Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Frustrated at how people in care homes are denied basic freedoms

96 replies

Nananananana · 26/06/2022 08:45

Work in various homes as agency staff. A lady has just asked me if I can get her up at 10am instead of 8:15.. reported this back to the permanent staff and they said, no, she has to get up now. Tell her she needs to get up now.
Why?
Or they have to be put to bed at 7am.
I understand that some have morning medication etc. But this can be given whilst they're in bed still if needed, just woken up for it/something to eat then back to sleep if they want.
I've seen this across different homes, it probably happens in many.
Feels like they're in a prison sometimes, why should they be denied basic freedoms?
They pay thousands to live here.

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 26/06/2022 11:04

Bit rude to go out ehen you are expecting carers
Quite a lot of people see carers as some kind of lowly serf unfortunately. Sad thing is the carer probably won't even be paid for the wasted trip.

dottypotter · 26/06/2022 11:01

converseandjeans · 26/06/2022 09:11

It sounds like a prison that you pay a £1000 a week to stay in. It's horrible that the elderly are treated with so little patience when they're paying for the pleasure of staying there.

Lol its nothing like a prison. Bet you've never spent time in either.

ShahRukhKhan · 26/06/2022 10:57

A care home is supposed to be someone's home, and carers don't always seem to remember that and run it more like a military operation. It might be because they are super stretched and stressed, but staff also seem to get institutionalised in their approach.. Small things like they decide what 'has' to be on the TV instead of listening to what the residents want. Or deciding who sits with who at dinner. Or randomly removing half the chairs from the lounge even though it means residents can't use it as much. All stories from my mam's place.

NellesVilla · 26/06/2022 10:50

I had a call at 7:30 in the evening from one of my mum's carers to say my mum wasn't there.
I pointed out my mum wasn't a prisoner and was at liberty to go out if she so chose.

Well, if you or your mother booked the carer, your mother kinda needed to be there to receive the said care, no?

And I hope the carer still got paid for the call. Not their fault the su wasn’t home (ex-carer here who was regularly mucked about both by service users and agencies after spending 25 mins’ sitting in traffic).

LindaEllen · 26/06/2022 10:49

OhamIreally · 26/06/2022 09:01

Agree it happens with people with carers coming in too.
I had a call at 7:30 in the evening from one of my mum's carers to say my mum wasn't there.
I pointed out my mum wasn't a prisoner and was at liberty to go out if she so chose.

Bit rude to go out when expecting carers, who are overworked and underpaid, isn't it?

VladmirsPoutine · 26/06/2022 10:43

I saw deprivation of liberty happening multiple times. Locking people in their rooms so they wouldn't stroll out, keeping the outer gates locked so again they wouldn't stroll out. The carer has tons of tasks to complete without spending half the afternoon panicking if gran went for a stroll then got lost. Sorry but carers just don't have the time for it. If they want to eat dinner later that's fine but they'll be given their dinner at say 7:30pm - they can leave it on the side if they want.

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 26/06/2022 10:40

Bednobsbroomsticks · 26/06/2022 09:08

My mum used to work in care homes. She let them get up anytime they wanted. Their home. Disgusting how they are treated when they are paying thousands

There's no way your mum could of done this.
It's a tricky situation and I think some people haven't done the job personally.

Night staff even get residents dressed and put them back in bed! On average I looked after 8 residents (some needing 2 members of staff to assist) how can 1 person get 8 people washed and dressed and breakfast given by letting people get up when they want?

The sorry truth is there's simply not enough staff and a bit like school and nursery you need structure and when you have limited staff and poorly paid wages....

vodkaredbullgirl · 26/06/2022 10:37

Glad I work in a care home, that is person centred care.

Hmm I'm sure there was a similar post months ago.

2022again · 26/06/2022 10:36

user143677433 · 26/06/2022 09:38

I’ve recently started visiting an elderly ex-neighbour in a care home. It does have the feel of a prison.

When she walked me to the door she looked very upset and said “oh, they don’t let us out”, had to get a member of staff to let me out and then the staff member gave her a withering look and rolled her eyes at being asked to unlock the door.

P.s. this IS deprivation of liberty in this specific instance unless there are specific aspects of her care plan that you don't know about that means she isn't entitled to leave the home alone. There should be clear arrangements that a resident knows about for how she can go out if she wishes to but I think covid has led to a huge problem over how an individuals rights are managed.

VladmirsPoutine · 26/06/2022 10:35

I have a lot to say about care homes but I'll stick to the brief points. Carers earn pittance yet some of the residents are spending a fortune to live there.

There has to be a routine or everything goes out the window. There is some flexibility but more often it has to stick within the confines. I know that care homes often seem like prisons and they are horrible places but care staff are under enormous pressure to complete all their duties.

Carers also have to swallow their tongue a lot when interacting with some of the resident's family members. If you cared that much then take your mum home with you. Carers suffer from empathy fatigue. At some point it really does become I need to give number 34 medication at 8pm then go and change number 47 etc etc - there is no time for anything else.

When I briefly worked in care it was categorically the worst job I'd ever had.

AmaryIlis · 26/06/2022 10:34

singingbirds · 26/06/2022 09:57

I remember seeing on tv care home staff treating residents like family playing games cooking with them doing their hair reading to them ect. Time doesn't allow for that anymore and it's so sad. We have strict rules and procedures in place now that means we have to have a certain number of activities done in a certain amount of time. I don't agree with it at all. It's shocking but because there is such low levels of staff we can't spend the time with each individual it's such a shame

It depends on the home. The one my mother was in regularly organised activities and outings (apart from during lockdown), had a hairdresser come in, etc. They would also do quite impromptu fun things, e.g. a party when it was one of the carer staff's birthdays. They weren't charging extra, in fact prices were fully in line with those charged at other care homes we investigated, and they were lower than many.

snoochieboochies · 26/06/2022 10:32

I know, same when I was a carer. Working in this industry showed me I can't let my parents live in a care home.

HoppingPavlova · 26/06/2022 10:32

I guess a basic problem is breakfast is probably served at 7.30 or similar and everything cleaned away by 8.30. So if she got up at 10, there’s no breakfast and it’s not practical for the kitchen to make hers separately, staff supervise one person eating etc. If everyone wanted their own different routine it just wouldn’t work.

ScarlettnotOHara · 26/06/2022 10:32

I remember seeing an tv programme with a hidden camera . It was shocking !! Cords to pull for assistance tied up so the resident couldn’t use them . Residents being put to bed at 7pm , my mum is mid 80s and stays up until 11 every night .
Care homes need to be regulated and care workers need to report this abuse 😞

2022again · 26/06/2022 10:29

yep ,having worked in care homes before & whilst I did my healthcare degree, then working in the NHS and visiting care homes as part of my role, i would personally book a trip to Switzerland before voluntarily going into one. However having seen a number of different care settings I would say there are HUGE variations in the dignity, respect and care shown to residents and some places are absolutely lovely and provide outstanding care ..whereas once on a ward we had someone admitted from a NH with maggots in their bandages (not deliberately part of the wound care I hasten to add!!) ,so shows the extremes. Having been an 18 yr old doing bank/temporary care home work and knowing absolutely nothing at the time other than being told I had to do x.y.z at certain times of the day and being faced with so many vulnerable people to get up and get ready, get toiletted,fed etc, I didn't know any better but as a minimum wage job it's really a lot to put on someone and it takes maturity (and financial security!!)before you are able to start standing up for the people you care for.

Squareflair · 26/06/2022 10:28

AmaryIlis · 26/06/2022 10:23

Not really. She's still paying the agency and the carer.

So? That's doesn't mean it's not selfish, instead of just phoning to say we don't need x today which would take a few seconds, the carer travelled to the property, had no answer and so had to phone - probably whilst running through all sorts of scenarios and wondering whether this would be a situation where the person was unconscious inside and had to escalate. Just because someone is paid for a service it doesn't mean you can treat them like crap and waste their time.

AmaryIlis · 26/06/2022 10:27

singingbirds · 26/06/2022 09:47

In all honesty unless you've worked in care you would not under stand the pressure we as carers are under. We have routine for a reason. If we were to allow one person to get up an hour later that would mean we would have to push other care calls earlier/later which clients/residents may not want either. I agree it would be lovely if we could allow them to choose but unfortunately we don't have the staff capacity to allow for that I've worked in homes and the community and would love nothing more than to give every person exactly what they want but we are under such strict time allocations it's impossible.

