Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have had enough of ‘be kind’

196 replies

Trainfromredhill · 25/06/2022 06:59

DC (9)is at a school with a ‘be kind’ mantra. In her head at least this has taken hold as ‘I must be kind to all people at all times irrespective of how horrible they are to me or how uncomfortable they make me feel’.
Standing up for herself no longer appears to be allowed because it may upset the person who has upset her or made her feel uncomfortable, and that would be unkind. Fast forward a few years and I’m genuinely concerned that she will find herself unable to set boundaries for fear of appearing unkind.
has anyone else experienced similar?

OP posts:
glowbabe · 25/06/2022 09:13

Orphlids · 25/06/2022 08:36

A couple of years ago, my DD who was seven at the time, found a little pin badge someone had dropped. In tiny letters, the badge states, “Do no harm, take no shit.” She loves this badge, mostly because it has a naughty word on it. But I think it’s an excellent motto, and we use this to counteract the “be kind” bullshit. I bought another similar badge from Etsy for my other DC.

Brilliant its going to be my mantra too .

Singleandproud · 25/06/2022 09:07

@hallyup89
But girls and women have been told to do that constantly, it's a message on our clothing, on cups and mugs etc.
You see it in action all the time, the women in a DV relationship who repeatedly takes the violent partner back because "it was only once", "he didn't mean it", "I made him do it, I'll do better next time". The female wants to give him the benefit of the doubt, to not cause a fuss, to be kind.

Hurstlandshome · 25/06/2022 09:07

Not the same but my daughters school used the 'be kind' mantra to passive aggressively divert parents from the school failing to effectively react to the pandemic. 'remember to be kind as we navigate through these unprecedented times' ugh get your shit together! Sorry OP - your post reminded me of this. I'll go now :)

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2022 09:05

Hallyup89 · 25/06/2022 08:58

FFS. Stop taking things out of context. Be kind doesn't mean don't stand up for yourself and don't challenge unwanted behaviour.

Except that’s exactly what it means. In all it’s trite and insipid glory.

Sunnysideup999 · 25/06/2022 09:04

Yes - ‘be kind’ annoys me to!
’be kind’ for who??!!!
Because it makes someone’s life easier , at the expense of how your feeling? Nope.
I don’t teach my kids to ‘be kind’. 🤢
I teach my kids instead to ‘BE BRAVE!!’
bravery will take you further .

ldontWanna · 25/06/2022 09:04

Hallyup89 · 25/06/2022 08:58

FFS. Stop taking things out of context. Be kind doesn't mean don't stand up for yourself and don't challenge unwanted behaviour.

To a lot of people that's exactly what it means because it makes their lives easier in various forms. Let's not pretend otherwise.

Hallyup89 · 25/06/2022 08:58

FFS. Stop taking things out of context. Be kind doesn't mean don't stand up for yourself and don't challenge unwanted behaviour.

Reekingpitofdoom · 25/06/2022 08:57

I tell my DDs bollocks to being kind, what they need to be is respectful and to be fair.

darisdet · 25/06/2022 08:53

I teach DD "don't be a dick".

🤣

I also like 'Do no harm. Take no shit'

Singleandproud · 25/06/2022 08:53

I tell my daughter and form of 14-15 year olds to "be indifferent". You don't have to like everyone, if you don't get on that's fine but you have to be polite and professional, if you are put into a group with them work with them to complete the task etc. Just like you might have to work with someone you don't like in the workplace or coparent a child with an ex partner when you are grown up

darisdet · 25/06/2022 08:51

Well said @whumpthereitis Agreeing with everything you've said there.

It's meaningless and stupid on its own. I also dislike the way it seems to be aimed at girls and women. And those who spout #bekind that I've seen, well let's just say it's usually a case of ' the irony!'

BogRollBOGOF · 25/06/2022 08:47

I talk about "kindness" with my sons. DS1 in particular is autistic and his world view strongly centres around himself and he needs some guidence in seeing other perspectives.

I don't like a blanket "be kind" ethos which does tend to involve telling females to overlook their needs. I've never seen "be kind" on a boy's t-shirt. It's too often used as "put up and shut up".

Manners, and kindness make the world a more pleasant place, but boundaries are important too and need to be in place first.

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2022 08:44

ldontWanna · 25/06/2022 08:34

I don't know about OP's DD but I'll give some examples from my experience.

Child told off for tale telling, because it isn't "nice". Incident including another girl following them to the toilet, calling her names , trying to look under the door,climb the wall to look over and kicking the door while she was using the toilet.

Told that she should tell the teachers and give them a chance to sort it , instead of telling mum. It's not nice or fair to keep quiet because then they can't deal with it.

Told off for excluding said girl and not wanting to play with her ,that it's not nice AFTER being kicked and her hair pulled by same girl.

Told that x has a,b,c issues and she needs to be kind and understand that. Massively unprofessional and a breach of privacy for that other girl.

Most schools and staff are great, work incredibly hard ,do their best and most ant their best for their kids. Some suck or try to take the easy way out. It happens.

Yep. Regardless of what people think it should mean, in reality it absolutely is used to mean ‘be endlessly accommodating. Don’t fuss, don’t complain, don’t make me have to deal with something I don’t want to deal with’. Because it’s easier.

ldontWanna · 25/06/2022 08:42

Orphlids · 25/06/2022 08:36

A couple of years ago, my DD who was seven at the time, found a little pin badge someone had dropped. In tiny letters, the badge states, “Do no harm, take no shit.” She loves this badge, mostly because it has a naughty word on it. But I think it’s an excellent motto, and we use this to counteract the “be kind” bullshit. I bought another similar badge from Etsy for my other DC.

