Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Class action lawsuit against Christian religion to pay for unwanted children?

85 replies

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 26/06/2022 23:05

I’m not in America but I was wondering if rich American women could band together to fund a class action lawsuit. It would be against evangelical Christian churches to force them to pay for the upkeep of all children up to 18 in states which have banned abortion. They should also be sued to pay for medical bills for the mothers including mental health bills.

OP posts:
Ravenclawdropout · 27/06/2022 05:42

@SaintHelena I think you are somewhat mislead there! If you are very poor in the USA your healthctea and that of your children is covered by Medicaid. If you are 65+ you get government funded Medicare. Its the working poor that struggle.

Congregations do give to many local and national causes of need: food banks, social services, prison ministry, trafficking victims, refugees etc etc. Churches are generally on a tight budget and mostly run by volunteer labor of the Congregation and small paid staff. Its definitely true that you can turn to the Church in an emergency (such as unable to pay your rent) but then case management is taken over by social services if its a more chronic issue.

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 05:31

Imv if you can't afford your healthcare or whatever in the US you can turn to charity from your church. This may be the reason that churches/religion are so strong. Churches are very rich.

Ravenclawdropout · 27/06/2022 05:16

@MangyInseam so right. The Democrats had 50 years to pass a federal law on abortion. Obama had control of all of Congress for the first two years and could've passed federally mandated maternity leave, subsidized childcare and all sorts of family and women friendly legislation. This isn't just about the Supreme Court.

Catholics make up 20% of the US population to date, there have only been 15 Catholic justices — out of 115 justices total — in the history of the Supreme Court. Sonia Sotomayor, a justice on the Supreme Court, is also Catholic and voted to keep Roe in place.

Other Catholics in the US government include the President Joe Biden and the Speaker of the House (considered the second most powerful position after the President) Nancy Pelosi.

"According to an analysis released on Jan. 3 by the Pew Research Center, about 88 percent of Congress identifies as Christian, compared with just 71 percent of all U.S. adults. Catholics now make up 30.5 percent of Congress; 21 percent of U.S. adults identify as Catholic."

This is from 2018. As you can see, more Democrats in Congress are Catholic than Republicans and Catholics are pretty much split right down the middle when it comes to voting Democrat or Republican.

A lot more people identify as religious in the US than the UK. Most Catholics in the US are also not of European descent so I would be careful for anyone tempted to launch into stereotypes

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 05:12

MangyInseam · 27/06/2022 03:18

But they've not actually made a Catholic argument, they've made a legal argument. You can't just assume that a legal decision has no basis because you don't like the religion of the justices, not unless you address their argument and say it doesn't make sense. I've not actually seen anyone on MN do that. And the fact is that the majority legal scholars in the US who write on constitutional law think it was a bad ruling. It's not like that is some bizarre left field legal opinion, it's mainstream, and i's unlikely those people all have a religious agenda to undermine the law.

But this highlights how the whole approach of dealing with this through the courts has been terrible all along. The idea that political leaders would stack the courts with judges who would support a particular ideological position is a serious undermining of the political process. Laws are meant to be proposed by legislators and passed into law by the congress, in the US either at the federal or state level.

Using the courts as a back-door method of making law is a bad idea and I'm not sure why people don't see why normalizing that is problematic. It probably could not happen in the UK in the same way because the system protects better against that kind of abuse.

It couldn't happen in the UK because there is no written Constitution. There is only the principle that Parliament can make whatever law it likes. This is much more democratic.

as long as you don't elect a bunch of charlatans and idiots

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 05:09

The people who have banned abortion are the legislatures in the states such as Texas etc. Go and bang on their doors.

The Supreme Court of the US didn't ban abortion. All it said was that state laws banning abortion weren't unconstitutional.

Any state legislature in the US is free to legalise abortion or (as most have) keep it legal, just the same as Parliament in the UK. Therefore it's really up the the voters in places like Texas to elect representives who will legalise abortion instead of looking for a bunch of crusty old legal gerontocrats to save them.

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 04:49

Surely with dna testing the father can pay for the child's upbringing.
I think this is quite well enforced in Canada as the men can have their passports removed.

