Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think state schools should do more to push academic pupils?

211 replies

PickleM · 25/06/2022 13:05

I've worked in both state and private schools. My observation with my own dc (in state schools) is that those who are very able academically could be given better opportunity to excel, but aren't. I see it as a great shame.

It seems like in order to tick the 'inclusive' box or help those who need more support, the children who are more capable aren't really given very challenging work.

An example would be that my dd is put in a very mixed ability group for maths and English. However, previously the class had different tables depending on level of work - those most able were given more challenging work. Those less able were given less challenging work. I've now been told by the teacher that this wasn't 'inclusive' enough for the slt. Apparently my dc is learning through 'coaching others'. I think she should give a higher level of work to those most able, I'm not interested in my dc 'coaching others' when she could be learning more complex work.

Private schools seem to have no issue with streaming children. Perhaps I've just been unlucky, ultimately it doesn't matter as I help my children learn at home, but what about capable children who don't have home support?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
zingally · 01/07/2022 16:46

I knew before I even opened the thread that this would be a wonderful example of the "humble brag".

rainbowmilk · 01/07/2022 15:42

I'm not bothered about more able kids helping the less able (as long as it's in a way that benefits both parties and isn't just supplementing the teacher), but the problem I had at school was being used to assist in crowd control.

I was a quiet able kid and we had mixed ability classes in all subjects. Most of the lessons were completely derailed by the disruptive kids (who weren't all less able, but often it was those who weren't following and were bored and acting up instead), and the teachers would struggle to manage it whilst actually doing some teaching. The approach was basically sitting the quiet able kids next to the disruptive ones in the hope that we'd rub off on them. What ended up happening was that the disruptive ones would bully and humiliate us, and we'd lose our own interest in the subject or the learning itself.

What should have happened was more focus on the kids who weren't participating in the lesson to identify what help was needed (whether more explanation/support or more challenge). But that requires funding and proper classroom ratios and we all know that doesn't happen.

Too much of state schooling is just throwing the kids into childcare and hoping for the best, and I do agree with others that it leads to all kids being failed.

Sandcastles24 · 01/07/2022 14:02

@Summerwhereareyou thank you. That uis very interesting to hear about the different ways people's minds work. I bet you can speed read too

UsernameNowAvailable · 01/07/2022 12:13

I agree, I had this problem particularly in Maths, in primary and lower secondary. Started to see the same in my kids and have chosen to go private.

Anyone looking at my grades at school would say there was nothing wrong (got all top grades including further maths, went to top uni, good career).

However - I did start to reach my limits with maths at uni, and perhaps I could have been a deeper mathematician if I had been stretched more, instead of being taught almost nothing from the age of 7-14.

When you are mathematical most of the concepts taught at primary are pretty obvious and natural once taught, and don’t require as much ‘bedding in’ as some of the primary teachers seem to think.

My theory is that certain countries are ‘better at maths’ because they stretch the brighter kids earlier. They prioritise nurturing some very competent skilled people - rather than prioritising raising the lower ability kids. Ideally we could do both!

georgarina · 01/07/2022 11:43

When I was at school we had four class types - basic, standard, advanced, and a2.

It was a good way of dividing classes so no one was left struggling or ignored.

I have dyscalculia so I took basic maths but was in a2 in my other classes. It was helpful to be in classes tailored to my starting point and abilities.

Summerwhereareyou · 01/07/2022 11:25

@Sandcastles24

Phonics created a barrier between dd and the words.
So we took advice from here ,lots of research and went back to Peter and Jane books and flash cards for 100 high frequency word's.
Peter and Jane got her flow and confidence back.
Literally starting with ,Jane/Peter.
This is Peter and Jane.
This is Jane and Peter etc.

Within a few weeks only she had gone from stuttering sounding out,slowly trudging through to smoothly reading more advanced Peter and Jane.
Then we got a reading chest subscription and followed our school reading scheme and for her through the levels to where she should roughly be age wise.
This impacted her self esteem and of course being able to actually read means she was so much more engaged in the lesson's!!

She understands what she is reading and can verbally say it but with an actual written comprehension she still struggles.
She has two tutors who support her now and I'm hoping the foundations are now in .

She now instinctively knows how to pronounce harder words and doesn't need any sounding out at all.
We also followed different strategies for spelling a s again she now has an excellent instinct for harder words.

I was one of those people who just found the word's made sense one day when I was very young.
Had anyone tried to force phonics on me you would have taken a very early reader, and confused and delayed them.
I knew it all instinctively. I didn't need phonics. I struggled with other aspects of learning so being such a good reader was crucial to my self esteem.

Phonics has become a cult.

faffadoodledo · 01/07/2022 11:05

I doubt Imperial would let you in without Further a maths tbh. Certainly not for a maths based degree

thing47 · 01/07/2022 10:48

Valeriekat · 01/07/2022 07:03

Don't be ridiculous but at the top school ie Imperial, many state school pupils are at a massive disadvantage and they know it. A lot of our state school students are playing catch up because they usually haven't had the opportunity to study Applied or Further Maths.
That is the problem with not setting for Maths early on.

