty selfish.

You wouldn't which one of the many reasons govts wont do this.

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/06/2022 19:43

Car driving is much more heavily subsidised than public transport....roads are an enormous cost and are paid for out of general taxation. 50 million for one new junction type of cost.

Agree with the rest of your points though

2MinuteRice · 27/06/2022 19:42

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 27/06/2022 09:58

Morally you’re probably correct but the logical outcome is that state school numbers increase by 8% overnight, which benefits nobody given the already parlous state of many state schools.

also many independents (eg for SEN) are actually run by Trusts and provide education for children who cannot survive in the state system because of disabilities such as autism. Do you want to put them out of business or just the ones that benefit rich kids?

Lots of state schools are designated SEN. They take state pupils from mainstream and support their disabilities.
So why should the private ones have charitable status?

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 19:37

It's remarkable how touchy private school parents are about the fact that others might think they're .. selfish people.

And hilarious that someone has used the word 'diversity' in the context of their choice to buy their kids an unfair advantage.

Of course having the school that suits the child is important. It couldn't be more important. But it's important for every child, not just the middle class ones. The funnelling off of some children has a profound impact on the country as a whole - and not just because the sharp-elbowed remove their attention from the state education system, which would improve with their democratic pressure: here is barely a single aspect of our society which the funnelling off doesn't infect. It props up inequality. It maintains inequality. It is, in fact, inequality. That's what you're buying - inequality.

This is not an act without consquence for others - like choosing Heinz baked beans instead of Sainsburys, because you can afford it and why shouldn't you - and you're all despicably disingenuous in pretending it is. The existence of private education damages all the children left behind, and the adults they go on to become. It damages us all. Except for you, private school parent, and your lovely offspring who were lucky enough to have parents who could afford the fees - - through your own bloody hard work, no doubt, and nothing to do with the class privilege you inherited.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 27/06/2022 19:36

Additionally, it's not that easy to remove charitable status. Broadly, charity assets can't be used for non-charitable purposes so it would create a fair bit of legal confusion. There would be a potential risk to other organisations like Universities if it was held that the provision of education for a fee was not charitable.

I suspect the cost of removing charitable status would mean that nowhere near as much money was raised as expected. eg if the schools can reclaim VAT as well as having to pay it the amount raised is reduced and if higher fees push some people into the state sector then that has a cost implication.

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/06/2022 19:36

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 17:25

scholarships and bursaries add up. If a school is making less than 200k "profit" a year and they have to use half of that to cover the fees of scholarship and bursaries there will be v v little left to invest in keeping up the facilities, staffing levels etc. Again, whilst some schools have v wealthy endowments, ancient benefactors, assets etc, the vast majority really don't and have been hit hard in the last two years by Covid causing a drop in international boarders. As a pp said, if the aim in abolishing private schools was to somehow use it to massively improve and diversify the state sector that would be great. If its ideological "smash the rich" just to bring everyone down to the same poorly funded and over used state level then no.

If there were no private schools, politicians and their wealthy donors would have to send their children to state schools. Therefore state schools would improve.

Rich people hold all the power in this country. Private schools perpetuate that.

If private schools don't buy an unfair advantage why does anyone use them?

LuaDipa · 27/06/2022 19:33

ElbowGreaseLightning · 27/06/2022 19:18

I’m really intrigued as to how exactly the standards will miraculously go up in my local state school if I take my kids out of private?

I think it’s more likely that instead of 30 in a class, it’ll be 35-40 kids. Instead of 5 maths sets, there will be 6 or 7 with many of those children pushed down a set. I’ll also buy a house next to the school and drop £200 quid a month on maths lessons to make sure my kid is in the top set and working towards an 8/9.

A private school recently closed in my area and the local council could not accommodate them. They ended up to an hour away. My town has exploded in population and instead of expanding the secondary, the narrowed the caption area. I was in it, then got my 4th choice of school, a failing one, so said screw this, my DC is staying in private. They had the option to buy an existing school, with masses of land and a pool and they didn’t, they sold it to a housing development.

I’m agog at the naivety. Tax private school and/ or remove charitable status? It would make the state system worse, not better.

This.

My kids go to an independent school and saving the government money wasn’t part of the decision making process. But that doesn’t change the fact that each privately educated child saves the taxpayer around £7000 per year.

If even 10% of children left independent school, the taxpayer would have to find an extra £42,000,000 to fund their education. I would bet that a significant increase in fees in the current climate would price out more that 10%.

That would mean more competition for school places in areas of high demand and even bigger class sizes. It seems to be unpalatable to many, but like it or not state education is already subsidised by the private sector.

AFineBalance · 27/06/2022 19:32

OP you are right it is ridiculous.

Lots if illogical responses about how state system couldn’t cope with overnight changes which isn’t what you suggested. Or how private school parents should get tax breaks for the state place they didn’t use. Tax and the social contract don’t work like that.

Yes we should gradually withdraw the use of charitable status for private schools. The private school sector has been enhancing its elitism so it can bring in more money from overseas. Burseries etc and other activities which might be seen as charity related are not top priority. So they shouldn’t get the status. Or the tax breaks.

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/06/2022 19:30

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 09:58

The parents who send their children there are paying for a state school place too, and not using it, which does benefit the state schools and every pupil in them.

Promoting equality may be what you feel is a public good, but that’s very much a value judgement. I support equality of opportunity for example, but not equality of outcome.

If you support equality of opportunity then presumably you would like to see state schools banned.

ElbowGreaseLightning · 27/06/2022 19:18

I’m really intrigued as to how exactly the standards will miraculously go up in my local state school if I take my kids out of private?

I think it’s more likely that instead of 30 in a class, it’ll be 35-40 kids. Instead of 5 maths sets, there will be 6 or 7 with many of those children pushed down a set. I’ll also buy a house next to the school and drop £200 quid a month on maths lessons to make sure my kid is in the top set and working towards an 8/9.

A private school recently closed in my area and the local council could not accommodate them. They ended up to an hour away. My town has exploded in population and instead of expanding the secondary, the narrowed the caption area. I was in it, then got my 4th choice of school, a failing one, so said screw this, my DC is staying in private. They had the option to buy an existing school, with masses of land and a pool and they didn’t, they sold it to a housing development.

I’m agog at the naivety. Tax private school and/ or remove charitable status? It would make the state system worse, not better.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 19:10

We don’t tax all services. Lots aren’t subject to VAT. If education is to be subject to VAT that will hit lots of people other than those paying for private schools as others have pointed out.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 18:49

@TullyApplebottom I totally agree. I don't want to take away anyone's freedom! I just think private education should be taxed like any other service. Why shouldn't it?

We tax goods & services. If you choose to send children to a fee paying school you should pay tax on those fees just like any other service.

I don't see why you wouldn't

Swipe left for the next trending thread