Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you not to tolerate the term "pregnant people"

305 replies

flashbac · 26/06/2022 22:21

It might seem harmless and kind but it is not harmless. I'm seeing the term alot at the moment due to the horrid state of affairs across the pond.

Pregnancy, abortion, menstruation, menopause. These are issues that affect women and reasons why men have sought to control us, to control our bodies. We are seen as vessels, chattels, playthings, property, servants, and then, when we can no longer get pregnant, as useless rubbish. All due to our biological function. If you tolerate language change so these things are seen as 'people' rights issues that affect both 'men' and women we lose the truthful and valid argument that bad and oppressive practices, laws, policy decisions etc, e.g. banning of abortion, are rooted in misogyny, which of course they are.

Abortion bans are because of misogyny. Especially in countries where there is no free maternal care, no statutory maternity leave or pay, no shits given about the children once they are born. This is a women's rights issue, a sex based one. And we, as a sex class, must never take any rights we have for granted.

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:38

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:34

The dictionary definition isn’t scientific though.

Ahahahahahaha this is deliciously ironic!

What isn't scientific is gender woowoo, my love.

Slothtoes · 27/06/2022 07:37

I don’t want ‘men’ or ‘women’ to become meaningless words where it’s not certain who is being referred to, or where these sex based terms are being used to describe the opposite sex as well. That’s what the word ‘people’ is for.

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:37

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:36

When you call yourself a woman that’s gender

No, when I call myself woman I mean I am an adult human of the female biological sex. Gender isn't relevant to me.

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:36

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:25

I’d like to know this too. Maybe then all women could live as males and misogyny would be dead. Just give us the rules then

I think it involves having the confidence to assert yourself and do what you want without putting others first all the time.

Which is ironic, because asserting ourselves against male people is exactly what women are being vilified for in this debate.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:36

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:33

Do what is gender?

When you call yourself a woman that’s gender

Powp0w · 27/06/2022 07:35

HotPenguin · 27/06/2022 00:03

It's totally confusing to talk about people having a right to abortion, it makes it sound like you are including men who want their partner to have an abortion. That's exactly why we have invented more specific words like "women".

Absolutely.

It's actually incredibly selfish imo to insist on using the word "people" in this scenario because it makes you feel better.

It actually really fucking matters on a much wider scale that this is seen as a WOMAN'S issue. Transmen aren't confused about the fact they are biologically female. They won't read "woman" and not understand that actually on a biological level it includes them.

But it matters that this is not seen as a "people's" issue. It matters that people know this is a misogynistic oppression of WOMEN, not PEOPLE. Distinction does matter.

And to turn that around because you individually want to be "included" in that with your preferred whatever the fuck (when you're already fucking included in the word woman) is utterly selfish

HandScreen · 27/06/2022 07:35

FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 23:13

Referring to a pregnant woman as a pregnant person is like referring to a young black male as “boy.”

It may well be a word that is technically correct, but it comes with bagage and context which renders it offensive.

Sorry, WHAT??

You are so far off fucking base. Sit down.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:34

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:31

You know there’s this really cool thing called a dictionary. You can get them as books or online. Stop being obtuse and explain why you think women are not allowed to define themselves but trans people are?

The dictionary definition isn’t scientific though.

DrBlackbird · 27/06/2022 07:34

Its the removal of ‘women’ but not the removal of ‘men’ from medical literature that signals something to be concerned about.

Men have prostrates. Whilst people have uteruses. Surely that alone indicates that this is not about being ‘inclusive’ but is rather misogyny hidden in a clever disguise. And one that works going by comments made here.

Plus, given that typically it’s TW voices that seem to be heard the most in public debate, why was it that the words ‘man/men’ were not the first to be removed from medical journals and health services to make them feel better about themselves? Odd that…

SunflowerGardens · 27/06/2022 07:34

'It is acknowledging that people who were born female and now live as male or as non-binary still have a uterus and therefore can still menstruate and get pregnant.'

If you're born female and still have a uterus then you're still a woman. Sorry.

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:33

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:33

I totally disagree. I live in the world and do not see the word “woman” going out of fashion. I am a woman and see no threat to referring to myself, and being recognised by others, as such. I only see the odd attempt here and there to make health provision more inclusive so that assumptions are not automatically made about how gender maps onto biology. The perceived threat to women is routed in transphobia.

Do what is gender?

NotBadConsidering · 27/06/2022 07:33

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:06

For the love of god it is not trans people who are taking away women’s rights to abortion or taking away our contraception. You are directing your anger at the wrong people and on the wrong issues. This is not helpful. get a bloody grip!!

The men on the right want to take away women’s rights by controlling bodies, the men on the left want to take away women’s rights by controlling the language needed to defend those rights.

It’s two sides of the same misogynistic coin. Toss it, and women lose either way.

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:33

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:24

You have no sympathy at all. You just dismissed their core selfhood as “a nonsense”. You were also extremely offensive and judgemental in suggesting that their experience of self is routed in trauma.

I dismissed it as nonsense because it is nonsense.

They are redefining men and women as stereotypes, which is offensive to the rest of us. And whilst I can see why some female people might not like the idea of being a woman, they can't identify out of their sex and they won't gain any male privilege, so it is entirely pointless.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:33

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 07:29

We can call women women and recognise that trans men also can and do get pregnant.

They aren't calling women however. That's the whole point of the thread, which you totally misconstrued in the argument you made.

I totally disagree. I live in the world and do not see the word “woman” going out of fashion. I am a woman and see no threat to referring to myself, and being recognised by others, as such. I only see the odd attempt here and there to make health provision more inclusive so that assumptions are not automatically made about how gender maps onto biology. The perceived threat to women is routed in transphobia.

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:31

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:29

Yes please- do remind me of the definition of female and male.

You know there’s this really cool thing called a dictionary. You can get them as books or online. Stop being obtuse and explain why you think women are not allowed to define themselves but trans people are?

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:31

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:08

Why do they have to make that choice though? Cos you said so?

Because getting pregnant and giving birth, and "living as a man" are completely incompatible.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:29

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:20

So can you see who the words ‘uterus haver’ would be offensive to those women? That implies they are not women. If a female does not have a uterus, she’s still a woman. If a male does not have a uterus, that’s normal biology. All women are female. All females do not identify as women. They are still female though. Maybe we should go back to female and male
for clarity

Yes please- do remind me of the definition of female and male.

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 07:29

We can call women women and recognise that trans men also can and do get pregnant.

They aren't calling women however. That's the whole point of the thread, which you totally misconstrued in the argument you made.

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:25

Comedycook · 27/06/2022 07:23

It is acknowledging that people who were born female and now live as male

How does someone live as a male please?

I’d like to know this too. Maybe then all women could live as males and misogyny would be dead. Just give us the rules then

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:24

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:20

The fact that they can still get pregnant and may need an abortion, and that they are still oppressed due to their sex, is proof that "living as a man" is a nonsense.

I have a lot of sympathy for trans men because I think that in most cases their identity comes from a place of trauma and a desire to opt out of womanhood. But this just shows that you can't opt out of it so you may as well embrace the label "woman" - meaning adult human female, reject the stereotypes that go with it, and fight for your sex based rights.

You have no sympathy at all. You just dismissed their core selfhood as “a nonsense”. You were also extremely offensive and judgemental in suggesting that their experience of self is routed in trauma.

Comedycook · 27/06/2022 07:23

It is acknowledging that people who were born female and now live as male

How does someone live as a male please?

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:20

Jujy · 26/06/2022 22:46

But surely all you are doing here is battling people who are biologically female. People who were born female, but for whatever reason feel so completely at odds with their biology that they are choosing to live as men. Transmen. Some of whom may still be able to get pregnant and breastfeed, or may need cervical smears, or access other traditionally termed 'women's' services. So is it really that big a deal to use language that encompasses both females who are women and those who identify as transmen?

The fact that they can still get pregnant and may need an abortion, and that they are still oppressed due to their sex, is proof that "living as a man" is a nonsense.

I have a lot of sympathy for trans men because I think that in most cases their identity comes from a place of trauma and a desire to opt out of womanhood. But this just shows that you can't opt out of it so you may as well embrace the label "woman" - meaning adult human female, reject the stereotypes that go with it, and fight for your sex based rights.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:20

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 07:09

For the love of god it is not trans people who are taking away women’s rights to abortion or taking away our contraception

And absolutely no one said it was.

Are you not capable of understanding the issue actually being discussed?

The OP is conflating attempts to make health provision inclusive of trans people with threats to women’s sexual and reproductive rights. There is absolutely NO REASON at all why trans inclusion means we can’t talk about misogyny and biology. We can call women women and recognise that trans men also can and do get pregnant.

Conflictedunicorn · 27/06/2022 07:20

Tandora · 27/06/2022 07:15

Some women don’t have and have never had a uterus though.
And some men don’t have a penis.

So can you see who the words ‘uterus haver’ would be offensive to those women? That implies they are not women. If a female does not have a uterus, she’s still a woman. If a male does not have a uterus, that’s normal biology. All women are female. All females do not identify as women. They are still female though. Maybe we should go back to female and male
for clarity

hattie43 · 27/06/2022 07:19

When people look back in history they'll realise how really f@cked up we were .