Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
wonderstuff · 26/06/2022 22:49

My state school doesn’t stream, we get fantastic results, much better than many, many other state schools that do. Streaming is very negative for pupils who are always in the bottom streams and doesn’t improve the performance of those in the top.

Inclusive teaching is just good teaching.

echt · 26/06/2022 22:44

Certainly!!!!!! Embarrassing English teacher typo! Blush It's being upside down, the blood rushes to my head.

echt · 26/06/2022 22:43

This is purely anecdotal, but I've recently retired from 15 years of teaching in Victoria, where class sizes are capped, by union agreement, at 25. Mostly classes were 22-23. Lots were 20.One was 10!!!!

You ceratinly get to know the students better and support them better at lower numbers; 20 was best. 10 is hard work, as you lose the sense of the group, harder to get discussions going.

This was English in an unstreamed, unsetted school.

Alexandria12 · 26/06/2022 22:42

I mean maybe a brilliant teacher will do well with a larger class, but all things being equal smaller classes will be better.

At the extreme, with a very large class like some university lectures, there is little chance for interaction or responsiveness so pupils might as well be watching a video of a brilliant teacher with a TA to do behaviour management. Perhaps that will be the eventual government plan....

underneaththeash · 26/06/2022 22:39

justfiveminutes · 25/06/2022 13:11

Mixed ability grouping has been proven to have a positive impact on lower attainers but no detrimental impact on higher attainers.

Explaining methods to others is also an excellent way of embedding learning, improving understanding, improving mathematical vocabulary and stretching quick learners.

Having said that, it should just be one tool and not the only tool so if you are concerned that your child finishes the core lesson and is not provided with extension tasks or challenges, you should ask about that.

I had this conversation with someone the other day. So clever kids teaching the less clever ones brings them up, but has no affect on the academic achievements of higher achievers - but based on GCSE levels - so kids who would get 9s, get 9's anyway - as they cannot achieve more highly. It doesnt take into account that they are bored, annoyed or stressed having to do a teachers jobs.

Alexandria12 · 26/06/2022 22:37

Well smaller class sizes will make it easier to be a good teacher.
Each teacher will have less students, so more chances to get to know students and adapt teaching to their needs, more time to mark work, less need for crowd control, more ability to give individual help where needed, more chance to ask all students questions in class to make them feel engaged and check for understanding.

cantkeepawayforever · 26/06/2022 22:35

Yeah, I'm aware the EEF isn't perfect - just like Pisa isn't perfect - and would encourage anyone to maintain a critical attitude to educational research. There are so many interlocking variables that just isolating the effect of 1 can be impossible (and open to biased interpretation). I was really interested in the poster upthread whose school really had tried out different setting arrangements - being in a singe school reduces variability due to very different intakes etc - and monitored their results.

echt · 26/06/2022 22:31

It is better to be in a class of 30 with a great teacher than in a class of 15 with an OK teacher, for example. There is plenty of pedagogic research to back this up

That's quite a claim. What research?

echt · 26/06/2022 22:28

The old trope about class sizes is largely a myth, though, certainly at primary school and for the most part up to A level. Or rather, it is a much less important factor than is typically supposed – the quality of teaching is significantly more important

No it isn't: www.aeuvic.asn.au/sites/default/files/class_size_research_summary.pdf

Summerwhereareyou · 26/06/2022 22:19

The difference with class size is time surely?you teach the concept to dc of total random ability?
Who has the time to concentrate on the DC who just don't get it, can't read properly yet?
Illegible writing?
DX needing special skills from a teacher who doesn't have them because they don't understand dyslexia?

Summerwhereareyou · 26/06/2022 22:07

Op I can't Wade through all the pages but what age?

Primary year 3/4 possibly 5 I can sort of see why it maybe helpful to have her coaching others,and I agree it's such a great way to learn and embedded it.

But...I had with my dd sat next to highly disruptive children whose issues meant my dd would have no bearing on them.

She was used and had little to show for it.
The same started to happen at secondary so I eventually moved her to a grammar,( and for other issues)

I felt she had a lot to give but wasn't getting much back.

A few years ago oftesd said the brightest sx were being let down in comps and this is why progress 8 has been brought in to track progress.

I can't see how comps can suit all DC.
It's a crazy idea and we should have loads more types of school,not less.
I have one classic accadmically able child.
I have one less classically accadmically able child who needs a different way of teaching and who should be doing far more creative things and hand's on leaning.
We should be embraceing all the differences our DC have not being frightend of them...and corralling them all into one place so it seems like they are all the Same.
They. Are .not.

noblegiraffe · 26/06/2022 22:03

cant I don't know if the EEF have updated their setting research page in the last few years but their findings have been heavily disputed (with maths!) here:

teachingbattleground.wordpress.com/2018/04/02/the-eef-were-even-more-wrong-about-ability-grouping-than-i-realised/

thing47 · 26/06/2022 21:48

Valeriekat · 26/06/2022 19:04

There is no evidence re class sizes because the research doesn't get funded.
It is self evident that students in a smaller class get more teacher attention and better feed back.
Some of the posters on here must be the LT.

