Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you not to tolerate the term "pregnant people"

305 replies

flashbac · 26/06/2022 22:21

It might seem harmless and kind but it is not harmless. I'm seeing the term alot at the moment due to the horrid state of affairs across the pond.

Pregnancy, abortion, menstruation, menopause. These are issues that affect women and reasons why men have sought to control us, to control our bodies. We are seen as vessels, chattels, playthings, property, servants, and then, when we can no longer get pregnant, as useless rubbish. All due to our biological function. If you tolerate language change so these things are seen as 'people' rights issues that affect both 'men' and women we lose the truthful and valid argument that bad and oppressive practices, laws, policy decisions etc, e.g. banning of abortion, are rooted in misogyny, which of course they are.

Abortion bans are because of misogyny. Especially in countries where there is no free maternal care, no statutory maternity leave or pay, no shits given about the children once they are born. This is a women's rights issue, a sex based one. And we, as a sex class, must never take any rights we have for granted.

OP posts:
nightwakingmoon · 27/06/2022 08:36

@Tandora since you’re into epistemology, can you explain then how someone can “know” themselves to be the opposite sex, when quite logically they can never have experienced what it is like to be the opposite sex, apart from through gender stereotypes?

How can that then be anything other than a fantasy or a mirage? You’re dismissing on the one hand knowledge of biological sex as “gender”, whilst simultaneously relying on it (as a sleight of hand) to claim that trans people can “know” what it is to be the opposite sex. The entire argument deconstructs itself.

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:35

The men on the right want to take away women’s rights by controlling bodies, the men on the left want to take away women’s rights by controlling the language needed to defend those rights. It’s two sides of the same misogynistic coin. Toss it, and women lose either way.

Excellent point.

onlywhenidream · 27/06/2022 08:35

Sone people know they are terrible fat

We call it anorexic

Sone men know they are women we call it transgender

Sone people know the world is flat , they are also incorrect

FOJN · 27/06/2022 08:34

The men on the right want to take away women’s rights by controlling bodies, the men on the left want to take away women’s rights by controlling the language needed to defend those rights. It’s two sides of the same misogynistic coin. Toss it, and women lose either way.

100%

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:34

All I said was whilst your body parts are your body parts, how you understand your body parts is a cognitive, psychological and social process. I don’t understand how you can reasonably dispute this.

What you said was this

When you call yourself a woman that’s gender

You're saying that my definition of being woman comes from 'gender', I'm saying no it isn't. So you're policing how I define myself.

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 08:33

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:31

But people can and do. So rather than dismissing it as absurd nonsense and impossible, maybe you should direct your energies towards trying to understand it?

No, they can't and they don't.

Whatever a trans woman believes themselves to be, it has absolutely nothing to do with being female.

itsgettingweird · 27/06/2022 08:31

Ditto chest feeding. And the language isn’t used for everyone, it’s allowing people to have the option of language that’s more inclusive to them if they wish it. I was a pregnant woman, and I breastfed. I have been involved in the care of people who now identify as male and have given birth and chosen to chest feed. It doesn’t take anything away from my experience by allowing them to have theirs.

This is something I'm always interested and want to learn more about. Why would a trans man want to get pregnant and have a baby? If they truly believe they are male surely they don't want to experience the lived experience of a woman?

Please answer factually and informatively because it's an area I genuinely don't understand and want to.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:31

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 08:23

You cannot "know yourself to be the opposite sex".

That is an absurd nonsense.

Trans women cannot know themselves to be female because they are not female, they are male.

Trans men cannot know themselves to be male because they are not male, they are female.

But people can and do. So rather than dismissing it as absurd nonsense and impossible, maybe you should direct your energies towards trying to understand it?

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:29

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:19

But you are allowed to use whatever terminology to describe yourself!

Except that you're not allowing women to state that their understanding of what sexy they are comes from their sex characteristics alone.

? I don’t understand this? Of course your understanding of what sex you are may come from your sex characteristics- ( although not necessarily so for everyone).

All I said was whilst your body parts are your body parts, how you understand your body parts is a cognitive, psychological and social process. I don’t understand how you can reasonably dispute this.

itsgettingweird · 27/06/2022 08:28

Absolutely agree and very well put and argued.

Although I was actually quite shocked at the number of hysterically crying woman in the USA supportive of the abortion ban ruling there. I can't deny I was despairing at a subsection of our sex.

Justthisonceharold · 27/06/2022 08:27

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:10

But you are allowed to use whatever terminology to describe yourself! You’re just not allowed to dictate how it applies to others.

It's the terminology of others forced on to women, that's what this thread is all about, not what we call ourselves. Do you not see that?

FOJN · 27/06/2022 08:25

DiscoBadgers · 27/06/2022 06:44

@FOJN I am literally saying I know and work with FTM transgender service users during pregnancy. I have firsthand knowledge and experience. Do you even know anyone transgender?

Why yes I do. I lived with a trans person for 5 years, possibly before some people commenting on this thread were even born. They are one of the best people I have ever met. I have met several others since and would like to think I can count a transman among my friends.

Is there a reason you think women are not allowed to have an opinion on their rights and female language unless they personally know someone trans?

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 08:23

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:02

You say “they know what sex they are” but I’m not sure entirely what you mean. Trans people are aware of their bodies, but they often know themselves to be the opposite sex. There’s a book called whipping girl which is incredibly helpful for elucidating trans experience. It’s author Julia Serano actually rejects the terminology of “gender identity” because she thinks it implies to conscious/ deliberate a process. She refers instead to the concept of “subconscious sex”. As a trans woman her subconscious sex is female.
(The book is also really helpful in elucidating how transphobia is actually rooted in misogyny).

You cannot "know yourself to be the opposite sex".

That is an absurd nonsense.

Trans women cannot know themselves to be female because they are not female, they are male.

Trans men cannot know themselves to be male because they are not male, they are female.

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:19

But you are allowed to use whatever terminology to describe yourself!

Except that you're not allowing women to state that their understanding of what sexy they are comes from their sex characteristics alone.

nightwakingmoon · 27/06/2022 08:17

But you are allowed to use whatever terminology to describe yourself! You’re just not allowed to dictate how it applies to others.

Women! Pay attention to what you are and aren’t allowed to do.

What does that remind me of? Oh yes, of what women have been told throughout history.

Pure sexism, only this time it’s pretending that it’s progressive.

Meet the new boss, same as the old boss…

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:17

Subconscious sex sounds like an awfully useful term.

I wonder why we couldn't apply 'subconscious' to things like race?

NotBadConsidering · 27/06/2022 08:15

You say “they know what sex they are” but I’m not sure entirely what you mean. Trans people are aware of their bodies, but they often know themselves to be the opposite sex. There’s a book called whipping girl which is incredibly helpful for elucidating trans experience. It’s author Julia Serano actually rejects the terminology of “gender identity” because she thinks it implies to conscious/ deliberate a process. She refers instead to the concept of “subconscious sex”. As a trans woman her subconscious sex is female.

(The book is also really helpful in elucidating how transphobia is actually rooted in misogyny).

Oh, here comes the Queer theory 🙄🚩🚩.

It’s time for the Queer Theory jeopardy video me thinks:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Mipq8FjTXrw

GrabbyGabby · 27/06/2022 08:14

In some countries the right to abortion is based on their sex discrimination statutes, lack of abortion would disproportionately affect women, so under sex discrimination law, it is legal.

But if men can get pregnant, then abortion affects everyone, and there is no argument under sex discrimination.

This is why language matters. This is why we need to fight tooth and nail to retain the ability to organise as a sex class, to use the word woman unashamedly and without qualification.

When we are fighting for things as critical as abortion rights, my view is that personal gender identity should play second fiddle to maintaining the clarity of language and purpose. We are discriminates against because of our sex not gender.

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:12

Your female body parts would still be your female body parts, but how you “understand” them is absolutely a cognitive, psychological and social process.

No. How I define my female body parts is scientifically evidenced and clearly classifiable.

How I understand to societal stereotypes about gender is an entirely different process and is driven by societal norms and different depending on the culture, geography and historical period that I live in.

roarfeckingroarr · 27/06/2022 08:10

Trans"women" aren't affected by these burdens, so they aren't owed a seat at the debating table. Trans"men" are biologically female - and will be all too aware that one cannot opt out of the biological realities of womanhood.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:10

Justthisonceharold · 27/06/2022 08:05

Agreed. I feel sorry for women. Now we have an extra layer of pressure telling us we are wrong and we aren't allowed to use the terminology that makes us feel better about ourselves.

You've hit the nail on the head, but not in the way you think.

But you are allowed to use whatever terminology to describe yourself! You’re just not allowed to dictate how it applies to others.

Justthisonceharold · 27/06/2022 08:05

stayathomer · 26/06/2022 23:28

Do people on mn never get tired of just arguing all the time? What does that term actually do to you? Yourself? Has anyone ever argued terminology you’ve used about yourself? I’d say not. I feel sorry for all the people in the world struggling to figure out their place that have an extra layer of having people tell them they’re wrong and aren’t allowed use the terminology that makes them feel a bit better about themselves

Agreed. I feel sorry for women. Now we have an extra layer of pressure telling us we are wrong and we aren't allowed to use the terminology that makes us feel better about ourselves.

You've hit the nail on the head, but not in the way you think.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:05

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 07:56

That “observation” you have made is a cognitive , psychological and social process.

What, so if I'd been socialised differently, I would understand my female body parts as something else?

Erm, no.

Your female body parts would still be your female body parts, but how you “understand” them is absolutely a cognitive, psychological and social process. That’s not to say all those processes themselves can be reduced to “socialisation”, there will be a biological element too.

roarfeckingroarr · 27/06/2022 08:04

Can I steal this please OP?

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:02

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 07:49

Trans people also know what sex they are.

If knowing what sex you are is gender, what is being transgender?

You say “they know what sex they are” but I’m not sure entirely what you mean. Trans people are aware of their bodies, but they often know themselves to be the opposite sex. There’s a book called whipping girl which is incredibly helpful for elucidating trans experience. It’s author Julia Serano actually rejects the terminology of “gender identity” because she thinks it implies to conscious/ deliberate a process. She refers instead to the concept of “subconscious sex”. As a trans woman her subconscious sex is female.
(The book is also really helpful in elucidating how transphobia is actually rooted in misogyny).