Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
WinterDeWinter · 28/06/2022 17:51

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 13:10

Winter enough of society is already disadvantaged without private education going anywhere near it.

They have been are still being failed in crap comps, which by now should be slick highly functional places to give each child their best shot.

You think because there are bad things in the world, other bad things are ok?

WinterDeWinter · 28/06/2022 17:50

faffadoodledo · 28/06/2022 13:22

@WinterDeWinter let me introduce myself. Did the rounds of private schools because we could absolutely afford it (oh the hard graft and sacrifice 😂). But decided it wasn't for us. Two super bright DC, with educated parents (one Oxbridge and PhD, me just a mere Masters). And we felt they didn't need an extra leg up because of all that cultural capital behind them (although at the time I didn't have a label for it!). Moreover we wanted them at school in their community, rubbing shoulders with all levels. Fortunately this terrible child anise we inflicted did no harm. They got a Cambridge and Durham degree and satisfying jobs out of it.

Have some faith in your DC!!

Not quite sure why aimed at me? This is what I am advocating for.

ElbowGreaseLightning · 28/06/2022 16:04

It was for Winter

faffadoodledo · 28/06/2022 14:24

@ElbowGreaseLightning who me?
That's funny...!

DdraigGoch · 28/06/2022 14:22

I know literally no-one in real life who would actually actively disadvantage their kid for a point of principle.

Wasn't that the reason for Jeremy Corbyn's second divorce? His then wife wanted to send the kids to grammar school whereas he refused on principle.

ElbowGreaseLightning · 28/06/2022 13:25

Jeremy Corbin, is that you?

whumpthereitis · 28/06/2022 13:24

WinterDeWinter · 28/06/2022 12:28

"I know literally no-one in real life who would actually actively disadvantage their kid for a point of principle."

Then you are mixing with the wrong crowd @ChiselandBits . It's not a question of 'actively disadvantaging' your child, it's about not stealing for them an unfair advantage in relation to others. From that perspective, can you see that yours is an ideologically individualist position which disadvantages the rest of society?

The thing is we are a society that balances the common good with individual freedom. You’re working with the assumption that parents have a moral duty, beyond legal duty (taxes) to support state schools by sending their children to them. They don’t. The primary responsibility of a parent is to their own child, no one else’s, and most won’t deny their children opportunities because others don’t have access to them.

Removing charitable status is going to have the impact of making private schools even more ‘elitist’. Those who would have benefited from bursaries, or those whose parents could only just afford it, are going to lose out.

faffadoodledo · 28/06/2022 13:22

@WinterDeWinter let me introduce myself. Did the rounds of private schools because we could absolutely afford it (oh the hard graft and sacrifice 😂). But decided it wasn't for us. Two super bright DC, with educated parents (one Oxbridge and PhD, me just a mere Masters). And we felt they didn't need an extra leg up because of all that cultural capital behind them (although at the time I didn't have a label for it!). Moreover we wanted them at school in their community, rubbing shoulders with all levels. Fortunately this terrible child anise we inflicted did no harm. They got a Cambridge and Durham degree and satisfying jobs out of it.

Have some faith in your DC!!

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 13:10

Winter enough of society is already disadvantaged without private education going anywhere near it.

They have been are still being failed in crap comps, which by now should be slick highly functional places to give each child their best shot.

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 13:09

Great post elbow grease.
Ddgraigh

Totally agree.

As we can see some poster's actually don't care about people with literacy issue's filling up prison's,or a lack of Sen provision (unless they can drag out funding issue's/of Which in agree there are issues but aren't the whole issue!).

It's not a good political soundbite.

WinterDeWinter · 28/06/2022 12:28

"I know literally no-one in real life who would actually actively disadvantage their kid for a point of principle."

Then you are mixing with the wrong crowd @ChiselandBits . It's not a question of 'actively disadvantaging' your child, it's about not stealing for them an unfair advantage in relation to others. From that perspective, can you see that yours is an ideologically individualist position which disadvantages the rest of society?

ElbowGreaseLightning · 28/06/2022 11:17

DomPerignon

It’s called Tall Poppy Syndrome and you find it everywhere here in the UK.

Anyone who is deemed to have something that you don’t, usually house, salary, education is in the wrong and has acquired it by either inheriting it from some Lord or they’ve screwed over someone vulnerable to get it. Instead of working hard themselves, studying and taking risks, it’s far easier to demonise others and pull them back down and put them in their place.

Even at my independent school, the parents get their knickers in a twist over someone getting on the sports team instead of theirs, or someone getting an academic award. They and their DC aren’t prepared to work hard for anything.

I now realise that actually I am privileged. I’m privileged to have seen and experienced hardship when young. I’m privileged to have lived amongst other cultures and see how they value education. I’m privileged to witness the culture here in the UK where education is not valued and people let their DC fail. I’m privileged in that I can process all this and realise that if you want something, you have to work for it and grab education with both hands If I can’t send them to this school, I’ll still do the above. What I won’t do is sit here and whinge about what other people have got and how me and mine are held back by people better off than me, of which there are many.

