Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religious pondering Roe v. Wade

92 replies

LemonSwan · 26/06/2022 17:25

So with the news from America being so heavily influenced by religion I have been doing some deep thinking.

So my thinking with some religious framing -

If god knows me, every unspoken word, every thought, every action I will take and the path of my life. And thus for everyone in the world.

Surely god would know in advance when he gives the gift of life to an embryo which would be aborted. So how is it against the will of god IYSWIM. Surely god would just not fertilise that egg if he didn’t wish for the embryo to be aborted.

I don’t want this to descend into pro choice vs. Anti abortion because that’s everywhere right now. This is more about people’s thoughts on the above.

And yes I know not everyone is religious so anything offensive re religion is not really where I am going with this. I am pondering philosophy of religion and insight into thought tracks of why religious people are so anti abortion if they trust in god knowing in advance all that will be.

If anyone wants to muse in with anything insightful I would be really interested.

OP posts:
TheIsaacs · 26/06/2022 20:23

TankFlyBossW4lk · 26/06/2022 20:12

I utterly despair. It's hardly a wonder we're in such a state with people with your "ponderings" voting.

What gives you the impression the OP is religious? Having read their posts, I think the OP is wondering why religion is used as an excuse to punish abortion when it clearly is illogical. A feeling many of us share, i’m sure you’ll agree?

it seems like we can’t even discuss the nonsensical abuse of religion as an excuse without everyone misreading it as a challenge to force religion on you. Reading comprehension at it’s absolute finest…

voldr · 26/06/2022 20:20

buntywindermere · 26/06/2022 20:09

I believe there was a Plan A, when the world was created by God, and Plan A was free from suffering, natural disasters, illness, fear. God created this world with Plan A in mind in the hope that despite having the choice to live separately from Him, humanity would choose not to.
I don't necessarily believe in the literal Adam and Eve account but it's a good way of explaining how humanity chose to separate from God - thinking we know better. The separation of God and humanity caused huge shockwaves across creation and threw the perfect world off kilter.
The Old Testament is Plan B. God working to bring people back to Him, a 'reset' in the form of the flood, punishments and all sorts.
The New Testament is Plan C. Jesus. Someone to clarify different laws, highlight what's important (love, respect, tolerance, forgiveness) and be God suffering WITH humanity, so we can turn to God/Jesus knowing He knows what suffering is. We don't have to be separate from God any longer because we knows he gets it.
What transcends all of this is that this world isn't "it". We have hope in an after life, which IS still perfect. Jesus opened up the possibility of Heaven to everyone, and while other Christians will disagree, I don't believe at all that atheists/other religions won't get in. The person of Jesus and the unconditional love he demonstrated to all regardless of who they were is enough for me to believe that.

I miscarried in January this year at 8 weeks. It was a missed miscarriage, and so I had to take misoprostol as I was at risk of infection. It was an ordeal I wish nobody had to go through. When we got the certificate of foetal remains from the hospital they wrote Baby Surname on it. Because that foetus wasn't just a clump of cells that could be so easily discarded. If we were still on Plan A, it would have survived and thrived. But the world is broken, and things like chromosomal abnormalities exist and cells stop multiplying and my baby wasn't able to grow. My faith helps me with this, and I trust my baby is with God in Paradise, where one day we will be reconciled. Life is a wonderful gift, but I believe it's the ability for humanity to bring about life that is the real God-given gift. Again, in Plan A, infertility wouldn't be a thing. And yet so sadly here we are.

You can probably guess, I'm pro-life, but a) I'm not against abortion for religious reasons. Having had friends who have had abortions themselves has only made me look at the whole debate from different angles, and b) that's not what you asked, so I'm not looking for a debate as you won't change my mind and I gave up trying to change others minds about 10 years ago.

Hopefully my explanation helps a little from this Christian's perspective.

Be "pro-life" if you want, just don't try to force it on others.

TheIsaacs · 26/06/2022 20:17

Discovereads · 26/06/2022 17:34

If god knows me, every unspoken word, every thought, every action I will take and the path of my life. And thus for everyone in the world.

Only one sect of Christianity that I know of believes in predestination, the Calvinists. This isn’t a belief shared by the Christian religious right in the USA.

I thought it was Presbyterians who believe in predestination.

