Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you not to tolerate the term "pregnant people"

305 replies

flashbac · 26/06/2022 22:21

It might seem harmless and kind but it is not harmless. I'm seeing the term alot at the moment due to the horrid state of affairs across the pond.

Pregnancy, abortion, menstruation, menopause. These are issues that affect women and reasons why men have sought to control us, to control our bodies. We are seen as vessels, chattels, playthings, property, servants, and then, when we can no longer get pregnant, as useless rubbish. All due to our biological function. If you tolerate language change so these things are seen as 'people' rights issues that affect both 'men' and women we lose the truthful and valid argument that bad and oppressive practices, laws, policy decisions etc, e.g. banning of abortion, are rooted in misogyny, which of course they are.

Abortion bans are because of misogyny. Especially in countries where there is no free maternal care, no statutory maternity leave or pay, no shits given about the children once they are born. This is a women's rights issue, a sex based one. And we, as a sex class, must never take any rights we have for granted.

OP posts:
Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:56

you seem to be reimagining gender as part of an epistemological process of knowledge production when it has never been understood that way

Ha if only that were true! I’d be a very famous social scientist. Sadly I can’t claim these ideas are original to me.

onlywhenidream · 27/06/2022 08:55

By having a baby you acknowledge your sex

By trying to avoid that you force others to accept gender - telling women that women means gender means we must choose - accept gender if you accept the term woman

Gender that many reject , not by identifying as the opposite sex but by saying gender is pointless and should be applied to no one

if I am no longer a women - which I can't be if I don't accept the gender only the sex - what prison do you put me in? Must I participate in male races ? Use the mens open plan changing rooms - after all your explanations mean I can't use womens as I am not a woman

WifeMotherWorkRepeat · 27/06/2022 08:52

I am a woman and I have a problem with this language. Only women/girls/females can have periods, have wombs and cervix’s, become pregnant, give birth and naturally breastfeed. All this ambiguous BS is for men to exert further control of women.
So to be clear for those on here still confused - Trans Men are biological women, dress it up how you want but XX and XY are undeniable facts. I will not have my identity erased to pacify a minuscule minority.

lovesT · 27/06/2022 08:50

100% I've complained to Tommy's (charity) for using it before. Can't stand it. Let's wipe out women shall we?

Agree with all the points you made too.

LondonWolf · 27/06/2022 08:50

I think you should spend some time talking to trans people as you have a very superficial understanding of their experience.

The trans people I know agree with me. They say it themselves 🤷🏼‍♀️

peachescariad · 27/06/2022 08:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This with big fucking bells on 👏

nightwakingmoon · 27/06/2022 08:49

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:42

”Gender” is the knowledge and understanding that gives meaning to bodily differences.

@Tandora

The established meaning of “gender” is that it is the system of social attribution of “masculine” and “feminine” traits to social behaviours. eg:

“Gender refers to the characteristics of women, men, girls and boys that are socially constructed. This includes norms, behaviours and roles associated with being a woman, man, girl or boy, as well as relationships with each other. As a social construct, gender varies from society to society and can change over time.”

Have you decided to change that definition? Because you seem to be reimagining gender as part of an epistemological process of knowledge production when it has never been understood that way.

You’re internalising the social as something that is innate. This isn’t what we generally understand as “social”: in fact we normally use the terms in opposition to one another.

It’s a creative definition of gender, but it is still an unorthodox and epistemologically incorrect one.

jeaux90 · 27/06/2022 08:49

Queer theory and gender ideology can do one. It's the worst American import (and I've eaten bleached chicken)

ReneBumsWombats · 27/06/2022 08:47

Trans people are aware of their bodies, but they often know themselves to be the opposite sex.

No, because your sex is in your body. This is just Newspeak. You can't make an argument by changing the meaning of words.

You may feel, very strongly, that you ought to be the opposite sex but that's possible only if your body is sexed, and sexed the way you don't want.

There can be no such thing as a trans person if sex and gender are not distinctly separate things. Gender exists as a concept only if it is not the same as sex. "Subconscious sex" simply means gender identity, but worded in a way to try to obfuscate the meaning of sex and suggest they are the same thing, or not different significantly. In which case, there is no such thing as a trans person.

I understand that you lot rely on Newspeak and intellectual dishonesty to make your so-called arguments, but how do you not realise that by spouting this nonsense, you are denying the existence of transgenderism?

Why can't you use the prefix "trans"? Don't you want a clear and accurate term for this group of people? When gay rights campaigners marched, they weren't calling to be called straight.

Aprilx · 27/06/2022 08:47

DiscoBadgers · 26/06/2022 22:48

IT IS NOT ABOUT MEN NOT HAVING PERIODS. It is acknowledging that people who were born female and now live as male or as non-binary still have a uterus and therefore can still menstruate and get pregnant. This isn’t about men claiming to be women to access changing rooms and blah blah blah, the usual MN trans hysteria.

Ditto chest feeding. And the language isn’t used for everyone, it’s allowing people to have the option of language that’s more inclusive to them if they wish it. I was a pregnant woman, and I breastfed. I have been involved in the care of people who now identify as male and have given birth and chosen to chest feed. It doesn’t take anything away from my experience by allowing them to have theirs.

If a person born female chooses to live as a man, surely that means taking steps to not get pregnant.

onlywhenidream · 27/06/2022 08:46

No sex explains body differences not gender

Like breasts are for feeding children that you give birth to

Timing of puberty and how it relates to body strength and size

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:46

LondonWolf · 27/06/2022 08:44

But people can and do. So rather than dismissing it as absurd nonsense and impossible, maybe you should direct your energies towards trying to understand it?

They do not. They know that they prefer living their life with "female" tropes. They prefer how women are treated in society, or rather the gender roles which have been forced upon them. They cannot possibly know what it is to have and live within a female body and all that entails. It is putting on "femaleness" as a costume.

I have directed energies towards understanding since 2015 and that's how I know the above Smile

I think you should spend some time talking to trans people as you have a very superficial understanding of their experience.

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:45

Gender” is the knowledge and understanding that gives meaning to bodily differences.

My understanding of bodily differences comes from scientific analysis.

Youre conflating all of this with societal stereotypes.

These are not applicable to my conclusions that I'm a woman because I have breasts, a uterus, a cervix and not a penis, testes, etc.

ErrolTheDragon · 27/06/2022 08:44

Tandora is using the the wrong word in relation to gender. If I called myself 'feminine', that would be 'gender'.

LondonWolf · 27/06/2022 08:44

But people can and do. So rather than dismissing it as absurd nonsense and impossible, maybe you should direct your energies towards trying to understand it?

They do not. They know that they prefer living their life with "female" tropes. They prefer how women are treated in society, or rather the gender roles which have been forced upon them. They cannot possibly know what it is to have and live within a female body and all that entails. It is putting on "femaleness" as a costume.

I have directed energies towards understanding since 2015 and that's how I know the above Smile

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:42

”Gender” is the knowledge and understanding that gives meaning to bodily differences.

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:41

and I didn’t say it “comes” from gender. I said it is gender.

okay then. My definition of being a woman is not gender, it's sex.

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 08:40

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:39

and I didn’t say it “comes” from gender. I said it is gender.

It didn't make any sense the first time you said it, and it still doesn't.

babyjellyfish · 27/06/2022 08:39

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:37

But people can and do

Ive never understood this. Given that they've never been the other sex, how would they know that's right?

This.

A male person with dysphoria has nothing in common with a female person without dysphoria.

They are not experiencing the same thing.

The female person is experiencing femaleness.

The male person is experiencing maleness and dysphoria.

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:39

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:37

Not at all. I have clarified exactly what I meant by that statement, if you don’t want to engage with the actual point that’s up to you.

and I didn’t say it “comes” from gender. I said it is gender.

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:38

I have clarified exactly what I meant by that statement

Well no. But I can see you've run out of ground with this particular argument 😉

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:37

But people can and do

Ive never understood this. Given that they've never been the other sex, how would they know that's right?

Tandora · 27/06/2022 08:37

TheKeatingFive · 27/06/2022 08:34

All I said was whilst your body parts are your body parts, how you understand your body parts is a cognitive, psychological and social process. I don’t understand how you can reasonably dispute this.

What you said was this

When you call yourself a woman that’s gender

You're saying that my definition of being woman comes from 'gender', I'm saying no it isn't. So you're policing how I define myself.

Not at all. I have clarified exactly what I meant by that statement, if you don’t want to engage with the actual point that’s up to you.

onlywhenidream · 27/06/2022 08:37

When I call myself a women it's because I was taught that women means adult human female

My parents also spent a long time helping me understand that I did not need to accept any gender concepts

It seems people insist that because transgender people say they are the opposite women we must accept it but when we say that's not what women means to us we are bigotted

Sexism in action again

NotBadConsidering · 27/06/2022 08:36

But people can and do. So rather than dismissing it as absurd nonsense and impossible, maybe you should direct your energies towards trying to understand it?

People can and do think they’re Elvis. Are they? Is that possible?

This all detracts from the theme of the thread, which is that women are unable to define themselves in the fight for rights because a group of men get upset when the word woman is used to describe “not them”. They hate it. Fight tooth and nail to make sure woman is never rooted in its definition of a sex. Whenever you see “pregnant people” remember it’s the males who are being kept happy for that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread