Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not hide my baby?

106 replies

littlefirecar · 25/06/2022 09:05

This happened a few months ago but I have seen this woman out a few times now and she still makes me really uncomfortable

My baby is now bigger but when she was a couple of months old I was pushing her in her pram and she was enjoying looking around / cooing at things (she had only just moved to a sit up rather than basinet pushchair so was still enjoying the novelty)

All was good until we we crossed the road to a traffic island and were waiting to cross the next road to go on our way.

The lights at this crossing point always seem to take ages so I'm chatting to baby while she is happily cooing and starting to reach out to the stranger standing next to us also waiting to cross (she was very interested in strangers / other people at this stage and still is)

Anyway this woman then turns to me and asks me (pretty abruptly) to pull the hood down so my baby stops staring at her!

I was pretty stunned by this and lights still hadnt changed to cross so I just said 'no she's just being friendly' . She then seems more agitated and says 'you should be more considerate of others, I miscarried and our IVF failed, i don't want to be constantly reminded!'

I didn't really know what to say and felt really awkward but didn't want to pull the hood down on my baby as she doesnt like that so I just turned back to baby and lights changed a few seconds later

Crossed over and continued on our way but since then I have wondered if I dealt with the situation correctly.

I get she obviously had some trauma going on but I felt she was unreasonable and rude to expect me to hide my baby from her

Since then I have seen her around (I guess she must live in my area) but thankfully not stood close again!

WIBU or was she?

OP posts:
Truenorthmum · 25/06/2022 13:37

As someone with PTSD relating to both infertility and then birth trauma and a near loss of my child I recognise this woman's state of mind and behaviour.

The woman is clearly suffering and her behaviour was obviously inappropriate, we can all see that without even being there so not sure what the point of this is other than to perpetuate the 'hysterical woman' stereotype.

I hope she has access to the treatment that she needs, but she probably doesn't because is most areas it isn't accessible unless you have loads of money to pay for private therapy.

georgarina · 25/06/2022 13:35

YABU because this is a stupid thread. This woman (if she exists which I doubt) is in a bad place. Obviously you're not biting your nails wondering if you should hide your baby away.

WimbyAce · 25/06/2022 13:11

No need for a thread on this if indeed it even happened at all.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 25/06/2022 13:11

She didn't ask you to hide your baby. Hmm At most she asked for you to put a hood up for a few moments or to stop your baby reaching out to strangers for the time it took to stand on a road island - which takes less than a minute.

She shared something traumatic. You refused to countenance any change or consideration. I would have said I was sorry for her loss and difficulties and positioned myself between her and my baby. It's not hard to treat people like human beings rather than constant combatants. ffs - this place.

NC12345665 · 25/06/2022 12:58

How is this even a serious question?

BingeBitch · 25/06/2022 12:55

Of all the things that didn’t happen. This didn’t happen the most.

humptydumptysatonawall · 25/06/2022 12:51

YANBU, a strangers fertility struggles should not be your worry when doing anything with your child, she's obviously struggling which is sad for her but she was really out of order in my opinion.

I think this obsession with people pleasing and trying not to offend every single person at the same time is getting ridiculous

October2020 · 25/06/2022 12:48

This didn't happen.

SurpriseSurprise · 25/06/2022 12:43

I feel sorry for her. I’ve had losses and struggles and at one time I had to take myself away when someone else announced a pregnancy

She may have just heard her latest IVF failed, or that her eggs weren’t perfect or whatever. It does sound like you were trying to draw attention to yourself and your baby and she probably really struggled

Stravaig · 25/06/2022 12:30

What an odd thread to start. Of course you don't have to 'hide your baby away'.

I would have pulled the hood down as asked for the length of the crossing because the woman who spoke was clearly distressed, and it would a tiny kindness to her.

This anecdote should elicit empathy for those who have experienced loss, not outrage that your precious firstborn had her view restricted for a few seconds. The woman was probably mortified at her own outburst later.

Merryclaire · 25/06/2022 12:30

YABU posting this. Of course you don’t need to hide your baby - and you also don’t need to make a big deal about it.

All that happened is you got the brunt of someone in the middle of a fertility crisis.

Yes it was twattish to speak to you like that and she probably feels embarrassed now, but for all you know she just found out that morning that her latest IVF failed, and felt utterly hopeless so lashed out.

Have some sympathy, don’t take it personally and move on!

QueenWatevraWaNabi · 25/06/2022 12:25

I think the key here is not that she wanted your baby to be hidden but where you say “starting to reach out to the stranger standing next to us also waiting to cross.” Your child was trying to engage her attention and it was obviously not something this woman wanted

This was my take from it too. Just because your baby is 'very interested in strangers' doesn't mean every person you come across should be expected to indulge you both. It sounds like you were maybe a bit full on with all the cooing and expecting her to join in the performance.

NotLongNow12 · 25/06/2022 12:21

I do feel for the woman but obviously you shouldn't hide your baby. And I don't think you have an intention of doing that?

I have had IVF for years, and several losses. I'm now pregnant but for months during this pregnancy, I kept it private.
Partly because of the losses. But also because I felt guilty for being pregnant as I understand the effect it has seeing a pregnant woman when you're having such difficulties trying to conceive or you have had a loss.

For the first 4 months of being pregnant, I felt jealousy seeing other pregnant women because of the trauma of the losses and the IVF etc. even though I was pregnant myself. I still felt that sadness and jealousy.

It's an awful situation and I can understand it was hard for her. And unpleasant for you too.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 25/06/2022 12:10

YANBU at all OP. I'm unlikely to be able to have children, my sister is currently pregnant and I'm really struggling but there's no way I'd ever tell her to hide her pregnancy or baby.

I also really struggle sometimes seeing babies but I'd never say that to anyone, it's not fair and also your baby is a person in his/her own right and shouldn't be hidden away.

PegasusReturns · 25/06/2022 12:05

If this happened which I doubt then perhaps just recognise it as a snapshot in time where a vulnerable and sad woman struggled to cope.

You can’t possibly believe that you’re expected to keep your baby hidden, so I’m not sure what the post is for other than to goad.

PurpleButterflyWings · 25/06/2022 11:55

Rosebel · 25/06/2022 11:35

I don't know. I feel sorry for this woman. I've had 4 miscarriages. I also have 3 children so I'm lucky and I can totally understand how she felt. I used to cry at the sight of babies and pregnant women after I lost my babies.
I wouldn't have said what she did but I also don't think she was so awful for saying it. In your place I probably would have put the hood up for a few seconds.
Not because you need to hide your baby from everyone (and you would be hiding your baby for a few seconds from one person) but because you could have made someone's day just a bit easier.
You know how horrendous it is to lose a child. I'm surprised you weren't more sympathetic actually.

Hmm
PurpleButterflyWings · 25/06/2022 11:53

Tilltheend99 · 25/06/2022 11:19

I can. The lady probably sadly had mental health or drug problems . It could have been any issue that caused her to lash out verbally at a stranger. It is sad that she suffered miscarriages thoughts. It’s a shame there is not more help for people struggling like this.

Its more likely for mums in maternity leave to end up bumping into vulnerable people on the fringes of society. People working 9-5 and commuting just don’t have the opportunity to see what goes on on local communities day to day

Confused
BattenburgDonkey · 25/06/2022 11:49

Enjoyallthewine · 25/06/2022 11:43

Lay In is not said much in the north.

also hate when people say “my one” just bloody say mine.

Not sure you’re in the right place 😀

Zippy1510 · 25/06/2022 11:46

YANBU your baby doesn’t need to be hidden to accommodate a stranger or anyone else’s feelings. We have run into a situation with friends who are struggling to conceive their second child and are visibly unhappy whenever we bring our baby to group events. It’s horrible for them to be struggling but I won’t pretend she doesn’t exist or not let her join in with activities when all the older toddlers are invited.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 25/06/2022 11:44

...heads back to the style and beauty board.

Enjoyallthewine · 25/06/2022 11:43

Lay In is not said much in the north.

also hate when people say “my one” just bloody say mine.

AmbushedByCake · 25/06/2022 11:36

Rosebel · 25/06/2022 11:35

I don't know. I feel sorry for this woman. I've had 4 miscarriages. I also have 3 children so I'm lucky and I can totally understand how she felt. I used to cry at the sight of babies and pregnant women after I lost my babies.
I wouldn't have said what she did but I also don't think she was so awful for saying it. In your place I probably would have put the hood up for a few seconds.
Not because you need to hide your baby from everyone (and you would be hiding your baby for a few seconds from one person) but because you could have made someone's day just a bit easier.
You know how horrendous it is to lose a child. I'm surprised you weren't more sympathetic actually.

Don't be daft. Everyone has losses and pain. They don't give you the right to stop people going about their lives.

Trivester · 25/06/2022 11:36

She could be just as uncomfortable at seeing you now. People aren’t static, and your reaction to her demand might have given her something to think about too.

Try not to let it worry you.

Being out and about with a baby is strange - so many people speak to you who wouldn’t otherwise, and the vast majority are lovely. But others have their issues - I had a lady try to claim I was stealing her baby, another who glared at my baby until he stopped smiling, one who followed me down the street ranting that I was responsible for over populating the planet, and one who was evangelising for breastfeeding at the traffic lights.

Rosebel · 25/06/2022 11:35

I don't know. I feel sorry for this woman. I've had 4 miscarriages. I also have 3 children so I'm lucky and I can totally understand how she felt. I used to cry at the sight of babies and pregnant women after I lost my babies.
I wouldn't have said what she did but I also don't think she was so awful for saying it. In your place I probably would have put the hood up for a few seconds.
Not because you need to hide your baby from everyone (and you would be hiding your baby for a few seconds from one person) but because you could have made someone's day just a bit easier.
You know how horrendous it is to lose a child. I'm surprised you weren't more sympathetic actually.

itsgettingweird · 25/06/2022 11:34

Yanbu.

You often hear reasons that explain behaviour but it doesn't excuse it.

You just met someone who was clearly going through an emotional time and she offloaded on you because of that.

But remember that's one person your whole babies life. You aren't being asked by society to cover up and hide your baby away.
One woman had a moment during a time of intense grief for her and made an unreasonable request.