Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
ChiselandBits · 28/06/2022 07:22

@MyBrilliantFriend don't you think that's a bit insulting to the 93% of parents who currently send their kids to state schools though? Do they not care enough, make enough fuss? What's so amazing about the other 7 that's suddenly going to transform the entire edifice of state education?

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 07:20

The biggest in equality in our schools is not to do with private school.

It's well within state sector with DC like mine being let down?
My dd was lucky she had me
She shouldn't need me, what about the other DC who don't have a me?

How many illiterate people are in prison? How many with literacy issue's are in prison?

That's your inequality but that doesn't fit the cosy entrenched views does it.

Attack Sen ,get all over it, get it into pgce, train tas and pay them properly, get special tas specialised in Sen, get consultants in...

That's true leveling up.

MyBrilliantFriend · 28/06/2022 07:17

@Summerwhereareyou that would be brilliant. Because the difference is funding. That’s all.

All state schools would benefit from the kind of motivated, wealthy parents who choose private schools sending their dc to state schools instead - because then they’d be invested in the state sector. They’d fight for it instead of just opting out. And we’d be able to improve things for all DC because if everyone had to use state schools, we wouldn’t end up in a position where it was acceptable for government to cut funding year on year so we’re in a situation now where in 3 years time we might just return to the same funding schools were getting in 2010. That’s appalling.

No one is doing the state sector a favour by choosing private education. Yes higher numbers in state schools would be an initial challenge but the state sector would be massively benefited in the longer term - which would be better for absolutely everyone.

faffadoodledo · 28/06/2022 07:14

My children were (through our choice) state educated and did very well indeed (Oxbridge and another specialist top uni, followed by jobs) so this isn't personal - no chips!
But several things always strike me on these threads


  1. the number of posters who talk about 'sacrifice'. I'm not sure they know the meaning of the word. They're actually talking about 'choice'

  2. the poster who always crops up implying that people who can't afford private school spend all their money on trainers and big TVs. I won't name names but scroll up and you'll find her. It's a horrible assertion imo.

  3. the assumption that giving a child a subsidised place on a scholarship or small bursary is pure charity. It isn't; the school is getting something in return - it gets a talented musician or mathematician or athlete to boost its results. And deprives a local school of that result.

  4. The assumption that people like me are ok because we used a mythical 'leafy comp'. No. We were living in an area and just used the local school (in our case it's just swerved special measures but to be fair my youngest left it 6 years ago).

Those are just small points and don't touch the whole inequality thing. It's way too big and gnarly to face this time in the morning!

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 07:01

Winter my DC are not in private but I would move them,one of them in a flash if I could

Thankfully I was able to get one into a grammar school and she's ok now,the local comp although rated now outstanding left much to be desired.

The younger has some Sen and left to again an outstanding primary without my intervention I dread to think where we would be.
I dread to think.

We need more types of school not less, more variety not less.
The amount of DC at private school is actually very small compared to state.
Yet seemingly v successful.
Perhaps it's time to start modelling state on private if that's the success story you think it is.

Why drag everyone down?

ChiselandBits · 28/06/2022 06:57

@WinterDeWinter but the parents are perfectly nice, hard working people who want the best for their kids. They happen to earn enough in their chosen career to afford fees, or have made other choices and sacrifices to afford it. Lots are farmers, or self employed tradespeople who have done well. We also don't live in the south and some made the choice to move away from there to free up cash from housing costs. Are we really calling parents doing the best for their kids cunts now? I know literally no-one in real life who would actually actively disadvantage their kid for a point of principle.
I don't think all indie schools are great and all state schools crap. There are plenty of amazing state schools but plenty aren't, or don't offer whats needed.
Until there is a viable plan to level up the state sector to something comparable, taxing the private sector and effectively killing off most of it would be a spectacular own goal for any government.

sashh · 28/06/2022 05:20

CrotchetyQuaver · 27/06/2022 10:36

Oops. Was going to add that a lot of the special colleges for SEN older students are charities too. That stuff is very expensive to provide and places like that and their students would suffer greatly if this was bought in.

I wonder how childless people feel about paying their local and national taxes towards education?
I think you need to drop this

I'm childless.

I have no problem paying my taxes to educate children, as I get older I'm going to need more healthcare and I want there to be Drs and nurses and social workers and street sweepers and refuse collection.

I want all of those people to be educated.

State schools need more funding and less regulation.

Private schools with charitable status IMHO need to be transparent and they should do more than just benefit those already attending.

There was a TV show on a while ago where a private and a comp school did a sort of exchange trip, 2 weeks in each other's schools.

Some of the state pupils were then offered scholarships to attend the private school.

I don't know if the school was a charity but if they were using charitable funds to offer those scholarships then what good were they really doing? Those 2 or 3 children would get a top education, but that would leave the comp with fewer academic and well behaved children.

The money that was spent on the scholarships, and not all children took them, could have funded something that benefitted every pupil in the comp.

montysma1 · 28/06/2022 04:10

There are plenty of public services I dont use. Should I get the tax back?
Oh and childless people arent costing the education sector money either. How about giving them back some tax too?

Its simply not how the tax system works.

maryso · 28/06/2022 00:18

It would be useful to weigh up the consequences of removing charity status, mainly that there need no longer be fee remission or bursaries at independents without charity status. I'm agnostic about this since I don't really know what the consequences are.

Independents are always shouting about the many pupils who get fee remission, however anecdotally many of these are said to be from sharp-elbowed middle class families, rather than the "deserving poor". Would this not increase the sharp-elbowed impact on state schools, where anecdotally "normal" families tend to be elbowed out of the "better" state schools?

The trouble is there don't seem to be any facts easily available about who would not have attended without charity status, and the wider consequences resulting from this. So airing perceived grievances becomes pointless because the lack of data or analysis means firstly nobody will take any notice, and if they do for political reasons, the consequences may be directly opposed to what campaigners say they want anyway. So I say, show us the data, and the likely outcomes. At least then we can have an adult conversation and judge if these outcomes are what we expect and whether they actually get delivered.

DdraigGoch · 28/06/2022 00:02

I've said on previous threads that if these schools want to retain their charitable status, they should raise funds on high streets with collection boxes, or are they scared or ashamed of trying it.
@jcyclops how many charities receive most of their funds through collection boxes? Most of the big charities receive large amounts of government funding, and pay their executives handsomely.

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 23:55

Relentless cunts”
you got a mirror handy?'
We'll, do you have a defence handy? You don't like my vehemence, but you don't seem to have an argument against my point that private school parents are kidding themselves if they think they are not deeply anti-social and selfish.

SlowHorses · 27/06/2022 23:54

I looked at their books on company house yesterday. The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous.

Whatever my feelings on private schools this is a stupid comment. Have you seen how much money is moving through ‘actual’ charities?10’s, 100’s and billions of pounds.

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 23:52

mathsquestions · 27/06/2022 23:02

Their kids will be working to pay your pension and fund the NHS in your later years.

I'd be very impressed if that were the case. But in fact, they'll be working to fund the better lifestyle that their parents' selfishness has bought them. They're only accidentally paying towards universal benefits like pensions to which they will also be entitled. They're compelled to.

WinterDeWinter · 27/06/2022 23:49

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 22:07

@WinterDeWinter you know what, I'd love you to come and spend a couple of days at my school. Meet the kids, the staff, the parents. And then call us all cunts. Cos I bet all the money you think we have that we don't that it and we would be absolutely nothing like what you think we are.

I'm calling the parents cunts, not the children. Until the kids do the same thing for their own kids, which they will. An unearned head start.

I can see that sEN shifts everything.

Yazo · 27/06/2022 23:46

Completely agree and private education isn't doing the rest of us a favour by saving money. Where I am there is no secondary school in the whole postcode, thousands of kids a few miles out of the city centre because all the land is taken up educating a few hundred kids (mostly overseas children) People don't put their kids in school for the greater good but their own benefits. Charitable or not I think we should have a bit of honestly.

DdraigGoch · 27/06/2022 23:40

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 14:29

15% of the average is £2k (based on ISC numbers)

I don't understand why people think of it as 'paying twice'. The proportion of taxes that go towards education come regardless of whether you have a kid in education. Education is a benefit to society, an educated workforce is a driver of our economy. It is in all our interests to ensure public education is well funded. It's sad that some see it as inadequate for their children but paying for private education, like private healthcare is a luxury that should be taxed as such.

Taxes subsidise public transport but car owners don't expect cars to be tax free because they already paid for public transport.

If education is a benefit to society, then it shouldn't be taxed.

Blinkingbatshit · 27/06/2022 23:10

In France if you choose to go private the state still pay what they would in the event your child went to state school and then you just top up the difference……just imagining your reaction if that were to be suggested in the uk!😂

mathsquestions · 27/06/2022 23:02

Their kids will be working to pay your pension and fund the NHS in your later years.

TullyApplebottom · 27/06/2022 22:58

Presumably the schools would all just become CICs - no increase in tax paid as they don’t have to make a return for shareholders and would just invest profits in the school. Plus they’d escape regulation as charities and not be subject to public benefit test, so under less pressure to offer bursaries, provide assistance to state sector etc.
cant see how that helps anyone, really

Namenic · 27/06/2022 22:55

I can see the logic in removing charitable status. I don’t think it will do much good - because not all teachers in private schools would transfer to state sector (where there is already a lack of teachers), there would be a large extra cohort for the state sector to cope with in 1 go. Richer parents would buy houses near top state schools and send their kids to tutoring. Overseas pupils studying in U.K. would reduce, reducing income for the country.

Skidaramink · 27/06/2022 22:39

My children go to a private school and I voted YANBU.

Frankly, I wish there were no such thing as private schools. If there weren't, I strongly believe state schools would be better (more middle-class, professional, "pushy" parents).

I can't see private schools actually being banned any time soon but making them so expensive that hardly anyone can afford them would be the next best thing.

ChiselandBits · 27/06/2022 22:07

@WinterDeWinter you know what, I'd love you to come and spend a couple of days at my school. Meet the kids, the staff, the parents. And then call us all cunts. Cos I bet all the money you think we have that we don't that it and we would be absolutely nothing like what you think we are.

BanjoVio · 27/06/2022 22:04

Private schools with charity status give out scholarships to allow local students from less affluent backgrounds to attend for free. The schools I’ve worked at had several students who didn’t pay fees (because they couldn’t), but they still passed the entrance exam.

FelicityFlops · 27/06/2022 22:00

Most private schools were originally charitable foundations to help and educate "the poor".
These days the state educates "the poor".
My aunts and my mother all went to a Woodard Corporation school, my sister and I went to a school founded in 1558 as a charity for "Blue Maids".
I do not really get the point that you are making as the current state system was only instigated after the 1944 Education Act.
As with anything state it is oversubscribed ditto the 1947 National Health Service.
Many fee-paying schools have scholarships and bursaries available to anyone. My school had a far greater social mix than the school I did my teaching practice in, which was 95% or higher C2s.
Why do you not like the idea of people spending their money on something they value, such as education?

PixellatedPixie · 27/06/2022 21:46

Why not rather go after huge corporations that don’t pay their taxes the taxes they are owed. Being angry about independent schools is often the politics of envy! My local state school has some parents dropping kids off in Ferraris and life in massive houses but the local independent has some parents who live in small flats with ancient cars.