Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

*SPOILER ALERT* To think that Stranger Things is inappropriate for children / teens

158 replies

leawakeford · 25/06/2022 20:39

My child wants to watch Stranger Things because all the other kids at school have watched it. From what I can see it features violence, sex, inappropriate language and very scary imagery. Surely parents shouldn’t be letting their young children and teens watch this!

OP posts:
LibraryFairy · 26/06/2022 11:18

DH and I watched together (just the two of us) from the beginning but have just gone back and binged from Season 1 right up to date with our two sons who are 12 (turning 13 this week) and 14. They love it and now we're all desperately waiting for the new episodes this Friday.

I would've been scared at their ages but they're more worldly and cynical than I was and they comment on the special effects etc. The sex scenes are really mild as is the language and we've loved having a more grown up series to all get into together.

OP your 14 yo is missing out compared to his friends .. sit and watch with him!

Pinkyxx · 26/06/2022 11:02

It's not for young children but 13+ it's fine so long as they are sufficiently mature and not disturbed by some of the gore / dark themes. My DD (13) loves it.. If she was sensitive to these things I wouldn't let her watch it. There are however some very positive themes: friendship, hope, over coming adversity, that hero's don't always look like hero's, taking responsibility & never giving up..... Some people are more sensitive to the dark / gore content so it just isn't for everyone.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 26/06/2022 11:00

If he was 10 I’d say you were fair enough not to let him watch it.

but at 14 you’ll really be singling him out from his peer group. Dd2 is 14 and definitely mature enough to watch it, as are all her friends.

Bonjovispjs · 26/06/2022 10:59

Thanks @DjoChateaux I may brave it when I get that far then😊

Snoozer11 · 26/06/2022 10:57

You are performance parenting, OP. Why would you let the people who decide the ratings of a film or TV show decide whether or not your kids can watch something.

Some 14 year olds are very mature. Some are very immature. You know your kids.

What do you honestly think is going to happen if your 14 year old hears someone use a four letter word?!

I remember I had a science teacher at school who refused to teach any form of sex education because she believed the 14 year olds were too young. Someone else had to cover her class.

She was also having kittens once because her 15 year old daughter had gone to the cinema with a friend and had seen a 12A. She was going around the sixth formers asking who had seen the film, what it was like, the language in it etc. It's pathetic and it's not "good parenting".

ToldItToTheBees · 26/06/2022 10:54

We let our 12yo watch previous seasons, but this one is a massive no. We watched the first episode together, me naively not realising the gruseomeness was amped up considerably, and she felt unsettled afterwards. So did I, and I'm not watching any more episodes myself.

As an aside though, I'm chuffed on Kate Bush's behalf!

Jackiewoo · 26/06/2022 10:45

14 oh gosh let him watch it.

My 13 yo loves it and so do all his friends, they care about the characters and identify with them, not the horror (and I don't remember any sex in it, maybe a bit of fumbling then fade to the view out of the window).

I'm not naive enough to think my DS wouldn't watch it at a friends house if I banned it so we watch it together. Yes its gory but its squelchy monsters not real world stuff and the 80s setting also gives it some distance. They'll see and hear much worse at school. The central characters age and their bonds of friendship and struggles are the biggest part of it. Teens rescuing each other with minimum input from adults, misfits who are heroes, managing friction and relationships, taking charge and thinking for themselves is a very positive message, and you can have a good laugh about tinned tomatoes and the overuse of sticky goop.

Shortname · 26/06/2022 10:10

I thought this was going to be about a primary aged kid, Ive just told my 10yr old he can't watch it, I know he'd be really scared. But 14?! YABU it's a great series, really good fantasy story and unless he's especially sensitive should be absolutely fine at 14. Pick your battles, at 14 this really isn't one to fight.

NoSquirrels · 26/06/2022 09:59

leawakeford · 25/06/2022 20:45

He’s 14 and we don’t let any of the kids have free control over the TV or Netflix etc normally so making an exception for this seems a bit out of line with how we parent

Intrigued by what you mean by this, OP? Do you all watch everything together, then?

Grigorisangel · 26/06/2022 09:51

I also grew up with Freddy Kruger, chainsaw massacre kind of films. They terrified me and I slept with the light on for a lot of my younger life but continued to watch scary movies. My 9 year old loves horror films and against the grain of most people on here I let him watch them, I’ve yet to find one he says is scary and he has watched all stranger things. We only introduced him to it in May after he was wanting something new to watch in the evening and he is totally hooked and watched series 1-3 twice before season 4 came out. He is now counting down to the second part of season 4 and wants to watch it all next Friday when’s it comes out.
I appreciate it’s a controversial topic and definitely is not aimed at children his age and most would be very scared by it but I also think I’m quite laid back and happy to let him try things like this and see how he finds it. I know in my friendship group there are a fair few children of similar ages who watch and enjoy it but at the same time some whose parents would not dream of letting them watch it for years, both options are fine.
At 14 I think unless they act very immature it’s a little odd to control their viewing so much but as I said I am pretty laid back

DjoChateaux · 26/06/2022 09:50

Bonjovispjs · 26/06/2022 09:36

I started watching the first series last night. Doesn't sound too disturbing for teenagers, but what about a squeamish person like me? I don't mind scary stuff, but I hate blood and gore, from what I gather from this thread, I should be ok up until series 4? Is that about right?

