Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Class action lawsuit against Christian religion to pay for unwanted children?

85 replies

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 26/06/2022 23:05

I’m not in America but I was wondering if rich American women could band together to fund a class action lawsuit. It would be against evangelical Christian churches to force them to pay for the upkeep of all children up to 18 in states which have banned abortion. They should also be sued to pay for medical bills for the mothers including mental health bills.

OP posts:
LibrariesGiveUsPower · 27/06/2022 10:21

Boxowine · 26/06/2022 23:20

Evangelical and Catholic churches are already putting together their plans to have the government award them contracts to run foster homes and crisis pregnancy centers and adoption services.

They want for there to be more babies, they want to adopt them out and they want an income stream from the government while they do it. It's part of the plan. Idaho's governor already alluded to it.

The Mormon church calls it bleeding the beast

What they are not going to do is allow poor mothers to get money from the government directly in order to be able to raise their children. Those babies are going to go to Christian homes to be raised.

Evidence please?

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 27/06/2022 10:11

Last I checked it was the government who made laws not churches. YABU.

Hornbostel · 27/06/2022 10:08

It's a nice idea but doesn't seem realistic.

The Satanic Temple are currently suing Texas saying that abortion is a religious ritual. 'Mon the Satanists!

knittingaddict · 27/06/2022 09:45

Homelander42 · 26/06/2022 23:06

I don't think it's the church though, is it? It's the government that's abolished abortion. Sue them.

Wrong on all counts.

It's the US, of course it's white evangelical churches that are the cause of this.

It's not the government, it's the Supreme Court, which is political to a ridiculous degree which shouldn't be allowed.

The court action suggested by the op won't work though, I don't think. I would love it to happen though and I've been a Christian most of my life.

SwapPlaces · 27/06/2022 09:13

The Court is trying to push the decision back onto the legislators - that is part of the doctrine of ‘originalism’. They believe that Legislators, as the elected body (so can be voted out if citizens don’t like the legislation they pass), should pass the law and not leave it up to the Courts (who are appointed Judges and beyond the reach of citizens) to create policy.
Ie Obama could have codified Roe - but said it was "not my highest legislative priority," once elected, presumably because of fear of voter backlash.

Catholicism is tangential, not because of religion per se, but because Catholics tend to practice Originalist not Activist jurisprudence.

AlienatedChildGrown · 27/06/2022 09:02

etulosba · 27/06/2022 08:57

Wages can be garnished.

I love this US terminology.

I always imagine a bit of parsley on top.

I may be remembering wrong, but I recall several conversations about my father’s salary being garnished early on in my parents’ divorce. IIRC that is what eventually happened. It was taken direct from his net income before he received what was left. That was in the U.K. in the mid-late 80s.

I had visions of parsley too, which is why it stuck in my memory.

etulosba · 27/06/2022 08:57

Wages can be garnished.

I love this US terminology.

I always imagine a bit of parsley on top.

AlienatedChildGrown · 27/06/2022 08:53

You can either plot fights against a 2D, imaginary, parody of all of the people who have qualms about abortion.

Or you can listen to the people on, or around, the fence about their qualms. Take time to digest the content of said qualms and develop honest arguments that will engage with those qualms.

One will make you feel good online in a spot where people mostly agree with you already. The other is far less exciting and extremely time consuming. But more likely to make a difference in the long run. Because until the “somewhere on or around the fence” people are prepared to make access to legal abortion a “must have” at the ballot box, with the insistence that the recipient of their vote takes all available steps to firm up the law around it so it doesn’t have to be a bogeyman stick to wave at election time anymore, then access to legal abortion will remain vulnerable.

The iceberg has flipped in the USA. When America sneezes Europe risks catching the cold. Pro life didn’t change their tactics all that much, nor did pro choice. But whatever is the status quo attracts the weight of extreme, high visibility poor outcomes and deliberately provocative/ “my moral superiority” / no debate opinions. Over time it becomes the big end, and the flip happens. Unless we wish to wait it out for several decades til they catch enough weight from being the status quo, the mode of engagement with more flexible hearts and minds needs to change. That can’t happen if we prance around in digital armour, fighting dragons we created in our imagination instead.

The religious zealot who gets excited about the prospects of a Talibanesque control of women is a rare beast, and doesn’t tend to make much of a dent in public opinion in the west. The people who have qualms can and do. At the moment they are shifting each other. Less with slogans and big acts of defiance, more with nuanced and calm-ish conversations. Where people can speak without being labelled mole, bot, spy or heretic. Either we show up in those conversations, or we carry on with Big Acts of Defiance & soundbites that failed to stop the iceberg flipping.

I genuinely wish to not just keep abortion accessible and legal where is already is (or was in some states), I’d like it to expand to countries where at present it is illegal. I don’t believe that can be achieved by doing the same thing again and expecting a different result.

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 08:38

@DownNative

I can't disagree with that: I was using a common expression to describe the UK constitution, but what you say is more accurate.

DownNative · 27/06/2022 08:34

IncompleteSenten · 26/06/2022 23:18

They should sue the lawmakers.
If you are going to force women to give birth you should pay their medical bills and bloody child support!

You think they should sue....Congress? For the decision made by the independent Supreme Court? 🤷‍♂️

DownNative · 27/06/2022 08:09

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 05:12

It couldn't happen in the UK because there is no written Constitution. There is only the principle that Parliament can make whatever law it likes. This is much more democratic.

as long as you don't elect a bunch of charlatans and idiots

The UK does have a written constitution. What the UK doesn't have is a codified constitution - it's not written down in one place.

Lord Norton of Louth is regarded as a leading expert on the UK constitution and he confirms we have a written constitution. And, of course, the constitution not being codified has to be qualified against our membership of the EU as well as the Good Friday Agreement for Northern Ireland. Effectively, the UK has SOME codified constitutional law in writing, but most of it remains uncodified all the same.

DownNative · 27/06/2022 08:00

BritWifeInUSA · 27/06/2022 01:26

Completely wrong. The supreme court is the judicial branch of the government. It’s as much a part of the government as Congress (legislative branch) and the president and cabinet (executive branch is).

It is not completely wrong as you suggest as government is political and the Presidential administration is referred to as government by shorthand by the people commonly. Similar to how people say "America" rather than the official name of "United States".

The Supreme Court is independent of the administration (Executive). That is correct.

From uscourt.gov:

"....independence of the judiciary from the political branches of government."

This is what I'm talking about which explains the reference to Biden.

Congress has some discretion in relation to the Supreme Court. For example, Congress (Legislative) set the number of Justices which isn't in the constitution itself. It's been nine since 1869, but has been as low as six.

At the end of the day, the decision was made by the USSC and the OPs statement is a non-starter. The USSC is the final arbiter of the interpretation of law in the United States of America.

From supremecourt.gov:

"As the final arbiter of the law, the Court is charged with ensuring the American people the promise of equal justice under law and, thereby, also functions as guardian and interpreter of the Constitution."

Only the Supreme Court judges are responsible for the ruling of the Supreme Court.

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 07:54

Simonjt · 27/06/2022 07:51

This.

It will become a breeding program to increase their congregation.

Link?

Simonjt · 27/06/2022 07:51

Boxowine · 26/06/2022 23:20

Evangelical and Catholic churches are already putting together their plans to have the government award them contracts to run foster homes and crisis pregnancy centers and adoption services.

They want for there to be more babies, they want to adopt them out and they want an income stream from the government while they do it. It's part of the plan. Idaho's governor already alluded to it.

The Mormon church calls it bleeding the beast

What they are not going to do is allow poor mothers to get money from the government directly in order to be able to raise their children. Those babies are going to go to Christian homes to be raised.

This.

It will become a breeding program to increase their congregation.

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 07:27

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 07:07

@TomPinch
I'm stunned that you don't think religions are rich and powerful - look at the Latter Day Saints or Scientology

That's not what I said. See above for what I did say. And if you think the Scientologists are a standard example of "a religion" then, frankly, I don't think you know what you're talking about.

You have reminded me of something that happened in the C of E parish where I grew up. The C of E has a lot of assets. It also has a lot of church roofs to fix. That's why it has been closing and selling off church buildings right left and centre for the last two decades: it can't afford them any more.

In said parish, the diocese decided to close the church. Up popped a local worthy who said this must be wrong because the C of E was very rich. Eventually the daft radge accused the vicar of embezzling the money that Must Be There, and the police got involved.

I appreciate that the C of E is not American but the story is illustrating.

NiceViper · 27/06/2022 07:13

I think some of these US states should continue this theme by criminalising people who leave their children (i.e. mainly men) or who don't pay maintenance! Lets see how long the opposition to abortion lasts then

You do realise that it already is? Also sanctions such as forfeit of driving license

I don't know if it's the case in every state, but that wouldn't be either a new or a startling development.

It's nowhere near as wishy washy as UK

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 07:07

@TomPinch
I'm stunned that you don't think religions are rich and powerful - look at the Latter Day Saints or Scientology

Gogster · 27/06/2022 06:44

IncompleteSenten · 26/06/2022 23:18

They should sue the lawmakers.
If you are going to force women to give birth you should pay their medical bills and bloody child support!

They'll argue that they haven't forced anyone into getting pregnant though

Nothappyatwork · 27/06/2022 06:38

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 04:49

Surely with dna testing the father can pay for the child's upbringing.
I think this is quite well enforced in Canada as the men can have their passports removed.

How many American men dont have passports ?

take their driver’s license and they cant work and therefore cant pay anyway. The jails are full I believe.
How does PAYE work over there ? Take child support at source ? Still its only 20% of the salary …. Who’s paying the rest ? The poor woman

Carpy88999 · 27/06/2022 06:34

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 26/06/2022 23:14

The justices overturned it due to their relight beliefs. Every news piece shows the religious right overjoyed by the news. They should all dig deep to support their ‘pro-life’ beliefs.

No they haven't. They've abolished it due to legal grounds.

I'm not religious or right wing and I am pro life but I wouldn't ever stop someone making a decision that effects their own body. Same with assisted dying, it should be up to the individual and no one else.

Nothappyatwork · 27/06/2022 06:34

“I’m not in America but I was wondering if rich American women could band together to fund a class action lawsuit. It would be against evangelical Christian churches”

its rich women that are voting for this shit !
currently only the wrong type of babies are available for purchase, this new law might bring more suitable and profitable ones onto the market

GeorgiaMcGraw · 27/06/2022 06:31

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 26/06/2022 23:05

I’m not in America but I was wondering if rich American women could band together to fund a class action lawsuit. It would be against evangelical Christian churches to force them to pay for the upkeep of all children up to 18 in states which have banned abortion. They should also be sued to pay for medical bills for the mothers including mental health bills.

Op, usually people expect parents to care for the children they create, unless they give them to the state for adoption. HTH.

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 06:27

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 06:16

www.therichest.com/world/the-10-richest-religions-in-the-world/

The religions are loaded. And will spend it on evangelism.

And yes, it's the working poor I was thinking of regarding help with health care. I've lived in the US and remember collections for health care for workers of other expats.

This is a great example of I Am An Expert in <insert X> Because Google. You expect people to take that link seriously?

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 06:16

www.therichest.com/world/the-10-richest-religions-in-the-world/

The religions are loaded. And will spend it on evangelism.

And yes, it's the working poor I was thinking of regarding help with health care. I've lived in the US and remember collections for health care for workers of other expats.

TomPinch · 27/06/2022 05:52

SaintHelena · 27/06/2022 05:31

Imv if you can't afford your healthcare or whatever in the US you can turn to charity from your church. This may be the reason that churches/religion are so strong. Churches are very rich.

Yeah, in the sense that Croydon Borough Council is rich, ie, assets and income, and obligations.

Not in the sense of Bishop Brennan in his bath.

Swipe left for the next trending thread