Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 02/07/2022 14:10

Oh yes and don’t we hear all about the charity work 🙄

I expect this from ds school I expect state schools to add to the community too which they do

faffadoodledo · 02/07/2022 12:19

Bickles · 02/07/2022 12:05

DS is at private school and they do have a lot of bursaries and scholarships as well as doing a lot of community work. I think their charitable status is justified.

And they get something in return for those scholarships: talent. They are buying talent from other schools.
Sports scholarships attract athletes; music scholarships attract musicians. And not all are n financial need either by any means

howtomoveforwards · 02/07/2022 12:11

Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions

I am not sure this is much of an argument. I don't benefit from a whole host of charities that are out there because my personal circumstances are such that I don't need their services or have no interest in whatever it is they are campaigning for. A charity supporting homeless people in London is of no use to me whatsoever, even if homeless, if I am living in Birmingham. But I assume you wouldn't argue the London charity shouldn't exist just because you can't use it's services. Confused

Just because we can't all benefit doesn't mean there aren't people who will benefit.

Bickles · 02/07/2022 12:05

DS is at private school and they do have a lot of bursaries and scholarships as well as doing a lot of community work. I think their charitable status is justified.

ChiselandBits · 02/07/2022 11:59

I don't think you have any idea of the actual financial status of the vast majority of private schools or the majority of parents that send their kids there. Again, how is making life tougher for them going to help the state sector? It simply won't so all you're doing is making life worse for more kids. Many schools would close if the extra 20% had to be passed on to parents. Those kids then enter the state sector and swell numbers further.

HRTQueen · 02/07/2022 10:32

I have not mentioned closing private schools many are hugely wealthy

i have said they absolutely should not have charitable status. Schools shall have to suck up the extra costs and some will have to be passed on to families they are businesses this happens with business

state schools have had to tighten their belts too

its a privileged position to be in a child at private school there is no need for extras privileges

ChiselandBits · 02/07/2022 10:07

@HRTQueen but it really is a very few of "these schools" that have huge cash reserves. As I have repeatedly said, the vast majority are actually very tightly run, narrow margins and often, whilst the buildings might look lovely as they are older, not flat roofed 60s/70s built comps, the actual infrastructure, especially tech is often way behind. But parents still want their kids to go there for all the reasons I have outlined preciously. I 100% agree we should be focusing on how to level up state schools but anyone that thinks closing private schools would achieve that is deluded.

TullyApplebottom · 01/07/2022 22:13

WinterDeWinter · 28/06/2022 21:51

I don't know @TullyApplebottom - I guess according to the extent that you feel a twinge of recognition, or mildly stung? I don't feel that I can in conscience stop pointing out inequity and describing its impacts because people find it or me awkward. It is often excruciating for me tbh. But I do feel a moral obligation - and in particular to point out that many of the things we think are 'natural' are not at all, and are in fact very ideologically conservative, individualist, anti-communitarian, and have the goal of making us believe that consumer capitalism is the natural state of humanity. But I can't make you hear it if you won't.

The arrogance and pomposity of this. Actually very funny

antelopevalley · 01/07/2022 14:58

@Getoff A company have to be undertaking activities that meet charitable benefits. These were tightened a few years ago around concerns that it was being used by some as a tax loophole. But schools are still covered if they do additional things to prove their charitable status.

ElbowGreaseLightning · 01/07/2022 08:57

So basically, removing charity status would have no financial consequences on the school at all, but it would make some people feel better about themselves for having scored points against those who are deemed to be privileged.

HRTQueen · 30/06/2022 20:17

Getoff · 30/06/2022 09:32

of course they shouldn’t hold charitable status iits shocking that they do

I think this is based on a misunderstanding. Charity status means that they do not pay corporation tax. They cannot distribute profits to owners, so ultimately they will have to spend all their money. If their profits were taxable, they could just find a way to spend money in the same tax year it came in, and get the same result, of paying no corporation tax. In other words, for an organisation that is not trying to make a profit to benefit owners, and would rather further their own aims than give money to HMRC, all charity status does is give them some extra flexibility around how they spend.

I once worked alongside a management consultancy that charged out its workers at thousands per day. It was legally a charity, which one of the consultants did look embarrassed about when he mentioned it. But I saw nothing wrong with that, as all it meant was that all the money they took in would go out in salaries, which money would be taxed at a higher rate than it would have been if passed to owners as profits.

I’m well aware of what it means. Are you aware Getoff of how much wealth some of these
schools are.

Most parents make sacrifices for their children I don’t know any who don’t. Being able to choose to send your child/children to private school you are in a privileged position. That privilege should not come on top of other privileges of the school

DomPerignon12 · 30/06/2022 16:01

@WinterDeWinter once again, you have missed the point.
We have an obligation to those ‘left behind’. By providing what they need.
Not by tearing down others.
Your argument throughout this thread was that private schools should be closed. But the bigger picture is that some people will always be more privileged. Not just with money, as I pointed out more involved parents etc.

Why so much effort in cutting them down? Why not just provide more for state schools, SEN provision etc?

Its not a zero sum game. Having private schools doesn’t take away from state schools, if the latter were properly funded in the first place

faffadoodledo · 30/06/2022 13:39

Unsure of your definition of sacrifice @BiFoldChampion. Wouldn't 'choices' be a better word?

BiFoldChampion · 30/06/2022 11:54

What about those parents who make lots of sacrifices to afford school fees?

Getoff · 30/06/2022 09:32

of course they shouldn’t hold charitable status iits shocking that they do

I think this is based on a misunderstanding. Charity status means that they do not pay corporation tax. They cannot distribute profits to owners, so ultimately they will have to spend all their money. If their profits were taxable, they could just find a way to spend money in the same tax year it came in, and get the same result, of paying no corporation tax. In other words, for an organisation that is not trying to make a profit to benefit owners, and would rather further their own aims than give money to HMRC, all charity status does is give them some extra flexibility around how they spend.

I once worked alongside a management consultancy that charged out its workers at thousands per day. It was legally a charity, which one of the consultants did look embarrassed about when he mentioned it. But I saw nothing wrong with that, as all it meant was that all the money they took in would go out in salaries, which money would be taxed at a higher rate than it would have been if passed to owners as profits.

WinterDeWinter · 30/06/2022 09:20

DomPerignon12 · 29/06/2022 16:31

@WinterDeWinter @ArcheryAnnie the only way to make things completely fair would be to remove children from their homes completely and put them all into boarding schools.
Then we can get rid of ALL influencing factors. This would especially benefit children who have a bad home life like abuse etc.

Strangely.. not a popular idea.

And it’s not even about money. Parental attitude and support is a big influence. Where I come from illiterate people make their children study - they know it’s one of the only ways out of poverty. However a child whose parents had just given up wouldn’t. Same school. Same economic background.

Of course it’s not to THAT extent in the U.K. but similar, there are people In ‘deprived’ communities who value education. You’d want to punish them though. You think it’s unfair their children have involved parents.

Once again, I point out that the fact that perfection is not possible does not mean that we have no obligation to those left behind.

faffadoodledo · 30/06/2022 07:22

Excellent @Blinkingbatshit - and I wonder if they can claim 15 per cent tax relief on that from the tax payer?
Sheesh. Just awful

Blinkingbatshit · 30/06/2022 07:14

Anyone else see the story in the news yesterday about Kings Canterbury School taking a massive donation from a now sanctioned oligarch to build new science labs?! Just imagine how that (unfortunately most likely dirty) money might have helped a real charity…

HRTQueen · 29/06/2022 21:07

of course they shouldn’t hold charitable status iits shocking that they do

they absolutely are businesses and many are extremely successful

and no there shouldn’t be a tax rebate state schools will still be there if you need them

SW1amp · 29/06/2022 20:47

@ArcheryAnnie
i just think the end result would be that those who know how to game the system get a bigger advantage, and the rest stay where they are

same as the ‘abolish private schools’ crew, who don’t have an answer for what do with the parents who would send their kids to the super elite Swiss boarding schools, or the french/Swiss outposts that would be hastily created by the newly-abolished British schools

because what would happen is that those already at the top of the privilege tree climb even higher, and those on the lower branches slip down

ArcheryAnnie · 29/06/2022 20:33

@SW1amp @DomPerignon12 I did say that I dont thinkbits possible to have an entirely fair system, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't think about tweaks that would make the current system a bit fairer, overall. It wouldn't work the same for everyone, but then so system does.

@SW1amp that's one of the things that I don't think can be accounted for, but you can't account for every variable, just do your best.

University admissions are (or should be) about picking the kids who have potential, and who would make the best of the opportunities and do well on whatever degree course it is. Giving admissions tutors as much information as possible about what might have helped or hindered each candidate in showing that potential (or lack of it) seems to be a good thing, even if it can't be done perfectly.

DdraigGoch · 29/06/2022 19:11

greywinds · 28/06/2022 19:54

I'd like global and local inequality to change, but I don't think it's best achieved by closing down schools or institutions that are not failing.

New ideas are needed. Where I am, private school for senior is less than the extra house price costs - less selfish because you've paid through your house price and not school fees?

In fact it's more selfish as you may get the house price back when you sell on to other well heeled parents.

And yet so many feel that is more virtuous.

Quite. Look at the senior politicians (Blair, Cameron etc.) who have made a political point of sending their children to state schools. These certainly aren't failing inner city comps of course, they're the best state schools that house prices or arranging church flowers can buy.

If you go out of your way to get your child into a good state school, you're just as sharp-elbowed as those who pay school fees. Yet according to some on here, only the latter are reinforcing inequality.

Summerwhereareyou · 29/06/2022 16:42

Dom that wouldn't work either.
Some teachers and boarding school would be vastly better than others and again, some would be abusive hell holes.

DomPerignon12 · 29/06/2022 16:34

Also r.e tutoring vs not.
all you’re saying is those who didn’t get any learnt the exact way school taught. Am equally bright child who is a more visual or hands on learner for example may be left out. Doesn’t mean they’re not as bright . Tutor might have unlocked their potential.

There are a lot of free tutoring programmes, in religious institutions like mosques. Serving many poorer members of the community.
So not declaring that is fine?
but a middle class parent paid professional tutor is not fine?

DomPerignon12 · 29/06/2022 16:31

@WinterDeWinter @ArcheryAnnie the only way to make things completely fair would be to remove children from their homes completely and put them all into boarding schools.
Then we can get rid of ALL influencing factors. This would especially benefit children who have a bad home life like abuse etc.

Strangely.. not a popular idea.

And it’s not even about money. Parental attitude and support is a big influence. Where I come from illiterate people make their children study - they know it’s one of the only ways out of poverty. However a child whose parents had just given up wouldn’t. Same school. Same economic background.

Of course it’s not to THAT extent in the U.K. but similar, there are people In ‘deprived’ communities who value education. You’d want to punish them though. You think it’s unfair their children have involved parents.