DdraigGoch · 28/06/2022 10:52

@DomPerignon12 indeed, it's the same attitude as used in the 1960s - instead of improving the secondary moderns, they brought everything else down to their level.

DomPerignon12 · 28/06/2022 09:58

@ElbowGreaseLightning same here. I’m stunned by the lack of critical thinking on this thread.
Many people seem to think that making state schools the ONLY option would force ‘them’ to improve.
Ignoring people buying privilege with expensive houses in catchment areas.
Ignoring private tutoring, homeschooling etc as a private option.

The same attitude has led to the new rules on landlords, which will be a spectacular own goal for the gov as many LL’s sell up and rental supplies restricted. Let’s just cut down the people we deem ‘privileged’, instead of fighting for more funding/provision for everyone.

Fordian · 28/06/2022 09:13

Since Tories are highly unlikely to tax the schools their own DC are advantaged by, the only way is contextual offers at uni, taking into account education to Y11, not just sixth form.

ElbowGreaseLightning · 28/06/2022 09:06

through your own bloody hard work, no doubt, and nothing to do with the class privilege you inherited

Yep, through my own hard graft, and DH's. Both brought up in the NW, on estates and went to state schools. Moved to and lived in London, lived and worked overseas for 17 years and saved like mad, came back here and put our DC in private school.

Where I lived overseas taught me some very important life lessons about how you should invest your time and effort in your DC's education and hobbies.

My eldest just sat 11 GCSE's and was predicted all 9's. I don't care if anyone thinks I am a c**t or selfish.

Hey Winter, what have you done to improve your life and your DC's? Have you put in as much graft as I have?

ChiselandBits · 28/06/2022 09:00

The biggest hurdle to overcome in the field of education, medicine, infrastructure, all of it is short term thinking. No government is prepared to get behind a programme that will take twenty years to bear fruit. Its all short term quick fixes that don't work but look good ready for the election every 5 years.

faffadoodledo · 28/06/2022 07:43

I think a big issue is that the children of people who make decisions about the education of the majority of children in this country don't actually attend state schools. So the decision makers have no skin in the game and no real insight. That is a big structural problem and one that I'd argue makes for restricted funding and muddled thinking when it comes to managing our schools.

faffadoodledo · 28/06/2022 07:42

@BiFoldChampion and those schools will be getting something in return for those children who they are subsidising - specialist talents and the resulting exam results. Let's not pretend this is pure charity. It is transactional.

BiFoldChampion · 28/06/2022 07:42

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 27/06/2022 19:45

@LuaDipa but a 20% tax paid by the remaining 90% at private school would bring in £1.5bn.

The billion or so extra to the treasury would certainly help.
You could almost restore the pupil premium to where it was in 2014 before all the real term cuts came in.

what makes you think that’s how the Treasury works? They don’t make money in one place then direct that into another equivalent place. How do you think they got the money to pay for covid.

with this government’s track record on education any money coming from the method you describe would not go into education. It would simply mean the education system is burdened further, bigger class sizes. Most people couldn’t afford the increase in fees

MyBrilliantFriend · 28/06/2022 07:39

@ChiselandBits not at all intended to insult anyone - I’m a motivated involved state school parent myself.

But if more people didn’t have the option of opting out of the state sector, it would improve. Just look at our current government - none of them have any experience or investment in the state sector. Which is why they’ve happily cut funding for state schools year on year and seem absolutely intent on waging a war against teachers. If they were looking at their local schools & knowing their dc would be going there, they’d be funding them better for a start.

BiFoldChampion · 28/06/2022 07:39

Ablababla · 27/06/2022 09:55

Most of the most expensive private schools are charities. The one local to us does some outreach to local primary schools by providing after school clubs for things like chess. Other than that there’s very little they do that I’d consider charitable

I think you’ll find there are children on fully subsidised places or with a high percentage bursary.

Namenic · 28/06/2022 07:36

@Yazo overseas pupils increase U.K. gdp.

@MyBrilliantFriend - a lot of things in schools take a long time to change. I don’t know what exactly the private school parents would do in a state school to improve things for everyone? Wouldn’t they just send their kid to tutoring? (I’m guessing this should be taxed too) They would buy houses near the best schools - so people would pushed to the lower rated schools.

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 07:27

It's an absolute myth and doesn't play out at all.
Grammar and private school are in the mintory,plenty of rich people send their DC locally and make not one jot of difference.
This largely because state school don't see them as accountable at all to their clients.

The parents and children.

We see this time and time again on here,the sheer seething contempt of teachers against parents.

It's a strained relationship which I believe would be made far better with a more open transparent relationship and also more parent accountability and work with some parents who don't back up the school.
But the flip side is remember that parents and children are the clients!

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 07:23

My brilliant not at all.

I know parents on governor board, others who have lobbied, complained etc to the comp I removed dd from.
It's just got an outstanding but is known for arrogant SLT who don't listen to anyone.
Aside from the money to actually peruse legal action what on earth would other parents do?

This is a leafy wealthy area with many wealthy parents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread