Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private Schools being able to hold charitable status

565 replies

IdiotCreatures · 27/06/2022 09:14

I went and looked at a building associated with a local independent school yesterday, as it's always piqued my curiosity.
The school is run by the Woodard Corporation. I looked at their books on company house yesterday.
The amount of money moving through them is ridiculous. If people want to pay for a private education, then surely the institutions should be taxed.
Apart from a small number of scholarships, the average person is not benefiting from these institutions.
In the case of Eton, as pointed out on another thread, these schools are probably leading to damage to society and definitely do not promote the idea of equality.

OP posts:
ChiselandBits · 04/07/2022 14:14

@antelopevalley I work in a small indie school. It is a fantastic place and not in any way failing, but it does have very tight margins, just like most of the others. Most of our parents are not super-wealthy and can afford fees due to 2x professional income, grandparent help or similar. We are not in the south east so housing costs are less which also helps. Your assertion that only "not very good ones" would fail is naive and disingenuous. We also have numerous children with us via LA funding or charitable funding for kids with particular backgrounds who would sink in the state sector - not because those schools are no good or don't care but just scale. This does not have to be an us vs them situation, but decimating the private sector is not the solution to the problems in the state sector.

faffadoodledo · 04/07/2022 14:05

@justasking111 do you have links to that? The number of SEN pupils for whom councils are paying for private provision? I'd love to be surprised with some facts. Genuinely. Because I had no idea this was happening. At DC's comp (tho they left a few years ago) SEN was catered for in-house.

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 14:02

Plantstrees · 04/07/2022 13:57

I assume you mean VAT. If a school was registered for VAT it would be able to deduct all its input VAT on its expenses and capital expenditure so your calculations are way out.

I've tried telling them that to no avail sigh

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 14:00

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 13:57

@justasking111 No I would not. I have already talked about that. And those would continue.
The only private schools that might be affected are those marginal ones that are not that good and already struggling.

So you're the arbiter of what schools deserve to survive then

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 13:57

@justasking111 No I would not. I have already talked about that. And those would continue.
The only private schools that might be affected are those marginal ones that are not that good and already struggling.

Plantstrees · 04/07/2022 13:57

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 11:23

@Badbadbunny I'm suggesting a sales tax on fees not profit.

And I've already said if that was 20% sales tax at the same rate as other services it'd generate £1.5bn a year.

That's nearly 2.5% increase per pupil. I think it's worth it given the poor funding of state schools. Obviously I'd like more to come from other sources.

I assume you mean VAT. If a school was registered for VAT it would be able to deduct all its input VAT on its expenses and capital expenditure so your calculations are way out.

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 13:56

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 13:43

@ChiselandBits I do not believe this. I already posted research that the majority of children in private schools are from the top income families. They can afford it and do not need subsidised by the state.

You'd then be surprised to learn how many local councils are paying the bulk of private school fees for SEN pupils

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 13:43

@ChiselandBits I do not believe this. I already posted research that the majority of children in private schools are from the top income families. They can afford it and do not need subsidised by the state.

ChiselandBits · 04/07/2022 13:34

If you did this, an awful lot of private schools would close. For some of you who are ideologically opposed to them anyway, great, but for those who object on financial grounds, this would be a massive own goal. It would not raise revenue but because the schools would close so not generate it and you'd have about 5% more kids in the state sector than you have now with no additional revenue. It just doesn't work as an idea.

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 12:57

The number of people who use private tutoring, should they be taxed??

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 12:56

NO charities can make a profit they aim to make a loss eg cancer research make 180 million they'll spend 182 million. Check out charities commission

Badbadbunny · 04/07/2022 12:30

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 11:23

@Badbadbunny I'm suggesting a sales tax on fees not profit.

And I've already said if that was 20% sales tax at the same rate as other services it'd generate £1.5bn a year.

That's nearly 2.5% increase per pupil. I think it's worth it given the poor funding of state schools. Obviously I'd like more to come from other sources.

If you did that, you have to apply to ALL forms of private education, i.e. swimming, dance, music, etc. You can't just charge VAT on a particular provider because you don't like them, it would fail any court challenge. It has to be across ALL providers. Would do more harm than good.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 11:23

@Badbadbunny I'm suggesting a sales tax on fees not profit.

And I've already said if that was 20% sales tax at the same rate as other services it'd generate £1.5bn a year.

That's nearly 2.5% increase per pupil. I think it's worth it given the poor funding of state schools. Obviously I'd like more to come from other sources.

Badbadbunny · 04/07/2022 10:42

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 08:47

So private education is an industry like any other. Providing a service like any other, one that's exported like any other.

Why not tax it like any other?

That's exactly the point.

Those who attend private school earn 35% more than state school leavers by the time they're 25.

That's what most parents are buying. I know there are a minority of lower income or SEN kids at private school but they are exceptions. The average private school fees are £15k a year and we all know and see the benefits that buys. It should be taxed.

Tax is on "profit" not income, and very little of the £15k would be "profit", so very little tax revenue would be raised. In fact, private schools aren't allowed to make a "profit", they can make a "surplus" but ultimately the surplus has to be spent on charitable activities, i.e. the provision of education, so a surplus in one year will be spent to cover a deficit in another or on capital spending, i.e. building improvements, or invested to gain investment income to spend on their charitable purposes. So, basically, over time, there'd be no "profit" and therefore no tax revenue.

Badbadbunny · 04/07/2022 10:19

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 08:40

@user1497207191 it's every year. So that's £5bn in 10 years.

Or if we added 20% tax it'd raise £1bn a year, even if 20% of people went into the state system. So that's £5bn in 5 years.

That'd make quite an improvement in state schools.

For all those who argue the government wouldn't use it for schools, I know this government wouldn't ever do this so I'm assuming it would be brought in by a progressive government committed to state education as a solution to the UK productivity crisis.

But some parents wouldn't pay more and take their kids back into the state sector, putting pressure on state schools and increasing the cost to the taxpayer.

Half a million is chicken feed when the cost of education is a whopping 96 BILLION to the UK taxpayer.

There are 20,000 state schools in the UK, so your proposal would give each state school a wonderful £250 per year! What use would that be? It wouldn't cover the cost of every school having one extra pupil moving to it from the private schools.

It'd basically be a massive own goal that would do more harm than good. Half a million sounds a lot, but do the Maths, spread it over the number of schools/pupils and it's basically loose change!

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 08:47

sst1234 · 03/07/2022 22:20

Ok here are some facts to cut though the usual uninformed ranting. Private schools contribute almost £14bn to the UK economy, support over 300k jobs and generate over £4bn in tax revenue. Not only that but about £3.5bn is saved for the state by school places not being taken by students who go to private schools.

Education is one of the biggest exports for this country’s economy - pre university education alone generating roughly £19bn.

Sometimes, it helps to step outside your narrow, uninformed tunnel vision and look at the bigger picture rather than quoting the first soundbite that you hear on social media.

So private education is an industry like any other. Providing a service like any other, one that's exported like any other.

Why not tax it like any other?

That's exactly the point.

Those who attend private school earn 35% more than state school leavers by the time they're 25.

That's what most parents are buying. I know there are a minority of lower income or SEN kids at private school but they are exceptions. The average private school fees are £15k a year and we all know and see the benefits that buys. It should be taxed.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 04/07/2022 08:40

@user1497207191 it's every year. So that's £5bn in 10 years.

Or if we added 20% tax it'd raise £1bn a year, even if 20% of people went into the state system. So that's £5bn in 5 years.

That'd make quite an improvement in state schools.

For all those who argue the government wouldn't use it for schools, I know this government wouldn't ever do this so I'm assuming it would be brought in by a progressive government committed to state education as a solution to the UK productivity crisis.

Plantstrees · 04/07/2022 08:14

faffadoodledo · 04/07/2022 06:21

@sst1234 those aren't reasons for charitable status though are they? Otherwise Sainsbury's or Kelly's Ice Cream would get the same tax breaks. Rather your argument supports abolition of that charitable status.

But you are quoting businesses that make a profit for their owners/shareholders. Independant schools that have charitable status do not.

user1497207191 · 04/07/2022 07:57

@ThinkAboutItTomorrow

Would raise £522,000 for state schools. Not much but something.

Not "something" at all - it would cost more than that to change the law and administration.

faffadoodledo · 04/07/2022 07:48

But literally tens of thousands of businesses don't benefit from the same tax status. And can you tell me that every member of school ancillary or domestic staff doesn't draw on UC?

sst1234 · 04/07/2022 07:27

faffadoodledo · 04/07/2022 06:21

@sst1234 those aren't reasons for charitable status though are they? Otherwise Sainsbury's or Kelly's Ice Cream would get the same tax breaks. Rather your argument supports abolition of that charitable status.

Sainbury’s doesn’t provide a service that directly saves £3.5bn for the taxpayer. In fact Sainsbury’s costs the public purse by paying low wages that have to subsidized by the taxpayer by tax credits or UC.

faffadoodledo · 04/07/2022 06:21

@sst1234 those aren't reasons for charitable status though are they? Otherwise Sainsbury's or Kelly's Ice Cream would get the same tax breaks. Rather your argument supports abolition of that charitable status.

Runnerbeansflower · 04/07/2022 01:51

? What's that got to do with whether they get tax breaks?

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 22:38

@sst1234 Do you always insult everyone you talk to?
I am sure everyone knows private schools create jobs and pay suppliers. Is any industry that generates wealth automatically good?

sst1234 · 03/07/2022 22:20

Ok here are some facts to cut though the usual uninformed ranting. Private schools contribute almost £14bn to the UK economy, support over 300k jobs and generate over £4bn in tax revenue. Not only that but about £3.5bn is saved for the state by school places not being taken by students who go to private schools.

Education is one of the biggest exports for this country’s economy - pre university education alone generating roughly £19bn.

Sometimes, it helps to step outside your narrow, uninformed tunnel vision and look at the bigger picture rather than quoting the first soundbite that you hear on social media.

Swipe left for the next trending thread