Not so. It has been extensively researched over a number of years, not least by Ofsted (in this country) and PISA (internationally), as well as by other sources, both objective and subjective.

I have no idea what LT stands for, I'm afraid, but I do have a background in educational research and no personal dog in the fight as a) I'm no longer in this field and b) my own DCs are post-school age.

cantkeepawayforever · 26/06/2022 20:43

EEF is a reputable source of summaries of education research that gives an indication both of impact of a factor and strength of evidence:

Within class attainment grouping

Setting and streaming

Reducing class size

This is the home page from which a research on whole range of possible factors is linked.

RampantIvy · 26/06/2022 20:38

Explaining methods to others is also an excellent way of embedding learning, improving understanding, improving mathematical vocabulary and stretching quick learners.

Interesting you should say this. When DD was revising for her finals one of her friends hadn't paid any attention in the lectures for the module the next exam was on, so she did several revision sessions with him using a whiteboard to explain concepts. She said that it helped her enormously with her revision.

In answer to @PickleM's observation this was something that ofsted criticised DD's old school about a few years ago. They were told not just to get GCSE pupils up to a C from a D, but to get the A and B students up to A* and A.

Goodskin46 · 26/06/2022 20:32

JudgeJ · 26/06/2022 19:26

Then I would be looking for another school if they're not setted by Year 8 or Year 9 at the very latest, it is doing your child no favours, it's simply ticking pc boxes sticking with mixed ability for Maths.

Thank you for your input. She is yr 10, we were promised setting for year 9. We had started to look at a few schools in yr 8, then Covid. She returned to her school in Sept 2020 (yr9) they kept them in the same class and classroom for everything because of Covid, then of course the school closed again. I thought they had been set this year to start their GCSE courses, we only learnt they weren't at parents' evening in Febuary. Moving her now would be very disruptive. Her brother has just done Maths and Further maths A-level one of his friends is going to help her next year as she is simply not being stretched in maths. This is a grammar school btw.

Believeitornot · 26/06/2022 20:18

other than the very lowest attainers who couldn't give a damn

why do you think low attainers don’t care?

MotherofPearl · 26/06/2022 19:42

My DD's state secondary streams for nearly all subjects. She's in a huge school that I think does a great job of pushing her, as well as supporting those who need extra help. The school run a 'gifted and talented' programme which DD was selected for. She's also been able to select EPQ as one of her GCSE options, as she's in G&T. I appreciate that all schools are different though.

MrsHamlet · 26/06/2022 19:38

the very lowest attainers who couldn't give a damn
This is a really unpleasant statement.

JudgeJ · 26/06/2022 19:26

Goodskin46 · 26/06/2022 05:15

I know of no state secondary schools that don't set pupils in Maths at least from very early on

Dd's school doesn't.

Then I would be looking for another school if they're not setted by Year 8 or Year 9 at the very latest, it is doing your child no favours, it's simply ticking pc boxes sticking with mixed ability for Maths.

JudgeJ · 26/06/2022 19:20

Mixed ability grouping has been proven to have a positive impact on lower attainers but no detrimental impact on higher attainers.

Proven where? It causes a great detrimental impact on the majority of pupils, other than the very lowest attainers who couldn't give a damn and the very highest attainers who will succeed despite the distractions. The concept of 'mixed ability' has always been nonsense, as a Maths teacher it was ridiculous to try and teach the Higher skills of the National Curriculum in a mixed ability class, the reason that the vast majority of schools started setting for most subjects.

Valeriekat · 26/06/2022 19:04

There is no evidence re class sizes because the research doesn't get funded.
It is self evident that students in a smaller class get more teacher attention and better feed back.
Some of the posters on here must be the LT.

Valeriekat · 26/06/2022 19:01

Able pupils for less affluent backgrounds are not encouraged/supported nor shown how to access the top universities.
That is the scandal

thing47 · 26/06/2022 13:14

Oh I'm on your side, @IdontWanna in that I was saying having a good teacher is way more important than most other factors. In fact, the single most important factor.

Maybe I was wrong to tag you, it's just that so many parents seem to think smaller class size is the Holy Grail of education, whereas the real Holy Grail is great teachers. The evidence supports this.

ldontWanna · 26/06/2022 12:37

@thing47 I am primary. But why compare 30 with a great teacher and 15 with an ok teacher? If both teachers are great is there still no difference?

And I didn't just say class size , when you add in a (or several) cohort with a very significant difference in ability, not just from low to highs, but even between the lows and the next group up. We did do it though,we definitely tried our best, worked incredibly hard (it definitely wasn't easy) under extreme pressure and scrutiny, but even so,I'm sure there was at least one lesson(or more likely several) where we failed at least one kid.