Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Abortion Overton window

321 replies

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/06/2022 17:57

There's already been a few and there will be more.

Following the American decision regarding abortion, campaigners and trolls will be trying to move abortion provision in other counties, including the UK, into a 'debate'. Our right to safe, accessible, free healthcare isn't a debate. As soon as people start behaving as though essential healthcare for women is debatable, we are in a dangerous place.

Please consider, when opening threads about abortion at the moment, that the aim is to move the Overton window. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window#:~:text=The%20Overton%20window%20is%20the,as%20the%20window%20of%20discourse

I'm not enabling voting because that would rather feed into my point.

OP posts:
bronzepig · 26/06/2022 22:20

If you want to reduce abortion rates then you need to improve sex education, access to contraception, and the circumstances into which girls/women are expected to bring children into the world.

The US appears to be doing none of these, and indeed many schools in red states are attempting to censor sex education classes in schools.

bronzepig · 26/06/2022 22:17

MrsTerryPratchett · 26/06/2022 16:51

That's to everyone contributing to this conversation. Including those neatly demonstrating my point with their straw men.

It's also worth listening to and telling the stories of the women who went before us. My own family has it's tragic stories. We probably all know a woman who has been forced to give birth, I know I do. Women dying from backstreet abortions is in living memory and is happening right now in places like Nicaragua. It will take a while for the trade to start up again in the US but it will.

Women will die from botched attempts to terminate pregnancies.

Yes

And many will die or suffer injuries at the hands of abusive partners trying to induce a miscarriage because abortion is now harder or impossible to access

MrsTerryPratchett · 26/06/2022 22:14

You're just doing what I'm talking about. Fucking about with hypotheticals to distract from the actual issue. Women being denied the right to end pregnancy safely.

You'd rather talk about some incredibly unlikely scenario with a psychotic woman trying to end a pregnancy in labour. Demonstrating my point beautifully.

OP posts:
FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 22:02

MrsTerryPratchett · 26/06/2022 22:01

I'm very glad that you are so happy to show your misogyny. It makes it much easier to ignore every single word from you.

I don't actively want abortions en route to delivery. Unlike you however, I TRUST WOMEN to choose. And therefore 'as late as necessary'.

And fortunately that view will never become law here in the U.K., or any other civilised country. You can rage all you want, better people than you will not allow it.

FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 22:01

Arashi · 26/06/2022 22:00

@FemmeNatal the issue I think is whilst the thought of a woman terminating on her way to the delivery room, or terminating due to sex is not great, the alternative to anything other than free choice full stop is limited choice and to me is a worse option.

It’s the option that we have in nearly every civilised country.

MrsTerryPratchett · 26/06/2022 22:01

FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 21:52

And I believe that it’d be better to deliver the baby and euthanise the mother.

I'm very glad that you are so happy to show your misogyny. It makes it much easier to ignore every single word from you.

I don't actively want abortions en route to delivery. Unlike you however, I TRUST WOMEN to choose. And therefore 'as late as necessary'.

OP posts:
Arashi · 26/06/2022 22:00

@FemmeNatal the issue I think is whilst the thought of a woman terminating on her way to the delivery room, or terminating due to sex is not great, the alternative to anything other than free choice full stop is limited choice and to me is a worse option.

titchy · 26/06/2022 21:53

And I believe that it’d be better to deliver the baby and euthanise the mother.

Wow....

titchy · 26/06/2022 21:52

And you femme are demonstrating OP's actual point. So very clearly.

I guess we should thank you.

FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 21:52

SexyLittleNosferatu · 26/06/2022 11:30

I believe a 39 week old foetus should be allowed to be aborted if the mother wishes it to happen. I believe that with all my heart. #itrustthewoman.

And I believe that it’d be better to deliver the baby and euthanise the mother.

FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 21:50

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 26/06/2022 09:49

there are a number of people on this thread advocating for women to be able to abort their baby at any stage and for any reason

No one is arguing that. They are arguing that it is a private decision between a woman and her doctors.

The Law doesn’t mandate when a limb can be amputated or chemotherapy given. Those are decisions with huge, potentially life-threatening, consequences, but we trust patients and doctors to reach the decision. Abortion should be no different.

You are arguing exactly that. You are arguing that any woman should have the right to abort up to and including the point that she in in labour.

Why are you now pretending otherwise? You are getting angry at anyone who disagrees that a 9 month termination should be legal.

FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 21:47

Intheflicker · 26/06/2022 00:33

You are the exact bloody reason OP started this thread.

And people like you who think an abortion on the way to the delivery room is acceptable are the reason that I am glad that the U.K. does not elect anyone like you to power.

FemmeNatal · 26/06/2022 21:45

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 25/06/2022 22:35

The poster to whom I was responded is fine with people in the UK choosing to abort at full-term because they are bearing a girl. I see no problem being happy that they don’t get to make any laws

Where did I mention term? Or the U.K?

Thank you, though, for providing a perfect example of the bad faith whataboutery and misrepresentation that the OP is warning us about.

Chip, chip, chip away at women’s right to choose. Sow doubt. Try to make people uncomfortable about siding with pro-choice arguments by misrepresenting them. We see you.

I asked if you were fine with sex-selective abortions, and you indicated that you were. You didn’t say that you only support it in certain countries.

If I misrepresented your view, I apologise, so will ask again. Do you support a woman’s right to have an abortion at eight months if she decides that she would like to, as she’s carrying a female?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 26/06/2022 21:13

Only 0.1% of abortions are performed over 24 weeks. This includes those to save the life of the mother.

RadicalisedByMumzNet · 26/06/2022 20:55

Walserwasstrange · 26/06/2022 18:12

"At 8 months abortion would only be an option to save the life of the mother. Abortion after 24 weeks isn’t a “trust the woman” thing under mainland U.K. law and never has been. After 24 weeks it is extremely limited and has to be authorised by two doctors."

Exactly, I think this is coming from posters who either don't understand the rules in the UK or are trying to scaremonger. Although there is never really a 'trust the woman' moment, abortion at any stage of a pregnancy has to be authorised by two doctors, and after 24 weeks only considered if:

  • the woman's life is in danger
  • there is a severe fetal abnormality
  • the woman is at risk of grave physical and mental injury

So it isn't an Exactly abortion after 24 weeks can be carried out for a myriad of reasons. I don't class down syndrome as a severe fetal abnormality but a woman can abort at any time.

If doctors and the woman decide it is in the best interest they I trust them. It happens infrequently, it is not scaremongering to say that it does. And I support it.

As early as possible As late as necessary.

Walserwasstrange · 26/06/2022 18:12

"At 8 months abortion would only be an option to save the life of the mother. Abortion after 24 weeks isn’t a “trust the woman” thing under mainland U.K. law and never has been. After 24 weeks it is extremely limited and has to be authorised by two doctors."

Exactly, I think this is coming from posters who either don't understand the rules in the UK or are trying to scaremonger. Although there is never really a 'trust the woman' moment, abortion at any stage of a pregnancy has to be authorised by two doctors, and after 24 weeks only considered if:

  • the woman's life is in danger
  • there is a severe fetal abnormality
  • the woman is at risk of grave physical and mental injury
VladmirsPoutine · 26/06/2022 17:59

Yup! A complete bin fire.

mmmmmmghturep · 26/06/2022 17:58

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If_These_Walls_Could_Talk

Blimeyherewegoagain · 26/06/2022 17:56

VladmirsPoutine · 26/06/2022 17:47

It strikes me that you can’t take away with one hand and not give with the other. Women in USA really NEED to have access to cheap, readily available contraception regardless of health insurance status. It’s a no brainer.

It's a no brainer but if it were about babies lives the US would have universal healthcare, hugely subsidised day care / nurseries, mandated maternity leave. It's about power and control; the ins and outs of foetus or baby, bunch of cells vs a human life are largely redundant because again this is not about the wellbeing of women nor their offspring.

It’s all broken isn’t it?
A country should be judged on how it takes care of the most vulnerable in society.

Walserwasstrange · 26/06/2022 17:50

@Impier High as opposed to what? Something can’t just be high it has to be high compared to something else. If you look at data for global abortion rates, England and Wales – which is presumably what you’re referring to – indeed the whole of the UK seems well below average in terms of rates of abortion. It does not figure in tables that list the countries with the highest rates such as Russia nor does it quite make it into the countries with the lowest. In addition, there’s a wealth of evidence that shows that where women can’t get access to legal abortion the abortion rate doesn't go down, all that happens is that abortions are extremely likely to be unsafe procedures and/or women will resort to drastic, life-threatening measures.

Unsafe abortion is a leading cause of maternal mortality worldwide that’s not to mention the women who survive but have serious, long-term health issues – read Annie Ernaux’s book ‘The Happening’ if you need an example which describes her attempts to abort using knitting needles as a teenager in France before abortion was available, or talk to older women who remember what it was like in the days before abortion was legalised in England. Women like my gran who has lifelong medical issues stemming from repeatedly throwing herself down a flight of stairs after finding herself pregnant in an extremely abusive relationship.

VladmirsPoutine · 26/06/2022 17:47

It strikes me that you can’t take away with one hand and not give with the other. Women in USA really NEED to have access to cheap, readily available contraception regardless of health insurance status. It’s a no brainer.

It's a no brainer but if it were about babies lives the US would have universal healthcare, hugely subsidised day care / nurseries, mandated maternity leave. It's about power and control; the ins and outs of foetus or baby, bunch of cells vs a human life are largely redundant because again this is not about the wellbeing of women nor their offspring.

Blimeyherewegoagain · 26/06/2022 17:27

It strikes me that you can’t take away with one hand and not give with the other. Women in USA really NEED to have access to cheap, readily available contraception regardless of health insurance status. It’s a no brainer.

Also at what point is an unborn baby a person? When a woman miscarries and loses a much wanted pregnancy she mourns the death of an unborn baby. When a woman has an abortion a foetus is terminated.
So which is it? In the eyes of the law it can’t be both - foetus or baby? human being or a collection of cells? I guess that when the law starts looking at viability and stage of gestation to decide. Because at some point if an unborn baby is viewed in the eyes of the law as a person, then the argument is that is has rights.
Maternal safety then must be considered also.

Selective abortion based on sex also most certainly does take place. In some countries there is a far higher percentage of male babies born- too high for it to be just nature. There was a discussion thread on this a few years back. What do people think of that? Who is making the choice there? The men? The women? Are we to trust them for that?

Link to the figures here

MrsTerryPratchett · 26/06/2022 16:51

That's to everyone contributing to this conversation. Including those neatly demonstrating my point with their straw men.

It's also worth listening to and telling the stories of the women who went before us. My own family has it's tragic stories. We probably all know a woman who has been forced to give birth, I know I do. Women dying from backstreet abortions is in living memory and is happening right now in places like Nicaragua. It will take a while for the trade to start up again in the US but it will.

Women will die from botched attempts to terminate pregnancies.

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 26/06/2022 15:06

I have a relative who has had 3 abortions and 2 children. She's very fertile and it's only 5 conceptions over 40 years. Is that too many abortions? Too many children? Why? She doesn't regret either the abortions or the children BTW. I've never needed an abortion as I'm not very fertile. So what? I would have had one if I'd needed it.

If people want to reduce abortion rates, there are lots and lots of ways to do that that don't involve making medical care unsafe, mostly to do with making it easy to prevent pregnancy.

Livpool · 26/06/2022 13:51

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/06/2022 21:17

So you’re fine with people deciding to abort because the fetus is female?

So you're fine with forcing women to raise girls in violently misogynistic houses where people wish they didn't exist?

👏🏼 what a thoughtful response to this. I always stumble when someone says this but love this response.

As early as possible, as late as necessary- always