Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 30/06/2022 22:17

DD’s state grammar pushed. DD’s take was anything below a 7 (A) was viewed as unacceptable. No sets except there was one top maths set who also did further maths. It’s not super selective - top table in primary in catchment should get a place. Other local schools are outstanding so catchment parents only tend to enter children school will be a good fit for. It’s not a full grammar county we are up north.

Konstantine8364 · 30/06/2022 22:06

My experience at school (admittedly a while ago!) As a bright kid was that setting is really beneficial. We were set for all core subjects apart from english. None of the bright kids wanted to work in English as we would be mocked/bullied. So I messed around like everyone else to fit in. I got Bs in English and A/A* for everything else at GCSE. In maths for example with other bright children it was a good space to ask questions and learn. Im in Trafford and if I have kids they will be aimed for the 11plus and grammar (and I'll pay for private if they don't pass!).

dizzydizzydizzy · 30/06/2022 21:21

Surely it varies by school? I thought our (state) secondary school handled this really well but the primary less well.

It also depends on how motivated the DCs are.

DC1 grabbed every single opportunity the school gave, worked very hard and and is very clever. Got 4 x A* at A-Level.

Mibby16 · 30/06/2022 21:14

Absolutely agree OP. My fairly bright DD was told bluntly, and in my earshot, the her state primary were only teaching the basic maths to achieve a 'meets expectations ' SATs grade and if she wanted to attempt Greater Depth we would have to buy books and teach her at home. Same for English, they were confident she would pass and wouldn't stretch her, preferring to have her help less able friends
We've chosen a secondary that sets from xmas of y7

onemouseplace · 30/06/2022 21:12

I have two DDs of similar academic ability (on the high side) but about 5 years between them. DD1 was taught mostly in ability groups, but clearly policy has changed in the intervening years at the same school and DD2 is being taught in mixed ability groups for everything.

The difference in their progress and where they are academically at the same age is more than noticeable - to the extent that I am concerned that DD2 is being failed by the same school and being held back.

pointythings · 30/06/2022 20:55

Valeriekat · 30/06/2022 20:48

The better private schools set for maths very early on. Without it they would not be able to access some of the higher Maths they need eg for engineering.

Because nobody from a state school ever managed to do an engineering degree and succeed in that field, of course. Hmm

Valeriekat · 30/06/2022 20:52

ldontWanna · 25/06/2022 14:12

It depends how it's done. For example a very bright child might be perfectly able to do something, but struggle to explain in any meaningful way or actually understand what they are doing so they can then apply it to something else.That means they can't often answer reasoning/why questions which are just as important as the ability to do long division in your head. Explaining the workings of a problem 1 2 1 with a peer, in a way they can understand it deepens their own understanding of the method and it helps "stick".

Now if you have one kid supporting a whole table just doing the questions for them or giving them the answers, that's pointless for everyone.

That is teacher BS and you know it.

Valeriekat · 30/06/2022 20:48

The better private schools set for maths very early on. Without it they would not be able to access some of the higher Maths they need eg for engineering.

CulturePigeon · 28/06/2022 07:58

entropynow I agree. How do researchers know that very able children don't suffer? Just because they may perform well and come out top of the class doesn't mean they are achieving their potential.

When I was doing my PGCE (long ago, admittedly) were were told 'be aware that you may be teaching children who are more able/intelligent than you are'. I've worked in both secondary and primary state schools and I've seen lots of cases where teachers just didn't recognise this and let very able children coast (or occasionally worse - they developed a chippy, grudging attitude to them). Not teacher bashing- I don't know how teachers do it these days with all the demands made on them, and in the situation they find themselves in, something has to snap - they're not superhuman.

And class size is important! I can't see how anyone could question this. Any teacher knows that the difference between 25 and 30 is very noticeable. Smaller would be even better, not only for able children but the less able who often find waiting for the teacher's attention very difficult - a big cause of disengagement and disruption.

Goodskin46 · 28/06/2022 07:37

modgepodge · 28/06/2022 06:45

In many comprehensives, the top 25% of pupils would probably be the top set (near us most schools are 4-6 8 forms per year, the bigger ones don’t tend to have 6 sets, they split the year group in 2 and have two lots of sets 1-3).

i appreciate not everyone who passes the 11+ will be a maths whizz but I doubt many of them are scraping 1/2s and being taught alongside those getting 8/9s as might be happening in a comprehensive school mixed ability class.

Very true. However one doesn't go through the stress of the 11+ and travel to a grammar school so that one's daughter can have an experience equivilent to that in a "bog standard" comp. I was hpoing for some more differentiation than the top 25% at 10 being lumped together for 5 years.

modgepodge · 28/06/2022 06:45

Goodskin46 · 27/06/2022 18:55

I knew someone would say that. In Kent it's the highest achieving 25%, that doesn't necessarily corrleate to those who are most mathmatically able. There is still a wide range of ability.

In many comprehensives, the top 25% of pupils would probably be the top set (near us most schools are 4-6 8 forms per year, the bigger ones don’t tend to have 6 sets, they split the year group in 2 and have two lots of sets 1-3).

i appreciate not everyone who passes the 11+ will be a maths whizz but I doubt many of them are scraping 1/2s and being taught alongside those getting 8/9s as might be happening in a comprehensive school mixed ability class.

Summerwhereareyou · 28/06/2022 06:34

It's interesting that low attainers are referred to many times in those links and with marginal results found.
My dd was a low attainer and that's because unfortunately no teacher had the skills to help her unlock her learning.
I had to rely on the kindness of strangers and also then, buy in help.
What's frightening is, she didn't need much at all!
Just a few tweaks here and there to help put her learning into context, visual aids and so on.
So I'm taking reports of impact on low attainers with a pinch of salt. Since my experience with dd I've linked up on FB site's a d spoken to many parents in rl and on here about it.
Most agree unfortunately not enough Sen strategy is taught in the pgce so teachers have no skills or knowledge on their lower attainers.
To insist it's in the pgce,to help tas access the tips, to roll out consultantations from Sen strategists would help enormously.
With reading for instance they just kept hitting the nut with the wrong hammer. Phonics!

MrsHamlet · 28/06/2022 05:23

They are judged on GCSE A-C, getting borderline kids over the threshold is what they focus on. Schools have been open about this with

Not any more it isn't. Progress 8 has, rightly, seen to that. I'm as likely to be asked why Delphine "only" got an 8 as why Bob "only" got a 3

SausageinaBun · 27/06/2022 23:49

My perspective is as a parent of two bright primary school children where the biggest issue is the pace in maths.

I think coaching others is useful (along with a range of other work). Probably the best comment in a school report about my Dd1 is that she 'effectively scaffolds peers learning in maths'. Unpacking a maths problem into steps and trying to understand what the gap is in a peer's thought process engages higher level thinking skills.

But there are issues for my DDs in maths lessons. The slow pace of teacher explanations and worked examples at the beginning of lessons bores them. DD1 whinged until I negotiated an alternative to her sitting through that, but I seemed to have to renegotiate every year. DD2 just switches off and day dreams, but apparently that's ok because she can still do all of the work. Some of the issue is also the curriculum. As an example, time is spent each year on place value (for a few years at least) with slightly larger numbers each year. Some children just get it, can extrapolate it to larger numbers and don't need it explained year after year.

cantkeepawayforever · 27/06/2022 23:10

I think there is a difference between ‘being in different groups that are targeting different tiers in the few subjects these exist’ in Y10/11, and being fully streamed for all subjects early in KS3?

BungleandGeorge · 27/06/2022 22:55

cantkeepawayforever · 27/06/2022 22:37

Entropy,

The school is wrong in saying this is what they are judged on - in 'the old days', and perhaps by parents who rely on raw results league tables, maybe. However, Ofsted and others now look at progress of ALL pupils, so a school that concentrates solely on the 3-4 or 4-5 borderline pupils will come horribly unstuck unless they are also making sure able pupils move from 8s to 9s.

There are far fewer at the top though, so concentrating in the middle creates the greatest return on effort.
I don’t really understand how it’s possible to be in mixed ability groups for subjects with different entry tiers?

cantkeepawayforever · 27/06/2022 22:37

Entropy,

The school is wrong in saying this is what they are judged on - in 'the old days', and perhaps by parents who rely on raw results league tables, maybe. However, Ofsted and others now look at progress of ALL pupils, so a school that concentrates solely on the 3-4 or 4-5 borderline pupils will come horribly unstuck unless they are also making sure able pupils move from 8s to 9s.

entropynow · 27/06/2022 22:14

justfiveminutes · 25/06/2022 13:11

Mixed ability grouping has been proven to have a positive impact on lower attainers but no detrimental impact on higher attainers.

Explaining methods to others is also an excellent way of embedding learning, improving understanding, improving mathematical vocabulary and stretching quick learners.

Having said that, it should just be one tool and not the only tool so if you are concerned that your child finishes the core lesson and is not provided with extension tasks or challenges, you should ask about that.

Not my son's experience in any way whatsoever.
Bluntly, schools have no interest in very able children. They are judged on GCSE A-C, getting borderline kids over the threshold is what they focus on. Schools have been open about this with us

Goodskin46 · 27/06/2022 18:55

modgepodge · 27/06/2022 18:21

ah, but a grammar school is basically a top set anyway! All the children there will be very able (of course there will be some variation).

interesting to see Hattie slated on here, lots of the research quoted on here about class sizes not mattering and setting having a negative effect is probably his. I’ve heard him quoted many times on leadership training so interesting to see he’s not rated in the real world (or mumsnet, anyway!)

I knew someone would say that. In Kent it's the highest achieving 25%, that doesn't necessarily corrleate to those who are most mathmatically able. There is still a wide range of ability.

noblegiraffe · 27/06/2022 18:50

@modgepodge it isn't just on here that Hattie is slated, there are some pretty robust criticisms of his methodology around on the internet e.g.
robertslavinsblog.wordpress.com/2018/06/21/john-hattie-is-wrong/

Hattie responds to the garbage in garbage out accusation with:

"The argument is that the quality of the research included in the Visible Learning dataset is more akin to junk food than organic produce grown with love. If the ingredients are junk, so the criticism goes, then so must be the results….

“…If we only included the perfect studies or meta-analyses, there would be insufficient data from which to draw conclusions. Indeed, in the What Works Clearinghouse (WWC), which only allows RCTs [randomised controlled trials] and similarly high-quality designs, the median number of studies in each of the 500 reviews is two! It is hard to draw conclusions based on two studies.

“So, we have a choice to make. We either limit ourselves to collecting the perfect studies or we mine the lot but take great care over how we interpret the data and the conclusions that we draw from them. In the case of Visible Learning, the latter approach was taken.”

I think that he is wrong to say that there aren't enough good studies so it's fine to use crap ones. The correct approach would be to commission better studies and say the jury is out, not to bodge together a table ranking interventions based on crap that will then be wheeled out in INSETs as if inscribed on stone tablets.

SummerPuddings · 27/06/2022 18:38

7Worfs · 25/06/2022 13:29

I was a high ability student and never got any stretch assignments - I spent 12 years of education doing no studying, got good grades and went to uni without the habit and ability to work hard and apply myself.

It is so easy for able children to become lazy if not challenged, and it persists through life, turning them into underachievers.

This! 100%

modgepodge · 27/06/2022 18:21

Goodskin46 · 26/06/2022 20:32

Thank you for your input. She is yr 10, we were promised setting for year 9. We had started to look at a few schools in yr 8, then Covid. She returned to her school in Sept 2020 (yr9) they kept them in the same class and classroom for everything because of Covid, then of course the school closed again. I thought they had been set this year to start their GCSE courses, we only learnt they weren't at parents' evening in Febuary. Moving her now would be very disruptive. Her brother has just done Maths and Further maths A-level one of his friends is going to help her next year as she is simply not being stretched in maths. This is a grammar school btw.

ah, but a grammar school is basically a top set anyway! All the children there will be very able (of course there will be some variation).

interesting to see Hattie slated on here, lots of the research quoted on here about class sizes not mattering and setting having a negative effect is probably his. I’ve heard him quoted many times on leadership training so interesting to see he’s not rated in the real world (or mumsnet, anyway!)

echt · 27/06/2022 02:52

The thing about education research is that it is quite often poorly conducted, or different studies look at completely different things and then people lump them together so you end up with someone trying to do a meta analysis that is literally garbage in, garbage out

This. I'm looking at you, John Hattie, you shyster.

noblegiraffe · 27/06/2022 00:26

The thing about education research is that it is quite often poorly conducted, or different studies look at completely different things and then people lump them together so you end up with someone trying to do a meta analysis that is literally garbage in, garbage out.

Dylan Wiliam has talked about how teaching will never be a research-based profession because of this. For example you might have studies looking at the effectiveness of homework at primary and conclude that homework at primary is useless (as is often stated) but then you think about parents listening to to their child read and how vital this is, or perhaps something like practising times times. Then they might say 'oh but we were looking at homework tasks like 'build a volcano' or similar that is simply work for the parents and that turned out to be useless, we didn't mean don't listen to your child read'.

Wiliam said if something doesn't sound right, then you can probably dismiss the research on that basis. Like size of class doesn't matter. I mean, pfft, of course it does, despite what Hattie says.

And in teaching, so many other factors come into play that you can't control for, like the personality of the teacher, and the personality of the class.

Alexandria12 · 26/06/2022 23:01

@noblegiraffe wow that article about the EEF conclusions on setting is quite damming. Makes you wonder what else they have wrong.

I do wonder how much the slight negative effect on lower attainers is down to behaviour. If lower attainers who wanted to learn were separated from those who are not attaining well because of behaviour issues perhaps this effect would disappear.