I think tbh the American Christian’s who use their religion to mandate abortion bans are not necessarily aligned with the wider Christian world. For some time it’s been clear that there seems to be a new type of American Christian fundamentalism emerging that doesn’t necessarily fit with Roman Catholicism, Anglicanism, etc. I find the American Christian beliefs of the southern churches very extremist. They ignore completely that other religious groups not only allow but in some instances encourage abortion (E.g. Judaism)

Topgub · 26/06/2022 20:15

@buntywindermere

Surely God knew plan a would fail?

Why set it up to fail?

And if the aim is death to get to paradise, surely the more abortions the better?

TankFlyBossW4lk · 26/06/2022 20:12

I utterly despair. It's hardly a wonder we're in such a state with people with your "ponderings" voting.

buntywindermere · 26/06/2022 20:09

I believe there was a Plan A, when the world was created by God, and Plan A was free from suffering, natural disasters, illness, fear. God created this world with Plan A in mind in the hope that despite having the choice to live separately from Him, humanity would choose not to.
I don't necessarily believe in the literal Adam and Eve account but it's a good way of explaining how humanity chose to separate from God - thinking we know better. The separation of God and humanity caused huge shockwaves across creation and threw the perfect world off kilter.
The Old Testament is Plan B. God working to bring people back to Him, a 'reset' in the form of the flood, punishments and all sorts.
The New Testament is Plan C. Jesus. Someone to clarify different laws, highlight what's important (love, respect, tolerance, forgiveness) and be God suffering WITH humanity, so we can turn to God/Jesus knowing He knows what suffering is. We don't have to be separate from God any longer because we knows he gets it.
What transcends all of this is that this world isn't "it". We have hope in an after life, which IS still perfect. Jesus opened up the possibility of Heaven to everyone, and while other Christians will disagree, I don't believe at all that atheists/other religions won't get in. The person of Jesus and the unconditional love he demonstrated to all regardless of who they were is enough for me to believe that.

I miscarried in January this year at 8 weeks. It was a missed miscarriage, and so I had to take misoprostol as I was at risk of infection. It was an ordeal I wish nobody had to go through. When we got the certificate of foetal remains from the hospital they wrote Baby Surname on it. Because that foetus wasn't just a clump of cells that could be so easily discarded. If we were still on Plan A, it would have survived and thrived. But the world is broken, and things like chromosomal abnormalities exist and cells stop multiplying and my baby wasn't able to grow. My faith helps me with this, and I trust my baby is with God in Paradise, where one day we will be reconciled. Life is a wonderful gift, but I believe it's the ability for humanity to bring about life that is the real God-given gift. Again, in Plan A, infertility wouldn't be a thing. And yet so sadly here we are.

You can probably guess, I'm pro-life, but a) I'm not against abortion for religious reasons. Having had friends who have had abortions themselves has only made me look at the whole debate from different angles, and b) that's not what you asked, so I'm not looking for a debate as you won't change my mind and I gave up trying to change others minds about 10 years ago.

Hopefully my explanation helps a little from this Christian's perspective.

DaffyDaydream · 26/06/2022 19:45

To Scuttling Herbert

Can you give the bible reference. Thank you

Spaceprincess · 26/06/2022 19:42

God doesn't exist and the Bible

Nolongerteaching · 26/06/2022 19:42

Apologies for poor typing

Nolongerteaching · 26/06/2022 19:41

@AclowncalledAlice

ao a baby that is 8/12 months old in the womb isn’t ‘alive’. They can be seen moving on a scan and kicking the mothers stomach but they are not alive before they have taken a breath.

independently not living perhaps but to say not alive isn’t correct (imv). All respect to the Rabbi but I surprised at this one.

ReneBumsWombats · 26/06/2022 19:39

Some religions teach that the forces of good and evil are both God and work together to enable free will. This also accounts for the fact that many things are not clearly good or evil and it's overly simplistic to think of it that way.

Nolongerteaching · 26/06/2022 19:37

OP, I remember covering a biology lesson in a Catholic school (I as also raised Catholic) and the pupils were being taught about conception/cell/sperm/zygotes.

The information they were been given illlustrated that life began at conception from a biological perspective.

I have often thought about this because as a state school they cannot teach anything that doesn’t adhere to good scientific thinking and the curriculum. I clearly remember looking at the resource and wondering about it but didn’t know enough to question it with the science dept.
My point is that if you are taught an idea and science is used to underpin it and you are taught that you have had a good education then you are unlikely to question much of that.

*Biologists - I know my example is vague and I apologise. I saw diagrams and terms I didn’t know so wanted to make sense of it.

Dahlietta · 26/06/2022 19:35

All those talking about the OP and her 'imaginary friend'... I don't get the impression that the OP is religious. She certainly doesn't know much about it!!

DoYouRememberTheInnMiranda · 26/06/2022 19:19

I don't think the original argument from the OP really holds water - God knows how every life will end, but that doesn't mean he is pleased by the way every life will end. Murder (the totally non-controversially wrong type against born people) is against the Ten Commandments, and God made people that are murdered (e.g. Abel). That doesn't somehow show God approves of murder, any more than the fact foetuses are aborted shows God approves of abortion.

PrachtStück · 26/06/2022 18:58

I’m a Christian - not a Calvinist or Methodist or other denominations mentioned here.

God knows what is going to happen to me, before I do it, but there’s something called free choice which gives me the freedom to make the decisions I want to make. God might see my future, but He won’t force me to choose His will - even if that goes against His wishes for my life, or hurts Him.

I’m pro-choice. Because God is pro-choice - He doesn’t force anybody to believe in anything or do anything they don’t want to. The tragedies that we see in this world are a consequence of the state of this planet - there are diseases, genetic conditions and terrible deaths due to miscarriage, accidents, etc. God doesn’t get involved in what happens down here - you can only ask Him to be present in your life, but that doesn’t spare you from suffering.

All the ‘religious’ people campaigning as pro-lifers in the US right now, also encourage you to ‘choose God’s love’ etc. Apparently you’re free to choose that, but not what happens to your body? Makes no sense and contradicts the Bible’s teachings which they claim to follow.

In short, you won’t get a rational answer from anybody who wants to take away free choice from a human being. There is no way they can justify their beliefs rationally.

AclowncalledAlice · 26/06/2022 18:45

I'm just going to leave this here because this says everything I want to.

Religious pondering Roe v. Wade
jeaux90 · 26/06/2022 18:36

Your imaginary friend has no baring over my medical requirements.

Hoardasurass · 26/06/2022 18:28

@LemonSwan I can't answer your question but I have 1 of my own my grandmother was Irish Catholic and 4 still births none of which were allowed to be baptised as they had never taken a breath so we're never a living person with a sole and as such couldn't be buried on consecrated ground. This was fully indoreced by Catholic doctrine for centuries so why did the Catholic Church suddenly feel the need to change this centuries old doctrine so that they could punish women for an abortion as a mortal sin, if a fetus has no sole and isn't a real person until they take a breath how can it be a sin ? Because they magically now have a sole at conception and yet my grandmother still can't have her dead babies buried on Church grounds.
I'll tell you why it's just another way to control and maline women

Applesandroses · 26/06/2022 18:27

DebtWorry · 26/06/2022 18:24

Why is it then in Texas they are anti abortion but have the death penalty that’s so confusing to me

tbf half the punishments in the bible are being put to death so I guess at least they follow through in that respect (I am anti death penalty and no supporting them to be clear_

Comedycook · 26/06/2022 18:26

Why is it then in Texas they are anti abortion but have the death penalty that’s so confusing to me

I am pro choice but I guess the reasoning here is that the death penalty is for those who have committed heinous crimes whereas unborn babies are completely innocent. I'm not pro life but I can imagine this is the thought process...I could be wrong

Pinkandpurplehairedlady · 26/06/2022 18:26

I would say it’s down to free will. I’m religious and would not personally have an abortion but that is my choice and I do t have to the right to impose that choice on any other woman. Abortion is a fact of life and I would far rather women have access to a safe medical procedure than go back to the old days where women were dying.

DebtWorry · 26/06/2022 18:24

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Why is it then in Texas they are anti abortion but have the death penalty that’s so confusing to me

ehb102 · 26/06/2022 18:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Genevieva · 26/06/2022 18:18

So none of that was very religious others than that, where the population is more religious and that religiosity means people are more opposed to abortion, the laws will likely be stricter than in states that do not consider abortion to be a religious or moral issue for society at large, but instead see it as a private one.

DebtWorry · 26/06/2022 18:18

shorty- shitty !