Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
thing47 · 26/06/2022 12:27

ldontWanna · 26/06/2022 09:34

That might have a lot more to do with number of pupils in class and a smaller gap in ability.

The old trope about class sizes is largely a myth, though, certainly at primary school and for the most part up to A level. Or rather, it is a much less important factor than is typically supposed – the quality of teaching is significantly more important.

It is better to be in a class of 30 with a great teacher than in a class of 15 with an OK teacher, for example.

There is plenty of pedagogic research to back this up.

7Worfs · 26/06/2022 09:53

Thanks @Namenic will look those resources up

dottiedodah · 26/06/2022 09:52

Miss Dolly mix ,Yes state schools can be very good.My DS missed the GS by a few points ,but excelled at his state School ,He is now working in industry with an MSC!

MrsHamlet · 26/06/2022 09:49

Progress 8 means that the focus on the progress of ALL students, not the "magic 5".
If Bob doesn't get his 2, the same questions will be asked as if Delphine doesn't get her 9.

Clarinet1 · 26/06/2022 09:41

It’s a long time ago (70’s) but my experience in some ways wasn’t great. I changed schools twice between 11 and 16 and the approach to setting me for maths (which I found difficult) at the new school was just to ask which book I had been on at the previous school and send me to a particular set. This took no account of the fact that I was one of the few people in that group who was actually prepared to concentrate and work steadily rather than talking, walking round the room.....(you get the picture). Also, homework was always to get to the end of exercise (whatever) which I had already done in class. I got a CSE grade one but with a little attention and stretching in a more focussed group surely I could have got an actual O level.
In today’s terms, I’m afraid the focus on the middle ability range
must have lot to do with the attention given to “value added” and overall achievement in the school - it’s easier to make sure the lower-middle ability pupils come up to “decent” and get the “magic 5” GCSE A-C than it is to make the top groups get all A. (Sorry some of my terminology may be out of date but the general idea still stands).

MrsHamlet · 26/06/2022 09:35

Namenic · 26/06/2022 09:03

@MrsHamlet - is it more acceptable for everyone to attempt the lowest level, then move onto the harder questions if there is time? Or are there just easy questions present? It really depends on how big the range of ability is - and I expect the range will grow as kids get older.

In my y10 class this year I have students with targets of 7 and students with targets of 2.
I am expected to teach to the top end and support those at lower end to get somewhere close there. My subject has untiered exams.
It's all about the scaffolding. I don't make differentiated worksheets. I teach the scaffold.

ldontWanna · 26/06/2022 09:34

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 26/06/2022 09:07

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children.

I this is obvious. Parents are paying a lot of money! OP

That might have a lot more to do with number of pupils in class and a smaller gap in ability.

FlatWhiteLover · 26/06/2022 09:33

I do agree with others that if academically gifted children are not pushed it can cost them later in the university years when they actually have to knuckle down and do the hard yards. Some of my highly intelligent friends who coasted all throughout secondary ended up failing University because of lack of work effort. I am dyslexic so really had to work my arse off throughout secondary to achieve decent grades, which then transferred to University and I graduated with a masters.

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 26/06/2022 09:07

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children.

I this is obvious. Parents are paying a lot of money! OP

Namenic · 26/06/2022 09:03

@MrsHamlet - is it more acceptable for everyone to attempt the lowest level, then move onto the harder questions if there is time? Or are there just easy questions present? It really depends on how big the range of ability is - and I expect the range will grow as kids get older.

MrsHamlet · 26/06/2022 08:54

My dd’s school used to provide 3 levels of work colour graded for complexity. Pupils could then choose which they did. It was offered to all so was inclusive. Perhaps you should suggest something like that with the head?
This is the sort of "differentiation" which is no longer considered acceptable for a number of - some valid - reasons.

modgepodge · 26/06/2022 08:42

Believeitornot · 26/06/2022 05:52

I suspect schools do this because they have 30+ kids in class and it’s easier.

cheers Tories.

In some ways it is easier. But I only have 16 in my classes and I still do it! It works really well for my classes.

modgepodge · 26/06/2022 08:41

Soontobe60 · 26/06/2022 05:42

That way of working is the opposite of inclusive.
inclusive means that everyone in a given situation can be included. So everyone in a maths lesson can access the work provided. A child who’s not capable of completing red maths tasks but chooses it anyway because they don’t want their friends to think they’re not clever enough will, by default, self exclude. They’ve chosen a task they will rarely succeed on.

I disagree. I use this method of teaching around half the time (the textbook we use is set out like this, with 3 sections coverin the same skill at different levels). If used regularly, children learn where it is likely best they start, and the ethos and environment means no one is embarrassed to choose the correct level for thief. Of course, they don’t always make the right choice and they know they can change their mind if it proves too easy/hard. Plus an adult will be circling and discussing any surprising choices.

the alternatives would be everyone having the same work (an issue for those at the top and the bottom), or direct each child/group to the best task for them (as would happen with traditional table groupings, can be limiting if children find the work easy).

it works well for me and my classes make excellent progress 🤷‍♀️

Believeitornot · 26/06/2022 05:52

Soontobe60 · 26/06/2022 05:42

That way of working is the opposite of inclusive.
inclusive means that everyone in a given situation can be included. So everyone in a maths lesson can access the work provided. A child who’s not capable of completing red maths tasks but chooses it anyway because they don’t want their friends to think they’re not clever enough will, by default, self exclude. They’ve chosen a task they will rarely succeed on.

I suspect schools do this because they have 30+ kids in class and it’s easier.

cheers Tories.

Believeitornot · 26/06/2022 05:51

Goodskin46 · 26/06/2022 05:15

I know of no state secondary schools that don't set pupils in Maths at least from very early on

Dd's school doesn't.

My DS school does. He’s been set from week 3 of year 7.this is common.

OP, many secondary private schools require pupils to be of a certain ability before they can attend. They have a different approach and can do because a) no Ofsted b) more money c) smaller class sizes

imagine what state schools could do with the per pupil funding that we had pre 2010 (I.e.before George Osborne and David Cameron with their austerity. Oh and they knew that it was the financial crisis which caused the issues of the economy before you say Labour spent all the money. George admitted as much on a recent documentary and just shrugged).

Soontobe60 · 26/06/2022 05:42

MumsGoneToIceland · 26/06/2022 04:48

My dd’s school used to provide 3 levels of work colour graded for complexity. Pupils could then choose which they did. It was offered to all so was inclusive. Perhaps you should suggest something like that with the head?

That way of working is the opposite of inclusive.
inclusive means that everyone in a given situation can be included. So everyone in a maths lesson can access the work provided. A child who’s not capable of completing red maths tasks but chooses it anyway because they don’t want their friends to think they’re not clever enough will, by default, self exclude. They’ve chosen a task they will rarely succeed on.

Soontobe60 · 26/06/2022 05:38

MintJulia · 25/06/2022 13:37

Yanbu. That's the whole reason my ds is at an independent school.

Ds had been at the same 'good' state primary school for 7 years. Mid-year 6 his form teacher 'wasn't sure' he would pass his SATS. How could they not know after teaching him for 6 years?
He got 110,112 and 114 and they were so surprised they gave him a prize 😀but I'd lost faith in the state system. They seemed to pay no attention at all to the mid-class kids.
A year at independent school and he got 119,119,119 and is so much happier & more engaged.
I'm a single mum and it's a huge stretch for me but worth it to know he isn't bored..

Firstly, it’s an odd school where the same person teaches a child for 6 years.
Secondly, there is no such thing as ‘passing’ SATs. Or indeed ‘failing’. Each child receives a scaled score. A score of 100 is considered to be working at the expected standard for their age. A score of 101+ means they’re exceeding the expected standard. So your child was exceeding in all areas. He didn’t get the scores that you stated by being left to do nothing. He achieved them by being well taught and working hard. The higher scores that he got a year later cannot be compared. He is a year older, so the scaled scores can’t be compared as it’s a test for 11 year olds, not 12 year olds. An increase in a scaled score of 9 points means that they’ve got about 2 more questions correct; an increase of 5 points means they got 1 extra correct - that’s hardly a massive difference in results - bearing in mind the age increase.

Goodskin46 · 26/06/2022 05:15

I know of no state secondary schools that don't set pupils in Maths at least from very early on

Dd's school doesn't.

MumsGoneToIceland · 26/06/2022 04:48

My dd’s school used to provide 3 levels of work colour graded for complexity. Pupils could then choose which they did. It was offered to all so was inclusive. Perhaps you should suggest something like that with the head?

Quincythequince · 26/06/2022 04:35

I thought all schools put children into sets.
180 boys per year in my sons’ school - streamed for core subjects, languages, and PE.

I agree that your situation doesn’t sound great and what a nightmare to teach.

Bluedabadeeba · 26/06/2022 03:37

As a primary school teacher, comments like this enrage me. She will be being pushed with more complex work. She will have the opportunity to use further ideas and be pushed with differentiation.. otherwise the school with have failed ofsted. Are you taking your DC's word for this? Yes coaching is highly valuable but there, of course, will be other tools being used. Teachers have to show proof of every single child making progress every single half term. Literally by opening the book at the start and end.

And, as you've worked in both, you'll know about the differences in class size, ratio and therefore feedback loop possible in private schools. How outrageous to compare the two. Of course state schools kids should have access to all the top notch facilities and perks of private school kids, but unfortunately, we do not live in a fair world.

Phew, nice to get that off my chest!

echt · 26/06/2022 01:18

Actually less able children do better in streamed classes where they are not constantly reminded of their own inadequacies in comparison with their more able classmates. They get appropriate lessons and targets and a sense of achievement. Their progress is real

I'd love to see evidence of this.

Also, the significant measure of progress is the movement of pupils between streams. Having taught in both streamed and setted schools, apart from initial misplacements, students stayed where they were. I'm aware this is anecdotal.

SammyScrounge · 26/06/2022 00:36

MardyBumm · 25/06/2022 13:49

But it negatively impacts the lower attaining children. What about their social mobility?

Actually less able children do better in streamed classes where they are not constantly reminded of their own inadequacies in comparison with their more able classmates. They get appropriate lessons and targets and a sense of achievement. Their progress is real.

DomPerignon12 · 25/06/2022 23:45

Namenic · 25/06/2022 23:33

@7Worfs - could chunking things into small units help? DH had a similar problem to you at school. He has read about the pomodoro method, zettelkasten method and Getting things Done book to try and improve. He is also trying to improve sleep/exercise to boost energy levels. I don’t know if strategies that help people with adhd could help you too?

people who were always bad at sport sometimes get super fit in their 40s - there is hope yet!

probably because they found the right sport!

Namenic · 25/06/2022 23:33

@7Worfs - could chunking things into small units help? DH had a similar problem to you at school. He has read about the pomodoro method, zettelkasten method and Getting things Done book to try and improve. He is also trying to improve sleep/exercise to boost energy levels. I don’t know if strategies that help people with adhd could help you too?

people who were always bad at sport sometimes get super fit in their 40s - there is hope yet!