Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
TuppyBarmyFotheringale · 25/06/2022 13:56

I agree. Schools' failure to give gifted children work that will challenge them is a form of neglect, in my opinion.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 13:56

Your reference to 'tables', however, makes me wonder whether you are actually taking about primary schools? Setting is rare in primary schools, for obvious reasons of the way the primary timetable works. The idea of fixed 'ability tables' is widely discredited, because of the ceiling of expectations it can place on some children. However, I would say that the idea of core and extension work, accessible to all and reached by the higher attainers in each specific lesson (whether they be the children who are seen as 'always able', or whether they arte a child who simply excels in that particular aspect of the subject while struggling in others) is also a normal part of every primary teachers' armoury - being asked to 'coach others' is a lazy solution. Not one I have come across in person, I point out, but I have heard of it.

BobbinHood · 25/06/2022 13:55

I went to a comprehensive school but it streamed us for every subject from year 7 onwards which was introduced in the time between my older sister going there and me going there (4 years). We went in at the same sort of standard and similar level of natural intelligence/inclination to work hard, but our experiences were totally different and I did much better as well as enjoying school more. If I have a bright child I’ll definitely be looking for a secondary that streams from the start.

Tiredalwaystired · 25/06/2022 13:55

Your comment is a sweeping generalisation. My daughter is yr 9 in a state comp. Did well in her physics exam. School have organised a special group for to 20% female physics students in the year to cover extra work, being mentored by yr 11 pupils who also excel in physics.

noblegiraffe · 25/06/2022 13:55

Why have you extrapolated from your DC's school to all state schools?

Rotherweird · 25/06/2022 13:54

My child’s school only sets for PE and Science in KS3. They set for Maths and English in Y10 and Y11. That seems very standard in our city - setting has gone dramatically out of fashion (due to the research cited earlier in the thread) but the problem is that only the very best teachers can differentiate adequately in a completely mixed ability Maths class.

eatsleepswimdive · 25/06/2022 13:51

My kids school absolutely pushes all children. The highest achievers come out with nothing less than a 7 and the vast majority will have a clean sweep of 8’s and 9’s. The less able will still get very good grades mainly 6’s and 7’s and only a tiny proportion, say about 15 out of a year of 180 will get less than the 5 good passes. They are set for maths, science and English from year 9

pointythings · 25/06/2022 13:51

Florenz · 25/06/2022 13:42

Schools should stream vigourously, and should not hinder pupils with high potential at the expense of low-achieving disruptive kids. The whole ethos of "inclusivity" has been an absolute disaster, which is why so many people are desperate to privately educate their kids, even if it they get into heavy debt to do it.

Please don't lump low achieving kids in with disruptive kids. That Venn diagram is nowhere near being a perfect circle and it is both offensive and ignorant to phrase your post this way.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 13:50

Do you mean 'stream' [be in a single group for all subjects] or 'set' [placed in the correct group for each individual subject]?

I know of no state secondary schools that don't set pupils in Maths at least from very early on. IME, they then set across a wider range of subjects through KS3 (Maths; English; Sciences; sometimes languages; often PE). Some remain in mixed ability groupings right through to GCSE (often humanities and arts).

Streaming is rare, again IME, because it has such obvious issues - why should a child who excels in Maths but finds English hard be placed in a 'middle' stream as an average?

I would also say that - as a parent of two able children, both state educated throughout - that they have been very obviously extended throughout, and this is well reflected in their final results and destinations. Yes, Further Maths GCSE and the option of a third language to GCSE were after school clubs, not delivered during the school day, but they were most definitely 'there'.

MardyBumm · 25/06/2022 13:49

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:31

It also costs no more to stream children vs mixed ability. It may be less 'inclusive' but would surely improve the outcomes and social mobility of academic children.

But it negatively impacts the lower attaining children. What about their social mobility?

RedWingBoots · 25/06/2022 13:42

Mixed ability grouping has been proven to have a positive impact on lower attainers but no detrimental impact on higher attainers.

I know from my own state education that statement is completely dependent on the teacher of the class. Like with all professions a few teachers are excellent, while most are good and some poor.

Yes the OP DD can learn through coaching others but it shouldn't be because the teacher won't give her additional work that will stretch her.

Florenz · 25/06/2022 13:42

Schools should stream vigourously, and should not hinder pupils with high potential at the expense of low-achieving disruptive kids. The whole ethos of "inclusivity" has been an absolute disaster, which is why so many people are desperate to privately educate their kids, even if it they get into heavy debt to do it.

hunge · 25/06/2022 13:42

The G and T programme was just lip service, to be fair.

Hoppinggreen · 25/06/2022 13:39

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 25/06/2022 13:33

I absolutely disagree with the policy of brighter kids coaching others. This helps those less able but does not help the brighter kids.

I have few friends who are teachers at State Secondaries, some SLT.
They all say that while this practice certainly helps less able children it can be harmful to higher achievers, especially if there are behavioural issues in the class as well.
It was one of the reasons why we chose Private as our State Secondary doesn’t stream.

UndertheCedartree · 25/06/2022 13:38

I prefer mixed ability groups and a little bit of 'coaching' is really good to really embed the work for high achievers. But I agree it shouldn't be all the time and shouldn't replacing teaching from the actual teacher. The teacher should be differentiating across the class. An example is in my DD's maths book there is a 'challenge' section that the high achievers can work on while others are still completing the first section.

MintJulia · 25/06/2022 13:37

Yanbu. That's the whole reason my ds is at an independent school.

Ds had been at the same 'good' state primary school for 7 years. Mid-year 6 his form teacher 'wasn't sure' he would pass his SATS. How could they not know after teaching him for 6 years?
He got 110,112 and 114 and they were so surprised they gave him a prize 😀but I'd lost faith in the state system. They seemed to pay no attention at all to the mid-class kids.
A year at independent school and he got 119,119,119 and is so much happier & more engaged.
I'm a single mum and it's a huge stretch for me but worth it to know he isn't bored..

Rotherweird · 25/06/2022 13:37

I think the coaching is ok up to a point but it can’t be the only way of dealing with bright pupils. I wouldn’t want everything to be streamed, I think one of the brilliant things about state education is having to run along with lots of people who are very different to you. But as the OP said, providing genuinely challenging extension work is a must. My child is always complaining about being given work that takes 5 minutes and then having to sit there bored for 20 minutes doing nothing.

pointythings · 25/06/2022 13:37

Your thread title is misleading - some state schools operate in the way you describe and I agree that it doesn't help the very able. Many absolutely do push their very able pupils. My local state school (very mixed catchment, really not leafy) had multiple GCSE support sessions available, all aimed at taking groups of students to the next level. Nobody was allowed to coast. Maths and the sciences were set, humanities and the arts were not - it worked very well. One of DD1's best friends started Yr 10 expecting to scrape a 3 in maths - she and her peers were stretched, challenged and enabled and she improved to a solid 5, just off a 6. You can't tar all state schools with the same brush.

Sherrystrull · 25/06/2022 13:35

*cost more

Sherrystrull · 25/06/2022 13:34

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:31

It also costs no more to stream children vs mixed ability. It may be less 'inclusive' but would surely improve the outcomes and social mobility of academic children.

It does cost most to stream children.

If you have mixed ability classes then the teacher is able to support the group of children who cannot access the curriculum. If you stream then you have a full class of children who cannot access the curriculum. Therefore you need lots of support staff in that classroom.

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 25/06/2022 13:33

I absolutely disagree with the policy of brighter kids coaching others. This helps those less able but does not help the brighter kids.

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:31

It also costs no more to stream children vs mixed ability. It may be less 'inclusive' but would surely improve the outcomes and social mobility of academic children.

OP posts:
7Worfs · 25/06/2022 13:29

I was a high ability student and never got any stretch assignments - I spent 12 years of education doing no studying, got good grades and went to uni without the habit and ability to work hard and apply myself.

It is so easy for able children to become lazy if not challenged, and it persists through life, turning them into underachievers.

Rotherweird · 25/06/2022 13:28

The problem for a bright child is that they can easily get bored and frustrated and switch off. My child (ordinarily bright, not a genius) get very frustrated and angry.

I 100% agree that the priority should be supporting disadvantaged children - but it’s a shame that children with academic talent are not supported in the way they would be if they had a talent for e.g. football

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:28

@MissDollyMix that sounds excellent. I can't afford private school education, but with streaming then academically strong pupils in state schools can perform as well as their private school peers. With 180 pupils per year it's perfectly feasible to have different sets for academic subjects and high expectations.

OP posts: