Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
Minimalme · 25/06/2022 16:29

That should say ds. I worry far more about my other ds who struggles academically and is very well behaved and quiet in class.

He needs all the help he can get.

I find it hard to be concerned about an academically able child who finds the work easy but is lazy.

Minimalme · 25/06/2022 16:25

My academically able does fine in the state sector.

He finds the work easy at school but does extra at the weekends by himself because he enjoys it.

I'm sure your dd is fine. You really shouldn't worry.

Thunderpunt · 25/06/2022 16:22

Thanks @LizzieVereker and @cantkeepawayforever for the streaming/setting explanation

Namenic · 25/06/2022 15:59

@cantkeepawayforever - have you seen the diamond model put into practice? It sounds interesting.

I suppose as long as the kid has some book to look through if they get their work done, it should be ok? It must be v hard teaching a large class of kids - and especially at primary I guess it can be hard to extend sideways (eg as PP mentioned, with number bonds or times tables - depending on how quickly the kids pick them up).

CinnamonJellyBeans · 25/06/2022 15:41

Shocking! Ask for a refund.

Or you could spend an hour or two with her yourself at home, or buy her a book, or talk to her about maths. Just what are you expecting from one teacher and 30 little kids? I wouldn't dream of asking for the teacher to pull something out of her arse every time my child finishes first. They can read a book, or practise some French tenses they are struggling with from their French book. If your child is that smart, she'll find something challenging to do or improve on in a classroom full of books.

It's a free service and compared to the other free services we get, like policing, social care and healthcare, it's consistently delivered opportunity and results for decades, even through covid.

CulturePigeon · 25/06/2022 15:38

Porcupineintherough I agree.

It's not just that inclusive teaching might frustrate bright children in terms of making them bored and de-motivating them. Working at a slower rate is one thing, but if the less able children are disruptive, that would be a serious hindrance to learning.

Sure - if the research says that one child explaining to another can be useful in terms of learning, then fine - do it as an occasional exercise - but not all the time, surely? It sounds like a recipe for disaster, frustration and boredom all round. Isn't that what pupil-teachers did in Victorian Board Schools?

I remember when my top set English group's teacher was absent and we were combined with the bottom set. Oh my goodness - nothing got done that lesson and most of us sat open-mouthed at the wasted time and messing about which took place. Combining children of vastly different abilities at secondary school seems to be a policy driven by ideology and not pragmatism - or indeed, trying to do the best thing for all the students. At least 2 totally different teaching styles were needed for the 2 groups and no-one learned any English that day!!!

Ideology seems to be a massive hindrance to progress in some ways.

tobee · 25/06/2022 15:21

I still don't think that there's enough provision for those that struggle. And those that are in the middle. I'd like to hear people speaking up about that.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 15:19

I would also set for the smallest possible number of subjects - Maths and PE are possible contenders, possibly Science and languages in upper KS3.

Veol · 25/06/2022 15:18

I stopped doing mixed ability groups years ago because it seemed to result in the higher ability children telling the lower ability children what to write down. It resulted in better work in the books of the lower ability children but in reality very little learning went on and it was also demoralising for them. It was a waste of time for the higher ability ones.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 15:17

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/06/2022 15:09

I didn’t say it would be obvious. I meant that I’d be happy to trust a teachers judgment.

I’m coming at this from the perspective of what I think is best educationally for children, not what I expect schools and teachers to be able to achieve right now.

The thing is, I don't think it's possible to say that a particular system is better for 'all children' - one particular child could benefit educationally from mixed ability teaching, while another might benefit from setting, but a school has to have one or the other.

IMO the least worst option is a diamond model - a top set for exceptionally high attainers, a small set with very high staffing levels for those who have significant additional needs in that subject, and a large number of completely parallel middle sets, whose coverage of the curriculum is kept in step with the highest set for as long as possible to allow movement between them (ie that the highest set is extended through depth and further exploration, not acceleration through future year group material).

LizzieVereker · 25/06/2022 15:16

@Thunderpunt streaming is when children are put into broad groups for ability, usually for all subjects, so for example you might have three broad “streams” in a year group, and the children stay in their stream for all their lessons. Setting is when you are put into a group for one subject according to ability - so you might be in top set for maths but set 3 for English.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 15:12

Thunderpunt · 25/06/2022 15:06

@cantkeepawayforever is there a difference between setting and streaming (asking honestly, not in a sarcastic way!) I've heard both used and assumed they meant the same thing.

'Streaming' = a year group divided, full time and for all subjects, into different ability groups. So a child will be in 'the top stream' or 'the lower stream' for every lesson. It's relatively rare now, though I have known it in e.g. Kent, where some of the non-grammar secondary moderns have a 'top stream' that is meant to be more 'grammar like'.

'Setting' = ability grouping for each individual subject, so a child could be top set Maths and lower set English and middle set PE. This is much more common, particularly in Maths in secondary.

That is how the terms would be used 'in educational discussions', in general, though I can quite see that in 'general conversation' use they could have become less distinct.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/06/2022 15:09

I didn’t say it would be obvious. I meant that I’d be happy to trust a teachers judgment.

I’m coming at this from the perspective of what I think is best educationally for children, not what I expect schools and teachers to be able to achieve right now.

DomPerignon12 · 25/06/2022 15:06

noblegiraffe · 25/06/2022 14:00

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

When you look at the current GCSEs, you'll see that this is balls and actually it is the lower achieving students who are poorly served by the current school system.

It depends on how you define being well served though, doesn’t it?
A bright child who could have gotten A*s gets B’s. They’re still ‘ok’, but not pushed to their full potential.
A child that could have failed gets D’s with ‘some’ extra support. However said child could have achieved B’s and C’s with more tailored tutoring.

There’s also the disengagement etc of bright students.

At the end of the day a factory systems which shoves kids into too big classes, not enough space for individual support is always going to fail pupils. For me failure = not achieving full potential. Not just exam grades, but passion for learning.

Thunderpunt · 25/06/2022 15:06

@cantkeepawayforever is there a difference between setting and streaming (asking honestly, not in a sarcastic way!) I've heard both used and assumed they meant the same thing.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/06/2022 15:05

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 15:00

setting for individual subjects is a must to enable all children to achieve their potential IMO.

All subjects? Is the evidence there for ALL subjects? Art? DT?

It doesn’t say all subjects, it says individual subjects. I can’t see schools ever having the resources to be able to set for subjects like art or DT, but in an ideal world, it would be wonderful if they could offer enrichment clubs for children who are talented in all the subjects.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 15:05

A good teacher will know whether a child on the border should be moved up or down according to that individual.

'Well, Child A is good at x and y aspect of the subject, near peer B at a and b. there are only 32 spaces in top set, I have to choose between them (and the 5 others in the same position)"

I think it is simplistic to say it is obvious to a teacher where a child would do best, particularly if the two children have been in different sets, taught by different teachers, and the decision is about where they should be the following year with 2 yet further members of staff..

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/06/2022 15:01

@cantkeepawayforever isn't that where teacher’s knowledge, experience and judgment should be used? A good teacher will know whether a child on the border should be moved up or down according to that individual.

It’s not something that I think is essential from primary right the way through, but children do benefit from it IME from Y7/8.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 15:00

setting for individual subjects is a must to enable all children to achieve their potential IMO.

All subjects? Is the evidence there for ALL subjects? Art? DT?

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/06/2022 14:55

Really bright children are able to work out how to extend the task and challenge themselves so aren’t sitting there with nothing to do, claiming to have finished. Same in maths; a really bright child will be able to demonstrate multiple ways to find a solution.

This is all true, but what about the child that isn’t really bright, just normal bright with normal things going on in life that create barriers to learning? Or the child that is really bright but has a poor grasp of how to extend and challenge themselves because they have never been supported at home? Wouldn’t that child gain more in a class where the teacher input time could be spent less explaining the story and more initiating the debate about whether or not the Bayeux Tapestry was a credible source because the class had already grasped everything else?

Tbf, history probably isn’t the best example of where streaming is needed.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 14:48

Clocks

Setting works OK, in general, for those who sit in the middle of a set's ability range. They don't work well for those in the grey areas at the top and bottom of each set - should someone who get 1 mark less in a one-off exam be at the top of Set 2 while their near-peer be at the bottom of Set 1? The first child might really miss out on the challenge and peer explanations they would get in Set 1. The second might be intimidated by the pace of Set 1 and feel 'stupid' by comparison.

On an anecdotal level, I am aware of a school that set in KS2 for maths. Their SATS results for Maths - both at Greater depth and Expected - increased extraordinarily when they moved to mixed ability teaching. I enquired as to why, and was told that the greatest improvements were from those who would have been in the top third of the set below - which was expected - but also those who would have been in the bottom 25% or so of the set above, which wasn't expected.

bigfootisreal · 25/06/2022 14:42

Work is progressive, the old model prevented those working below standard to ever moving up as their work was only ever given at a lower standard meaning that was all they could ever achieve. Now work is progressive so they all get the same work and it gradually gets harder. Differentiation prevents others from ever achieving. Making work progressive so those who are able will rapidly move through the easier work onto the challenging work allows all to achieve. In the same way that children who are working above expectations might really struggle in one area such as position or time and then they will just flounder if given the harder stuff without having access to the basics first.

Pieceofpurplesky · 25/06/2022 14:42

What year is your DC in OP? Where I teach Year 7 are mixed ability and then they are setted from Year 8 onwards. We do this as primary data can sometimes be misleading (not all but there is a variation between schools). By keeping mixed ability it means the kids can be put in the correct sets using a variety of data.

I think the school you talk about is in the minority as many schools really push for high achievers

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/06/2022 14:40

I’m not sure I agree with full streaming where children are considered to either be high, middle or lower ability across all subjects, but setting for individual subjects is a must to enable all children to achieve their potential IMO.

The state secondary my children went to had 4 sets for English, 6 for maths and 2 for sciences and languages. The one that excelled in maths but needed extra support in English undoubtedly benefited from being in a set that was right for them.

Unless we believe that children have a responsibility to be a tool to aid other children’s learning, I don’t see how anyone can argue with setting.

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 14:38

Every subject should be streamed. Some kids will be in the top stream for Maths, and a lower stream for English, for instance, some in the top streams for everything, some in the lower streams for everything

That's called 'setting'. Your use of the word 'streaming' instead is misleading.