Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
Meem321 · 25/06/2022 23:27

7Worfs · 25/06/2022 22:16

@Meem321 No one is saying to leave behind less academically inclined children. In fact it makes sense to rethink approach to them also, e.g. identify aptitudes and channel them into more practical education - not everyone needs to be a surgeon or a scientist, the world also needs plumbers, electricians, mechanics etc - trades that earn very well.

@Namenic thank you, I’ve done ok, but I’m still skating by at nearly 40 🤫 I’m physically unable to complete boring work I’m not personally interested in, and that holds me back.

Well actually, by the OP's own admission, their proposal would be 'less inclusive' so...

As an experienced teacher, I can assure you that, despite many parents thinking that they know best (especially after all the 'home education that' happened' during lockdown 😂), we do, in fact have the students' best interests at heart and do our very best to give every child a positive, challenging education with rapidly diminishing funding and ever increasing criticism from all angles.

As a parent of two children who have gone through a streamed state school education, I have no regrets about not privately educating them. I also trusted their teachers and leaders to do their best by them. But that's probably because I'm a reasonable person without delusions of grandeur.

And yes, I teach in state ed. The classes are streamed in the core subjects only. I have taught both core and non core subjects and therefore both steamed and mixed ability. All of my students have succeeded in achieving qualifications reflective of their ability and some have worked hard enough and engaged with extra tuition (provided unpaid in my own time) that they have exceeded.

I suspect that OP is one of 'those' parents who would find something else to complain about if her DC's classes were streamed. OP would probably be the one who complains about the lack of/ quantity/ quality/ frequency of/ subject matter of homework.

7Worfs · 25/06/2022 22:16

@Meem321 No one is saying to leave behind less academically inclined children. In fact it makes sense to rethink approach to them also, e.g. identify aptitudes and channel them into more practical education - not everyone needs to be a surgeon or a scientist, the world also needs plumbers, electricians, mechanics etc - trades that earn very well.

@Namenic thank you, I’ve done ok, but I’m still skating by at nearly 40 🤫 I’m physically unable to complete boring work I’m not personally interested in, and that holds me back.

Namenic · 25/06/2022 20:34

@7Worfs - learning to work hard is not over after school/uni. There is plenty of scope in a job. I have known people who have messed up (variety of reasons including not doing enough work) at some stage of their education/career. They have recovered, learnt and gone on to do pretty well. Keep on going!

@Bobbybobbins - really interesting for what works well. I do think the bottom set should have smaller classes and experienced teachers plus TAs.

Sherrystrull · 25/06/2022 19:50

I agree @Meem321

They seem to expect a private school
experience in a state school.

Meem321 · 25/06/2022 19:18

noblegiraffe · 25/06/2022 13:55

Why have you extrapolated from your DC's school to all state schools?

Because the OP appears to be both a snob, whilst at the same time not 'socially mobile' enough to privately educate DC.

Ignorance and snobery.

Meem321 · 25/06/2022 19:13

*god

Meem321 · 25/06/2022 19:13

And his forbid you may ever have a child or grandchild who is less academically able because you've just admitted that your proposed model will simply improve social mobility for the more academic children.

Let them eat cake, eh?

Meem321 · 25/06/2022 19:10

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:31

It also costs no more to stream children vs mixed ability. It may be less 'inclusive' but would surely improve the outcomes and social mobility of academic children.

Why don't you just write down all your grumbles and solutions and take them to the school directly? I'm sure they would be delighted to have your input.

fUNNYfACE36 · 25/06/2022 18:56

RedHelenB · 25/06/2022 17:37

Maybe the grammar schools could use SATS content, just a thought

I think the thinkiing is that grammar schols should select by academic potential rather than attainment, so as not to disadvantage those that have been less well taught

fUNNYfACE36 · 25/06/2022 18:52

My DC are all at been at a state school, a grammar school. Great results but extremely high workload and pressure.. I would say be careful what you wish for!

TeenPlusCat · 25/06/2022 18:40

The majority of the country doesn't have grammar schools. The easiest way to stop the 11+ issues is to go fully comp, and then set appropriately.

bigfootisreal · 25/06/2022 18:34

DustyTulips · 25/06/2022 18:25

The problem with using SATs style is that the most able kids hit the ceiling of the test and you can’t differentiate. At dd’s super selective the kids who took SATs all have scores of 120 / 119 across the board. And if you use SATs content but presented in unusual ways, then those DC who have had some tutoring / exam prep will do better than those who haven’t seen those types of problems before.

SATs style questions should be the norm. That is where the critical thinking comes in and shows real understanding and there are lots of ways to prevent a child hitting a ceiling. There are 4 levels of SATs style questions and a set % are the higher level ones. It is very easy to challenge children with questions.

DustyTulips · 25/06/2022 18:25

RedHelenB · 25/06/2022 17:37

Maybe the grammar schools could use SATS content, just a thought

The problem with using SATs style is that the most able kids hit the ceiling of the test and you can’t differentiate. At dd’s super selective the kids who took SATs all have scores of 120 / 119 across the board. And if you use SATs content but presented in unusual ways, then those DC who have had some tutoring / exam prep will do better than those who haven’t seen those types of problems before.

ldontWanna · 25/06/2022 18:14

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 25/06/2022 18:04

It’s hard, though, as the best interest of the class as a whole is not the same as the best interest of some individual pupils.

Yes, higher abilities students will benefit from explaining concept to their peers, or consolidating learning but not as much as they would benefit from being set more challenging work or learning new concepts.
But at the same time, mixed groups do benefit lower abilities students so I can understand why it is done like this, especially with 30 kids for 1 teacher + 1 TA if you are lucky 🤷🏻‍♀️

At my school we always have extra questions,that expand on the subject(reverse,reasoning,word problems etc) and if those are all done, there are challenge cards in a box for the kids to help themselves.

What I have noticed is that a lot of the high ability kids start wasting time and doing less , to avoid doing anything "extra".Grin

Franca123 · 25/06/2022 18:13

Jeez I'd be annoyed if my kids were coaching other kids. I would absolutely expect them to be able to crack on with the higher level work as I was in primary school. I would certainly pull them out and go private. Definitely something I'll be asking about when we visit schools in the coming months.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 25/06/2022 18:04

It’s hard, though, as the best interest of the class as a whole is not the same as the best interest of some individual pupils.

Yes, higher abilities students will benefit from explaining concept to their peers, or consolidating learning but not as much as they would benefit from being set more challenging work or learning new concepts.
But at the same time, mixed groups do benefit lower abilities students so I can understand why it is done like this, especially with 30 kids for 1 teacher + 1 TA if you are lucky 🤷🏻‍♀️

Ylvamoon · 25/06/2022 18:03

From my perspective, state schools absolutely cater for the bright kids.
The schools in our area have sets, the focus seems to be on the top 2 with good teaching and acess to better facilities (online homework / learning programmes regular library access to name a few.)
The bottom set is known as the dump (as per my DC), teaching is minimal and pupils are very disruptive. Difficult to get out of the bottom set as it's just not productive. Homework is often given on an A5 sheet of paper and does not look challenging... (I have had DC at both ends. And it was my hard work & paid tutors that helped DC move up.)
On top of this, the school seems to be pushing 6th form and university at every opportunity.

Very disheartening if DC isn't academic.

Bunnycat101 · 25/06/2022 17:57

Our local comp doesn’t set for anything other than maths from y9. There is no way my children will go there if I can afford private. My own experience showed me that mixed ability classes can be a bit of a disaster zone and it’s not something I want for my own children.

RedHelenB · 25/06/2022 17:37

Towcester · 25/06/2022 16:31

We live in a grammar school area. Our primary appears to do nothing to help kids who may want to attend grammar. From what i can gather, unless you have a tutor or do it yourself your child would never encounter 11plus non verbal reasoning questions until they were in the exam. They are only interested in sats. I find it strange.

Maybe the grammar schools could use SATS content, just a thought

cantkeepawayforever · 25/06/2022 16:57

Towcester · 25/06/2022 16:31

We live in a grammar school area. Our primary appears to do nothing to help kids who may want to attend grammar. From what i can gather, unless you have a tutor or do it yourself your child would never encounter 11plus non verbal reasoning questions until they were in the exam. They are only interested in sats. I find it strange.

In my county, state schools are legally prevented from doing any 11+ preparation. They teach the national curriculum, which is not what the 11+ tests.

MrsHamlet · 25/06/2022 16:50

We tried single sex top sets in English once. The boys made rapid progress in comparison to the mixed groups. It didn't close the gap though, because the girls also steamed ahead.

StaunchMomma · 25/06/2022 16:49

100% agree. Bright kids have special educational needs that are routinely ignored.

I always eye roll when I hear some guff about 'helping all children to achieve their potential' because it's simply not true.

If I had the money for prep I'd move my DS out of mainstream in a heartbeat.

Bobbybobbins · 25/06/2022 16:47

In my state comp we have tried every single formation if groups over the years in my subject (English): single sex, completely streamed, completely mixed ability, top set then rest mixed, support group then rest mixed.

In order this has worked best/worst for us in terms of results:

  1. Support group then rest mixed - v low ability kids in a v small group with suitable curriculum and support. Rest mixed allows middle ability kids to be inspired and aim high but can still teach complex concepts as least able kids not in group. Results v good at all ability levels.
  1. Completely mixed ability - as above with inspiration but results lower at top and bottom.
  1. Top set then rest mixed - good results at top and bottom but worse for middle ability kids - interesting.
  1. Completely streamed - good results at top but rest not good.
  1. Single sex. Disaster apart from most able girls.
7Worfs · 25/06/2022 16:33

I find it hard to be concerned about an academically able child who finds the work easy but is lazy.

That’s because you haven’t seen many able children go to uni/workforce and are unable to build even a modest career, because they’ve become accustomed to skating by.

Towcester · 25/06/2022 16:31

We live in a grammar school area. Our primary appears to do nothing to help kids who may want to attend grammar. From what i can gather, unless you have a tutor or do it yourself your child would never encounter 11plus non verbal reasoning questions until they were in the exam. They are only interested in sats. I find it strange.