I teach DD "don't be a dick".Grin

justfiveminutes · 25/06/2022 08:42

As a teacher, parents always want the other children to be kind but don't mind too much if theirs isn't.

If someone doesn't want to play with their child, because they make them feel uncomfortable, they want them to be kind and include them.

If a child has a party and invites everyone but their child, because they're enforcing boundaries and refusing to invite the child they don't like, they want them to be kind and invite them.

If a group of friends reject someone from the group because they have said or done something the others don't like, or are a bit bossy in games, they want those children to be kind and include their child.

Kindness is short-hand for a lot of things at primary school. Acceptance, inclusivity, compromise, rubbing along with people you're not keen on, biting your tongue to avoid hurt feelings.

It absolutely does not mean accepting mistreatment, accepting bullying, saying yes to things that make you uncomfortable. And at all times, if in doubt about any situation, kids are told to talk to an adult.

stayathomer · 25/06/2022 08:41

There’s definitely got to be a middle ground- I was always taught to be nice to people but make sure people didn’t walk all over me. As with everything there’s a middle ground, personally it seems a lot more people teach their children they deserve it all leading to a more selfish cohort that parrot off ‘be kind’ but don’t practice or mean it

MrsPrimulaSpread · 25/06/2022 08:40

Shit, and 'just stay away from them', errr no, fucking sort it, you are the adult that they have told
Deal with it

pictish · 25/06/2022 08:39

ThatshallotBaby · 25/06/2022 08:35

Be aware might be more helpful.

Yes.

MrsPrimulaSpread · 25/06/2022 08:39

Oh God, I have a problem with 'stop telling tales' too
I hate people saying that

SilverGlitterBaubles · 25/06/2022 08:38

Orphlids · 25/06/2022 08:36

A couple of years ago, my DD who was seven at the time, found a little pin badge someone had dropped. In tiny letters, the badge states, “Do no harm, take no shit.” She loves this badge, mostly because it has a naughty word on it. But I think it’s an excellent motto, and we use this to counteract the “be kind” bullshit. I bought another similar badge from Etsy for my other DC.

Love this

Orphlids · 25/06/2022 08:36

A couple of years ago, my DD who was seven at the time, found a little pin badge someone had dropped. In tiny letters, the badge states, “Do no harm, take no shit.” She loves this badge, mostly because it has a naughty word on it. But I think it’s an excellent motto, and we use this to counteract the “be kind” bullshit. I bought another similar badge from Etsy for my other DC.

ThatshallotBaby · 25/06/2022 08:35

Be aware might be more helpful.

ldontWanna · 25/06/2022 08:34

justfiveminutes · 25/06/2022 08:17

Please explain in what way your dd is not allowed to stand up for herself.

Of course schools encourage kindness.

That doesn't mean saying 'yes' to things you're uncomfortable with, putting up with bullying or unkind behaviour, or being ingratiating while someone hits you or calls you names.

In what circumstances has she been asked to be kind?

I don't know about OP's DD but I'll give some examples from my experience.

Child told off for tale telling, because it isn't "nice". Incident including another girl following them to the toilet, calling her names , trying to look under the door,climb the wall to look over and kicking the door while she was using the toilet.

Told that she should tell the teachers and give them a chance to sort it , instead of telling mum. It's not nice or fair to keep quiet because then they can't deal with it.

Told off for excluding said girl and not wanting to play with her ,that it's not nice AFTER being kicked and her hair pulled by same girl.

Told that x has a,b,c issues and she needs to be kind and understand that. Massively unprofessional and a breach of privacy for that other girl.

Most schools and staff are great, work incredibly hard ,do their best and most ant their best for their kids. Some suck or try to take the easy way out. It happens.

KilmordenCastle · 25/06/2022 08:34

I've always told my dd that if someone is being unkind to her she should say "you're not being very kind right now so I'm going to play somewhere else" and then just walk away. I've told her that she doesn't have to be rude about it but she doesn't have to put up with people being rude to her either, just walk away. So far this has worked well but she is only in year 2 so I know she will need more/different strategies as she gets older.

We recently had a chat about how that if people are being rude or mean to you and don't stand up for yourself and walk away then they will think that you don't mind and will just keep being mean to you. Obviously I didn't want to just say "some people are just plain horrible and they will walk all over you if you let them" to a six year old but it is a fact of life and I want her to know that.

I think its really hard to explain the line between being unkind and setting boundaries to a child. Children see things in such a black and white way. I have always been the type of person to stick up for myself and not let people walk all over me. Some of the stories my friends tell me or that I see on here shock me as I just can't imagine not shutting that crap down long before it got the ridiculously CF stage. But both my dc's (one girl and one boy) are the complete opposite to me in that regard and I know that I will have to put a lot of work in to teaching them how to set boundaries and assert themselves.

RedLeggedChuff · 25/06/2022 08:32

Kindness directives can be actually harmful.

My Dd was bullied and coerced by another girl throughout y3 and y4. Isolated from other friends and emotionally manipulated. School dealt with this through (repeated) kindness assemblies and kindness circles.

My dd spent long and pointless hours trying to appease this girl, to include her alongside other friends, to reassure her and to do as she wanted. To Be Kind.

The bully did nothing. She didn't see herself as unkind. She saw my dd as unkind for not embracing an exclusive friendship and cutting herself off from all competing friendships.

My dd ended up with a bloody breakdown, self harming at ten years old. The bully was just given the lead in the school play. That was kind?