Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 14:37

But streamed tables is TERRIBLE practice. It's really obvious why.

Scenario A: The teacher has prepared basic, core and extension work. They have already decided, before the lesson is taught, that a fixed number of children, who sit at a particular table of a fixed size, will get the basic work, and that a similarly fixed number get the extension work. Similarly, a fixed number of children get the support of an adult sat at the tale they always sit at, and a fixed number get to access the practical resources that can help to support them with today's work.

Scenario B: The teacher has, similarly, prepared basic, core and extension work. They teach the core work to the whole class. As children are noted to find it difficult, an adult move to them, or they move to an adult, who can provide them with extra support. Similarly, a few children choose to use the practical materials that are on everyone's tables. The teacher swiftly evaluates who, if anyone, needs the basic work, and provides that if needed, as an entry point that then moves on to the core work. The rest of the class start the core work, with those who grasp the concept quickly - as identified during the teaching phase as well as during independent work - access the extension. All or most of the class may end up completing the extension work, or a few. Many, a few or no children may need the basic work.

It is the pre-determination of fixed ability tables that is poor, not the ability for children who need it to access work at the level they need it.

CalistoNoSolo · 25/06/2022 14:36

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 14:25

The local comp just wouldn't have helped her achieve her full potential.

What a shame that is the case at your particular local school - though I would question whether, in the presence of a grammar school, a school can be comprehensive, as it is by definition missing some of the cohort's higher attainers?

Confusingly, 'other' schools in grammar areas ARE colloquially referred to as comprehensives, while be definition being anything but comprehensive in their intake.

DD's mixed cohort at our local comprehensive did very well in STEM - 3-4 As / A*s was not uncommon. It's not a sector wider issue (and worth noting, btw, that the OP was so worded as to imply that grammar schools, as state schools, also didn't cater well to able pupils and only private schools could do so.....).

The local comp is in our home town, the grammar is a 40min bus journey so no, it's not affected by the few local students who go to this grammar (though there are three others in the wider area).

The comp isn't a bad school, but bright girls interested in stem don't do well in mainstream mixed which was one reason. They have a reputation for bullying which was another. I've never regretted the decision and DD has a lovely friendship group. I just wish the entire education system was revamped and funded properly from the bottom up.

Itsrainingatlast · 25/06/2022 14:34

There’s a real lack of understanding about what mixed ability means and the pedagogy behind it from some posters.
It’s perfectly possible to give 30 students the same task and then ensure every student is challenged. For example, if you were teaching a Y7 history class about the Battle of Hastings, your task might be to ‘Explain why Harold lost’. A lower ability child might need starter sentences to say that he lost because he was hit in the eye with an arrow. Whereas at the other end, a more able student would be able to independently write 500+ words, discussing a range of factors (just fought off HH in the North, tactical errors on Senlac Hill etc) and might even question why we think he got an arrow in the eye, and did this actually ever happen, how credible is the Bayeux Tapestry as a source! Really bright children are able to work out how to extend the task and challenge themselves so aren’t sitting there with nothing to do, claiming to have finished. Same in maths; a really bright child will be able to demonstrate multiple ways to find a solution.
We also have a system where Ofsted/league tables etc mean that there is a lot of ‘teaching to the test’. The pressure to get students through exams is enormous and means teachers focus on exam content, rather than going off at a tangent, if there is no potential to increase the child’s grade.
Finally, state schools are grossly underfunded, and teachers are leaving the profession in droves. Interestingly though, with many private schools leaving the TPS, they’re finding recruitment just as hard as state schools

Florenz · 25/06/2022 14:29

"But it negatively impacts the lower attaining children. What about their social mobility?"
They aren't going to have any social mobility, streaming or otherwise.

"Streaming is a really bad idea for children that are good in some subjects and not so good in others - they are bound to be in the "wrong" stream at least some of the time."
Every subject should be streamed. Some kids will be in the top stream for Maths, and a lower stream for English, for instance, some in the top streams for everything, some in the lower streams for everything.

maddening · 25/06/2022 14:28

@cantkeepawayforever

"Are you really saying that every primary school in the country fails children because they (necessarily) teach mixed ability classes??"

Actually the op said that they were already successfully teaching a mixed ability class with streamed tables which allowed the teacher to stretch the more able dc and assist those that needed it, however the slt felt that this was not inclusive and now they mic up the tables and the brighter dc are no longer stretched and are now expected to help teach the less able dc.

noblegiraffe · 25/06/2022 14:27

When I was a student teacher I was shocked by the attitudes towards the brightest students. They were safely going to “do well” ie at least 5 A-C grades so the focus was on the less able.