Academic achievement is not linear. Apart from a few brilliant outliers most DCs will experience peaks and troughs. Different DCs do better at different stages of education for a myriad of reasons relating both to the child him or herself and to their circumstances.

Furthermore certain types of exam suit some and not others. A level learning is a world apart from what is required at degree and post-graduate degree – someone can be, for example, not very good at revising for A levels but be a very good researcher when not under the artificial time pressures of an exam.

screamingbanshees · 01/07/2022 10:17

I am 19 and only finished school in 2019. Throughout school I was very advanced academically, and although teachers gave me extra work, it was not challenging enough for me to further improve my skills. There were plenty of opportunities that could have been offered to me given a little bit of effort on the school’s part, but going to an academy in one of the poorest areas in the country, their efforts were centred around rehabilitating badly behaved students - overshadowing my skills and that of other top performing students. As a result, my GCSE grades were lower than expected. However, I don’t personally blame the teachers. They are constantly having to juggle various roles and not being paid enough to do so. I blame the school overall for ignoring academically gifted pupils simply because they were not causing problems. I would suggest talking to the school and asking them to push extra support and opportunities.

pointythings · 01/07/2022 09:27

@Valeriekat the evidence suggests that state school pupils do better at university because they have had to work much harder to get there and are better at independent learning. The study demonstrating this dates from 2015 but has not been refuted. I think everyone would like all state schools to be excellent. I would like private schools not to exist - my home country manages very well without them. But it isn't just about pushing academic pupils, it is about getting the best out of everyone.

fUNNYfACE36 · 01/07/2022 09:25

Itsrainingatlast · 25/06/2022 14:34

There’s a real lack of understanding about what mixed ability means and the pedagogy behind it from some posters.
It’s perfectly possible to give 30 students the same task and then ensure every student is challenged. For example, if you were teaching a Y7 history class about the Battle of Hastings, your task might be to ‘Explain why Harold lost’. A lower ability child might need starter sentences to say that he lost because he was hit in the eye with an arrow. Whereas at the other end, a more able student would be able to independently write 500+ words, discussing a range of factors (just fought off HH in the North, tactical errors on Senlac Hill etc) and might even question why we think he got an arrow in the eye, and did this actually ever happen, how credible is the Bayeux Tapestry as a source! Really bright children are able to work out how to extend the task and challenge themselves so aren’t sitting there with nothing to do, claiming to have finished. Same in maths; a really bright child will be able to demonstrate multiple ways to find a solution.
We also have a system where Ofsted/league tables etc mean that there is a lot of ‘teaching to the test’. The pressure to get students through exams is enormous and means teachers focus on exam content, rather than going off at a tangent, if there is no potential to increase the child’s grade.
Finally, state schools are grossly underfunded, and teachers are leaving the profession in droves. Interestingly though, with many private schools leaving the TPS, they’re finding recruitment just as hard as state schools

You really can't do this in most topics of STEM subjects.

Anothernamechangeplease · 01/07/2022 09:04

My very bright dd has had excellent support in the state system.

At primary school, she was consistently given extension work and taken out to do stuff with a TA or with the deputy head. The school also worked with a group of other local primary schools to stretch their most able pupils, with the deputy head of each school taking a turn to set a monthly challenge for the most able pupils and then provide feedback.

There was less extension work at secondary, but they set for all subjects except art, music, PE etc from year 7, which probably helped. There was still a wide range of ability in the top sets, but actually, I think dd did learn a lot - both academically and socially - from having to explain stuff to her peers on a regular basis, and I never saw this as a negative thing at all.

I think a lot depends on the school, but perhaps there is less resource now in primary schools to replicate the kind of experiences that my dd had. Schools have so little money now!

redskyatnight · 01/07/2022 08:50

TeenDivided · 01/07/2022 07:38

I think it is fair to say that students who don't have access to FM A level but who would wish to study it will be disadvantaged.
What I don't know is how many students that would be?

I can imagine some schools not having sufficient numbers to run it, but I am also surprised (probably naive?) if there wasn't a different school within reach for those students to move to for A levels. Too often I see posts on MN where current school doesn't offer desired subjects, but the student is reluctant to move. However I am in Hants with gigantic colleges so small 6th forms isn't an issue.

There were only 3 students taking FM A Level in DS's year. For any other subject, this would have meant they didn't run it. However, the school sees that being able to offer FM is important and so accepts it will run with small class size (there were 2 large Maths A Level classes, so perhaps between the 3 groups it evened out). Like you, I'd be surprised if any but smaller schools would opt not to offer it at all.

Sandcastles24 · 01/07/2022 08:31

@Summerwhereareyou sorry I tried to reply to your post above

Sandcastles24 · 01/07/2022 08:30

This interests me, schools quote phonics as the answer to all reading problems. What was the problem with the and what was the spanner for the nut that your dd needed?

Sherrystrull · 01/07/2022 08:08

It's not really surprising that private schools with lots of money and resources, who can choose which children attend are able to support higher achieving children better.