The point is that care homes need to be run in a way that makes it possible. When you are taking over £1K a week from someone, it's the least you can do.

AmaryIlis · 26/06/2022 10:23

Squareflair · 26/06/2022 09:23

Yes, super selfish to not let the carer know.

Not really. She's still paying the agency and the carer.

ManateeFair · 26/06/2022 10:15

OhamIreally · 26/06/2022 09:01

Agree it happens with people with carers coming in too.
I had a call at 7:30 in the evening from one of my mum's carers to say my mum wasn't there.
I pointed out my mum wasn't a prisoner and was at liberty to go out if she so chose.

If I was a carer who had been booked to arrive at a specific time to deliver necessary care to someone who couldn’t look after themselves, I would, of course want to let the family know if that person was inexplicably absent, just in case there was something wrong. If your mum went missing and you then found out the carer had said nothing when they found her house empty the previous day, you would be furious.

Also, that time the carer wasted turning up at the house for no reason could have been spent with another client who might have really benefited from some extra attention.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 26/06/2022 10:13

They’re aren’t allowed to do this. It’s a form of institutional abuse and staff should have had training around this.

it certainly isn’t like that in every care home. I’d actually be taking it higher if they weren’t respecting the right of the residents.

Elleherd · 26/06/2022 10:12

ZealAndArdour

It happens in hospitals too, it’s a form of institutional abuse.
Yes.
I'm disabled and a frequent flyer and have to watch it all, and directly suffer a fair amount of it.
Your post made me swallow hard. Thank you, please don't change.

Ponoka7 · 26/06/2022 10:08

@Snuffy28 you can start with no experience but are trained while doing the job. You've got the chance to do NVQs and various certificates. There's senior care staff and people who carry the shift. As well as the Nurse in charge. As a new starter you'd be put on 2-1 residents with experienced staff. A lot of student nurses work in care homes while studying.

Some Care homes are 65 beds, many of the residents will need help to eat etc, there will be a few stroke etc patients who decide to stay in their rooms. How could you run the kitchen to feed on personal demand? bearing in mind that the CQC want to see menus and fluid charts and all nutrition has to be adequate (which is often a job in itself) and documented. Residents aren't just put to bed and left. There's pad changes, fluids and turnings/OBs to be done on some. As well as emotional support. The night staff also clean the lounge etc. It's great that there is flexibility for lower care needs residents, but we need more care homes so we can place people appropriately. Routine is needed for those who have higher care needs.

BellePeppa · 26/06/2022 10:06

OhamIreally · 26/06/2022 09:01

Agree it happens with people with carers coming in too.
I had a call at 7:30 in the evening from one of my mum's carers to say my mum wasn't there.
I pointed out my mum wasn't a prisoner and was at liberty to go out if she so chose.

She did the right thing didn’t she? If your mum needs a carer and she’s not there then surely the carer would rightly be concerned?

chiffchaffchiff · 26/06/2022 10:04

My grandmother is in a care home that has a varied approach to schedules. Her area is aimed at low-needs residents. At most, someone might need help getting up and getting to breakfast due to mobility issues. There aren't many who do and if they call and have to wait 10 minutes for someone to be free, they don't complain. They have a buffet breakfast in the morning that's available from 7-10, lunch and dinner are served in a 2 hour time slot. Everyone gets up when they want to, joins in with activities if they want, can go for a walk around or a day out. It's a bit like a budget hotel though costs thousands per year.

The high needs area upstairs is much more rigid. They have a lot of people with advanced dementia or complex medical issues so care is planned in advance to a rigid schedule. If they didn't, they could easily miss a resident. One of the biggest risks is pressure sores, if a resident is left for an hour longer because a few others have gone off schedule the consequences could be awful. The worst pressure sores can go down to the bone and prevention is easier than treating after they've started.

user143677433 · 26/06/2022 10:04

She didn’t discourage me, some things, including last ever bubble baths are more important than rigid time schedules and routines, and I will happily die on that hill.

@ZealAndArdour That made me cry. That was a lovely and hugely important thing that you did 💖