You'll be ok with season 4. There isn't more blood and gore. I'm not sure why people are saying it's more scary than a demogorogon chasing a small child through the woods in the pitch black in season 1 or a blob of human matter forming another creature/monster like in season 3. You see and hear bones snapping a few times and eyes 'pop'. I don't consider it any scarier than the other seasons.

Bonjovispjs · 26/06/2022 09:36

I started watching the first series last night. Doesn't sound too disturbing for teenagers, but what about a squeamish person like me? I don't mind scary stuff, but I hate blood and gore, from what I gather from this thread, I should be ok up until series 4? Is that about right?

MrsSkylerWhite · 26/06/2022 08:44

mamaduckbone · Today 08:23
The weeping angels, for example (ds1 had nightmares for weeks - it should have had an age warning!!“

you’re right, that whole series was really scary. The one with the gas masks, “are you my mummy”. Kept me awake at night!

mamaduckbone · 26/06/2022 08:23

The weeping angels, for example (ds1 had nightmares for weeks - it should have had an age warning!!)

mamaduckbone · 26/06/2022 08:18

Mykittensmittens · 25/06/2022 22:44

Goodness.

My now 11 year old and his 13yo DS bloody love it. We watch along, and have very much come to enjoy it too.

DS says Dr Who is just as scary. And some parts of Star Wars or Marvels. For some people
violence is just as bad a horror. The worst parts for us are the tension (Max in series 4, waking up,
all four of us screaming ‘COME ON MAX!!!’ As she ran for the light…)

Everything is subjective. Every child is different. Only you know what your child can handle and more importantly enjoy, so it’s personal choice.

Some bits of Dr Who are definitely more scary

NippyWoowoo · 26/06/2022 07:57

Sigh, OP won't be back.

Gibbertyflibberts · 26/06/2022 00:16

I would say there's very little sexual content (I think the most graphic is s1 when Nancy and Steve are naked in a pool and sex is alluded to, but you don't see anything). Language is pretty tame and I grew up in a household where the word 'bloody' was considered offensive. 'Horror' is a bit more subjective as it's not really blood and guts, but the idea of being trapped in an alternate dimension, which I guess some younger viewers could find scary.

Sometimeswinning · 26/06/2022 00:14

Badlifeday · 25/06/2022 23:59

Well the Texas Chainsaw Massacre is just a film, doesn't mean it didn't give me nightmares

Actually this is based on several true life happenings. I know horror. Some films turn my stomach and are actually disturbing. Stranger things is entertaining!

MyDogAteMyHousework · 26/06/2022 00:13

My oldest was the only child in his class in Y6 who hadn't seen the first series. I thought it was OK and let him watch it with me. He's now 13.5 and I seem to be way more disturbed by season 4 than he is.

My younger child (10.5) has seen the first two and a bit seasons. Ex let her watch it with him but gave up Netflix before they finished season 3. I don't agree at all with his viewing choices for the DC but can't control what he does in his own home.

DC2 is desperate to see the rest. I've said that we can re-watch slowly from the beginning from some point in Y6. I'm hoping to string it out long enough that she'll be much older by the time we get to season 4.

We do watch some 15s together, but that rating covers so many things. For example, we're watching Brooklyn 99 and it's great. DC2 just doesn't get the sex references (and they're not too bad anyway) and it's full of really positive messages. S4 of Stranger Things is quite dark - there is definitely no 'not getting' those gruesome deaths.

Even if you're generally quite cautious about viewing, I think 14 would definitely be OK to start from the beginning if you watch it once a week. It does depend on the individual, though. I have friends who won't watch it because they don't like anything scary.

By watching it together, I can at least say when I think something is really disturbing. DC often just says "but it's not real" so doesn't seem to experience it the same way I do anyway.

Badlifeday · 25/06/2022 23:59

Sometimeswinning · 25/06/2022 23:45

Ah my 10yo watches it. He's aware its a TV show so it's fine.

Well the Texas Chainsaw Massacre is just a film, doesn't mean it didn't give me nightmares

ZenNudist · 25/06/2022 23:46

I am finding season 4 too scary.

Probably OK for a 14yo. I'm just a wimp.

Sometimeswinning · 25/06/2022 23:45

Ah my 10yo watches it. He's aware its a TV show so it's fine.

Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 25/06/2022 23:38

14 and 16 year old loved it but won’t let my 11 year old yet, way too scary! It is brilliant though, watched it with my kids as they raved about it and ended up loving it so much!!

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/06/2022 23:35

We were very cautious with our young ones. Watching Stranger Things now with our youngest., 19.

it’s pretty tame.

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/06/2022 23:30

neverbeenskiing · 25/06/2022 20:51

I work in a secondary school. At 14 I'm pretty sure he knows about sex, and will almost certainly have seen pornography online. There is nothing in Stranger Things thats worse than what 14 year olds see on Tik Tok or hear at school every day.

This is very true. I can understand why you wouldn’t want him watching some of the really gory horrors but ST is aimed at a younger audience. The characters themselves in the beginning are tweens / teens.