MangyInseam · 27/06/2022 03:18

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/06/2022 02:49

The Supreme Court is deliberately and overwhelmingly loaded with Catholics. Massively out of proportion to the American population. This has been a looooong and premeditated plan.

But they've not actually made a Catholic argument, they've made a legal argument. You can't just assume that a legal decision has no basis because you don't like the religion of the justices, not unless you address their argument and say it doesn't make sense. I've not actually seen anyone on MN do that. And the fact is that the majority legal scholars in the US who write on constitutional law think it was a bad ruling. It's not like that is some bizarre left field legal opinion, it's mainstream, and i's unlikely those people all have a religious agenda to undermine the law.

But this highlights how the whole approach of dealing with this through the courts has been terrible all along. The idea that political leaders would stack the courts with judges who would support a particular ideological position is a serious undermining of the political process. Laws are meant to be proposed by legislators and passed into law by the congress, in the US either at the federal or state level.

Using the courts as a back-door method of making law is a bad idea and I'm not sure why people don't see why normalizing that is problematic. It probably could not happen in the UK in the same way because the system protects better against that kind of abuse.

sashh · 27/06/2022 03:12

Pyewhacket · 26/06/2022 23:23

It’s not the church or the government who have made this ruling. It’s the Supreme Court. The highest court in the land. The US constitution guarantees free exercise of religious belief. So no, you can’t sue the church.

But under Jewish law the foetus is not a baby. In some teaching it is considered water until 40 days and then becomes a potential human, not yet human.

Bluebellsunderthetrees · 27/06/2022 02:57

@BritWifeInUSA Don't even go there with Afghanistan . The US withdrew, let the Taliban take over and is now sanctioning Afghanistan causing thousands of children to starve to death. Those children don't count I guess to anti abortion USA

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/06/2022 02:49

ventreàterre · 27/06/2022 01:51

It's nothing to do with "the Christian religion". (Good luck trying to sue an entire religion, anyway...) Abortion isn't outlined in the original constitution, so it's up to individual states to decide what is legal, on a state by state basis.

The Supreme Court is deliberately and overwhelmingly loaded with Catholics. Massively out of proportion to the American population. This has been a looooong and premeditated plan.

Boxowine · 27/06/2022 02:39

BritWifeInUSA · 27/06/2022 01:35

It would be counter-sued (if it even got that far) by the claim that you are free to travel to another state should you wish to have an abortion and you live in a state where it is illegal. It’s not illegal all over the country. Not even close. Many states have abortion laws that are more relaxed than Europe.

I think it’s kind of cute that all the European woman are jumping onto this cause to fly the flag for women’s rights. Are you doing as much for women in Afghanistan? They can’t even choose what they wear outside of the house. Girls can’t even go to school beyond year 6 there. Surely that’s far more worthy of a fight?

I believe a great many men and women from the UK did fight in Afghanistan.

I think it's cute that you think women can just travel to another state. 89 per cent of the counties in the US do not have an abortion provider. Most of the states banning abortion are near to one another so a woman would have to have the wherewithal to travel through multiple states to get to one with a provider.

ventreàterre · 27/06/2022 01:51

It's nothing to do with "the Christian religion". (Good luck trying to sue an entire religion, anyway...) Abortion isn't outlined in the original constitution, so it's up to individual states to decide what is legal, on a state by state basis.

mathanxiety · 27/06/2022 01:51

@AchatAVendre - sorry to bust your bubble, but the US is way ahead of the UK when it comes to enforcing child support orders.

Wages can be garnished.

Failure to pay can result in a judgement of contempt of court.

The county state's attorney will prosecute delinquent parents to pay back any welfare payments the state has had to pay a resident parent because of the lack of support from the non-payer.

Professional accreditation bodies will send a questionnaire to an ex spouse asking whether child support has ever been late or not paid at all if someone wishes to be accredited to practice their profession in another state.

Cameleongirl · 27/06/2022 01:44

@MangyInseam I don’t think most posters know how federal and state laws work, let alone the branches of government.

its

mathanxiety · 27/06/2022 01:41

YY to BritWife.

How about a march to protest British arms sales to Saudi Arabia, where a bona fide despot can and does do as he pleases with his unfortunate subjects.

MangyInseam · 27/06/2022 01:40

I mean - you understand this decision doesn't criminalize abortion? It simply says that it's not constitutionally protected on the grounds that were argued in RvW, which relate to privacy.

You might not like that it leaves no federal abortion law but that is not really the job of the courts.

Cameleongirl · 27/06/2022 01:38

@BritWifeInUSA Thanks for educating posters on how things actually work in the US!

MangyInseam · 27/06/2022 01:38

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 26/06/2022 23:14

The justices overturned it due to their relight beliefs. Every news piece shows the religious right overjoyed by the news. They should all dig deep to support their ‘pro-life’ beliefs.

Even when the RvW decision came down, it was understood to be a weak legal decision - RBG said so herself. You could just as well say it lasted as long as it did because of the ideological make up of the court at an earlier time. Neither is what is supposed to happen.

In both instances it was justified on legal, not ideological grounds, and the difference between the two decisions reflects as much a difference in views about the role of the courts and how to interpret the constitution as it does in an underlying view about the ethics of abortion. There are long explanations of both decisions available, to say they made them for religious reasons is incredibly reductive.

mathanxiety · 27/06/2022 01:36

Yawn.

BritWifeInUSA · 27/06/2022 01:35

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 26/06/2022 23:05

I’m not in America but I was wondering if rich American women could band together to fund a class action lawsuit. It would be against evangelical Christian churches to force them to pay for the upkeep of all children up to 18 in states which have banned abortion. They should also be sued to pay for medical bills for the mothers including mental health bills.

It would be counter-sued (if it even got that far) by the claim that you are free to travel to another state should you wish to have an abortion and you live in a state where it is illegal. It’s not illegal all over the country. Not even close. Many states have abortion laws that are more relaxed than Europe.

I think it’s kind of cute that all the European woman are jumping onto this cause to fly the flag for women’s rights. Are you doing as much for women in Afghanistan? They can’t even choose what they wear outside of the house. Girls can’t even go to school beyond year 6 there. Surely that’s far more worthy of a fight?

BritWifeInUSA · 27/06/2022 01:30

AchatAVendre · 26/06/2022 23:56

I think some of these US states should continue this theme by criminalising people who leave their children (i.e. mainly men) or who don't pay maintenance! Lets see how long the opposition to abortion lasts then.

A serious point is that many men change their mind after the woman has become pregnant or lie about not being married, etc and then just sail off to impregnant another woman and fail to pay child support.

We already do criminalize the act of being a non-paying parent in child support cases. If you are the Jon-custodial parent and don’t pay what has been country ordered there are sanctions. You lose your drivers license and your passport. You can even be sent to county jail for being in contempt of court.

And what does the UK do in such cases?

BritWifeInUSA · 27/06/2022 01:26

DownNative · 26/06/2022 23:08

It's the US Supreme Court which is independent of the US Government, hence Biden's public statements on it.

Completely wrong. The supreme court is the judicial branch of the government. It’s as much a part of the government as Congress (legislative branch) and the president and cabinet (executive branch is).

ComfyChairPose · 27/06/2022 00:09

You're right that it's got to be a financial argument though.
I said on another thread that what exasperates me about these men in grey suits, there is just the blase expectation that women buckle in for 18-22 years of the expense of raising a child, as well as the reduced freedom to earn.

men are free to give 11% of their net earnings, men are free to work everyday and earn if that's what they want. Women aren't getting a reduction in their rent, they're not being taxed less or paying less paye. There are no breaks. Only disadvantages.

Women bear the cost of continuing the species (and this is true in the case of many wanted children too). But society as a whole needs to be funding childcare if women are going to be restricted from having abortions.

I am still pro-choice obviously, but I do think that this argument is the only thing that would make the dinosaurs do a u turn. OMG, pay more tax to fund childcare so the mothers can work? oh no no no.

FemmeNatal · 27/06/2022 00:03

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 26/06/2022 23:05

I’m not in America but I was wondering if rich American women could band together to fund a class action lawsuit. It would be against evangelical Christian churches to force them to pay for the upkeep of all children up to 18 in states which have banned abortion. They should also be sued to pay for medical bills for the mothers including mental health bills.

I can’t see how that’s going to work. What law would require them to do this?

CraftyGin · 26/06/2022 23:58

TBF, I think churches have proposed funding for continuing a pregnancy and looking at options for the birth mother keeping the child.