Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 21:38

For most it is take-home pay minus council tax.

Runnerbeansflower · 03/07/2022 21:31

Thebeastofsleep · 03/07/2022 21:24

Take home pay + any benefits/ other income after is just total income after tax to me.

For most of us this is near enough what it means in practice for our situation.

There will always be people who want to undermine your argument by fastening on to irrelevant details

Thebeastofsleep · 03/07/2022 21:24

Take home pay + any benefits/ other income after is just total income after tax to me.

Thebeastofsleep · 03/07/2022 21:23

Runnerbeansflower · 03/07/2022 19:56

Income after tax.

There are various qualifications to that, I think it is based on income tax and wealthy people are very good at finding loopholes.

But basically, for employed people, it is 'take home pay'. The money you allocate to housing, food, clothing, entertainment etc

You see I wouldn't consider that "disposable". You need to buy necessities, it's a choice where you live but you do have to live somewhere. Disposable to me suggests something you can choose what to spend on.

Runnerbeansflower · 03/07/2022 21:07

Although of course it could be 'normal' (or even low income) for your social group.

But looking at it from the perspective of the whole population

Runnerbeansflower · 03/07/2022 21:05

And also my point - whichever figure you use for an average household income, £60,000 is very well off and not 'normal '

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 21:04

Thebeastofsleep · 03/07/2022 19:46

What's considered a disposable income?

Mean and median income is all income from all sources.

Disposable income is all income minus direct taxes, such as Income Tax, National Insurance and Council Tax, have been accounted for.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth/bulletins/householddisposableincomeandinequality/financialyearending2021

So the above poster is incorrect. So most it is your take-home pay, plus benefits or pensions, minus council tax.

Runnerbeansflower · 03/07/2022 21:03

BungleandGeorge · 03/07/2022 20:50

@Runnerbeansflower see above you’re not quoting correct information so maybe don’t be condescending

There is no 'correct '

Any 'average ' is arrived at with a number of qualifications. Even at primary school I learnt three different ways of reaching an average (mean, median and mode).

Then it depends which specific situations are included/excluded. So the above figure might only include income subject to income tax, whereas the wealthiest people tend to benefit from income that is not subject to income tax

My point being that the figure I quoted was accurate and can be verified, along with the information about how it was arrived at. Given a previous poster attacked the figure.

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 20:50

£60,000 is more than the average income. I agree that it is not massively above, not super-rich. But a couple with two children would struggle to send them to private school for all their schooling, or even just secondary schooling, unless they had grandparents chipping in money or inheritance they were relying on.

More or Less on Radio 4 tonight talked about how retired people do have a lower income on average, but it is not that much lower. From memory, it was something like £509 per week versus £549, including all pensions and benefits.
So it does not have as much impact on the overall figure as you might think.
In terms of those elderly people though, it will include benefits like attendance allowance that pays for carers. So not all money to enjoy yourself.

The advice out there about being able to afford private schools often includes the fact that grandparents can gift money for this to reduce their inheritance tax bill.

There are of course children with complex special needs in private school placements paid by the local authority. So not all parents whose children go to a private school are well-off. But most are.

BungleandGeorge · 03/07/2022 20:50

@Runnerbeansflower see above you’re not quoting correct information so maybe don’t be condescending

BungleandGeorge · 03/07/2022 20:45

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 18:24

A couple with 2 children under 14 would be on the 50th centile if they have a disposable income of £39,400 a year. Interestingly couples without children have a much lower income on average. I wonder if benefits such as childcare tax credits account for some of the difference?

Those figures are not absolute they are equivalised and the occupants characteristics taken into account. They are not absolute values, they’re used for comparison so not the right ones to use really.

disposable income takes off:
income tax and National Insurance contributions
domestic rates and council tax
contributions to occupational pension schemes
all maintenance payments
student loan repayments
parental contributions to students living away
ground rent and service charges

so thousands off most people’s actual income

Runnerbeansflower · 03/07/2022 20:01

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 18:21

"2021, the average (median) real terms household income before housing costs was £539 per week (around £28,100 per year). This represents a reduction of 1.7%, or £9 per week, compared with FYE 2020. Average income after housing costs also reduced to £472 per week (around £24,600 per year)."

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/households-below-average-income-for-financial-years-ending-1995-to-2021/households-below-average-income-an-analysis-of-the-income-distribution-fye-1995-to-fye-2021#:~:text=Figure%204%20shows%20that%20in,around%20%C2%A324%2C600%20per%20year).

Thanks. As I quoted.

And I question the claim that single parents and retired people drag this figure down. For example my parents, who had above this income on retirement AND had paid off their mortgage. Or my friend who is a single parent, a solicitor, who earns above this.

On the other hand, another friend is on benefits because her husband is disabled, and gets considerably less.

Yes, if your bubble consists of traditionally professional, two parent families, then £60,000 probably seems quite normal. It's your normal. Not the normal of the majority of the population

Runnerbeansflower · 03/07/2022 19:56

Thebeastofsleep · 03/07/2022 19:46

What's considered a disposable income?

Income after tax.

There are various qualifications to that, I think it is based on income tax and wealthy people are very good at finding loopholes.

But basically, for employed people, it is 'take home pay'. The money you allocate to housing, food, clothing, entertainment etc

Thebeastofsleep · 03/07/2022 19:46

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 18:24

A couple with 2 children under 14 would be on the 50th centile if they have a disposable income of £39,400 a year. Interestingly couples without children have a much lower income on average. I wonder if benefits such as childcare tax credits account for some of the difference?

What's considered a disposable income?

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 18:32

Posted because I like facts.

"The proportion of children attending private school is close to zero across the vast majority of the income distribution, and doesn’t rise above 10% of the cohort except among those with the top 5% of incomes. Only half of those in the top 1% send their kids to private school."

"if we focus on those outside the top income decile, a large majority – up to four out of five children – are not receiving grants or bursaries.
Furthermore, among those who received it, average financial support was around £4,900 in 2011-2018."

blogs.ucl.ac.uk/ioe/2021/02/08/housing-wealth-not-bursaries-explains-much-of-private-school-participation-for-those-without-high-income/

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 18:29

And parents with that average level of disposable income and two children could not afford private school fees for them. Although I appreciate they might be able to if grandparents are paying a fair chunk of them.

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 18:24

A couple with 2 children under 14 would be on the 50th centile if they have a disposable income of £39,400 a year. Interestingly couples without children have a much lower income on average. I wonder if benefits such as childcare tax credits account for some of the difference?

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 18:21

"2021, the average (median) real terms household income before housing costs was £539 per week (around £28,100 per year). This represents a reduction of 1.7%, or £9 per week, compared with FYE 2020. Average income after housing costs also reduced to £472 per week (around £24,600 per year)."

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/households-below-average-income-for-financial-years-ending-1995-to-2021/households-below-average-income-an-analysis-of-the-income-distribution-fye-1995-to-fye-2021#:~:text=Figure%204%20shows%20that%20in,around%20%C2%A324%2C600%20per%20year).

Summerwhereareyou · 03/07/2022 17:56

And within state school there is a strange attitude to Sen.

And parents.
It all needs to be opened up and made transparent. Too much us and them and secrey.

Summerwhereareyou · 03/07/2022 17:51

@spongedog
Couldn't agree more.

Many posters are not interested in this sen issue because it's not fitting with their politics.

I have to pay to supplement dd education because our outstanding leafy primary can't teach her.
That's disadvantage right there.
That's inequality.

Luckily dd has me.
But she should not need me to get her educated.

My dd needs are not so great that she would need a specialist school she just needed the most basic tools to help her and this is what has concerned me the most really.
If I could afford private for secondary I would.

BungleandGeorge · 03/07/2022 17:44

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 03/07/2022 09:44

@BungleandGeorge @justasking111 you quote average hh income of £38k as though these make private school affordable.

The average private school fees are £15k so I don't see the point? No one on average income without a massive scholarship/ bursary or family money will be able to afford half that income on average private school fees.

It was as a direct counter to the made up figures of pp. and it’s disposable income and an average across the country including single, retired, young etc households. Annoying when people make up figures to suit themselves. and someone actually working in admissions at one of these schools is told their wrong🤷‍♀️ A lot of people are funding these schools from house equity, second jobs, grandparents, inheritances. It’s amazing what can be done if school is the top priority.

justasking111 · 03/07/2022 14:30

ChiselandBits · 03/07/2022 14:19

Do you honestly think that any of that would go to sen schools or Sen provision? Or directly to schools at all? And it wouldn't raise that because as discussed upthread, a lot of smaller schools would close within a couple of years. No fees generated, no extra tax money, just more kids in the state sector.

Welsh government would certainly funnel the money elsewhere. Rishi Sunek covid money was diverted away from businesses. Friends here have had a huge fight on their hands which lasts Three years minimum most parents give up along the way.

greywinds · 03/07/2022 14:25

On the subject of SEN I was reading a review of a new life of Ernie Bevin, he didn't believe in pulling down successful institutions - we need more pragmatism and less ideology in education. The reasons so many children aren't coping with mainstream state schools need to be fixed first before we start breaking down provision that's working. And the bloody waiting times for assessments and help are the key disasters.

ChiselandBits · 03/07/2022 14:19

Do you honestly think that any of that would go to sen schools or Sen provision? Or directly to schools at all? And it wouldn't raise that because as discussed upthread, a lot of smaller schools would close within a couple of years. No fees generated, no extra tax money, just more kids in the state sector.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 03/07/2022 09:49

@spongedog yeah, the Sen points been raised a few times on the thread.

I don't think it matters how private SEN schools are taxed because the places are usually all local authority funded so tax is just the government moving money between departments.

The issue of generally abysmal state SEN care is different. But imagine how many state SEN schools they could run if they got £1bn extra by taxing private schooling in line with other services.