Then this would be obvious in their Progress 8 and would be slated by Ofsted.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 14:25

The local comp just wouldn't have helped her achieve her full potential.

What a shame that is the case at your particular local school - though I would question whether, in the presence of a grammar school, a school can be comprehensive, as it is by definition missing some of the cohort's higher attainers?

Confusingly, 'other' schools in grammar areas ARE colloquially referred to as comprehensives, while be definition being anything but comprehensive in their intake.

DD's mixed cohort at our local comprehensive did very well in STEM - 3-4 As / A*s was not uncommon. It's not a sector wider issue (and worth noting, btw, that the OP was so worded as to imply that grammar schools, as state schools, also didn't cater well to able pupils and only private schools could do so.....).

RedHelenB · 25/06/2022 14:25

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:28

@MissDollyMix that sounds excellent. I can't afford private school education, but with streaming then academically strong pupils in state schools can perform as well as their private school peers. With 180 pupils per year it's perfectly feasible to have different sets for academic subjects and high expectations.

My dds achieved top marks without streaming or doing extra work. You're panicking unnecessarily, bright children do well in state schools. And when they get to uni they tend to do better than private school pupils cos they're less hothoused and spoon fed.

maddening · 25/06/2022 14:21

A - "Mixed ability grouping has been proven to have a positive impact on lower attainers but no detrimental impact on higher attainers." - based on what? And how have they determined "no detrimental effect " as that could be just mean "meets expectations " it may not measure lost opportunity to excel and strive beyond meeting expectations.

B - agree.with pp re harm where there are behavioural issues. In a Jordan Peterson interview recently he noted that where "Well behaved" children are placed with disruptive children they themselves become disruptive rather than the disruptive child being positively impacted.

CalistoNoSolo · 25/06/2022 14:16

user58486267489 · 25/06/2022 14:11

When I was a student teacher I was shocked by the attitudes towards the brightest students. They were safely going to “do well” ie at least 5 A-C grades so the focus was on the less able.

Coming from an independent school and oxbridge I couldn’t get my head round the lack of support to get students from 5 A-C grades at GCSE to 9 or 10 A grades (absolutely possible).

The teachers thought the grades they would get would be “enough” to get to sixth form and university. They lacked the ambition to help these kids raise their grades so they could go to almost ANY university and study anything.

I found it so utterly depressing.

That attitude is the reason DD is at an all girls grammar and on track to get excellent A level results in stem. The local comp just wouldn't have helped her achieve her full potential.

PreschoolMum4 · 25/06/2022 14:14

Depends on the state school. One of my daughters is generally working above her targets and they do take a small group of those children for more challenging work with the headteacher once a week. On the other end of the spectrum they support those struggling with extra activities but I’m grateful that they go to a state school in a good area so think that makes a difference I know they are not all the same!

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 14:13

user58486267489 · 25/06/2022 14:11

When I was a student teacher I was shocked by the attitudes towards the brightest students. They were safely going to “do well” ie at least 5 A-C grades so the focus was on the less able.

Coming from an independent school and oxbridge I couldn’t get my head round the lack of support to get students from 5 A-C grades at GCSE to 9 or 10 A grades (absolutely possible).

The teachers thought the grades they would get would be “enough” to get to sixth form and university. They lacked the ambition to help these kids raise their grades so they could go to almost ANY university and study anything.

I found it so utterly depressing.

I imagine it is entirely possible that some individual schools may have a culture like this (unusual, but possible).

To state, as the OP does, that this is a sector-wide situation that includes every single state school everywhere in the country is extrapolating a long way from a single data point......

ldontWanna · 25/06/2022 14:12

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 25/06/2022 13:33

I absolutely disagree with the policy of brighter kids coaching others. This helps those less able but does not help the brighter kids.

It depends how it's done. For example a very bright child might be perfectly able to do something, but struggle to explain in any meaningful way or actually understand what they are doing so they can then apply it to something else.That means they can't often answer reasoning/why questions which are just as important as the ability to do long division in your head. Explaining the workings of a problem 1 2 1 with a peer, in a way they can understand it deepens their own understanding of the method and it helps "stick".

Now if you have one kid supporting a whole table just doing the questions for them or giving them the answers, that's pointless for everyone.

user58486267489 · 25/06/2022 14:11

When I was a student teacher I was shocked by the attitudes towards the brightest students. They were safely going to “do well” ie at least 5 A-C grades so the focus was on the less able.

Coming from an independent school and oxbridge I couldn’t get my head round the lack of support to get students from 5 A-C grades at GCSE to 9 or 10 A grades (absolutely possible).

The teachers thought the grades they would get would be “enough” to get to sixth form and university. They lacked the ambition to help these kids raise their grades so they could go to almost ANY university and study anything.

I found it so utterly depressing.

Jewel1968 · 25/06/2022 14:10

My DD went to a primary with a very challenging demographic. Definitely didn't get pushed academically. Went on to a fairly pushy academic state secondary. In first few months she saw a big difference between herself and peers. Didn't take long to catch up. Pushed herself. They were heavily tutored at home and her response was to work harder. No pushing from me. She got mostly 9s in GCSE and all from her own self pushing.

To my mind I would prefer state schools focused more energy of the students who struggle.

daffodilandtulip · 25/06/2022 14:09

DD has just left school. She is the most able in her class and is likely to get mostly 8/9 in her exams. She used to finish classwork within ten minutes, get full marks and then get told off for sitting doing nothing Hmm
She's also never won a single award, certificate or even a single one of those merit point thingys in her entire school life - because she doesn't try 🤷‍♀️
I know it's tough for teachers to differentiate for everyone but is a little bit of encouragement too much to ask?

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/06/2022 14:06

With limited resources, the goal has to be to support the majority of the children to reach the minimum standard. Unless you think the less able children should be left to sink

It's not either/or. All children should have their needs equally prioritised.

all children matter equally.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 14:05

Are you really saying that every primary school in the country fails children because they (necessarily) teach mixed ability classes??

Or are you saying that in some classes, some of the time, a few children may not have their precise needs met in a few lessons? (IE that not every teacher and school can offer a perfect experience for every child all of the time, which is an obvious truth?)

redskyatnight · 25/06/2022 14:04

Streaming is a really bad idea for children that are good in some subjects and not so good in others - they are bound to be in the "wrong" stream at least some of the time.

My academic DD has spent her secondary years in a school that doesn't set (which might be what OP means) at all except for maths and is on target for good grades in all subjects. What this did require was excellent teachers, and she's been fortunate that many of her teachers were. The ideal would be that every child would be given work to their ability level with the ability to stretch themselves if appropriate.

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/06/2022 14:03

At my school, this isn’t enough for a significant minority so we also press on with the year aboves work

God I wish you taught my son. He is in reception and can easily do his cousin's y2 maths.

His teacher harps on about mastery but there's only so many ways you can approach number bonds to 20 and he knew was so secure on them all before starting school :(

CalistoNoSolo · 25/06/2022 14:01

Florenz · 25/06/2022 13:42

Schools should stream vigourously, and should not hinder pupils with high potential at the expense of low-achieving disruptive kids. The whole ethos of "inclusivity" has been an absolute disaster, which is why so many people are desperate to privately educate their kids, even if it they get into heavy debt to do it.

Completely agree. Mixed ability classes just mean they either all learn at the speed of the slowest, or that the slowest get left behind. And bright kids coaching less bright kids sounds like bs to me and I would be very unhappy if that had happened in DD's school.

noblegiraffe · 25/06/2022 14:00

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

When you look at the current GCSEs, you'll see that this is balls and actually it is the lower achieving students who are poorly served by the current school system.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 13:59

(I would also point out that I work in a town where all but one of the private schools are routinely outperformed by the local comprehensive. Private does NOT = better)

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/06/2022 13:57

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

Yanbu. It's because the government want to "close the gap" and basically the only way this will ever happen is if the most able are held back.

Actually mixed ability grouping has been shown to result in better outcomes for lower and middle ability pupils, but poorer outcomes for upper ability. Theres a conscious decision to relegate the needs of those children to give more attention to the less able.

My DH is miles ahead on maths. School don't give him any suitable work. All it means is we are struggling to resist the temptation of private school. It's not what we want and we are trying desperately to avoid it, but we can easily afford it and he gets nothing from his state school. 80% of the teacher's time & attention goes on the bottom third of the class.

In the state sector bright children are just ignored. It's actually worse than when I was a child; when i was a child the bright kids were taken out with the TA to do extension work as often as the struggling kids went out for intervention/support.

Rotherweird · 25/06/2022 13:56

@eatsleepswimdive That sounds brilliant. You are extremely fortunate to have access to a school like that. No schools in my city would fit that description. I think it’s hard for parents wuth kids in excellent state schools to understand how low expectations are elsewhere in the sector.