Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Forest school only for 'select' children

543 replies

Eyelashesrgreat · 25/06/2022 05:18

Ds in Y3 and his school have recently 'selected' children from his class to go to forest school. The children do this weekly whilst the other children have to stay at school and do work. The children (selected) get to wear their own clothes that day and have treats.

The school did the same thing last year and ds wasn't chosen then. Ds has had a really difficult time recently at school and would have loved to have been selected for this activity. I asked his teacher if all the children will eventually get their turn at the forest school but she has said only certain children can go. AIBU to think this is a bit unfair?

OP posts:
JustAnotherViper · 25/06/2022 13:21

You could always join the PTA and work to get funding/staff for all the children to enjoy forest school.

Walkaround · 25/06/2022 13:21

Walkaround · 25/06/2022 08:36

It is a shame if not all children get to try forest schools, as it is educational in itself and can enrich various parts of the school curriculum. Schools do not have the spare cash for pointless treats, though, and this school clearly doesn’t have the money or time to enable all children to benefit from forest schools.

The school has to have an educational justification that would satisfy Ofsted inspectors and the DfE, so the school will have reasons for picking the children it does that do not relate to whether the teacher likes them or not, and will have an educational purpose for what it is doing with the children who are not at forest schools. The OP hasn’t even said how well their child is doing academically. Is their child in one of the groups of children who ended up behind academically after the pandemic, or are they academically on track? SEN children are not the only children with extra needs - the national school led tutoring grant covers all children who fell behind in the pandemic. There are, basically, multiple possible reasons for different children having to be treated differently, but the OP only seems interested in the idea that forest schools is a treat or reward, which would be a ludicrous waste of money if it were.

As for cliquey schools, imvho, these are often schools with cliquey parents who gossip with each other and spread their nasty opinions around as fact, because they believe each other’s malicious gossip, whilst simultaneously assuming school staff are all liars. This sounds very much like the OP’s school. Where there is such a massive loss of faith in the school, this doesn’t seem like a tenable relationship- I think the OP should be looking around to see if there is an alternative school for her child, as she clearly has no trust in this one and is happy to believe parental gossip as gospel truth. Reality is likely to be more complex, but the damage has been done and trust is lost.

@5zeds - my original post, from which you randomly selected one comment to start a bizarre argument about whether or not you can have extra needs without officially having SEN.

Walkaround · 25/06/2022 13:16

5zeds · 25/06/2022 12:40

@5zeds It’s actually SEND, not SEN, well they are two slightly different groups, those with SEN have additional needs that impact the support needed to access education, those with D are disabled which may or may not impact their access to education.

Pupil premium children are not automatically on the SEND register, but they are considered to have additional needs that justify extra funding. I think most people are aware that additional needs are not all related to disability.

Do you think the OP’s child is on the school’s SEND register because she says he is anxious and being bullied? no it’s highly unlikely because she seems particularly blinkered as to WHY some children need more support than hers.

Do you think he is automatically on the register if he fell behind during lockdowns? no but let me ask you a question in response to your post.

Do you assume that everyone who holds a different view to yours is ignorant and or lacking in experience?

@5zeds Rather than quoting inaccurately and selectively from my original post, have the courtesy to go back and read the whole thing, ffs. I wasn’t agreeing or disagreeing with anyone, I was pointing out the OP was assuming the forest schools thing was just a special treat for favourites or randomly selected children. I was pointing out that even if she knows which children are on the SEND register, she doesn’t know the criteria for forest schools selection, nor does she seem to have an interest in what is being done with the children who are not going to forest schools. I was pointing out the school will have reasons that it must use to justify its actions to Ofsted and the DfE. You are just inventing arguments by selective quoting and then conflating educational needs and extra needs and then pretending you didn’t so as to continue an argument of your making.

Sockwomble · 25/06/2022 13:08

"Its a tricky one, on the one hand of course those who require additional support should receive it without bitterness; but when it is upsetting the other children because let's face it forest school, treats, wearing your own clothes for the day are beyond nurture rooms etc then is it actually a positive thing?"

Do you think that extra support should only be given if the extra support is something that those without the disability or disadvantage, don't want?

Do you consider how the child with the disability or disadvantage feels when they see their classmates having/doing things every day that they cannot do. Does that child feeling upset not matter?

ThePenOfMyAunt · 25/06/2022 13:07

Waffleboggy · 25/06/2022 12:49

Its a tricky one, on the one hand of course those who require additional support should receive it without bitterness; but when it is upsetting the other children because let's face it forest school, treats, wearing your own clothes for the day are beyond nurture rooms etc then is it actually a positive thing? If it is for those with extra funding is it the best way to utilise it? Is there no way for the others to be involved, ever? It's not schools faults as much as shrinking budgets and less being available to them- but there are children 'in the middle' who often get forgotten about and it does have an effect on them. Schools also aren't aware of every child's circumstances, others may benefit just as much.

So you're o.k with targeted intervention, so long as it doesn't look appealing to children who don't need it?

Oblomov22 · 25/06/2022 13:01

What do you want to happen here? School not offer forest school at all?

5zeds · 25/06/2022 12:57

but when it is upsetting the other children because let's face it forest school, treats, wearing your own clothes for the day are beyond nurture rooms etc then is it actually a positive thing?
having read this thread YES I’d say it was an excellent thing for able children to feel what it’s like to be upset when others can do the fun thing you would love to be able to join in. Shame we can’t give the parents a crash course in empathy too.

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 12:53

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 12:40

If the OP knows every little personal detail about every kid in the school, how come they don’t know the criteria for forest school?

Its not every little personal detail. It’s more general stuff.

No SEND
No FSM
Not PP
Not in a children’s home (very easy if there isn’t one in the village)
Not looked after
Not armed forces

She doesn’t know the criteria, as she didn’t actually ask. I think she should on Monday! There is also the possibility of asking any parents whose child was selected.

So if it’s not every single little personal detail, how come the OP is so sure that it’s a reward system rather than a nurture one?

5zeds · 25/06/2022 12:51

Or children who won’t cope with other activities or don’t need catch up hours, or the able ones who are particularly confident have been muddled in with the struggling to form friendships, or the ones going because they have been abused, bereaved, lost homes, have undisclosed issues, are going to have problems (eg terminal illness in the family), have invisible (to OP) difficulties chose those children, or those children have been excessively helpful all year.

OP doesn’t know because her school is not transparent.

Waffleboggy · 25/06/2022 12:49

Its a tricky one, on the one hand of course those who require additional support should receive it without bitterness; but when it is upsetting the other children because let's face it forest school, treats, wearing your own clothes for the day are beyond nurture rooms etc then is it actually a positive thing? If it is for those with extra funding is it the best way to utilise it? Is there no way for the others to be involved, ever? It's not schools faults as much as shrinking budgets and less being available to them- but there are children 'in the middle' who often get forgotten about and it does have an effect on them. Schools also aren't aware of every child's circumstances, others may benefit just as much.

Morph22010 · 25/06/2022 12:48

covilha · 25/06/2022 12:38

To do Forest School safely you have to know the children can and will follow instructions. Have the selected children reliably shown they will do this? I would be unwilling to risk civil or criminal prosecution or job loss which could follow if a selected child was unable to follow rules, for whatever reason

My child is rubbish at listening and following instructions and does forest school, it’s part of it, getting them to listen and act safely

PriamFarrl · 25/06/2022 12:47

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 12:40

If the OP knows every little personal detail about every kid in the school, how come they don’t know the criteria for forest school?

Its not every little personal detail. It’s more general stuff.

No SEND
No FSM
Not PP
Not in a children’s home (very easy if there isn’t one in the village)
Not looked after
Not armed forces

She doesn’t know the criteria, as she didn’t actually ask. I think she should on Monday! There is also the possibility of asking any parents whose child was selected.

Ever 6 counts if the child has ever been in state care. So this could be a child who was adopted into a well off family but spent some of their time in state care. That would class them as being PP.

People might think they know everything but a child could easily be ‘looked after’ if they are actually being brought up by a family member rather than parent. If they call them mum you wouldn’t know and no one at the school gate is going to say ‘oh Sophie is actually my granddaughter because her mother went to prison when Sophie was 6 months old’. Especially not in a village full of such dreadful gossips.

ThePenOfMyAunt · 25/06/2022 12:40

Of course the SENCo could have shared the number of pupils identified as having SEN without sharing how they were supported Confused

But OP's school parents clearly aren't making everything public knowledge if the forest school criteria is unknown.

If it's only just been decided now and it's until the end of term I would guess at rewards-based, rather than targeted intervention. If it runs all year around then I would guess at targeted intervention. But that is just guessing!

Ted27 · 25/06/2022 12:40

@Eyelashesrgreat

things really are not always what they seem.

I’m a civil servant, so reasonable income, live in a good area. I am an engaged mum, went to parents events, all school events etc. Between the ages of 8 to 14 my son had swimming and tennis lessons and had a personal trainer. He was a cub/scout and went to all the camping trips going, we had nice holidays in the UK and a few abroad. He is popular and has lots of friends. He is nearly 18 now, we have a couple of holidays coming up, plus he has 2 expensive duke of edinburgh trips.

What picture does that paint for you?

The truth is that he has ASD and is adopted. Now we are open about both of those things. But no one knows the truth about the first four years of his life spent in poverty and neglect or the state he was in when he went into foster care - not even my mum knows the whole story. No one would guess from the happy smiling face he has put on for the world this week, the very distressing news he has had about his birth family.

Now I’m sure that given the appalling lack of respect that appears to be paid in your school, to children’s right to confidentiality by both parents and teachers, if he had been in your school it would be common knowledge about his autism and adoption. But you wouldnt know the rest, because the school would not know

5zeds · 25/06/2022 12:40

@5zeds It’s actually SEND, not SEN, well they are two slightly different groups, those with SEN have additional needs that impact the support needed to access education, those with D are disabled which may or may not impact their access to education.

Pupil premium children are not automatically on the SEND register, but they are considered to have additional needs that justify extra funding. I think most people are aware that additional needs are not all related to disability.

Do you think the OP’s child is on the school’s SEND register because she says he is anxious and being bullied? no it’s highly unlikely because she seems particularly blinkered as to WHY some children need more support than hers.

Do you think he is automatically on the register if he fell behind during lockdowns? no but let me ask you a question in response to your post.

Do you assume that everyone who holds a different view to yours is ignorant and or lacking in experience?

CecilyP · 25/06/2022 12:40

If the OP knows every little personal detail about every kid in the school, how come they don’t know the criteria for forest school?

Its not every little personal detail. It’s more general stuff.

No SEND
No FSM
Not PP
Not in a children’s home (very easy if there isn’t one in the village)
Not looked after
Not armed forces

She doesn’t know the criteria, as she didn’t actually ask. I think she should on Monday! There is also the possibility of asking any parents whose child was selected.

PriamFarrl · 25/06/2022 12:38

I want to reiterate I’m not against any kind of extra funding, groups or trips for those who benefit from it. My point is more that actually there’s always children who would also benefit who just never quite qualify because they don’t have a disability, they don’t have a learning disorder and on paper seem to have nothing wrong and come from an ok income and traditional family, and actually would also benefit greatly from the life skills listed from a poster above.

I was taught that about 3 weeks into having your class you should make a list off all the children from memory.
There will always be about 5 children missing. They are the ones you should focus on. They aren’t the trouble makers, they don’t have SEN, they aren’t the ‘top of the class’ or the ones who answer all the questions, they aren’t the ones who need that bit extra. They are the ones who just quietly get on. They are the ones who get missed.

As an aside, yes, in an ideal world all the children should be getting the opportunity, but they can’t, so choices have to be made.

covilha · 25/06/2022 12:38

To do Forest School safely you have to know the children can and will follow instructions. Have the selected children reliably shown they will do this? I would be unwilling to risk civil or criminal prosecution or job loss which could follow if a selected child was unable to follow rules, for whatever reason

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 12:35

turquoise1988 · 25/06/2022 12:33

Wouldn't that be CEP plan? ^

Misses point of thread.^

Probably, I’m not in charge of the abbreviations.

turquoise1988 · 25/06/2022 12:33

@Pumperthepumper Gah, forgot to tag!

turquoise1988 · 25/06/2022 12:33

Wouldn't that be CEP plan? ^

Misses point of thread.^

ChocolatemilkBertie · 25/06/2022 12:32

In addition to my post because I pressed the button too soon…..

It would be worth asking who has funded it. If it’s pupil premium than it’s PP children who need to use it, likewise if it’s on EHCPs.

However if it’s from the school or another organisation then in this instance I feel it’s one every child can benefit from.

I want to reiterate I’m not against any kind of extra funding, groups or trips for those who benefit from it. My point is more that actually there’s always children who would also benefit who just never quite qualify because they don’t have a disability, they don’t have a learning disorder and on paper seem to have nothing wrong and come from an ok income and traditional family, and actually would also benefit greatly from the life skills listed from a poster above.

A lot of children slip through the cracks and just float under everyone’s radar. As a teacher, my planning is always first planned around the needs of my children with obvious additional needs, what are they doing, who’s going to support them, can they access this lesson? Trips are the same. Then the equal pressure load shifts to my most able, because they need to be pushed, so who have I got supporting them, how can I take them to the next level so they don’t get bored, this one’s got the head-smarts but can’t write well so they need the TA too and so forth.
Then there’s the middle. I can’t give them the TA. I can’t send them to intervention even though they’re plodding along at the bottom of average. I can’t give them anywhere near the level of 1:1 even though they’re also in wrap around till 6:30pm each night and don’t have time to read at home or go to the park or go on outings to learn life skills or social skills because they’re always in the care of someone else. They don’t qualify for state funded help for anything because they’re too well off on paper but in reality they also can’t go on trips out etc because everything pays for the bills.They’re communication skills aren’t good because they’ve had speech issues but these weren’t bad enough to get speech therapy on the NHS and as a result communication skills are poor but again because they aren’t violent or aggressive or such, it’s side lined as low priority. Or they're just plain average at everything and have a good enough balance in life and are left to it..

This is what I’m badly trying to explain with something like a forest School. If it happens every week across the year and it’s not attached to PP etc, why can’t it be split so everyone gets a turn? There would also be befits to that smaller class when some are out for the varying needs.I don’t believe Op is saying “her son deserves it more” in this instance.

Enquire as to the funding OP and go from there.

JLwac · 25/06/2022 12:32

Don't take this the wrong way, but why do you think you know better than the class teacher? They have their criteria and your child doesn't meet it. Maybe look at it another way and be glad your child isn't considered "bad" enough to need the forest school.

PriamFarrl · 25/06/2022 12:31

TabithaTittlemouse · 25/06/2022 12:24

Maybe these children have less tiresome parents?

😆

Pumperthepumper · 25/06/2022 12:29

turquoise1988 · 25/06/2022 12:28

@Pumperthepumper Which is an abbreviation of....?

Continuous enhanced provision. I’m a teacher, I use this every day.