It's not a fair comparison.
Give state schools more money and of course they'd do more.
State schools and staff have only so much capacity.

TeenDivided · 01/07/2022 07:38

I think it is fair to say that students who don't have access to FM A level but who would wish to study it will be disadvantaged.
What I don't know is how many students that would be?

I can imagine some schools not having sufficient numbers to run it, but I am also surprised (probably naive?) if there wasn't a different school within reach for those students to move to for A levels. Too often I see posts on MN where current school doesn't offer desired subjects, but the student is reluctant to move. However I am in Hants with gigantic colleges so small 6th forms isn't an issue.

faffadoodledo · 01/07/2022 07:35

@Valeriekat Where's your evidence about state pupils struggling to get Firsts? I am a fangirl for state schools. As I've said, the disadvantage pupils face is gaining access to 'top' universities. And that's not about grades - it's about the way private schools have special sessions and teachers to coach students through the process whereas state don't. This is something Oxbridge etc need to address. There is abundant talent in state schools.
DD did Further maths at her comp, and it wasn't a great one.

faffadoodledo · 01/07/2022 07:32

Sorry @Valeriekat geekspeak for mathematicians. It's what mathematicians call one another (and what others call them!).

Valeriekat · 01/07/2022 07:29

What is mathmos?

Valeriekat · 01/07/2022 07:26

faffadoodledo · 01/07/2022 07:11

It obviously depends on the child. My DD is a gifted mathematician, now using her maths in a research and medical setting at a top university. Went to bog standard comp. She was used to 'tutor' less bright, or worse, disruptive kids in her year in broadly streamed classes. IN other words the top sets had a broad range of ability. She was fine. It made her cross, sure. But tbh there's a limit to the knowledge you need to get an A star at A level, and she coasted that. So didnt need any extra push. I can see how some young people would be alienated by this treatment, and tbh it used to piss me off. But she rode it and used it to her advantage on her UCAS form. It's hard to find things to talk about for maths and she shoe-horned in her ability to explain and demonstrate tricky concepts.
It didn't happen to DS, who was the arty farty child (though equally gifted in his fields). Its seems to be the mathematicians who cop this treatment most!
@Valeriekat what are you talking about? I know masses of young engineers and mathmos, very few of whom went to a 'better private school'.

I am not saying that state school pupils can't get their engineering degrees but they have to work very much harder to compete with overseas pupils and students who have been able to do Further/Applied Maths.
It can mean the difference between a First and a 2 1.
They are at a massive disadvantage you can't think that this is a good thing surely?

faffadoodledo · 01/07/2022 07:21

The problem at the top tier in state schools is definitely access to Oxbridge and other high institutions, rather than exam results. IME anyway. A stars aplenty. But no extra help for the specialist entrance exams, let alone interview practice. DS was lucky; his dad went to Oxford so 'got' what was required for the Cambridge application. School did diddly squat. By contrast the nearest private school did Wednesday afternoon sessions specially tailored for oxbridge, vet and med school.
I'd like to blame our school but I suppose they're too busy fire fighting further down the pecking order - trying to get kids across the lines set by exams.
But yes, state school kids (by which I mean most comps) are hugely disadvantaged when it comes to applications when it comes to Oxbridge and specialist places.

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 01/07/2022 07:12

I teach English so I think it's easier for pupils to work at their own level. I try to stretch and challenge every pupil, but tbh I think a lot of that reaching for extra challenge comes from within. My eldest has an offer from Oxford for October. She was perfectly happy at our bog-standard comprehensive but a lot of her drive and ambition came from her.

My boys are both very bright but they will underachieve because of their personalities. They probably would be doing better in a privately school but I think that being state-educated makes you a more rounded person.

faffadoodledo · 01/07/2022 07:11

It obviously depends on the child. My DD is a gifted mathematician, now using her maths in a research and medical setting at a top university. Went to bog standard comp. She was used to 'tutor' less bright, or worse, disruptive kids in her year in broadly streamed classes. IN other words the top sets had a broad range of ability. She was fine. It made her cross, sure. But tbh there's a limit to the knowledge you need to get an A star at A level, and she coasted that. So didnt need any extra push. I can see how some young people would be alienated by this treatment, and tbh it used to piss me off. But she rode it and used it to her advantage on her UCAS form. It's hard to find things to talk about for maths and she shoe-horned in her ability to explain and demonstrate tricky concepts.
It didn't happen to DS, who was the arty farty child (though equally gifted in his fields). Its seems to be the mathematicians who cop this treatment most!
@Valeriekat what are you talking about? I know masses of young engineers and mathmos, very few of whom went to a 'better private school'.

Valeriekat · 01/07/2022 07:03

pointythings · 30/06/2022 20:55

Because nobody from a state school ever managed to do an engineering degree and succeed in that field, of course. Hmm

Don't be ridiculous but at the top school ie Imperial, many state school pupils are at a massive disadvantage and they know it. A lot of our state school students are playing catch up because they usually haven't had the opportunity to study Applied or Further Maths.
That is the problem with not setting for Maths early on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread